- 1 - !"#"" "$$ %&%'$() *%(( + !"" # $ % && ' ( !" # $ "" ( )*#&$ ( " " ( + &, " "" , + ( ,, " ( &, "" ( ( ' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - - #" #" -$ ./ 011/22034 5/637 4./ 89:12063034 63 9&, 93 4./ ;62/ 9; 4./ 2/0<3/= ==6469302 6>62 ?=7/ 03= ( 0205?<076 @;9< A.9<4 B4./ <602 9?<4CD 6A 6:1?73637 4./ E?=7:/34 =04/= &, 10AA/= 63 <6:6302 11/02 9, 93 4./ ;62/ 9; 4./ 2/0<3/= ==6469302 6A4<684 03= /AA693A ?=7/ 0205?<076@;9<A.9<4B4./(6<A411/2204/9?<4CD0229F637 4./ 011/02 03= A/44637 0A6=/ 4./ E?=7:/34 9; 893>684693 03= 9<=/< 9; A/34/38/ =04/= ,, 10AA/= 5G 4./ <602 9?<4 03= 08H?644637 4./ 088?A/= ;9< 4./ 9;;/38/ 1?36A.052/ ?3=/< /84693 ) 9; /7946052/ 3A4<?:/34A 84@;9<A.9<4B4./84CD ./ ;084A 9; 4./ 80A/ 63 5<6/; 0</ 4.04 4./ 011/22034 0A 89:12063034 ;62/= 4./ 1<6>04/ 89:120634 07063A4 4./ </A193=/34088?A/= 022/7637 89::6AA693 9; - 3 - 4./9;;/38/1?36A.052/?3=/</84693)9;8446A 4./8934/346939;4./89:120630344.044./088?A/=6A4./ =6A4<65?49<;9<62I0:02"20A468A6:64/=03=6A<?336374./ 5?A63/AA 63 4./ 30:/ 03= A4G2/ 9; J ?8.030226K 04 .9FI06390=0205?<076./088?A/=F0A63 3//= 9; :93/G 03= ./ 011<908./= 4./ 89:12063034 ./ 89:12063034 2/34 03 0:9?34 9; A 49 4./ 088?A/= ./ 088?A/= 07<//= 49 </10G 4./ A0:/ 93 ), * 03= 0889<=6372G 6AA?/= 4./ 8./H?/ L" ;9< A =04/= ), * './3 4./ 8./H?/ F0A 1</A/34/= ;9< /380A.:/34 93 ), * 4./ A0:/ F0A</4?<3/==6A.939?</=0AB0889?34829A/=C ) /702 39468/ F0A 6AA?/= 49 4./ 088?A/= 63;9<:637059?4=6A.939?<9;4./8./H?/03=8022637?193 .6: 49 </10G 4./ 8./H?/ 0:9?34 3A164/ 9; A/<>68/ 9; 39468/4./088?A/=.0=394</106=4./8./H?/0:9?3403= 4./</5G 89::644/= 4./ 9;;/38/ 1?36A.052/ ?3=/< /84693 ) 9; 84 /38/ 4./ 89:12063034 </H?/A4/= 4./ - 4 - <6029?<44940I/89736M038/9;4./9;;/38/03=40I/2/702 084693 & ./ <602 9?<4 499I 89736M038/ 9; 4./ 9;;/38/ 03= </76A4/</= 9&, 88?A/= .0A 011/0</= 5/;9</ 4./ <602 9?<4 12/0=/= 394 7?624G 03= 8206:/= 49 5/4<6/=./89:12063034/L0:63/=.6:A/2;0A"'794 /L0:63/= "' 03= 794 :0<I/= LA" 49 " 63 A?119<49;.6A8934/34693./088?A/=.0A=/36/=0224./ 638<6:6304637 :04/<602A 0>062052/ 93 </89<= 63 .6A A404/:/34?3=/</84693))9;<"03=.0A/L0:63/= .6:A/2; 0A ' ./ <602 9?