- 1 - !"# $ % & && '"( )* && ++ '"( ) * !"#$%% && %'(% & ) & )*!$!*** !+ %#*%# Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) %*, &&- ++) * (" !"#$%" && %'(% & ) & ) * $ *** & !+ %#*%# + & & %% **" & . & / &)0 0 1 - 3 - "% % 2343 5663574 583 9:73; 83463<=:>37? @? =23 <75:A5B= 5B; =23 58B5=5C5 =5=3 D5; 85B46D8= D86D85=:DB E9D8 42D8= .D86D85=:DB/F 5G5:B4= =23 45A3HI;GA3B=5B;5J58;;5=3;* $ ***65443;@?=23 ;;:=:DB57 3B:D8 :>:7 I;G3 5B; 3A@38 !+ :H5?56I85E9D842D8=.8:@IB57/F:BD %#*%# * 23 95<=4 D9 =23 <543 583 =25= =23 5663775B=<75:A5B= A3= J:=2 5B 5<<:;3B= DB ( " *%' 834I7=:BG :B :BHI8:34 =D 2:A 3B<3 23 9:73; <75:A 63=:=:DB @39D83=238:@IB57<75:A:BG<DA63B45=:DBD94 *! 98DA=238346DB;3B=!D86D85=:DB 238:@IB57<DB4:;38:BG =233B=:83A5=38:5745>5:75@73DB83<D8;25;5J58;3;54IA D9 4 (#$"! J:=2 :B=3834= 5= $, 638 5BBIA 98DA =23 ;5=3 D9 63=:=:DB =:77 8357:K5=:DB 5B; ;:83<=3; =D 65? =23 <DA63B45=:DB ( GG8:3>3; @? =23 45:; HI;GA3B= =23 D86D85=:DB 254 68393883; =23 566357 :B & D *L(L**( ;:46I=:BG =23 5<<:;3B= :=4379 5B; - 4 - :B>D7>3A3B= D9 =23 D993B;:BG @I4 :B =23 5773G3; 5<<:;3B= =:4<DB=3B;3;=25==23<75:A5B=A:G2=25>395773B;DJB 98DA2:4AD=D8<?<73@?;8:>:BG:B5;8IBC3B<DB;:=:DB = :49I8=238<DB=3B;3;=25==2383:4;375?D9%';5?4:B9:7:BG =23&98DA=23;5=3D95773G3;5<<:;3B=5B;<75:A5B=254 BD= 544:GB3; 68D638 8354DB 9D8 9:7:BG =23 <DA675:B= 5= @375=3; 4=5G3 B & =23 ;5=3 D9 5<<:;3B= :4 42DJB 54 ( " *%' @I= :B <258G3!4233= =23 ;5=3 D9 5<<:;3B= :4 42DJB54( " *%# M %NA3;:<57@:77483>3574=25= =23<75:A5B=J54=835=3;54DI=65=:3B=DB* $ *%'@I= =23 5<<:;3B= D<<I883; DB ( " *%' 75:A5B= 254 BD= 68D;I<3; 5B? A3;:<57 83<D8;4 =D 42DJ =25= 23 254 4I4=5:B3; G8:3>DI4 985<=I83 :BHI8:34 5B; J54 5;A:==3; :B =23 2D46:=57 :AA3;:5=37? 59=38 =23 5<<:;3B= B M N )DIB; 38=:9:<5=3 <75:A5B= 2:A4379 4=5=34 =25= =23 5<<:;3B= D<<I883; ;I3 =D AD=D8<?<73 5<<:;3B= M " N 36D8= 42DJ4 DB7? AD=D8<?