Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63506 (KAR)
THIMMANAGOUDA v. REVANNA A.P AND ORS
MFA/201539/2024 · 2025-11-20
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63506 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63506 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$
'#( )
! " # # $
#
%
#
&
' ' #( )&
'
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' %
%* +,*&&%
%
' #,
( #( )& ! " # ' -
# ' %- #
& & & .+$
' '
"$ ' # +
'( + & '
# (
/ /
#( # *%
& ' ( ,
' ' ( +#
0 (
0 ( ( # &
" 0 ( $
123 455647 89:6; 6<=2>9 "$ >? =16 >=>; #612<763<=*"16;6294?=6;;6?6;;6:=>43@=16<=A?>;
31>;=$ 143 B669 ?276: BC =16 <742D49= <147769E29E =16
- 3 -
F8:ED69=49:4G4;::4=6: &54336:BC=16 ::2=2>947 692>; 2H27 (8:E6 49: 6DB6; / #2F4C458;429#> *%
&
'4<=3 E2H29E ;236 => =16 ?2729E >? =16 455647 B;26?7C 3=4=6: 4;6 =14= >9 & & 4= 4B>8= %& 1>8;3 ;6B427477458; ==4;4994:4=16:6<6436:14I89=474 49:>=16;3G6;6=;4H6729E29498998DB6;6:F665=>G4;:3 14;D43=147449: =16 342: F665 G43 B629E :;2H69BC=16 <742D49= 29 4 37>G 49: <48=2>83 D4996; +169 =16 342: F665<4D6964;;6B427477458;4==14==2D6=16:;2H6;
>? =16 7>;;C B64;29E 6E23=;4=2>9 > /
/* G43 G;>9E7C 54;I6: 29 =16 D2::76 >? =16 ;>4: G2=1>8= =4I29E 49C5;6<48=2>93;6E4;:29E=1658B72<34?6=C2 6 16:2:9>= 58= 3=>963 964; =16 H612<76 49: =16;6 G43 9>B>:C => 29:2<4=6 =16 54;I6: H612<76 >>I29E => =16 H612<76 =16 <742D49= 37>G :>G9 123 F665 4= =14= =2D6 49>=16; 7>;;C :;2H6; B64;29E 6E23=;4=2>9 > /
/%%) <4D6 ?;>D 129:32:62912E13566:294;43149:96E72E69=D4996; =16342:7>;;C:;2H6;894B76=><>9=;>7=1634D6432=G43
- 4 -
164H27C 7>4:6: G2=1 D8;D8D :4316: 49: :;4EE6: =16 F665>?=16<742D49= 34;6387=>?=164?>;6342:4<<2:69= =16342:F665G43<48E1=B6=G669B>=1=167>;;263 86=> 2D54<= =16 :6<6436: 383=4296: E;26H>83 29F8;263 49: 38<<8DB6:=>=1629F8;263
16<742D49=?276:456=2=2>989:6;6<=2>9))>?=16 <= 366I29E <>D56934=2>9 ?>; =16 :64=1 >? =16 :6<6436: 47>9EG2=129=6;63= %
5>9 36;H2<6 >? 9>=2<6 =16 ;635>9:69= >3 49: % 45564;6: =1;>8E1 <>89367 49: ?276: G;2==69 3=4=6D69= :69C29E =16 4H6;D69=3 D4:6 29 =16 <742D 56=2=2>9 16 ;635>9:69=>3 49::6352=636;H2<6>?9>=2<6:2:9>= 45564;B6?>;6=16;2B894749:G6;6574<6:6J/54;=6
9 =16 B4323 >? =16 5764:29E3 >? =16 54;=263 =16 742D3;2B8947?;4D6:=1623386349:=16;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=16 6H2:69<6 16 ;2B8947 BC 2D58E96: F8:ED69= 49: 4G4;:14354;=7C477>G6:=16<742D56=2=2>949:167:=14= =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => 4 <>D56934=2>9 >? 3 %%&&
/47>9EG2=129=6;63=4==16;4=6>?)K5 4
- 5 -
49::2;6<=6:;635>9:69=>3 49:%=>:65>32=&K64<1 >8=>?=16<>D56934=2>94D>89=47>9EG2=129=6;63= 629E 4EE;26H6:=165;6369=455647143B669?276: ) 16 764;96: <>89367 ?>; =16 <742D49= 143 ;4236: =16 ?>77>G29E<>9=69=2>93 4$ '2;3=7C =16 <742D49= 4336;= =14= =16 :6<6436: G43 4E6:4B>8=C64;34==16=2D6>?=164<<2:69=49:14:4 D>9=17C 29<>D6 >? 3 &&&&&
/ BC G>;I29E 43 49 4E;2<87=8;23= >G6H6;=16433633D69=>?D>9=17C29<>D6 >? =16 :6<6436: 4= 3 &&&
/ BC =16 ;2B8947 23 89F83=2?26:49:6;;>96>83 B$ 6<>9:7C=16;2B8947293=64:>?:6:8<=29E
;:>? =16 29<>D6 >?