<4 0;4/< 40I637 6349 893A6=/<04693 022 4./A/ :04/<602A 93 </89<= 80:/ 49 4./ 89382?A693 4.04 4./ 89:12063034 6A A?88/AA;?2 63 1<9>637 4./7?624 9; 4./ 088?A/=;9<4./9;;/38/1?36A.052/ ?3=/< /84693 ) 9; 84 5/G93= </0A93052/ =9?54 889<=6372G4./088?A/=F0A893>684/=03=A/34/38/=5G 4./<6029?<4 - 5 - /637 077<6/>/= 5G 4./ A0:/ 088?A/= 1</;/<</= 03011/02 63 <6:630211/02 9, ./ (6<A4 11/2204/ 9?<4 93 </011</8604693 9; 4./ :04/<602A 93</89<=80:/494./89382?A6934.044./89:120630346A 394A?88/AA;?2631<9>6374./7?6249;4./088?A/=5/G93= </0A93052/ =9?54 889<=6372G 0229F/= 4./ 011/02 03= 08H?644/=4./088?A/=/637077<6/>/=5G4./A0:/4./ 89:120630346A5/;9</4.6A9?<4 /0<= <6 07026 2/0<3/= 89?3A/2 ;9< 4./ 011/22034 03= <6 0370<I6 2/0<3/= 89?3A/2 ;9< 4./ </A193=/34 "/<?A/= 4./ :04/<602A 6382?=637 4./ <602 9?<403=11/2204/9?<4</89<=A * 3 >6/F 9; 4./ <6>02 8934/34693A ?<7/= 5G 4./ 2/0<3/=89?3A/2;9<4./10<46/A4./196344.04F9?2=0<6A/ ;9<:G893A6=/<046936A - 6 - G03AF/<494./059>/196346A634./BC;9< 4./;9229F637 46A 4./ A1/86;68 8934/34693 9; 4./ 89:12063034 0A 1/< 4./ 89:120634 4.04 4./ 088?A/= F0A <?33637 5?A63/AA 63 4./ 30:/ 03= A4G2/ 9; J ?8.030226K 04 0205?<076 (9< 4./ 1?<19A/ 9; .6A 5?A63/AA ./ F0A 63 3//=9;:93/G03=</H?/A4/=4./89:12063034492/3=4./ 0:9?34889<=6372G./2/346488?A/=07<//=49</10G 4./A0:/93), *03=0889<=6372G4./8./H?/L" F0A6AA?/=/036374./</5G044./46:/9;2/3=6374./ 0:9?34 9; A 4./ 8./H?/ 63 H?/A4693 F0A 6AA?/= 03= 64 F0A 1</A/34/= ;9< /380A.:/34 93 ), * 6/ 4./ =04/ 4./ 8./H?/ F0A 5/0<637 ?4 A4<037/2G394.637.0A5//3A404/=634./2/70239468/L" ) </70<=637 2/3=637 9; 4./ 0:9?34 03= 6AA?038/ 9; 4./ 8./H?/ 93 4./ =04/ 9; 2/3=637 9; 4./ 0:9?34 9:12063034 1208/A </26038/ 93 L" 4./ 2/44/< =04/= - 7 - ), *A06=49.0>/5//36AA?/=5G4./088?A/=A 1/<4.6A2/44/<29039;AF0A954063/=5G4./ 088?A/= ;9< 4./ 1?<19A/ 9; .6A 5?A63/AA 93/ :934. 508I 6/93) *03=4./8./H?/L"F0A6AA?/=93 ), * F.68. 6A 8934<0<G 49 4./ 8934/34693 40I/3 5G 4./ 89:12063034 63 4./ 89:120634 F./</ ./ A404/A 4.04 F.62/ 0>062637 4./ 2903 9; A 4./ 088?A/= 07<//=49</10G4./A0:/93), *03=0889<=6372G 6AA?/= 4./ 8./H?/ L" :/34693637 4./ =04/ 0A ), * , ?<637 8<9AA/L0:6304693 9; "' 4./ 89:12063034A404/A4.04./6A07/=&G/0<A./088?A/= 6A.6A;<6/3=A638/)G/0<AA1/<4./</89<=A4./07/9; 4./088?A/=6A932G)&G/0<A./30:/9;4./088?A/=6A :/34693/= 0A 0E? 0260A 070<0E 5?4 "' =?