<73 ;5A5G3 5B; =25= =23 @I4:B>D7>3;:B=235<<:;3B=:4BD=5=577;5A5G3; 9@I4 J54 :B>D7>3; :B =23 5<<:;3B= =2383 42DI7; 25>3 4DA3 - 5 - ;5A5G3=D=23@I4574D@I=5463836D8==2383:4BD ;5A5G3=D=23@I4 BD7IABD **D9=2363=:=:DB:=:4 4=5=3;=25=5==239:84=:B4=5B<3<75:A5B=J54=5C3B=D=23 D>38BA3B= D46:=57 5= 25;5<25B 5B; =23 ;8:>38 D9 =23 I434<563;98DA=235<<:;3B=46D= 238359=38<75:A5B= J54=5C3B=D=23:>:7D46:=57:H5?56I855B;=23B=D=23 D46:=57:H5?56I85 25;5<25BD7:<3J3B==D=23 :>:7D46:=57:H5?56I85@I==23<75:A5B=J54BD==2383 23B<3 =23? <DI7; BD= 83G:4=38 =23 <DA675:B= I@43OI3B=7? =23? 83G:4=383; =23 <DA675:B= DB %$ $ *%' DJ5483G:4=383;5B;=2I4=23<DIB437 9D8 D86D85=:DB 83OI34=3; =2:4 DI8= =D AD;:9? =23 HI;GA3B= 23 & D *(#'%**( :4 9:73; @? =23 <75:A5B=5G5:B4==2345A3HI;GA3B=433C:BG3B25B<3A3B= D9 =23 <DA63B45=:DB = :4 <DB=3B;3; =25= <75:A5B= J54 ;D:BG 5G8:<I7=I83 JD8C 5B; 358B:BG 4 *! 638 ADB=2 3 J54 =835=3; 54 :B65=:3B= 9D8 * ;5?4 :B :>:7 D46:=57 :H5?56I85 5B; " ;5?4 :B D46:=57 - 6 - :H5?56I855B;=23B9D8%$;5?4:BI;2:8252D46:=57 :85H5B;23J54=835=3;=23839D843<DB;=:A39D8%%;5?4 5B;5G5:B9D8(8;:B4=5B<323J54=835=3;9D8;5?45B;:B =23 =2 :B4=5B<3 23 IB;38J3B= 9:>3 4I8G38:34 = :4 574D <DB=3B;3; =25= =23 5ADIB=4 G85B=3; IB;38 577 235;4 :B5;3OI5=3 5B; =2I4 83OI34=3; 9D8 3B25B<3A3B= D9 =23 <DA63B45=:DB " 5BB38 D9 =23 5<<:;3B= 42DJ4 =25= DB ( " *%' J2:73 =23 <75:A5B= J54 8:;:BG =23 AD=D8<?<73 @358:BG 83G:4=85=:DB D !*#)!L'' 47DJ7? 5B; <5I=:DI47?=23@I4D9=23D86D85=:DB@358:BG83G:4=85=:DB D !*#&!%'""<5A398DA@32:B;:B85425B;B3G7:G3B= A5BB38J:=22:G24633;5B;;5423;=23AD=D8<?<73545 834I7= 23 9377 ;DJB5B; 4I4=5:B3; :BHI8:34 I= =23 <543 J54 83G:4=383; DB %$ $ *%' 75:A5B= 4=5=3; =25= 23 J3B==D=23D7:<3=5=:DB5B;;:4<7D43;=25=5@I4@358:BG 83G:4=85=:DB D !*#&!%'"" :4 =23 DB7? @I4 8IBB:BG DB =23 9:M3; 8DI=3 4=58=:BG 98DA :H5?56I85 5= # 5 A =DJ58;4 5BBI8 B<25G38: 3>58!:A@58G: 25;5<25B - 7 - DB:D756I85B;B;: D7:<33BOI:83;=23A5==38<5IG2= =235<<I43;@I==2383:4;375?:B=85<:BG=23>32:<735B; =235<<I43; $ BJ8:==3B4=5=3A3B=9:73;@?