Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63507 (KAR)
JAGADISHKUMAR @ BLADE RAJA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200137/2022 · 2025-09-10
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63507 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63507 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$""
"!! %
&%'!()&%((
*
! "
#
"
$%&%!'(
!)
"!*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" +,-
"
"
" '','! !+''
" ""
-%'+%- +%- +%- +,( . %'(%')" (&!" '! " "
/
#
$" #
01 2331442.5 617.8 501 299:;1< 7. 319724 2;1 =!+'' =. 501 >741 => 501 412?.1< $ <<757=.241;;7=.;:<81 2426:?287@>=?;0=?5A501?724 =:?5BC7;7D3:8.7.8501E:<8D1.5=>9=.F7957=.2.<=?<1? => ;1.51.91 <251< '','! 9=.F7957.8 07D >=? 501 =>>1.91; 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.; +,( . -%' +%- +%- +%- %'( %') =>501.<72.1.24 =<1!&('@>=?;0=?5A501BC2.<1957=.;(&!=> 501?=51957=.=>074<?1.>?=D1G:24>>1.91;95'! @>=? ;0=?5 A501 95BC 2.< ;1.51.97.8 5= :.<1?8=
- 3 -
;7D341 7D3?7;=.D1.5 >=? 2 31?7=< => % H12?; 2.< 5= 32H >7.1 => ;!''''$ >=? 501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.-%'=>*5=:.<1?8=?78=?=:;7D3?7;=.D1.5>=? 231?7=<=>!'H12?;2.<5=32H>7.1=>;%'''$>=?501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=. +,( . => * 5= :.<1?8=?78=?=:;7D3?7;=.D1.5>=?231?7=<=>H12?;2.< 5=32H>7.1=>;%'''$>=?501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.+%- =>*5=:.<1?8=;7D3417D3?7;=.D1.5 >=?231?7=<=>+H12?;2.<5=32H>7.1=>;!%'''$>=? 501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=. +%- => * 5= :.<1?8=;7D3417D3?7;=.D1.5>=?231?7=<=>H12?;2.< 5=32H>7.1=>;!''''$>=?501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=. +%- => * 5= :.<1?8= ;7D341 7D3?7;=.D1.5 >=?231?7=<=>!H12?2.<5=32H>7.1=>;%'''$>=?501 =>>1.913:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.%'( => * 5= :.<1?8= ;7D3417D3?7;=.D1.5>=?231?7=<=>(D=.50;2.<5=32H >7.1=>;%'''$>=?501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1?1957=. %')=>*5=:.<1?8=;7D3417D3?7;=.D1.5>=?231?7=< =>-H12?;2.<5=32H>7.1=>;%'''$>=?501=>>1.91
- 4 -
3:.7;02641:.<1?1957=.&=>95*2.<5=:.<1?8= ;7D341 7D3?7;=.D1.5 >=? 2 31?7=< => H12?; 2.< 5= 32H >7.1=>;%'''$>=?501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1?1957=. !=>95I750<1>2:45;1.51.91;
"295; => 501 92;17. 6?71> 2?1 5025 /$ $ 501 D=501?=>501F7957D87?44=<81<501>7?;57.>=?D257=.I750 2<6==4 =4791 5257=. 2827.;5 501 299:;1< 244187.8 9=DD7;;7=. => 501 =>>1.91; 5 7; ;5251< 7. 501 >7?;5 7.>=?D257=.5025501F7957D7;01?<2:8051?281<!,H12?;
