Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63495 (KAR)
SHUBASHREE v. THE STATE OF KARNATKA
WP/200528/2025 · 2025-10-23
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63495 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63495 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
! # $%!! # $%!"%& "
'!!(
! "#
#$%&%'()
*
#
' ##
$%+((('
)
# #,%&%'()
*
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
))+ )) ##
#
)( +) )()! ((')()%
-$ . )( +) )()! /
/
/
0 1234 531 6131370 126 8613137065 294 :9;;6< 3017 =>641370 126 75<65 <916< ((')()% 89446< "? 126 #950919@9 1916 <A303415913B6 53">09; #9;9">59C3 D75 42751 E126 53">09;F 30 88;3:91370 7)( +) )()! G2656"? 126 988;3:91370 D3;6< "? 126 8613137065 G94 <34A3446< ) 536D D9:14 7D 126 :946 956 1291 126 8613137065 G94 98873016< 70 :70159:1 "9434 94 90 44341901 >";3: 5746:>175948659887301A60175<65<916<)())()(D75
- 3 -
9 86537< 7D 43H A70124 75 13;; 865A90601 9887301A601 34
"630CA9<6G23:26B6534695;36557A13A61713A6126 9887301A601 7D 126 8613137065 G94 6H160<6< ? 75<65 <916< )(( )() 94 865 006H>56,+ 126 8613137065F4 465B3:64 294 "660 165A30916< 0 265 8;9:6 47A6 71265 865470G9498873016<"?75<65<916<)+( )()630C 9CC536B6<"?12649A61268613137065294988579:26<126 53">09; "? D3;30C 90 88;3:91370 7)( +) )()! 26 53">09; "? 314 75<65 <916< ((')()% <34A3446< 126 988;3:91370D3;6<"?1268613137065630C9CC536B6<"?126 49A6126861313706534"6D75612347>51
53A661 #>A95 642890<6 ;69506< 60375 7>046; 98869530C 70 "629;D 7D 532>4956 D75 126 8613137065 294 :70160<6< 1291 9<A3116<;? 126 3A8>C06< 165A3091370 75<65 294 "660 344>6< G3127>1 C3B30C 90? 0713:6 17 126 8613137065 26 49A6 34 30 B37;91370 7D 8530:38;647D091>59;I>413:690<:701595?17126857B343704 7D513:;64'!90<'+7D126704131>13707D0<39
- 4 -
9 6:70<;? 26 :70160<6< 1291 70 (+())() 126 8613137065 294 4>"A3116< 9 ;69B6 988;3:91370 1257>C2 CA93;56=>64130C;69B6D57A( ())()17' ())()70 126C57>0<129126570;?<9>C2165G94071@66830CC77< 269;12 26 49A6 294 071 "660 <348>16< "? 126 ;69506< <<313709; 7B650A601 <B7:916 98869530C D75 126 1916 048316 7D 1291 G3127>1 C3B30C 90? 0713:6 466@30C 6H8;9091370D57A1268613137065126165A309137075<65294
"660 89446< 70 126 C57>0< 1291 8613137065 G94 >09>1275346<;?9"4601D57A126<>1? " 941;? 26 :70160<6< 1291 126 3A8>C06< 165A3091370 75<65 294 "660 89446< A9@30C :651930 9;;6C913709C9304112686131370651291177G3127>1C3B30C90 788751>031?176H8;93012649A62649A63430B37;91370 7D 513:;6 '' 7D 126 704131>1370 7D 0<39 >51265 26 :70160<6< 1291 75<65 7D 165A3091370 34 071 9 43A8;3:3175 26 49A6 34 89446< A9@30C D9;46 9;;6C913704 9C93041 126 8613137065 0<65 12646 :35:>A4190:64 6B60 D75 126 :70159:16A8;7?6641260713:63456=>356<17"6344>6<0
- 5 -
1234 42751 C57>0< 26 :70160<6< 1291 126 531 6131370 34 56=>356<17"69;;7G6< ! ;69506< <<313709; 7B650A601 <B7:916 98869530C D75 126 1916 294 :70160<6< 1291 9887301A6017D861313706534D75986537<7D43HA7012470 :70159:1 "9434 4 865 126 :70159:1 601656< 3017 "61G660 126 8613137065 90< 126 564870<6014 3D 126 8613137065 B37;9164 90? :70<31370 7D 9887301A601 75<65 426 :90 "6 165A30916<G3127>1C3B30C90?0713:6 9 6 D>51265 :70160<6< 1291 9<A3116<;? 126 861313706529407191160<6<1267>51D57A( ())()17 ' ())() 90< G94 9"4601 D57A <>1? G3127>1 90?
