Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63500 (KAR)

VAIJANATH v. SHANTABAI

RPFC/200083/2025 · 2025-10-23

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$## %#! &' %#! & ' ! "! ! # "! $ % &" "' " $ !( ! $ % &"!) Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ) ) #&' ) )" ") " *** )" ! " *** " " + " & ' " +! !(!" ! $ % &"!) ' "! ! # " ! $+ % &" "' ) ) #&' ) )" *** )" - 3 - ! " *** " " *** " ) " " " ," "!" &," "!"' -./ ) 0** ** ./ 12 3-4 5.64 14.78 988:.4;4< 12 3-4 0:<4: <934< *** =9//4< .7 :>"./?0 *** 07 3-4 6.>4 06 :.7?.=9> @<84 <<.3.079> )9A.>2 0@:3!9>91@:98. /44B.7847-97?4A473 06A9.734797?46:0A/ 30/+ 8:9734<12 3-4 <<.3.079> )9A.>2 0@:3 !9>91@:98. .7 :>"./?0 ***<934<*** * -4 =43.3.074:C5.64 ./ 984< 910@3 249:/ 5-.>4 3-4 :4/=07<473-@/197< ./ 984< 910@3 $ 249:/ -42 -9;.78 >.;4< 9/ -@/197< 97< 5.64 5.3- 350 <9@8-34:/ 9 /07 06 5-.?- 074 /07 97< 9 <9@8-34: 9:4 /433>4< .7 3-4 7.34< 3934/ 06 A4:.?9 5-.>4 9703-4: - 4 - <9@8-34: ./ :4/.<.78 .7 4789>@:@ 9:4 1460:4 3-./ 0@:3 5.3-9<./=@3407A9.734797?49A0@73 + -4 9>>4893.07 .7 3-4 =43.3.07 ./ 3-93 :4/=07<473-@/197< 5-0 59/ 50:B.78 .7 3934 97B 06 2<4:919< -9;.78 :43.:4< 6:0A 3-4 /4:;.?4/ .7 3-4 249: ***+-9/1447:4/.<.7893!9>89:.>>984.7.>>.?.3 :4>93.07/-.= 5.3- -./ 7.4?4 60: 0;4: ++ 249:/ -9/ ?0A=>434>2 748>4?34< 3-4 =43.3.074:5.64 3 ./ -054;4: 9<A.334<3-933-4:4/=07<473-@/197<-9<?07/3:@?34<9/ -0@/407>030/.3@934<.<<9=@:0>072!9>91@:98. 97< -9< 8.634< 3-4 /9A4 .7 69;0@: 06 3-4 =43.3.074: 07 +* 054;4: 3-4 /9.< -0@/4 ./ 705 .7 9 <.>9=.<934< ?07<.3.07 97< 3-4 =43.3.074: ./ 703 91>4 30 :4/.<4 3-4:4.7 07/4D@473>2 /-4 ./ :4/.<.78 5.3- -4: 1:03-4:930 -93/-4-9/70.7<4=47<473 /0@:?4 06 .7?0A4 -93 3-4 :4/=07<473-@/197< ./ :4?4.;.783-4=47/.0706/ =4:A073-4/.<4/ -4 ./ 9>/0 =0 .78 ;9/3 3:9?3/ 06 98:.?@>3@:9> >97</ 2.4><.78.7?0A406/*>9B-/=4:977@A4/=.34-4 - 5 - 14.78?9=91>406=:0;.<.78A9.734797?430=43.3.074:5.64 -9/ <4>.14:934>2 748>4?34< 07/3:9.7.78 -4: 30 9==:09?- 3-4 3:.9> 0@:3 /44B.78 A9.734797?4 .7 9 /@A 06 /+ =4: A073- -054;4: 3-4 3:.9> 0@:3 -9/ 8:9734<07>29/@A06/ 5-.?-./.79<4D@934/ /@?- /-4 -9/ 6.>4< 3-4 =:4/473 =43.3.07 /44B.78 47-97?4A473 06 /9.< A9.734797?4 9A0@73 6:0A / 30/+ 7 :4/=07/4 3-4 ?0@7/4> 9==49:.78 60: 3-4 :4/=07<473 -@/197<5-0-9/9>/06.