- 1 - ! "#$## #%% &'(&)%*+&** , !" # $ % & Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' # $ % ( )*% % %+ +"% ( # ,!!,* ( ) !,,)( ( (( * ( ) !,,) ( (( ( ( - $# % - ./012345.//4.617890:4;2</6.13.30.77.1613=0:4 2>54>2?.;@A100.65.045,!!,,*/.7745890:464.>345 1B16A5=4.35(:2>./A>132) !,,)?2>0:4 2??43;4 /A317:.864 A354> 4;0123 * 2? 4=201.864 370>A<4307;0**%;0 ! (.;072?0:4;.74.>4.7A354> - 3 - :4 .//466.30 ;2</6.13.30 137010A045 . />1B.04 ;2</6.130 A354> 4;0123 !,, 2? 0:4 254 2? >1<13.6 >2;45A>4 ") .664=13= ;2<<177123 2? .3 2??43;4 /A317:.864 A354> 4;0123 * 2? 0:4 4=201.864 370>A<4307;0**:4;2</6.13.30C7;.74170:.00:4 >47/235430 .;;A745 :.5 82>>2D45 . :.35 62.3 2? !,,,,, & ?>2< :1< .7 .3 1<<451.04 ?13.3;1.6 .77170.3;4 ?2> 0:4 /A>/274 2? 470.8617:13= . ;2</.39 89 3.<4 >17:3. 9546 2D4> >1B.04 1<1045 0 17 ?A>0:4> .664=45 0:.0 02D.>57 517;:.>=4 2? 0:4 7.15 61.816109 0:4 .;;A745 177A45 . ;:4@A4 ?2> !,,,,, & :4 7.15 ;:4@A4 D:43 />4743045 ?2> 43;.7:<430 D.7 >40A>345 A3/.15 D10: 0:4 4352>74<430 E37A??1;1430 (A357F 5.045 !),!!,,) :4 ;2</6.13.30 ;6.1<7 02 :.B4 0:4>4.?04> 177A45 . 70.0A02>9 64=.6 3201;4 .7 ;2304</6.045 A354> 4;0123 *%8 2? 0:4 4=201.864 370>A<4307 ;0 13;4 0:4.;;A745?.164502;2</69D10:0:454<.35<.54130:4 70.0A02>9 3201;4 D10:13 0:4 />47;>1845 /4>125 0:4 - 4 - ;2</6.13.30 13101.045 ;>1<13.6 />2;44513=7 89 ?1613= 0:4 />47430/>1B.04;2</6.130A354>4;0123!,,> A>13=0:4;2A>742?0>1.6820:0:4;2</6.13.30 .35 0:4 .;;A745 .55A;45 2>.6 .7 D466 .7 52;A<430.>9 4B1543;4 13 7A//2>0 2?0:41> >47/4;01B4;2304301237 /23 ;237154>.0123 2? 0:4 <.04>1.6 23 >4;2>5 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.0489GA5=<4305.045!!,!,.;@A100450:4 .;;A745 :26513= 0:.0 0:4 B4>9 177A.3;4 2? 0:4 ;:4@A4 13 @A470123 D.7 52A80?A6 ==>14B45 89 0:4 7.15 2>54> 2? .;@A100.6 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 />4?4>>45 >1<13.6 //4.6 2* !, 84?2>4 0:17 2A>0 9 2>54> 5.045 !, 0:17 2A>0 517/2745 2? 0:4 .//4.6 740 .7154 0:42>54>2?.;@A100.6.35>4<100450:4<.004>020:4>1.6 2A>0 ?2> ?>47: ;237154>.0123 .35 517/27.6 13 .;;2>5.3;4 D10: 6.D .?04> .??2>513= >4.723.864 2//2>0A3109 02 820: /.>0147 + /23 >4<.35 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.04 >4&:4.>5 0:4<.004>.?>47:.35A354>022H.540.16457;>A01392?0:4 ;:4@A4 .664=45 02 :.B4 8443 177A45 89 0:4 .;;A745 3 - 5 - 7A;:4I.<13.01230:4>1.62A>02874>B450:.00:4>4D.7 . <.04>1.6 .604>.0123 13 0:4 5.04 /2>0123 2? 0:4 ;:4@A4 /.>01;A6.>69D10:>4=.>5020:494.>0D.73201;450:.00:4 94.> E!,,F :.5 8443 0.