/01. ;01 I2; 7. 501 0=:;1 26=:5 5I= D=.50; 12?471? 5= >747.8=>5019=D3427.5299:;1<74418244H5?1;32;;1<7.5=501 0=:;1 2.< 7.;7;51< 501 F7957D 87?4 5= 4=F1 07D :.<1? 3?=D7;1 5= D2??H 01? 1 2827. 92D1 5= 01? 0=:;1 =. !!'!) 25 !'' 3D 2.< 9=DD7551< 288?2F251< 31.15?257F1;1G:242;;2:45124;=D7;6102F1<I75001? 6H5=:907.801?7.233?=3?72514H2.<9?7D7.244H7.57D7<251< 5= 92:;1 01? <1250 1 :;1< 5= 7.;7;5 501 F7957D 87?4 5= 9=D15=2.12?6H0744=9J2?122.<:;1<5=9=DD75;1G:24 02?2;;D1.5 2.H 2 57D1; 01 02; 9=DD7551< ;1G:24
- 5 -
2;;2:452.<?131251<4H9=DD7551<288?2F251<31.15?257F1 ;1G:24 2;;2:45 501?16H 01 02; 9=DD7551< 501 244181< =>>1.91; 01 " 92D1 5= 61 ?187;51?1< 5251D1.5 => 501F7957D:.<1?1957=.!(-=>?I2;?19=?<1<2.< 7.F1;578257=. I2; :.<1?52J1. >51? 9=D34157.8 501 7.F1;578257=.>7.24?13=?592D15=61>741<
+ 01?724=:?55==J9=8.7K2.91=>501=>>1.91 01299:;1<23312?1<61>=?1501?724=:?53412<1<.=5 8:745H2.<9427D1<5=615?71<013?=;19:57=.1G2D7.1< /;$!5=!%2.<8=5D2?J1<G;$!5=$!7.;:33=?5=> 75; 9=.51.57=. 01 299:;1< <1.71< 244 501 7.9?7D7.257.8 D251?724;2F2742641=.?19=?<6:502;.=590=;1.5=412< 2.H 1F7<1.91 7. ;:33=?5 => 07; <1>1.91 01 ?724=:?5 2>51? 52J7.8 7.5= 9=.;7<1?257=. 244 501;1 D251?724; =. ?19=?< 92D1 5= 501 9=.94:;7=. 5025 501 3?=;19:57=. 7;
;:991;;>:4 7. 3?=F7.8 501 8:745 => 501 299:;1< 61H=.< ?12;=.2641 <=:65 2.< 32;;1< 501 7D3:8.1< E:<8D1.5 => 9=.F7957=.2.<=?<1?=>;1.51.9117.8288?71F1<6H501 ;2D1501299:;1<7;61>=?1507;=:?5
- 6 -
- 12?< ?7 2?502.<2332 2441;02332 44:? 412?.1<9=:.;14>=?5012331442.52.<?7=324J?7;0.2 2<2F 412?.1< 780 =:?5 =F1?.D1.5 412<1? >=? ?1;3=.<1.5 =! 1;3=.<1.5 = 50=:80 ;1?F1< 02;
?1D27.1< :.$?13?1;1.51< 1?:;1< 501 D251?724; =. ?19=?<7.94:<7.8501?724=:?5?19=?<;
% .
F71I => 501 ?7F24 9=.51.57=.; :?81< 6H 412?.1<9=:.;14>=?6=5050132?571;5013=7.55025I=:4< 2?7;1>=?DH9=.;7<1?257=.7;
H2.;I1?5=50126=F13=7.57;7.501A B >=?501>=44=I7.8
( 57;5019=.51.57=.=>5013?=;19:57=.5025501 299:;1< :;1< 5= 7.<:91 2.< 50?1251. 501 F7957D 87?4 I0= I2;2D7.=?281<!($!,H12?;2.<:;1<5=9=DD75;1G:24
- 7 -
02?2;;D1.5 ;1G:24 2;;2:45 2.< 02< 24;= 9?7D7.244H 7.57D7<251<01?5=92:;101?<1250102<3?=D7;1<01? 5=D2??H2.<3?=F7<1<D=674102.<;155=01?2.<7.;7;51< D2.H257D1;5=9=D15=2.12?6H0744=9J2?12I01?101 9=DD7551< 288?2F251< 31.15?257F1 ;1G:24 2;;2:45 ?131251<4H 1>=?1 >747.8 => 501 >7?;5 7.>=?D257=. 501 299:;1< 1F1. 02< 9=D1 5= 501 0=:;1 => 501 F7957D 2.< 9=DD7551<;:90295/01.501;2D1I2;6?=:8055=501 .=5791 => 501 7.>=?D2.5 $ 501 D=501? => 501 F7957D ;01 4=<81<501>7?;57.>=?D257=. , /$! 7; 501 F7957D /01. ;01 I2; >7?;5 1G2D7.1< 61>=?1 501 ?724 =:?5 501 319724 :<81 ?19=?<1< 501 >295 5025 501 D=501? => 501 F7957D I2;