>4<9=43.3.07.7) 0*$+ **?-9>>478.783-4;4:2/9A40:<4:?07347< 3-93 3-4 -0@/4 5-.?- ./ 9<A.334<>2 8.634< .7 69;0@: 06 =43.3.074:?07/./3/066.;4:00A/97<=0:3.0706.3-9/1447 :4734<97<3-4=43.3.074: 5.64./:4?4.;.78:4739>.7?0A4/ 6:0A 3-4 /9.< -0@/4 -4 6@:3-4: ?07347</ 3-93 3-4 :4/=07<473 -@/197< -9/ 10::054< 6.797?.9> 9//./397?4 6:0A 3-4 6.797?.9> .7/3.3@3.07/ 60: 3-4 =@:=0/4 06 ?07/3:@?3.07 06 -0@/4 97< 60: 4<@?93.07 =@:=0/4/ 06 ?-.><:475-.?--4.//3.>>?073.7@.7830:4=923.>><934-93 - 6 - -4./:4?4.;.78=47/.0706/+97<703/ 9/?0734734<123-4=43.3.074: -46@:3-4:/@1A.3/3-4:4/=07<473./4;47705 :49<2 97< 5.>>.78 30 ?9::2 0@3 3-4 :4=9.: 06 3-4 -0@/4 .6 972 .6 3-4 =43.3.074: =4:A.3/ -.A 30 ?9::2 0@3 3-4 /9A4 47?4/44B/60:<./A.//9>063-4=43.3.07 49:<4:@/4<3-4:4?0:</ 3 ./ @760:3@7934 3-93 3-4 =43.3.074: 97< 3-4 :4/=07<473933-./4;47.783.A4063-4.:>.649:41460:43-4 0@:3/ 60: 3-4 =@:=0/4 06 <434:A.793.07 06 A9.734797?4 9A0@734?0:</:4;49>4<3-933-4.:3-:44?-.><:47-9;.78 9?D@.:4<<48:44.778.744:.78350063-4A9:4/433>4<.7 3-4 7.34< 3934/ 06 A4:.?9 97< 074 .7 4789>@:@ 054;4: 3-4 A9:.39> <./?0:< 1435447 3-4 =43.3.074: 97< 3-4:4/=07<473-9/:4/@>34<3-./>.3.893.0730>.784:07 $ -4 3:.9> 0@:3 39B.78 .730 ?07/.<4:93.07 06 3-4 :.;9> ?>9.A/ 06 3-4 =9:3.4/ -9/ 8:9734< A9.734797?4 / =4:A073--43:.9>0@:3-9/9>/039B477034 - 7 - 06 3-4 69?3 3-93 3-0@8- 3-4 =43.3.074: -9/ ?0734734< 3-4 -0@/4 8.634< .7 -4: 69;0@: 12 :4/=07<473 -9;.78 14?0A4 <.>9=.<934< /-4 -9/ 703 =:0<@?4< 972 A934:.9> .7 3-./ :489:<-4:4/=07<473073-403-4:-97<-9//-057-./ :49<.74// 97< 5.>>.7874// 30 ?9::2 0@3 3-4 :4=9.: 06 3-4 /9.<-0@/4 # )@:3-4: 3-0@8- 3-4 =43.3.074: -9/ ?>9.A4< 3-4 :4/=07<473 ./ :4?4.;.78 / 9/ =47/.07 9A0@73 3-4 :4/=07<473 -9/ ?07347<4< 3-93 -4 ./ :4?4.;.78 07>2 /+ 9/=47/.07 07/.<4:.78 3-4 984 06 3-4 =9:3.4/ 3-4.: 6.797?.9>97</0?.9>/393@/3-./0@:3./063-4?07/.<4:4< ;.45 3-93 3-4 A9.734797?4 9A0@73 14 47-97?4< 30 / 12 9<<.78 / 30 3-4 A9.734797?4 9A0@73 9>:49<2 8:9734< 12 3-4 3:.9> 0@:3 5-.?- 50@>< A443 3-4 47</ 06 E@/3.?4 -4 47-97?4< A9.734797?4 9A0@73/-9>>14?0A4=9291>46:0A3-./<934 - 8 - 3 ./ @=30 3-4 =9:3.4/ 30 9A.?91>2 :4/0>;4 3-4 A9334:5.3-3-49.<97<9<;./4063-4.:?-.><:47.7?>@<.78 30?9::20@33-4:4=9.:/063-4-0@/4.6744<14 43.3.07/9:4<./=0/4<069??0:<.78>2 (& )##* $ ./30>0** !