=23D86D85=:DB:= :4<DB=3B;3;=25=%$;5?459=38=235<<:;3B==23<75:A5B= :B>D7>3; =23 @I4 :B =23 5<<:;3B= B 95<= =23 <75:A5B= A:G2= 25>3 95773B ;DJB 98DA =23 AD=D8<?<73 :B ;8IBC3B <DB;:=:DB ;I3 =D 8542 5B; B3G7:G3B= 8:;:BG D9 =23 AD=D8<?<73 75:A5B= 4=5=3; =25= 23 J54 5;A:==3; :B D>38BA3B=D46:=575=25;5<25B5B;=23D7:<3=5=:DB :B 25;5<25B :4 B35838 =D =23 2D46:=57 5B; 835<25@73 :B 9:>3A:BI=34=23839D83=23<DB=3B=4D9<DA675:B=&5B; 258G3!233=583577<835=3;4=D8:34 <<:;3B=D<<I883;5= $ " 6 A 23 <75:A5B= J54 42:9=3; =D D>38BA3B= D46:=57 25;5<25B 5B; =835=3; =2383 9D8 DB3 2DI8 5B; =238359=3823J5442:9=3;=D:H5?56I85:>:7D46:=575B; =2383 23 =DDC =835=A3B= 9D8 *!( ;5?4 23 ;:4=5B<3 D9 D7:<3=5=:DB:45@DI='=D#C A 98DA=235<<:;3B=46D= 3=DDC=835=A3B=:B D46:=579D8%5B;PADB=24 - 8 - =:49I8=2384=5=3;=25=DB=2346D=D9=235<<:;3B==2383 583 BD ;:>:;384 23 <75:A5B= A:G2= 25>3 <DB4IA3; 57<D2D7 5B; 8D;3 =23 AD=D8<?<73 :B 8542 5B; B3G7:G3B= A5BB38J:=22:G24633;5B;95773B;DJB ' 23 ;8:>38 D9 =23 @I4 J54 3M5A:B3; 54 )% 5B; 23 ;36D43; =25= 23 J54 DB ;I=? 98DA D756I8 =D :H5?56I85=28DIG225;5<25B3>58:A@58G:8DI=3 B ( " *%' J23B 2:4 @I4 J54 835<23; 5= 25;5<25B := J54 5= ' 6 A 5B; =23B 23 68D<33;3; =D 3>58! :A@585G::775G35B;835<23;=2383@?' (6 A 423 J54 JD8C:BG :B =23 45A3 8DI=3 DB ( " *%' 23 <DA673=3; 2:4 ;I=? 5B; 835<23; :H5?56I85 3 9I8=238 ;36D43;=25=:B2:43B=:83438>:<323254BD=<5I43;5B? 5<<:;3B= 5B; 95743 <DA675:B= 254 @33B 9:73; 5G5:B4= 2:A 59=38%';5?498DA=235773G3;:B<:;3B= 2383:4BDB3MI4 @3=J33B2:4@I45B;=235<<:;3B= 39I8=2384=5=3;=25= 46D=D9=235<<:;3B=:4B35838=D=23D7:<3=5=:DB M % :4 =23 73==38 D9 =23 3;:<57 99:<38 25;5<25B M * :4 =23 <DA675:B= M % :4 =23 & 5B; M ' :4 =23 <258G3! - 9 - 4233=5B;546386D=525K58M (=2383J54B3G7:G3B<3 D9 =23 ;8:>38 D9 =23 @I4 :B <5I4:BG =23 5<<:;3B= )% 68D;I<3; =23 73==38 :44I3; @? =23 D<=D8 D9 25;5<25B 8:A58? 357=2 3B=83 5;;83443; =D =23 3<I8:=? 99:<38 3658=A3B= B=2345:;73==38:=J544=5=3;=25= <75:A5B= 5B=D42 <5A3 =D =23 2D46:=57 J:=2 5 2:4=D8? D9 8D5; =8599:< 5<<:;3B= DB ( " *%' 5B; 23 J54 5;>:43; 834= =:77 %$ $ *%' 4 638 M * N 73==38 D9 3;:<57 I638:B=3B;3B= D46:=57 23 J54 5;A:==3; :B D46:=57J:=22:4=D8?D9AD=D8<?