?131251<4H 7.51?>1?7.8 I0741 ?19=?<7.8 501 1F7<1.91 2.< I2; ;11J7.8 2<E=:?.D1.5 01 F7957D I2; ?14:952.5 5= 2.;I1?2.H=>501L:1;57=.;3:55=01?2.<I2;;741.52.< ;01 24;= 7.;7;51< >=? 2<E=:?.D1.5 01 =:?5 02; .=51< 501<1D12.=?=>501F7957D7.501<13=;757=.5025I750=:5 2.H ?12;=. ;01 7; ;11J7.8 2<E=:?.D1.5 2.< ;01 7;
- 8 -
?14:952.55=2.;I1?2.HL:1;57=.2.<501?1>=?15019071>$ 1G2D7.257=. I2; <1>1??1< . 501 .1G5 <251 I01. 501 F7957D92D15=<13=;161>=?1501=:?5;0102;<13=;1< 7.;:33=?5=>50192;1=>5013?=;19:57=.01;5251;5025 =. !!'!) I01. ;01 I2; 24=.1 7. 501 0=:;1 501 299:;1< 92D1 5= 01? 0=:;1 2.< >=?91< 01? 5= 52J1 501 D=6741 30=.1 01 2<D75; 5025 501?1 2?1 ?1;7<1.5724 0=:;1;.12?6H2.<1F1.01?;7;51?I2;7.5010=:;101 7.97<1.5 .2??251< 6H 01? I2; .=5 .=5791< 1F1. 6H 01? ;7;51? =? 6H 501 .17806=:?1?; /75.1;; ;5251< 5025 01? 32?1.5;:;1<5=8=5=9==471I=?J1?;7;51?;2.<6?=501?;
I1?1;52H7.87.5010=:;101299:;1<7;501;=.=>01? 3251?.24:.941/75.1;;24;=;5251<5025501299:;1<02< 50?1251.1<01?:;1<5=52J101?5=501.12?6H0744=9J2?12 2.<9=DD7551<50126=F1D1.57=.1<=>>1.91102<1F1. 87F1.501D=674102.<;152.<I2;2;J7.801?5=924407D 99=?<7.84H;01:;1<5=924407D
& /$ 7; 501 7.>=?D2.5 M 501 D=501? => 501 F7957D87?4 /75.1;; ;5251< 5025 501 299:;1< I2;02F7.8
- 9 -
>==< ?18:42?4H 7. 01? 0=:;1 >=? 26=:5 =.1 H12? 2.< 5025 D2H61501?12;=.0=I501F7957D2.<501299:;1<92D1 7.94=;19=.5295I750=.12.=501?/$-7;5011H1I75.1;; 5=5017.97<1.51<13=;1<61>=?1501=:?550250102< ;11. 501 F7957D ;9?12D7.8 2>51? 501 299:;1< 9=DD7551< ?231 =. 01? 6=:5 ' 5= +' F744281?; 02F1 82501?1< 501?1 6:5 .=.1 => 501D 02F1 L:1;57=.1< 501 299:;1< 26=:5 ;:90 295; /75.1;; 24;= ;5251; 5025 1F1. 501 D=501? => 501 F7957D I2; 3?1;1.5 25 5025 57D1 .51?1;57.84H501I75.1;;;5251;5025501;27<7.97<1.502< =99:??1< 26=:5 2 H12? 629J 1F1. 50=:80 501 >7?;5 7.>=?D257=. I2; 4=<81< =. &!!'!) 2.< 501 I75.1;; I2;1G2D7.1<=.')'+''
) /$) 7; 501 <=95=?
I0= 1G2D7.1< 501 F7957D /75.1;;;5251<5025=.)!!'!)501F7957DI2;6?=:805 5= 501 0=;37524 I750 2 07;5=?H => ;1G:24 2;;2:45 01 ?19=?<1<50107;5=?H2;;5251<6H501F7957D2.<9=.<:951< 30H;79241G2D7.257=.;31?501<1.57;52.<?2<7=4=87;5 501 281 => 501 F7957D I2; 41;; 502. !& H12?; :5
- 10 -
299=?<7.85=501F7957D;01I2;281<!(H12?;G$!7; 501D1<792491?57>792517;;:1<6H/$)299=?<7.85=I0790 501F7957D02;87F1.50107;5=?H2;:.<1? ! "
#
$%$ && '(!) ) ) * !)