</4>45 D10: .35 2B4>D>10043 .7 E!,,F :4 >1.6 2A>0 :465 0:.0 7A;: .604>.0123 D430 02 0:4>2202?0:4<.004>.35>4354>450:4;:4@A452A80?A613 107 =43A1343477 2374@A43069 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.04 ?2A35 0:4 ;2</6.13.30C7 ;6.1< 0:.0 :4 :.5 .5B.3;45 . :.35 62.3 2? !,,,,, & 02 0:4 .;;A745 ?>2< 01<4 02 01<4 02 84 A37A870.301.045 .35 1</>28.864 3 0:17 >4.72313= 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.0489 GA5=<430 >4354>45 .?04> >4<.35 23;4 .=.13 />2;44545 02 .;@A10 0:4 >47/235430 .;;A745 2? 0:4 2??43;4 /A317:.864 A354> 4;0123*2?0:44=201.864370>A<4307;0 :172A>0:.7:4.>50:464.>345;2A3746?2>0:4 .//466.30 ;2</6.13.30 .7 D466 .7 0:4 64.>345 ;2A3746 ?2> 0:4 >47/235430 .;;A745 .0 ;237154>.864 643=0: .35 :.7 /4>A745 0:4 4301>4 >4;2>57 2? 0:4 ;.74 D10: /.>01;A6.> >4?4>43;402 0:42>.6 54/27101237 2? 820:0:4 ;2</6.13.30 - 6 - .350:4.;;A745.350:452;A<430.>94B1543;4/6.;4523 >4;2>5 /23;.>4?A64I.<13.01232?0:44301>4<.04>1.6 /6.;45 23 >4;2>5 .35 .?04> :4.>13= 0:4 64.>345 ;2A3746 .//4.>13= ?2> 820: 0:4 /.>0147 0:17 2A>0 ?1357 0:.0 0:4 =4347172?0:4;2</6.130>4707A/230:4.664=450>.37.;0123 2? . :.35 62.3 2? !,,,,, J 7.15 02 :.B4 8443 .5B.3;45 89 0:4 .//466.30 ;2</6.13.30 02 0:4 >47/235430 .;;A745?2><44013=0:4?13.3;1.6>4@A1>4<4307 2? >17:3. 9546 2D4> >1B.04 1<1045 0 17 0:4 ;.74 2? 0:4;2</6.13.300:.013517;:.>=42?0:47.1561.8161090:4 >47/235430177A45.;:4@A4?2>!,,,,, JD:1;:D:43 />4743045 ?2> 43;.7:<430 D.7 517:232A>45 D10: 0:4 4352>74<430 E37A??1;1430 (A357F 2 7A870.301.04 0:4 4I17043;4 2? . 64=.669 43?2>;4.864 5480 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 >46145A/230:4;:4@A4<.>H45.7I ) 2D4B4> . ;6274 .35 ;>101;.6 7;>A0139 2? 0:4 ;>277&4I.<13.0123 2? 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 >4B4.67 0:.0 :17 04701<239 6.;H7 7/4;1?1;109 .35 ;23717043;9 >4=.>513= 0:4 - 7 - /.>01;A6.>7 2? 0:4.664=45 :.3562.3 :43@A47012345.7 02 0:4 4I.;0 5.047 <254 .35 <.334> 13 D:1;: 7A;: . 7A870.301.6.<2A30D.7.5B.3;450:4;2</6.13.3070.045 0:.0 :4 ;2A65 320 >4;2664;0 0:4 540.167 .35 0:.0 0:4 7.15 .<2A30 D.7 6430 E?>2< 01<4 02 01<4F D:434B4> 0:4 .;;A745 <.54 . 54<.35 A;: . B.=A4 .35 ;.7A.6 B4>7123 47/4;1.669 13 >47/4;0 2? . 6.>=4 7A< 2? !,,,,, J 5247 320 137/1>4 ;23?1543;4 3 <.004>7 2? 0:173.0A>40:4;235A;0.35;>4518161092?0:4;2</6.13.30 /6.9 . B10.6 >264 .35 0:4 .8743;4 2? ;6.>109 .7 02 D:43 :2D .35 13 D:.0 5432<13.01237 0:4 .<2A307 D4>4 .5B.3;45>4354>70:4;6.1<52A80?A6 * 0 17 ?A>0:4> 02 84 32045 0:.0 23 . <401;A62A7 4I.<13.01232?I 0:4;:4@A413@A4701230:464.>345 .=170>.04:.7>1=:0692874>B450:.00:494.>130:45.04 ;26A<3 .//4.>7 02 :.B4 8443 0.</4>45 D10: >1=13.669 0:4 5.04 <43012345 D.7 !,!!,, .35 0:4 ?1=A>4 EF >4/>4743013=0:494.>17B1718692B4>D>1004302>4.5.7EF 0:4>489;23B4>013=0:494.>02!,,B4323.8.>4B17A.6 - 8 - 4I.