Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63511 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER v. TASLEEM BEGUM AND ORS
MFA/201157/2021 · 2025-11-20
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63511 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63511 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$"
#$ $! ""
%!& '(
"" )
%!&
'
(
! " #
"$%$ &
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! '
(
)
! $
&
(
' %
*
) ! ! *
% + %! " #
,% ! *
*)
-%%
+
&&!!&! !&-
- 3 -
! + + . )'
(
)
" #
! '
*
)
)
! $
(
' -
*
) ! ! *
% + %)
" #
- 4 -
/$%$ &
*)
-%-
+
&&!!&! + +
!&-
+
0+
0+
+
- 5 -
$
0+
1!&$*!&!234256789:;6
1<=1<>:21?>?7
1!&&( $!&!! 23 42567 89 :;6 @5>2A>?:3 B?76< 6@:21? *) 14 :;6 1:1< 6;2@563 @: -%% ;6<62?>4:6<<646<<67:1>3C:;6@:D41<3;1<:@;>556?E2?E :;6FB7EA6?:>?7>G><77>:67&&!!&!=>336789:;6 772:21?>5 6?21<
2H25 +B7E6 >?7 +
27>< 2? 1 !&-
! >@:3 E2H2?E <236 :1 :;6 4252?E 14 :;6 >==6>53 8<26459 3:>:67 ><6 :;>: 1? &$&!!&- >: >81B: $ $ =A :;6 76@6>367";>2I >5>A >3;> J >5>A >3;> @1A2?E :1G><73;23;1B364<1AB33:>?714>??>I;65521?;23 ?6G 63:<1 @11:9 1? ;23 =<1=6< 3276 >: :;>: :2A6 :;6 7<2H6<14:;6 B386><2?E6E23:<>:21? 1")%"
"% - 7<1H6 :;6 3>A6 4<1A 1==132:6 72<6@:21? 2? > <>3; >?7?6E52E6?:A>??6<G2:;1B:@1?:<15>?77>3;67>E>2?3:
:;6 76@6>367 3 > <63B5: 14 :;6 >41<63>27 >@@276?: :;6
- 6 -
76@6>367 3B3:>2?67 E<26H1B3 2?FB<263 >?7 3B@@BA867 :1 :;62?FB<2631?:;63=1:
) ;6 @5>2A>?:3 42567 > =6:2:21? B?76< 6@:21? (( 14 :;6 @: 366I2?E @1A=6?3>:21? 41< :;6 76>:; 14 :;6 76@6>367>51?EG2:;2?:6<63:
=1? 36<H2@6 14 ?1:2@6 :;6 <63=1?76?: >==6><67 :;<1BE; @1B?365 >?7 42567 G<2::6? 3:>:6A6?: 76?92?E :;6 >H6<A6?:3A>762?:;6@5>2A=6:2:21? $ ? :;6 8>323 14 :;6 =56>72?E3 14 :;6 =><:263 :;6 5>2A3<28B?>54<>A67:;6233B63>?7:;6<6>4:6<<6@1<767 :;6 6H276?@6 ;6 <28B?>5 89 2A=BE?67 FB7EA6?: >?7 >G><7;>3=><:59>551G67:;6@5>2A=6:2:21?>?7;657:;>: :;6 @5>2A>?:3 ><6 6?:2:567 :1 > @1A=6?3>:21? 14 3!)) &&&">51?EG2:;2?:6<63:>::;6<>:614-K=> >?772<6@:67:;6
1<=1<>:21?:176=132::;6@1A=6?3>:21? >A1B?:>51?EG2:;2?:6<63:62?E>EE<26H67:;6=<636?: >==6>53;>H6866?42567
- 7 -
( ;6 56><?67 @1B?365 41< :;6
1<=1<>:21? ;>3 <>2367 :;641551G2?E@1?:6?:21?3
> 2<3:59 :;6 >@@276?: 1@@B<<67 7B6 :1 :;6 ?6E52E6?@6 14 :;6 76@6>367 ;2A3654 ;6? :;6 76@6>367 :<267:11H6<:>I6:;68B34<1A:;6564:3276;6465571G? >?7 3B3:>2?67 E<26H1B3 2?FB<263 >?7 3B@@BA867 :1 :;6 2?FB<263 ;6 1446?72?E H6;2@56 G>3 ?1: 2?H15H67 2? :;6 >@@276?: H6? >3 =6< :;6 <6=1<: ?1 7>A>E63 G6<6 41B?71?:;61446?72?EH6;2@56;6<28B?>51?591?:;6 8>323 14 :;6 @;><E6 3;66: 42567 >E>2?3: :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 1446?72?EH6;2@56 ;>3;657:;>::;67<2H6<14:;68B3G>3 ?6E52E6?: 2? @>B32?E :;6 >@@276?: H6? :;6 @;><E6 3;66:
42567 >E>2?3: :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 1446?72?E H6;2@56 @56><59 723@51363:;>::;676@6>367>4:6<3662?E:;68B33B776?59 >==5267:;68<>I6:23H6<9@56><:;>::;676@6>367G>3 6?:6<2?E :;6 A>2?