=16 :6<6436: =>G4;:3 56;3>947 6J569363 143 :6:8<=6: &K 16 34D6 23 <>9=;4;C => =16 74G 742:
:>G9BC=16>9AB7685;6D6>8;=29! ##! !$$'
<$ 12;:7C4356;=16F8:ED69=>?=16>9AB7685;6D6 >8;= 29 =16 <436 >? ! *# + , & , - 64<1 >? =16
- 6 -
<742D49=2369=2=76:=><>D56934=2>9>?3 %%&&&
/89:6; =16164:>?@7>33>?7>H649:4??6<=2>949:<>93>;=28DA :$ 43=7C <>932:6;29E =16 4E6 49: 4H><4=2>9 >? =16 :6<6436: =16 >H6;477 <>D56934=2>9 4G4;:6: BC =16 ;2B894723294:6L84=649:>9=167>G6;32:6 +2=1 =16 4B>H6 <>9=69=2>93 =16 764;96: <>89367 3>8E1==>477>G=16455647
9 =16 >=16; 149: =16 764;96: <>89367 ?>; =16 938;49<6 >D549C 143 ;4236: =16 ?>77>G29E <>89=6;/ <>9=69=2>93 4$ '2;3=7C47=1>8E1=16<742D49=<742D=14==16:6<6436:
G43 64;929E 3 &&&&&
/ 56; D>9=1 6J<65= 5;>:8<29E =16 16 143 9>= 5;>:8<6: 49C >=16; :><8D69=3 => 38B3=49=24=6 123 <742D >936L869=7C =16 ;2B8947 143 <>;;6<=7C4336336:=1629<>D6>?=16:6<6436:9>=2>9477C B$ 6<>9:7C 329<6 =16 <742D49= 23 =16 >97C :6569:49= =16 ;2B8947 143 ;2E1=7C :6:8<=6: &K >? =16 29<>D6 >? =16:6<6436:=>G4;:356;3>9476J569363
- 7 -
<$ 12;:7C >9 455;6<24=2>9 >? >;47 49: :><8D69=4;C 6H2:69<6 49: <>932:6;29E =16 4E6 49: 4H><4=2>9 >? =16 :6<6436: =16 >H6;477 <>D56934=2>9 4G4;:6: BC =16 ;2B894723F83=49:;643>94B76 +2=1 =16 4B>H6 <>9=69=2>93 =16 764;96: <>89367 3>8E1==>:23D233=16455647
64;: =16 764;96: <>89367 ?>; =16 54;=263 49: 56;836:=16F8:ED69=49:4G4;:>?=16;2B8947 * =239>=29:2358=6=14=14I89=474:26:29=16;>4: =;4??2< 4<<2:69= ><<8;;6: >9 & & :86 => ;431 49: 96E72E69=:;2H29E>?=16>??69:29EH612<763BC=162;:;2H6;3 B64;29E 6E23=;4=2>9 >3 /
/* 49: /
/ %%) & 16 <742D49= <742D =14= :6<6436: G43 64;929E 3 &&&&&
/ 56; D>9=1 J<65= ?>; 5;>:8<29E =16 =16 <742D49= 143 9>= 5;>:8<6: 49C >=16; :><8D69=3 => 38B3=49=247=16<742D 9=164B369<6>?5;>>?>?29<>D6 =169>=2>94729<>D6143=>B64336336: <<>;:29E=>=16 E82:672963 23386: BC =16 4;94=4I4 =4=6 6E47 6;H2<63
- 8 -
