- 1 - ! " #$ % $$ $& '()'*'+*, (' ** - ! !" #$ !! % &" ' ! ("" ! ! ) ! !! ("""! % &*!' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ( #+,&' ) ( ! * ( ( # #,!!( * * $ # ! )!* ! ( ! (( ! # , ( ** + ! * ( (!! )* ! * ! -*** &! -***' ./ 0/121234/56 7/248 9::;6/< 36 94< 24 3#, 34 1./ =2>/ 3= 1./ >/954/< .2/= ;<2:29> *98261591/ 9<98252 ?=35 6.351 @1./ 529> 3;51AB 95/ 2C0;84248 1./ D;<8C/41 3= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ <91/< # :34E2:1248 1./C =35 1./ 3==/4:/;4</5/:1234#0;426.97>/;4</5/:1234,&9'&22' 3= 1./ 66/4129> 3CC3<212/6 :1 + ?=35 6.351 @1./ - 3 - :1AB94<6/41/4:24813;4</58362C0>/2C052634C/41 =35 34/ F/95 94< 13 09F =24/ 3= 6 /9:. G21. </=9;>16/41/4:/G.2:.G96:34=25C/<2452C249>00/9> 3#341./=2>/3=1./>/954/< 26152:194</662346 ;<8/9<98252?=356.351@1./(256100/>>91/3;51ABE2</ D;<8C/41<91/<$ (9:16 3= 1./ :96/ 24 752/= 95/ 1.91 1./ 3= 9<98252 3>2:/ 191234 5/:/2E/< :5/<27>/ 24=35C91234 5/895<248 159460351248 C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 C/941 13 7/ <261527;1/< ;4</5 1./ )3C/4 94< .2>< )/>=95/ :./C/ ./ G/41 13 1./ 6031 9>348 G21. 094:.96 !/ =3;4< 9::;6/< 3 <52E248 1./ 9;13 52:H6.9G G21. =2E/ 0>9612: 7986 :341924248 C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 G.2:. G/5/ C/941 =35 <261527;1234 ;4</5 )3C/4 94<.2>< )/>=95/ :./C/ 4 /4I;25248 9::;6/< 3 24=35C/< 1.91 ./ 9>348 G21. 9::;6/< 3 053:;5/< 1.36/ C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 94< G/5/ 053://<248 13 </>2E/5 1./C 13 9::;6/< 3# ./ 9::;6/<G/5/431.9E24894FE9>2<<3:;C/41613159460351 1./C2>H03G</509:H/1694<1./5/7F1./F.9E/:3CC211/< - 4 - 1./ 3==/4:/ ;4</5 /:1234 # 0;426.97>/ ;4</5 /:1234 , &9'&22'3=:1./C2>H03G</509:H/16G/5/6/2J/< ;4</5 1./ 6/2J;5/ C9.9J95 K 1./ 5/0351 G96 6;7C211/<131./03>2:/960/5K 41./796263=1./ 69C/(960/5K#:9C/137/5/8261/5/<94<9=1/5 24E/612891234:.958/6.//1:9C/137/=2>/< # ./ >/954/< *98261591/ 133H :3842J94:/ 3= 1./ 3==/4:/ ::;6/< .9E/ 900/95/< 7/=35/ 1./ 529> 3;51 0>/9</< 431 8;2>1F 94< :>92C/< 13 7/ 152/< ./ 0536/:;1234/K9C24/<)613$94<831C95H/<K6 13 24 6;00351 3= 216 :341/41234 ./ 9::;6/< .9E/ </42/< 9>> 1./ 24:52C2491248 C91/529>6 34 5/:35< 24 1./25 6191/C/41;4</5/:1234##3=57;1.9E/431>/< 94F/E2</4:/246;003513=1./25</=/4:/./529>3;51 9=1/5 19H248 2413 :3462</591234 9>> 1./6/ C91/529>6 34 5/:35< :9C/ 13 1./ :34:>;6234 1.91 1./ 0536/:;1234 26 6;::/66=;> 24 053E248 1./ 8;2>1 3= 1./ 9::;6/< 7/F34< 5/963497>/<3;71=351./3==/4:/0;426.97>/;4</5/:1234 # 0;426.97>/ ;4</5 /:1234 , &9' &22' 3= 1./ :1 - 5 - ::35<248>F0966/<1./2C0;84/<D;<8C/413=:34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ /248 98852/E/< 7F 1./ 69C/ 9::;6/< 36 94< .9E/ 05/=/55/< 52C249> 00/9> 3# 7/=35/ 1./ (2561 00/>>91/ 3;51 ./ (2561 00/>>91/ 3;51 34 5/9005/:291234 3= 1./ C91/529>6 34 5/:35<<26C266/<1./900/9>7F:34=25C2481./2C0;84/< D;<8C/41 3= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ 0966/< 7F 1./ 529> 3;51 /248 98852/E/< 7F 1./ 69C/ 9::;6/< 3694<95/7/=35/1.263;51 !/95< 52 9H9 >/954/< :3;46/> =35 1./ 0/121234/56 94< C1 5912 912> >/954/< !28. 