865A344370 D57A 126 23C265 9>127531? 30:6 12656 34 9 B37;913707D:70<3137047D9887301A60175<651269>127531? 29453C21;?165A30916<265D57A126465B3:64
" 6 D>51265 :70160<6< 1291 126 :70159:1 6A8;7?664 G27 29B6 "660 165A30916< 70 126 "9434 7D B37;913707D:70<3137047D126:70159:1<707156=>35690? - 6 -
0713:6 2656D756 26 :70160<6< 1291 126 53">09; 34 I>413D36<30<34A34430C126988;3:91370 % 695< 126 ;69506< :7>046; D75 126 8951364 65>46<126G531898654 + 13407130<348>1612918613137065G9498873016< 94 44341901 >";3: 5746:>175 "? 0713D3:91370 <916< ( (')()(70:70159:1"9434G3129:70<313701291165A7D :70159:1 34 D75 9 86537< 7D 43H A70124 75 13;; 56C>;95 9887301A601 34
"630C A9<6 G23:26B65 34 695;365 26569D165 126 9887301A601 7D 126 8613137065 G94 6H160<6< D57A 13A6 17 13A6 90< "? 126 3A8>C06< 75<65 <916< )(( )() 126 9887301A601 7D 126 8613137065 G94 165A30916< 1 34 B65? :;695 D57A 126 3A8>C06< 75<65 <916< )(( )() B3<6 006H>56,+ 1291 12656 34 90 9;;6C91370 9C93041 126 8613137065 1291 426 G94 >09>1275346<;? 9"4601 D57A 126 <>1? 260 4>:2 90 9;;6C9137034A9<66B609C930419:70159:1>9;6A8;7?6631 34 06:64495? 17 344>6 9 0713:6 466@30C 90 6H8;9091370 0 126 8564601 :946 126 8613137065 29< 4>"A3116< 126 ;69B6
- 7 -
;61165 70 (+())() 419130C 1291 265 <9>C2165 G94 46537>4;? 3;; 90< 126 49A6 29< "660 4601 1257>C2 6A93;
? 126 3A8>C06< 75<65 <916< )(( )() 12656 34 07 :7043<65913707D12656;6B901D9:14263A8>C06<75<6534 6H159:16<"6;7G
:
(1) ! "#$ %
& '() *
& % 11 +& ! #--+& ! ,'$ -. /$01 2'& . 3040 ' & $01 5 6' .. 02 78 9:7 %01 + !0. ; <! => 0 %
& 8 ,? )&@ > A" 40 6(B) 8$@ > A" 40 B. 9@ > %C$ 2C. D
< &@ > B. 9 4 07.01.2020 EFG H 5: => I$JK 8> BL MN <$O
). . (2) $P ! "#$ %
& Q' <R *
& % 02 +& ! #--+& ! ,' -. /> 2'& . 3040 ' & $01 5 6' ..010 7 G/S + (TU TU5 %01 %
& 8 ,? )&@ < A" 40 06(B) 8$@ > A" 40 B. 9@ > %C$ 2C D
< &@ > B. 9 4: 15.02.2022 EFG H 5: => I$JK 8> BL
MN <$O
). .