<1>7 >?7 3B776?59 >==5267 :;6 8<>I6 3:1==67:;63@11:6<>?7465571G?;68B3=>332?E1?:;6 ;2E;G>97>3;67:;6A1:1<@9@56>?7;63B446<67:;62?FB<9 ;6 <28B?>5 G2:;1B: @1?3276<2?E :;636 >3=6@:3 14 :;6
- 8 -
A>::6< ;>3 6<<67 2? ;1572?E :;>: :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 8B3 >51?6G>3?6E52E6?:2?@>B32?E:;6>@@276?: 8 6@1?759 :;6 @5>2A>?:3 >336<: :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 >E67 >81B: ! 96><3 >: :;6 :2A6 14 :;6 >@@276?: >?7 ;>7 > A1?:;59 2?@1A6 14 3!$&&&" 89 G1<I2?E >3 > 7<2H6< 1 =<1H6 :;6 3>A6 @5>2A>?:3 ;>H6 =<17B@67:;656::6<233B6789!>3=6<L&L@6=: :;>::;69;>H6?1:=<17B@67>?98>?I3:>:6A6?::13;1G :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 6><?2?E 3!$&&&" =6< A1?:;
1?36MB6?:59 :;6 <28B?>5 ;>3 @1<<6@:59 >3363367 :;6 2?@1A614:;676@6>367?1:21?>559 @ ;2<759 1? >==<6@2>:21? 14 1<>5 >?7 71@BA6?:><9 6H276?@6 >?7 @1?3276<2?E :;6 >E6 >?7 >H1@>:21? 14 :;6 76@6>367 :;6 1H6<>55 @1A=6?3>:21? >G><767:1:;6<28B?>5231?;2E;6<3276 7 >3:592?52E;:14:;62H2321?6?@;76@2321?14 :;23
1B<: 2? :;6 @>36 14 $ *! !! $%-(!&%
- 9 -
! %!&!&:;6<>:6142?:6<63:>G><76789:;6<28B?>5>: -K=>231?:;6;2E;6<3276 2:; :;6 >81H6 @1?:6?:21?3 :;6 56><?67 @1B?365 31BE;::1723A233:;6>==6>54256789:;6@5>2A>?:3 * ? :;6 1:;6< ;>?7 :;6 56><?67 @1B?365 41< :;6 @5>2A>?:3;>3<>2367:;641551G2?E@1B?:6<"@1?:6?:21?3
> 2<3:59 :;6 >@@276?: ;>3 1@@B<<67 7B6 :1 :;6 ?6E52E6?@6 14 7<2H6< 14 :;6 B3 AA672>:659 >4:6< :;6 >@@276?: > @1A=5>2?: ;>3 866? 517E67 >E>2?3: :;6 7<2H6< 14:;68B3;6152@6>4:6<:;1<1BE;2?H63:2E>:21?42567> @;><E6 3;66: >E>2?3: :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;68B3 ;6 7<2H6<14 :;6 8B3 ?62:;6< 42567 >?9 @1A=5>2?: ?1< @;>556?E67 :;6 @;><E6 3;66: 42567 >E>2?3: ;2A B<:;6< G;6? :;6 76@6>367G>36?:6<2?E:;6A>2?<1>7>4:6<1836<H2?E:;6 H6;2@56 =>332?E 1? :;6 A>2? <1>7 :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 8B3 7<1H6 :;6 3>A6 G2:; ;2E; 3=667 >?7 2? > <>3; >?7 ?6E52E6?:A>??6<7>3;67>E>2?3::;6A1:1<@9@56B6:1 2A=>@::;676@6>367465571G?>?73B3:>2?672?FB<263>?7 3B@@BA867:1:;62?FB<263;6<641<6<28B?>5;>3<2E;:59