<735<<:;3B= >3B :BM (N)DIB;38=:9:<5=3:=J544=5=3;54AD=D8<?<73 5<<:;3B= 75:A5B= J54 ;:4<258G3; 98DA =23 2D46:=57 DB *% ' *%' 23 :H5?56I85 :>:7 D46:=57 ;:; BD= 43B; =D =23 D7:<3 4 638 M L N <543!4233= D9 2D46:=57 :B=:A5=:DB J54 G:>3B =D =23 D7:<3 23 D86D85=:DB 4I@A:==3; =25= :B4I838 5B; DJB38 D9 =23 AD=D8<?<73J383BD=A5;354658=:345B;=2363=:=:DBJ54 7:5@73 =D @3 ;:4A:443; 9D8 BDB!HD:B;38 D9 =23 B3<34458? 658=:34 - 10 - # = :4 9D8 =23 DI8= =D 433 J23=238 =2383 :4 :B>D7>3A3B= D9 =23 @I4 @358:BG 83G:4=85=:DB D !*#&! %'"":B=235<<:;3B=;5=3;( " *%' ;A:==3;7?=2383 :4 ;375? D9 %$ ;5?4 :B 9:7:BG =23 <DA675:B= 2DIG2 :B M LN<543!4233=:B=:A5=:DBJ54G:>3B=D=23D7:<3=23? 25>3 BD= 83<D8;3; 4=5=3A3B= 5B; =23 :>:7 D46:=57 :H5?56I85 254 BD= 43B; =23 =D =23 D7:<3 3 J54 =835=3;:B43>38572D46:=574 =J544=5=3;=25=25;5<25B D7:<3J3B==D=23:>:7D46:=579D8=5C:BG<DA675:B=@?=23 <75:A5B= @? =25= =:A3 23 J54 BD= =2383 54 4I<2 =23? <DI7;BD=83G:4=38=23& L M ' :4 =23 73==38 98DA =23 >:775G384 D9 3>58 :A@58G::BJ2:<2:=:4463<:9:<577?4=5=3;@?=23>:775G384 =25= =2383 J54 BD 4I<2 5<<:;3B= :B =23:8 >:775G3 DB ( ' *%" M #:4=23DG!4233=M L:4=23)5?@:77 5B;)%:4=23;8:>38D9=23@I4J2D<73587?4=5=3;=25= 23<DA673=3;2:48DI=345937?J:=2DI=5B?5<<:;3B=DB=25= ;5? B95<=23254BD=<5I43;5B?5<<:;3B=:B2:43B=:83 =3BI83 :4 >384:DB :4 4I66D8=3; @? =23 >:775G384 D9 =23 - 11 - 3>58 :A@58G: = :4 9D8 =23 <75:A5B= =D 3M675:B =23 8354DB4 9D8 =23 ;375? :B 9:7:BG =23 <DA675:B= B 95<= <75:A5B=J54;:4<258G3;98DA=232D46:=57DB*' ' *%' 5B;54DB=23;5=3D9<DA675:B=23J54:B=232D46:=57 D ;DI@==23@I4@358:BG83G:4=85=:DBD !*#&!%'""J54 =23 DB7? @I4 :B =25=9:M3;8DI=3 98DA:H5?56I85 =DD=238 675<34@I==23;8:>384=5=3;=25=DB=25=;5?=2383J54BD 5<<:;3B= 5B; 23 <DA673=3; 2:4 ;I=? 5B; 835<23; :H5?56I85 45937? 3 574D 9:73; DG! DDC 54 M # 5B; )5? @:77 54 M L M :4 =23 >32:<73 658=:<I7584 98DA :H5?56I85 98DA 683>:DI4 DJB38 = J54 D@438>3; =25= =23 ;8:>38 D9 =23 @I4 D8 DJB38 D9 =23 @I4 254 BD= <25773BG3;=23<258G3!4233=9:73;5G5:B4==23A 423:4 (8;658=?