- 8 -
(3) 78 9:7 8> +& #, G.V (,.E) V .W.WX.G 2'& B$ % 4;7.2.2023 EYZ > %! )/ -[ & T$ \ MN. 2C. M68&01 5]. > 3 +#@)/, !& 645'< - ^ _E2) E_)& ` !> V * &01 a") C01 <NG <$O. bb, V &
; $PC _ MN <NC! 2'& . 3040 $ . . ; <@ cR8/d e (> f !&!>
Q! E_)& ` !g Mhi") Wjk! 5N/ - 5' lm 6GC ](. 7 G/S &(TU n 8> +& ! #d GoV
V oWoWXoG 2'&d @ <T % 2'& &
=> > 3 +#@8/d > 3 +#@8& (> f E_)& ` !g EZ &01 =d B (> f 2C. EZ 5]. 5' lm 6GC ](. o B/! 78 9:7 8> +& ! &<#d GoV p,oEq
V oWoWXG 2'& B$
7 G/S &(TU n 8> +& ! #d GoV
V oWoWoGo 2'& @ <T %$01 8> BL
+& ! #01
" g r]s > <= (> f % tu &01 G;@ o
! &01
<'9") !7G e $];
B. 7G. o
B. 9 v I% wxy zz% w{wx Q $|d
4} w{o{~ow{w•o &01 E!G 9$ 601
&d 78 9:7 8> +& ! #d GoV o p,oEq
*oWoW€oG 2'& B$
7 G/S &(TU nd 8> +& ! #d GoV o
V oW•oGo 2'&
- 9 -
@ <T %$01 8> BL +& ! #
" g e lT4 V!> (; r]s > <=G B. 7G. ‚o
57A569<30C7D1269"7B675<653134B65?:;695 1291 126 75<65 7D 165A3091370 34 071 9 43A8;3:3175 0 9;;6C91370 34 A9<6 9C93041 126 8613137065 1291 426 G94 9"4601 D57A <>1? >09>1275346<;? G3127>1 19@30C 90? 865A3443702604>:2909;;6C9137034A9<66B60D75126 :70159:16A8;7?664126?95656=>356<17D7;;7G8530:38;64 7D091>59;I>413:6"?C3B30C90713:60123442751C57>0< 126G53186131370<6465B6417"69;;7G6< & 0B36G7D1269"7B6G68944126D7;;7G30C
3 26G5318613137034 33 26 5<65 89446< "? 126 #950919@9 1916 <A303415913B6 53">09; #9;9">59C3 60:2 30 88;3:91370 7)( +) )()! <916< ((')()%34=>9426<
- 10 -
333 2675<65<916<)(( )()89446<"?126 '41 564870<601 90< 126 75<65 <916< )+( )() 89446< "?
126 )0< 564870<601
"69530C 7#3 # 29
() )(),)!B3<6006H>564,+90< 956 9;47=>9426< 3B 30:6 126 8613137065 294 "660 165A30916< D57A 465B3:6 70 )(( )() 90< 30 265 8;9:6 47A6 71265 :90<3<916 294 "660 98873016< 3D 90? 71265 B9:90:? 34 9B93;9";6426:90"69::7AA7<916<G31230 1G7G66@4D57A126<9167D56:63817D:78? 7D123475<65 B 26564870<6014429;;:70<>:160=>35?90< 12649A629417"6:7A8;616<G3123063C21 G66@4 D57A 126 <916 7D 56:6381 7D :78? 7D 123475<6526564870<6014956<356:16<17 C3B6 90 788751>031? 17 126 8613137065 90<
- 11 -
89449885785391675<654309::75<90:6G312 ;9G B3 D12686131370654>::66<43012660=>35?17
"626;<3012916B601126861313706529417
"6563041916<3017465B3:6
!)* '!( %
!)* '"%& "( %
3417';7%