- 10 -
;657:;>:7<2H6<14:;68B3>51?6G>3?6E52E6?:2?@>B32?E :;6>@@276?:
8 6@1?759 6H6? :;1BE; :;6 @5>2A>?:3 @5>2A67 :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 G1<I2?E >3 7<2H6< >?7 6><?2?E 3!$&&&"=6<A1?:;>?7=<17B@677<2H2?E52@6?@6>3=6< L->?76L>A2?67:;66A=5196<>3"!:;6<28B?>5 ;>3 :>I6? :;6 ?1:21?>5 2?@1A6 >3 A6<659 >3 3)&&&" =A @ ;2<759 @1?3276<2?E :;6 >E6 >?7 >H1@>:21? 14 :;6 76@6>367 :;6 1H6<>55 @1A=6?3>:21? >G><767 89 :;6 <28B?>5232?>76MB>:6>?71?:;651G6<3276 2:; :;6 >81H6 @1?:6?:21?3 :;6 56><?67 @1B?365 31BE;::1>551G:;6>==6>54256789:;6@5>2A>?:3 % 6><7 :;6 56><?67 @1B?365 41< :;6 =><:263 >?7 =6<B367:;6FB7EA6?:>?7>G><714:;6<28B?>5
- ;6 @>36 14 :;6 @5>2A>?:3 23 :;>: 1? &$&!!&- >:
>81B: $ $ =A :;6 76@6>367";>2I >5>A >3;> J
- 11 -
>5>A>3;>@1A2?E:1G><73;23;1B364<1AB33:>?714 >??>I;65521?;23?6G63:<1@11:91?;23=<1=6<3276 >: :;>: :2A6 :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 B3 86><2?E 6E23:<>:21?
1")%""% - 7<1H6 :;6 3>A6 4<1A 1==132:672<6@:21?2?><>3;>?7?6E52E6?:A>??6<G2:;1B:
@1?:<15 >?7 7>3;67 >E>2?3: :;6 76@6>367 3 > <63B5: 14 :;6 >41<63>27 >@@276?: :;6 76@6>367 3B3:>2?67 E<26H1B3 2?FB<263>?73B@@BA867:1:;62?FB<2631?:;63=1:
& ;6@5>2A>?:;>36L>A2?67;6<3654>33;6;>3 <62:6<>:67:;63:>:6A6?:A>762?:;6@5>2A=6:2:21??76< :;6 1:1< 6;2@563 @: 2? :;6 @5>2A =6:2:21? 8641<6 :;6 5>2A3<28B?>5:;63:>?7><714=<11423AB@;8651G:;>? G;>: 23 <6MB2<67 2? > @<2A2?>5 @>36 >3 G655>3 2? :;6 @2H25 @>36 171B8:8641<6:;6<28B?>5:;6<6AB3:8631A6 A>:6<2>5 1? :;6 8>323 14 G;2@; :;6 <28B?>5 @>? ><<2H6 1< 76@276 :;2?E3 ?6@633><9 :1 76@276 41< >G><72?E @1A=6?3>:21?8B::;6<28B?>523?1:6L=6@:67:1:>I61< :1>71=:>?2@6:914>@2H251<@<2A2?>5@>364:6<>552:23> 3BAA><96?MB2<9>?72:23:;656E235>:21?41<:;6G654><614
- 12 -
:;61@26:9;6=<1@6672?E3B?76<:;61:1<6;2@563@:
><6 ?1: >I2? :1 :;6 =<1@6672?E3 B?76< @2H25 <B563 6?@6 3:<2@:<B563146H276?@6><6?1:<6MB2<67:18641551G672? :;23<6E><7?:;6@>3614 !"# :;61?D856=6L