<637 8<9AA /L0:63046930=:64A4.0439F./</.6A30:/6A</;/<</=49 0A 070<0E 4<037/2G 4./ 2/702 39468/ F0A 0==</AA/= 49 0E?0260A070<0E03=0891G9;646AA/3449B0>6C34./ 39468/4./</6A39</;/</38/0A49F.G4./2/70239468/F0A - 8 - </;/<</= 49 B0>6C "' ;?<4./< 12/0=A 6739<038/ 059?4 4./ 5?A63/AA 4.04 6A 5/637 <?3 5G 4./ 088?A/= / =9/A 394 I39F F./4./< 64 6A 0 1<91<6/49<G 8938/<3 9< 0 10<43/<A.61;6<:'643/AAA404/A4.04./3/>/</3H?6</= 4./ 088?A/= 0A 49 F.G ./ </H?6</A A?8. .?7/ 0:9?34 9; A/.0A394954063/=03G=98?:/34F.62/ 2/3=637 4./ 0:9?34 9; A 4 6A 1/<463/34 49 394/4.04=?<6378<9AA/L0:6304693"'A404/A4.044./ 088?A/= .6:A/2; .0= .03=/= 9>/< L" 49 .6: 0A A/8?<64G4.04:/03A49I//18./H?/;9<059?493/:934. 03=634./:/0346:/./F622</10G4./29030:9?34 46A39468/=4.044./89:1206303403=088?A/= 594. 0</ 5?A63/AA:/3 /3=637 9; .?7/ 0:9?34 9; A =?<637 * 5G 0 5?A63/AA:03 26I/ 4./ 89:12063034 F64.9?4 4./</ 5/637 03G =98?:/34 6A ?36:0763052/'./389:120630346A05?A63/AA:034./</ :?A45/042/0A40A8<019;101/<49A.9F4.04./.0A2/34 A?8.0:9?34494./088?A/=4<037/2G4./89:12063034 6A394.0>63703G=98?:/34634.04</70<= - 9 - ./ 088?A/= .0A 40I/3 4./ =/;/38/ 9; 49402 =/3602 4<037/2G 4./ 8./H?/ L" 80:/ 49 5/ =6A.9?39?</= 0A B0889?34 829A/=C ./ 89:12063034 /L0:63/=4./0307/<9;4./03I0A"' A1/<"' 4./ 0889?34 A403=637 63 4./ 30:/ 9; 4./ 088?A/= F0A 829A/= 634./G/0< 6/ 059?4*G/0<A/0<26/<494./ =04/9;4./8./H?/./0889?34F0A829A/=0A646A393 </89>/<052/./89:120630346A3940F0</0A49F.046A :/0345GB393</89>/<052/0889?34C./088?A/=.0A02A9 394 /L12063/= 03G4.637 63 4.6A </70<= 4 6A 394 4./ 8934/34693 9; 4./ 89:12063034 4.04 />/3 4.9?7. 4./ 088?A/=829A/=.6A0889?34634./G/0< =/265/<04/2G ./.0A6AA?/=4./8./H?/L"0;4/<201A/9;*G/0<A03= 4./</5G89::644/=8./04637 4 6A 4./ 8934/34693 9; 4./ 2/0<3/= 89?3A/2 ;9< 4./ 011/22034 4.04 594. 4./ <602 9?<4 03= 4./ (6<A4 11/2204/9?<4./2=4.044./A67304?</;9?3=93LA" " " 03= " 011/0<A 49 5/ A6:620< 03= 4./</;9</ - 10 - 4./89:12063034.0A1<9>/=6AA?038/9;4./8./H?/L" 03= 6AA?038/ 9; 2/44/< L" 5G 4./ 088?A/= ;89?<A/ 4./63646025?<=/3934./89:12063034491<9>/6AA?038/9; 8./H?/F0A=6A8.0<7/=5G.6:?44./;084</:063A4.04 4./ 0889?34 63 H?/A4693 F0A 829A/= * G/0<A /0<26/< 49 6AA?038/9;4./8./H?/./8934/346939;4./89:12063034 634./89:1206344.044./8./H?/L"F0A6AA?/=934./ >/<G=04/93F.68.4./2903F0A2/345?4A?5A/H?