=D=2368D<33;:BG423;:;BD=<25773BG3:= % B 5 <:=5=:DB 836D8=3; :B @3=J33B ! :=J54237;549D77DJ40 - 12 - ! " ! - 13 - ! # $%&'( &) & * & + , %% 23 DI8=4 42DI7; @3 <5I=:DI4 :B 5<<:;3B= <5434J23B=2383:4;:46I=383G58;:BG:B>D7>3A3B=D9=23 - 14 - >32:<73 B>:3JD9=235@D>345:;3M=85<=3;<:=5=:DB:=:4 9D8=235663775B=!<75:A5B==D68D>3=23B3MI4@3=J33B=23 5<<:;3B= 5B; =23 D993B;:BG >32:<73 23 <75:A5B= 4:A67? 4=5=3; =25= DB 3BOI:8? 23 <5A3 =D CBDJ =25= =23 @I4 @358:BG 83G:4=85=:DB D !*#&!%'"" :4 =23 DB7? @I4 :B =25=8DI=3 54 4I<2 23 :B9D8A3;=23 45A3 =D25;5<25B D7:<3 = :4 9D8 =23 D7:<3 =D 3BOI:83 J23=238 5<<:;3B= D<<I883; :B =23 >:775G3 DB =25= 658=:<I758 ;5? D8 J23=238 =2383J545B:B>D7>3A3B=D9=23@I4:B=2345:;5<<:;3B= D8 BD= B M ' =23 >:775G384 25>3 <73587? 4=5=3; =25= =2383 J54 BD 5<<:;3B= :B =23:8 >:775G3 DB =25= 658=:<I758 ;5? 23 B>34=:G5=:BG 99:<38 :4 BD= 3M5A:B3; @? =23 <75:A5B= 9D8 =23 8354DB @34= CBDJB =D 2:A 23839D83 =2:4DI8=9:B;4=25=:=:45<7358<543D995743:A67:<5=:DBD9 =23@I4 B=233587:38;D<IA3B=4:=J544:A67?4=5=3;:= J54 AD=D8<?<73 5<<:;3B= 5B; 54 5B 59=38 =2DIG2= =23? J3B= =D 5B 3M=3B= D9 :B>D7>:BG =23 @I4 D9 =23 :H5?56I85J:=2DI=5B?@54:4 - 15 - %* D ;DI@= =23 <75:A5B= 4I4=5:B3; G8:3>DI4 :BHI8:345B;IB;38GDB39:>34I8G38:34@I=:=:49D82:A=D 68D>3=235<<:;3B=5B;=23:B>D7>3A3B=D9=23@I4@39D83 <75:A:BG=23<DA63B45=:DB 2383:4>58:5=:DB:B=23;5=3 D95<<:;3B=A3B=:DB3;:B=23&5B;=23<258G3!4233=5B; := <5BBD= @3 4:A67? 8I73; DI= 54 =?6DG8562:<57 388D8 23839D83=2:4DI8=9:B;4=25==23<75:A5B=95:73;=D68D>3 =23 :B>D7>3A3B= D9 =23 >32:<73 54 4I<2 =23 :>:4:DB DB=8D7738D9:4BD=7:5@73=D65?=23<DA63B45=:DB %( B>:3JD9=235@D>3=239D77DJ:BG0 : 23 566357 :B & D *L(L**( 9:73; @? =23 D86D85=:DB :4 577DJ3; @? 43==:BG 54:;3=23D8;38D9=238:@IB57 - 16 - :: DB43OI3B=7? =23 566357 :B & D *(#'%**( 9:73; @? =23 <75:A5B= 254 BD A38:=5B;:=:45<<D8;:BG7?;:4A:443; ,) '& ( % :4=D 0%7D 0%