1B<:;>3;657>3;6<62?8651G
! " # ! $
!# #
#
! ! ## # ! !! #
!! ! ! !! %
- 13 -
AA672>:659>4:6<:;6>@@276?::;6@1A=5>2?:>3 =6<L!;>3 866? 517E67 >E>2?3: :;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 8B3 ;6 152@6 <6E23:6<67 >? >3 =6< L >?7 7<6G :;6 >@;>?>A> >3 L) >?7 42567 > <1BE;
3I6:@;>3=6<L 4:6<:;1<1BE;2?H63:2E>:21?:;6 152@642567>@;><E63;66:>3=6<L*1723=<1H6 :;6 6H276?@6 14 @5>2A>?:3 :;6 <63=1?76?: 6L>A2?67 :;6 7<2H6< >3 " 6 76=1367 :;>: G;6? ;6 G>3 A1H2?E:;68B3H6<9351G59>::;63=66714&IA :;676@6>367:<267:11H6<:>I6:;68B34<1A564:3276 >?7465571G?>?73B3:>2?672?FB<263>?73B@@BA867:1 2?FB<263 ! 6;>H6E1?6:;<1BE;:;6@1A=5>2?:3=6<:;6 @1A=5>2?:2:23H6<9@56><:;>:76@6>367G>36?:6<2?E :1:;6;2E;G>9261A8>9:1976<>8>7
"($;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 8B3 @1A2?E 4<1A BA>?>8>7 3276 ;>3 :>I6? 6L:<6A6 <2E;: 3276 >?7 7>3;67 >E>2?3: :;6 A1:1<@9@56 H6? :;6 <1BE; 3I6:@; =<6=><67 89 :;6
- 14 -
152@6 >3 =6< L 723@51363 :;>: :;6 76@6>367 ;>7 6?:6<672?:1:;6A>2?<1>7>?78B3;>3@>A6:1:;6 6L:<6A6<2E;:3276>?77>3;67>E>2?3::;6A1:1<@9@56 ;6 <6=1<: =<17B@67 >3 L% 723@51363 :;>: :;6<6><6?1>?9H2328567>A>E631?81:;:;6H6;2@563 ) ?:;6@;><E63;66:4256789:;6152@6>E>2?3::;6 7<2H6<14:;68B32:23>531723@51367:;>::;676@6>367 G>3 6?:6<2?E 2?:1 :;6 ;2E;G>9 >?7 >: :;>: :2A6 :;6 8B3@>A62?;2E;3=667>?7@1A6:1:;66L:<6A6<2E;: 3276>?7@>A6:1:;6G<1?E3276>?77>3;67>E>2?3:
:;6 A1:1<@9@56 ;256 E12?E :;<1BE; :;6 @1A=5>2?: @;><E63;66:A>=<6=1<:>?7>?@;>?>A> 2:23H6<9@56><:;>::;676@6>367G>3>5316?:6<2?E:;6 A>2? <1>7 G2:;1B: 3662?E :;6 H6;2@563 G;2@; G6<6 =>332?E :;<1BE; :;6 ;2E;G>9 ;6 7<2H6< 14 :;6 8B3 G>3 >531 @1A2?E ;2E; 3=667 >?7 2? > <>3; >?7 ?6E52E6?: A>??6< >?7 @1A6 6L:<6A6 <2E;: 3276 >?7 7>3;67>E>2?3::;6A1:1<@9@561G6H6<:;67<2H6<14
- 15 -
:;68B:;>3?1:@;>556?E67:;6@;><E63;66:>?7;>3 ?1: 42567 >?9 @1A=5>2?: 4:6< E12?E :;<1BE; :;636 6H276?@631?<6@1<72:>==6><3:;>:81:;:;67<2H6<14 :;6 8B3 >?7 :;6 76@6>367 G6<6 @1?:<28B:67 :1 :;6 >@@276?:;67<2H6<14:;68B3;>3@1?:<28B:67:1>?