"
"+, -
%
. ) "
)
/ !+0
123'+ )
/) )4
"
+5
!' . 1G2D7.257=. /$) ;:881;51< 5025 501 ;19=.<2?H ;1G:24 902?2951? I2; I144 <1F14=31< 501?1 I1?1 .= 1G51?.24 7.E:?71; =F1? 6=<H .= 7.E:?71; =. 501 3?7F251 32?5 2.< 0HD1. I2; 5=?. G$!+ 7; 501 " ?13=?5 299=?<7.8 5= I0790 .= 64==< ;527.; .= ;1D7.24 ;527.; 2.< .= ;31?D25=K=2 I1?1 <151951< 7. 2.H => 501 751D;G$!-7;501>7.24=37.7=.7;;:1<6H/$)I01?1
- 11 -
2827.501?17;?1>1?1.915=50107;5=?H87F1.6H501F7957D 87?4 2.< 501 >7.24 =37.7=. 7; 87F1. 5025 501?1 2?1 .= 1F7<1.91=>?191.5;1G:247.51?9=:?;1
!! 57;31?57.1.55=.=5150252;31?G;$!2.< $!- 501 F7957D I2; 1G2D7.1< =. !)!'!) 01 >7?;5 7.>=?D257=. 92D1 5= 61 4=<81< =. &!!'!) 244187.8 50255017.97<1.502<=99:??1<=.!!'!)01?1I2;
<142H => 26=:5(<2H; 7.>747.8501>7?;5 7.>=?D257=. 01 =.4H ?12;=. 2;;78.1< >=? 501 <142H 7; 5025 5= J113 501 >2D74H0=.=:?5019=D3427.5I2;.=5?187;51?1<
! 01 7.97<1.5 5025 7; .2??251< 6H 501 7.>=?D2.5 2.< 501 F7957D 7; 5= 61 9=.;7<1?1< 7. 501 47805 => 501 07;5=?H 87F1. 61>=?1 /) 6H 501 F7957D 25 501 12?471;5 3=7.5 => 57D1 01 F7957D I2; 281< 26=:5 !( H12?; 2.< 501299:;1< I2;281< H12?; 99=?<7.8 5=/501 299:;1<:;1<5=02F1>==<?18:42?4H7.01?0=:;1>=?26=:5 2 H12? /! ;5251; 5025 501 299:;1< 7; 501 ;=. => 01? 3251?.24 :.941 01 F7957D 2.< 501 299:;1< 617.8
- 12 -
511.281?; <1F14=31< 7.57D29H I750 =.1 2.=501? 2J7.8 2<F2.5281=>501;75:257=.I01.50132?1.5;=>501F7957D 02< 8=.1 5= 9==471 I=?J 2.< <:1 5= 501 >295 5025 501 F7957D:;1<5=;52H7.5010=:;1;7.91;017;2;90==4<?=3 =:5 501H :;1< 5= 7.<:481 7. ;1G:24 295; >?1L:1.54H 2.< =.4HI01.501D=501?=>501F7957D92D15=J.=I5025501 299:;1<02<87F1.D=674102.<;152.<501F7957D:;1<5= 524JI75007DF1?H>?1L:1.54H2.<I2;8=7.8=:5I75007D 501>7?;57.>=?D257=.92D15=61>741<
!+ =I 501 L:1;57=. 2?7;1; 2; 5= I01501? 75 7; ?12;=.26415=5?12550187?4281<!(H12?;2;501AF7957DB 2.< 501 299:;1< 281< H12?; 2; A299:;1<B I01. 6=50 => 501D F=4:.52?74H 2.< I744>:44H 52J1. 32?5 7. 9=DD7557.8 501 295; F1. 50=:80 501 F7957D 87?4 ?131251<4H;5251<61>=?1501=:?55025;01I2;9?7D7.244H 7.57D7<251<6H501299:;1<2.<9=DD7551<501=>>1.91501 ;2D1 92..=5 61 2991351< 7.