<13.0123 2? 0:4 ;:4@A4 0:4 2B4>D>1013= 17 .//.>430 .35 ;.3320 84 1=32>45 A;: .604>.0123 13 0:4 5.04 2? . 34=201.864 1370>A<430 /.>01;A6.>69 >46.013= 02 0:4 94.> ;237010A047 . <.04>1.6 .604>.0123 D10:13 0:4 <4.313= 2? 4;0123*)2?0:44=201.864370>A<4307;0**D:1;: >4354>7 0:4 1370>A<430 B215 A36477 10 17 7:2D3 0:.0 0:4 .604>.0123D.7<.54D10:0:4;2374302?0:45>.D4> " :423C864A/>4<42A>013 :.7 ;.04=2>1;.669 :465 0:.0 .39 <.04>1.6 .604>.0123 <.54 D10:2A00:4;2374302?0:45>.D4>B101.0470:41370>A<430 .35 0:4 7.<4 ;.3320 84 43?2>;45 .=.1370 0:45>.D4> 3 0:4 />47430 ;.74 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 :.7 320 2??4>45 .39 7.017?.;02>92>;2=4304I/6.3.0123.702:2D2>A354>D:.0 ;1>;A<70.3;470:4.604>.0123130:494.>;.<40284<.54 32> :.7 :4 .55A;45 4B1543;4 02 7:2D 0:.0 0:4 7.15 .604>.0123 D.7 ;.>>145 2A0D10:0:4;237430 2> H32D645=4 2? 0:4 .;;A745 :17 A34I/6.1345 <.04>1.6 .604>.0123 - 9 - 0:4>4?2>4 70>1H47 .0 0:4 B4>9 >220 2? 0:4 ;2</6.13.30C7 ;.74.357:.H470:4.A0:4301;1092?0:4;:4@A410746? , 3 .5510123 D:43 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 .664=47 02 :.B4 6430 7A;: . 7A870.301.6 7A< 2? !,,,,, J .7 . :.3562.310D.713;A<8430A/23:1<02/>25A;4;>451864 52;A<430.>94B1543;454<2370>.013=:17?13.3;1.6;./.;109 02 .5B.3;4 7A;: .3 .<2A30 13 ;.7: I;4/0 ?2> 0:4 517/A045 ;:4@A4 0:4>4 17 32 <.04>1.6 7A;: .7 8.3H 70.04<4307 D10:5>.D.6 761/7 2> .;H32D645=<430 2? 5480 02 ;2>>282>.04 0:4 B4>7123 2? 0:4 ;2</6.13.30 :4 .8743;4 2? .39 7A//2>013= 4B1543;4 02 />2B4 0:4 72A>;4 .35?62D2??A357?A>0:4>D4.H4370:4/>47A</0123A354> 4;0123 " 2? 0:4 4=201.864 370>A<4307 ;0 D:1;: />47A<470:44I17043;42?.64=.66943?2>;4.86454802369 D:430:4?2A35.0123.6?.;07>46.013=02177A.3;42?;:4@A4 .>4470.8617:45 3B14D2?0:4.82B4517;A771230:172A>0172? 0:4 ;237154>45 2/13123 0:.0 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.04 :.7 >1=:069.//>4;1.0450:42>.6.3552;A<430.>94B1543;423 - 10 - >4;2>5 .35 :.7 .771=345 B.615 .35 ;2=430 >4.7237 ?2> .;@A10013=0:4.;;A745:4?13513=2?0:4>1.62A>00:.0 0:4 ;:4@A4 84.>7 . <.04>1.6 .604>.0123 ;2A/645 D10: 0:4 ;2</6.13.30C7?.16A>402470.8617:0:44I17043;42?.64=.669 43?2>;4.86454802>61.816109;.3320847.15027A??4>?>2< .39 /4>B4>7109 2> 1664=.6109 D.>>.3013= 1304>?4>43;4 13 .//4.6 :4 />47A</0123 A354> 4;0123 " 2? 0:4 ;0 8413= >48A00.864 70.357 4??4;01B469 517/6.;45 13 0:4 />47430 ;.74 89 0:4 7A>>2A3513= ;1>;A<70.3;47 .35 0:4 13;23717043;147130:4;2</6.13.30C72D34B1543;4 ! ;;2>513=690:172A>0?135732>4.723020.H4. 51??4>430 B14D ?>2< 0:.0 2? 0:4 >1.6 2A>0 :4 .//4.6 8413=54B2152?<4>10770.357517<17745:4GA5=<4302? .;@A100.6 /.7745 89 0:4 64.>345 .=170>.04 17 :4>489 ;23?1><45 -+ &##* $ 1702!62+