8=1>;2=C ?>; 4<<2:69=3 ><<8;;6: 29 =16 C64; & =16 9>=2>947 29<>D6 >? =16 :6<6436: 31477 B6 =4I69 4= 3 %&
/ 5 D 16 ;2B8947 143 ;2E1=7C 4::6: %&K >? =16 29<>D6 >? =16 :6<6436: =>G4;:3 ?8=8;6 5;>356<=3 183 =16 D>9=17C 29<>D6 <>D63 => 3 **&
/ 16 <742D49= 23 =16 183B49: >? =16 :6<6436: 9 H26G >? 74G 742: :>G9 BC =16 >9AB76 85;6D6 >8;= 29 .! #/ "385;4$ 2= 23 455;>5;24=6 => :6:8<=
;: >? =16 29<>D6 >?
=16 :6<6436: =>G4;:3 56;3>947 6J569363 49: ;6D42929E4D>89=143=>B6=4I694316;<>9=;2B8=2>9=> =16 ?4D27C 16 ;2B8947 143 ;2E1=7C =4I69 =16 D87=25726;
45572<4B76 => =164E6 >?=16:6<6436: 43@)A 183 =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => <>D56934=2>9 >? 0 12
"3 **&MM)M
$ >9 4<<>89= >? @7>33 >? :6569:69<CA
94::2=2>9=16<742D49=2369=2=76:=><>D56934=2>9 >? 012 >9 4<<>89= >? @7>33 >? 63=4=6A 49:
<>D56934=2>9 >? 012 >9 4<<>89= >? @?896;47 6J569363A
- 9 -
9H26G>?=1674G742::>G9BC=1685;6D6>8;=29 =16 <436 >? . !/ "385;4$ <742D49= 183B49: >? =16 :6<6436: 23 69=2=76: ?>;
<>D56934=2>9 >?02 89:6;=16 164:>? 07>33>? 35>8347<>93>;=28D0
183 =16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => =16 ?>77>G29E <>D56934=2>9 345607896:6;5< ;95<56857;0 3:6896 '0( >33>?:6569:69<C )&& '896;476J569363 )&& >33>?63=4=6 )&& >33>?35>8347<>93>;=28D %%&&& 87=
11
% 9=16;6387==16?>77>G29E>;:6;2354336:
4$ 16455647237==>5;9647<8 B$ 16F8:ED69=>?=16742D3;2B894723D>:2?26:
- 10 -
<$ 16 <742D49= 23 69=2=76: => 4 =>=47 <>D56934=2>9 >? 0 112434E4293=3 %%&&
/4G4;:6: BC=16;2B8947 :$ 635>9:69= >3 49: %/938;49<6 >D549263 4;6 :2;6<=6: => :65>32= &K 64<1 >? =16 <>D56934=2>9 4D>89=47>9EG2=129=6;63=4=)K5 4 ?;>D=16:4=6 >? ?2729E >? =16 <742D 56=2=2>9 =277 =16 :4=6 >? ;6472N4=2>9 G2=129 4 56;2>: >? 32J G66I3 ?;>D =16 :4=6>?;6<625=>?4<>5C>?=123F8:ED69= 6$ 16 455>;=2>9D69= :65>32= 49: ;676436 >? 4D>89= 31477 B6 D4:6 29 4<<>;:49<6 G2=1 =16 =6;D3 >? =16 4G4;:>?=16;2B8947
!;2 '$!( &
!;2 '"&# "( &
23=> 7> %