501 47805 => >?1L:1.5 295; 9=DD7551<6H501299:;1<2.<75I2;.=52;5?2H7.97<1.5
- 13 -
=> 9=DD7557.8 31.15?257F1 ;1G:24 2;;2:45 2; 501 F7957D 01?;14> 02; ;5251< 61>=?1 /) 5025 ;01 :;1< 5= 8= 5= 0744=9J2?12F=4:.52?74H:.<1?5013?151G5=>2.;I1?7.8501 .25:?1B;92442.<501299:;1<:;1<5=9=D15=01?0=:;1 F1?H>?1L:1.54HI01?1501H:;1<5=7.<:4817.;1G:24295;
!- 1957=. ( => 501
95 3?1;9?761;
3:.7;0D1.5 => ?78=?=:; 7D3?7;=.D1.5 >=? 2 51?D I0790 ;0244.=56141;;502.!'H12?;.=I'H12?; I0790D2H 1G51.< 5= 7D3?7;=.D1.5 >=? 47>1 /01. ;:90 ;1F1?1 3:.7;0D1.5 7; 3?=F7<1< :.<1? 501 295 501 ;52.<2?< => 3?==> >=? 9=DD7;;7=. => 501 =>>1.91 6H 501 299:;1< I744 24;=611L:244H0780/01.?12;=.2641<=:652?7;1;7.501 D7.< => 501 =:?5 5025 I01. 501 F7957D 02; ;:>>7971.5 D25:?75H 7. 7.<:487.8 7. ;:90 295; 2.< 02; 9==31?251< F=4:.52?74H 17501? 7.;7<1 501 0=:;1 =? =:5;7<1 :.<1? 501 >24;13?151G525412;5=.917.2I11J2D=>501=37.7=. 5025757;.=52>7592;1>=?9=.F7957.8501299:;1<5D2H 615017..=91.5295;=>5I=511.281?;I750=:5J.=I7.875;
9=.;1L:1.91; 01 F7957D 2.< 501 299:;1< D2H ?1L:7?1
- 14 -
?18:42?9=:.;147.801?1>=?12D=>501=37.7=.5025501 299:;1<7;.=5472641>=?9=.F7957=. !% 02F18=.150?=:805017D3:8.1<E:<8D1.5=> 9=.F7957=.2.<=?<1?=>;1.51.9132;;1<6H501?724=:?5 01 ?724 =:?5 02; 3?=911<1< 5= 299135 501 F1?;7=. => /! 647.<4H I750=:5 52J7.8 7.5= 9=.;7<1?257=. 2.H=> 501 >295;<7;9:;;1<26=F15=9=.F795501299:;1<01?1>=?1 501;2D17;4726415=61;152;7<1 !(.F71I=>50126=F12.;I1?50126=F13=7.5 7.501 2.<3?=911<5=32;;501>=44=I7.8
7 01?7D7.24331247;
77 01 :<8D1.5 => 9=.F7957=. '','! 32;;1<7.3197242;1 =!+'' =. 501 >741 => 412?.1< <<757=.24 1;;7=.;
:<81 2426:?287 7; 01?16H ;15 2;7<1 =.;1L:1.54H 501 2331442.5299:;1< 7;
29L:7551< >=? 501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.; -%' +%- +%- +%-
- 15 -
+,( . %'( 2.< %') => 2.< :.<1? 1957=.;(&2.<!=>95 777 274 6=.< => 501 2331442.5299:;1< 2.< 5025 =>07;;:?1571;;0244;52.<92.91441< 7F
"7.1 2D=:.5 7> 2.H <13=;751< 6H 501 2331442.5299:;1<7; =?<1?1< 5=61?1>:.<1< 5=07D2>51?23312431?7=<7;=F1? 187;5?H 5= ;1.< 629J 501 ?724 =:?5 ?19=?<; 24=.8 I7509=3H=>507;E:<8D1.5>=?7.>=?D257=.2.<>=?.11<>:4 2957=. +) %""( $
/ 7;5=!4=!,