3;51 3E/54C/41 >/9</5 =35 1./ 5/6034</41191/ /5;6/< 1./C91/529>6345/:35<24:>;<248529>3;5194<00/>>91/ 3;515/:35<6 4 E2/G 3= 1./ 52E9> :341/412346 ;58/< 7F 1./ >/954/<:3;46/>=35731.1./09512/61./032411.91G3;>< 9526/=35CF:3462</59123426 - 6 - *F 946G/5 13 1./ 973E/ 03241 26 =351./=3>>3G248 $ 1 26 1./ :341/41234 3= 1./ 0536/:;1234 1.91 9::;6/< 3 G96 159460351248 0>9612: 7986 :341924248 C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 G.2:. G/5/ C/941 =35 <261527;1234 ;4</5)3C/494<.2><)/>=95/:./C/G21.3;194FE9>2< <3:;C/416 94< 1./5/7F :3CC211/< 1./ 3==/4:/ 1 G96 9::;6/<3G.3266191/<13.9E/C/41234/<1./49C/ 3= 9::;6/< 3 1.91 ./ G96 9>63 G21. 9::;6/< 3 24 053:;5248 6;:. C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 94< G/5/ G2>>248 13 6;00>F 13 9::;6/< 3# *F 911/41234 G96 <59G4 13 1./ D;<8C/41 <91/< $ 0966/< 24 52C249> 00/9> 3#341./=2>/3=1./>/954/< 26152:194</662346 ;<8/ 9<98252 G./5/ 9::;6/< 3# .9< :.9>>/48/< 1./ - 7 - 2C0;84/< D;<8C/41 3= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ 0966/< 7F 1./ 529> 3;51 ./ 692< 900/9> :9C/ 13 7/ 9>>3G/< 1./ 2C0;84/< D;<8C/41 3= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3=6/41/4:/G966/1962</94<9::;6/<3#G969:I;211/< =351./973E/692<3==/4:/ , 3G 21 26 1./ :341/41234 3= 1./ >/954/< :3;46/> =351./0/121234/561.911./5/95/9763>;1/>F43C91/529>6 /E/4 9892461 9::;6/< 3 /K:/01 1./ 69F 3= 9::;6/< 3 !/4:/ 1./ 7/4/=21 3= 9:I;2119> 82E/4 13 9::;6/< 3#6.3;><.9E/7//4/K1/4</<139::;6/<396G/>> =24< :3462</597>/ =35:/ 24 1./ :341/41234 19H/4 7F 1./ >/954/<:3;46/>=351./0/121234/56./5/269763>;1/>F43 31./5 C91/529>6 0>9:/< 34 5/:35< 7F 1./ 0536/:;1234 13 91159:1/:1234#94<,3=:198924619::;6/<3 1 G96 1./ 69F 3= 9::;6/< 3 13 1./ 24=35C941 )# G.2:. C9</ 1./ 0536/:;1234 13 0536/:;1/ 9::;6/< 3 )./46;:.7/4/=21G96/K1/4</<139::;6/<3#<3431 =24< 94F 5/9634 =35 1./ (2561 00/>>91/ 3;51 13 5/D/:1 - 8 - 62C2>95 5/>2/= 13 9::;6/< 3 ./5/=35/ 9C 3= 1./ 30242341.919::;6/<3269>63/4121>/<=356;:.7/4/=21 /895<248 1./ 3==/4:/ :3CC211/< 7F 9::;6/< 3 1./5/ 95/ 6;==2:2/41 C91/529>6 13 :346121;1/ 1./ 3==/4:/ !/ G96 1./ <52E/5 3= 1./ 9;13 52:H6.9G 24 I;/61234 G./5/ 1./ C2>H 03G</5 09:H/16 C/941 =35 <261527;1234;4</5)3C/494<.2><)/>=95/:./C/G/5/ 7/248159460351/<!/.9<435/963497>//K0>9491234=35 1./ 69C/ ./ 0536/:;1234 26 6;::/66=;> 24 053E248 1./ 8;2>13=9::;6/<3./5/=35/./26>297>/=35:34E2:1234 + .9E/834/1.53;8.1./2C0;84/<D;<8C/413= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ 0966/< 9892461 9::;6/< 3 ./ 529> 3;51 .96 0530/5>F 9005/:291/< 1./ C91/529>6345/:35<94<.969552E/<919528.1:34:>;6234 <3 431 =24< 94F 5/9634 13 241/5=/5/ G21. 1./ 69C/ ::35<248>F 946G/5 1./ 973E/ 03241 @0951>F 24 1./ 9==25C912E/A94<053://<1309661./=3>>3G248 - 9 - &2' .//E26234/12123426 &22' ./ /E26234 /121234 =2>/< 7F 0/121234/5 39::;6/<326./5/7F &222' ./ /E26234 /121234 =2>/< 7F 0/121234/5 39::;6/<326 &2E' ./ D;<8C/41 3= :34E2:1234 94< 35</5 3= 6/41/4:/ <91/< # 0966/< 7F 1./ >/954/< .2/= ;<2:29> *98261591/ 9<98252 96 9892461 9::;6/< 3 26 ./5/7F &E' 346/I;/41>F0/121234/539::;6/<3 269:I;211/<3=1./3==/4:/;4</5/:1234# 0;426.97>/ ;4</5 /:1234 , &9' &22' 3= 1./ :1 &E2' 92>734</K/:;1/<2=94F7F9::;6/<3 6194<6:94:/>>/< - 10 - &E22' (24/9C3;41092<2=94F6.9>>7/5/=;4</< 139::;6/<334<;/2</412=2:91234 /82615F26<25/:1/<136/4<79:H1./529>3;5194< 00/>>91/3;515/:35<69>348G21.:30F3=1.26D;<8C/41 =3524=35C9123494<=354//<=;>9:1234 ., '$$* % )" 2613>3#, "