/342G04 4./46:/9;.6A/>6=/38/1<9=?8/=L"0A4./89>/<637 2/44/< 0889:103G637 L" 8</04/A A/<69?A =9?54 63 4./ 8934/3469340I/35G.6:;04022L"F0A63/L6A4/38/ 0A 0 89>/<637 2/44/< 49 4./ 8./H?/ L" 4./</ A.9?2= .0>/ 5//3 0 </;/</38/ 49 4./ A0:/ 63 4./ 2/702 39468/ L")03=4./1<6>04/89:120634;62/=5G4./89:12063034 5/;9</4./<6029?<4./</6A05A92?4/2G39/L120304693 634.6A</70<=F.68.8</04/AA/<69?A=9?54F64.</70<=49 4./ 80A/ :0=/ 9?4 5G 4./ 89:12063034 ./ :/</ ;084 4.04 4./ <602 9?<4 03= 4./ (6<A4 11/2204/ 9?<4 ./2= 4.044./A67304?</;9?3=93LA"""03=" - 11 - 0</A6:620<F622394=6A1/3A/F64.4./26056264G49=6A8.0<7/ 4./ 5?<=/3 93 4./ 89:12063034 38/ 4./ 088?A/= 6A A?88/AA;?2638</04637A9:/</0A93052/=9?54634./:63= 9;4./9?<4059?44./80A/:0=/9?45G4./89:12063034 4.0464A/2;6AA?;;686/3449</5?44./2/7021</A?:14693?3=/< /84693A03=),9;84 ) 4 6A 4./ A/442/= 19A64693 9; 20F 4.04 938/ 4./ 088?A/= 6A A?88/AA;?2 63 </5?44637 4./ 2/702 1</A?:14693 4./ 5?<=/3 07063 A.6;4A 93 4./ 89:12063034 49 1<9>/ .6A 8934/34693</70<=6372/3=6379;4./0:9?3403=/L6A4/38/ 9; 2/7022G </89>/<052/ =/54 03= 02A9 6AA?038/ 9; 8./H?/ L"./5?<=/349</5?44./2/7021</A?:14693934./ 088?A/= 6A 932G 5G 1</193=/<038/ 9; 1<950562646/A ./ 088?A/=6AA?88/AA;?2638</046370=/34634./80A/:0=/ 9?4 5G 4./ 89:12063034 ./</ 0</ A/>/<02 H?/A4693A F.68. .0>/ </:063/= ?303AF/</= 3=/< A?8. .0>/ </:063/= ?303AF/</= 3=/< A?8. 86<8?:A4038/A4./ 5/3/;64 9; =9?54F622.0>/49 /3?</ 49 4./088?A/= - 12 - & ./(6<A411/2204/9?<4;9<:/=0391636934.04 4./ 088?A/= 6A A?88/AA;?2 63 </5?44637 4./ 2/702 1</A?:14693 03= 4./ 89:12063034 .0A 394 1<9>/= 4./ 2/3=6379;4./0:9?34/.0A02A93941<9>/=.6A2/3=637 8010864G =9 394 ;63= 03G 1/<>/<A64G 9< 622/70264G 63 4./ A06=9163693/L1</AA/=5G4./(6<A411/2204/9?<446A 02A9 4./A/442/=19A646939; 20F 4.04 F./34F9 >6/FA 0</ 19AA652/ 4./ >6/F 4.04 6A 5/3/;68602 49 4./ 088?A/= F622 .0>/495/40I/3'./34./088?A/=6A08H?644/=5G4./ (6<A411/2204/9?<4?32/AA646AA.9F34.044./E?=7:/34 6:1?73/=6A1/<>/<A/9<07063A44./:04/<602A93</89<=64 F6223948022;9<634/<;/</38/5G4.6A9?<4 3 >6/F 9; 022 4./A/ ;084A 03= 86<8?:A4038/A 0:9;4./91636934.044./E?=7:/346:1?73/==9/A394 8022 ;9< 03G 634/<;/</38/ 5G 4.6A 9?<4 889<=6372G 03AF/< 4./ 059>/ 19634 63 4./ B3/7046>/C 03= 1<98//= 49 10AA4./;9229F637 - 13 - ./<6:630211/026A ,) %""( # ' 6A4929 "