6L:6?:14%&K:1 :;6 >@@276?:>?7 :;6 76@6>367;>3 @1?:<28B:67:1>?6L:6?:14!&K:1:;6>@@276?: +"
;6 @5>2A>?:3 @5>2A67 :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 G1<I2?E>37<2H6<>?76><?2?E3!$&&&"=6<A1?:;>?7 =<17B@67 :;6 7<2H2?E 52@6?@6 >3 =6< L- >?7 6L>A2?67 :;66A=5196<>3"!:;66A=5196<14:;676@6>367>?7 =<17B@67 :;6 56::6<"L& :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 =>92?E 3!$&&&" 9 @1?3276<2?E >55 :;636 71@BA6?:3 2: 23 ?1: 723=B:67 :;>: :;6 76@6>367 G>3 G1<I2?E>37<2H6<
1?3276<2?E:;6>E6>?7>H1@>:21? 14 :;6 76@6>367 G6 ><6 14 :;6 1=2?21? :;>: :;6 A1?:;592?@1A614:;676@6>367;>3:186>3363367>:
- 16 -
3(&&&" ;6 <28B?>5 ;>3 <2E;:59 @1?3276<67 :;6 >E6 14 :;6 76@6>367 >3 96><3 1 :;6 >41<63>27 2?@1A6 !$K ;>3 :1 86 >7767 1? >@@1B?: 14 4B:B<6 =<13=6@:32?H26G14:;65>G5>2771G?89:;6
1?3:2:B:21? 6?@;14:;6B=<6A6
1B<:2? ," -
. ;B3 :;6 A1?:;59 2?@1A6 @1A63 :1 3!&&&&" 3(&&&" N !$K 2?@6 :;6<6 ><6 62E;: 76=6?76?:32:23>==<1=<2>:6:1767B@:$:;14:;62?@1A6 14:;676@6>367:1G><73=6<31?>56L=6?363>?7<6A>2?2?E >A1B?:;>3:186:>I6?>3;23@1?:<28B:21?:1:;64>A259 ;676@6>367G>3>E67>81B: 96><3>::;6:2A614:;6 >@@276?:>?7AB5:2=526<>==52@>856:1;23>E6E<1B=23C D ;B3 :;6 @5>2A>?:3 ><6 6?:2:567 :1 @1A=6?3>:21? 14 / )00' 3!&&&&O!O O $ 1? >@@1B?: 14 C51331476=6?76?@9D $ ? >772:21? :;6 @5>2A>?:3 ><6 6?:2:567 :1 @1A=6?3>:21? 14 /' 1? >@@1B?: 14 C5133 14 63:>:6D >?7 @1A=6?3>:21? 14 /' 1? >@@1B?: 14
- 17 -
C4B?6<>56L=6?363D
5>2A>?: 1G24614:;676@6>36723 6?:2:56741<@1A=6?3>:21?14/'B?76<:;6;6>7 1405133143=1B3>5@1?31<:2BA0 ( ?H26G14:;65>G5>2771G?89:;6B=<6A6
1B<:2? :;6@>3614* ! - 0 $ 0 . @5>2A>?: 13! :1 * @;257<6?14:;676@6>367><66?:2:56741<@1A=6?3>:21?14 /' 6>@; B?76< :;6 ;6>7 14 C5133 14 =><6?:>5 @1?31<:2BAD>?7@5>2A>?: 1%=><6?:14:;676@6>36723 6?:2:56741<@1A=6?3>:21?14/'6>@;B?76<:;6 ;6>714C5133144252>5@1?31<:2BAD * ;B3 :;6 @5>2A>?:3 ><6 6?:2:567 :1 :;6 41551G2?E @1A=6?3>:21? 1234/56748493: 973:346359/ 184674 %/& 1331476=6?76?@9 !(%%&&& B?6<>56L=6?363 $&&& 1331463:>:6 $&&&
- 18 -
133143=1B3>5@1?31<:2BA &&&& 13314><6?:>5@1?31<:2BA ! &&&& 13314252>5@1?31<:2BA &&&& 65; <<0'
% ?:;6<63B5::;641551G2?E1<76<23=>3367
> ;6>==6>53><65;;=397425:6 8 ;6FB7EA6?:14:;6
5>2A3<28B?>523A1724267 @ ;6@5>2A>?:3><66?:2:567:1>:1:>5@1A=6?3>:21?14 /<<0'>3>E>2?3:3!)) &&&">G><767 89:;6<28B?>5 7 1551G2?E:;6FB7EA6?:14:;62H2321?6?@;14:;23 1B<: 2? :;6 @>36 14 >$ ? 3B=<> :;62?:6<63:>:-K=>233@>56771G?:1(K 6 ;6
1<=1<>:21? 23 72<6@:67 :1 76=132: %&K 14 :;6 @1A=6?3>:21?>A1B?:>51?EG2:;2?:6<63:>:(K=> 4<1A :;6 7>:6 14 4252?E 14 :;6 @5>2A =6:2:21? :255 :;6
- 19 -
7>:614<6>52P>:21?G2:;2?>=6<2171432LG66I34<1A :;67>:614<6@62=:14>@1=914:;23FB7EA6?: 4 ;6 >==1<:21?A6?: 76=132: >?7 <656>36 14 >A1B?:
3;>55 86 A>76 2? >@@1<7>?@6 G2:; :;6 :6<A3 14 :;6 >G><714:;6<28B?>5 E A1B?:2?76=132:231<76<67:186:<>?346<<67:1:;6 <28B?>5
9' %"& $
9' % $! & $
23: 15 1 &