- 1 - !"! #"$$ %% &' () %% * ( ) !" # $ #%&'( ! % $ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #%&'( ) ! *( +(&!(+ '&!(" $ *( ) !" # $ #%&'( ! % $ - 3 - #%&'( ) ! *( +(&!(+ ,(!(" $ - . " /011234534 6784923: 038 0;0<8 80:28 +(&!(+ =0>>28?@885:5A301235A< 5B517842038 A995>>5A32<CA< 9=1A@22> A9=23>0:5A3560@0=7</2<2530C:2<<2C2<<28:A0> . A995>>5A32<. CA< ?<2B5:@ 53 A'&!(" 038 3A,(!(":/2>20==201>0<2C5128 ! 9:<22:5 0:51 21D7385 120<328 EA73>21 >7?95::28 0==201> ;2<2 ?@ 53>7<2< E/011234534 C538534 AC A995>>5A32< 0?A7: <210:5A3>/5= AC E105903: ;5:/ A;32< AC 53>7<28 B2/5E12 0> 29=1A@22 038 29=1A@2< 038 :/2<2?@ 0BA58 150?515:@7382<0;0<8 - 4 - * : ;0> >7?95::28 ?<52C C0E:> 0> >:0:28 ?@ <2>=A3823:> ;2<2 :/0: <2>=A3823: 3A! 29=1A@2< 29=1A@28 :/29 0> /09015>EAA152 ;A<D923 53 4AA8> B2/5E12 ?20<534 3AF!&F%(+* A;328 ?@ /59 038 53>7<28 ;5:/ 0==21103: 53>7<2<A39A3:/1@;042>AC%(((F038%(F=2<80@0> ?/0:0:;0>C7<:/2<>:0:28:/0:0>=2<53>:<7E:5A3AC29=1A@2< 0: 0?A7: *( =9 A3 !"(*!(! ;/23 ;A<D923 ;2<2 A3 87:@ 53 0CA<2>058 B2/5E12 CA< :<03>=A<:534 4<0=2> :A;0<8> 06=7<320<5:/01F7D953529=120:03:30=7<B5110428<5B2< 8<AB25:53<0>/03832415423:90332<0381A>:EA3:<A1AB2<5: 72 :A ;/5E/ 5: :A==128 8A;3 ?@ >582 AC <A08 038 E07>28 0EE5823: 038 ;A<D923 >7>:05328 5367<52> 2>=5:2 :<20:923: :/2@ 858 3A: <2EAB2< C711@ 038 >7>:05328 =2<90323: =0<:501 =/@>5E0185>0?515:@ " 1059534 EA9=23>0:5A3 CA< >092 :/2@ C5128 0==15E0:5A3 7382< 2E:5A3 !! AC 9=1A@22> A9=23>0:5A3 E: <208;5:/2E:5A3!"038,9238923:E:!((+CA< >/A<:. E:. % 3 EA3:2>: A;32< AC B2/5E12 823528 042 038 9A3:/1@ 53EA92 AC E105903:> ?7: 0895::28 0EE5823: 038 - 5 - 29=1A@923:ACE105903:>0>EAA152>CA</5>4AA8>B2/5E12?7:A3 9A3:/1@ ;042> AC !%((F 038 8051@ ?/0:0 AC *(F 038 E105928 :A ?2 5382935C528 ?@ 53>7<2< 3>7<2< A==A>28 E1059 823@5340EE5823:?7:0895::285>>703E2AC53>7<03E2=A15E@038 823528 150?515:@ A3 4<A738 :/0: E105903:> ;2<2 4<0:75:A7> =0>>2342<>0383A:EAB2<287382<53>7<03E2=A15E@ ' 0>28 A3 =1208534> A995>>5A32< C<0928 5>>72> 038 <2EA<828 2B5823E2 105903:> 2G095328 :/29>21B2> 038 <0B53010>>:A*0384A:90<D28G>F:AF, 3>7<2<2G0953285:>ACC5E5010>F0384A:90<D28EA=@AC 53>7<03E2=A15E@0>GF , 3 EA3>582<0:5A3 A995>>5A32< /218 E105903:> 2>:0?15>/28 <210:5A3>/5= AC 29=1A@2< 038 29=1A@22 038 0?A7: 0EE5823:AEE7<<53487<534EA7<>2AC038A7:AC29=1A@923:: 82:2<95328 ;A<D903 53 3A'&!(" ;0> & @20<> 20<3534 9A3:/1@ 53EA92 AC %(((F : 0>>2>>28 85>0?515:@ 0: "H 38 0==1@534 <212B03: C0E:A< 52 !!'*& 0;0<828 :A:01 EA9=23>0:5A3AC',+!((F & 5D2;5>2 53 3A,(!(" 5: 82:2<95328 ;A<D903 ;0> + @20<> /5> 9A3:/1@ 53EA92 ;0> %(((F : - 6 - 82:2<9532885>0?515:@;0>0:'H380==1@534<212B03:C0E:A< AC!!'*&0;0<828EA9=23>0:5A3AC',%,((F A995>>5A32< 85<2E:28 53>7<2< :A =0@ 53:2<2>: 0: !H =2< 03379 C<A9 !"(*!(! 52 C<A9 80:2 AC 0EE5823: :511 5:> <2015I0:5A3 44<52B280==201>;2<2C5128?@53>7<2< + : ;0> C5<>:1@ >7?95::28 0> =2< =A15E2 53B2>:540:5A3 <2EA<8> E105903:> ;2<2 3A: 29=1A@22> ?7: 4<0:75:A7> =0>>2342<> ;/A>2 <5>D ;0> 3A: EAB2<28 : ;0> >7?95::28 53>7<28 B2/5E12 ;0> 0 J 28579 AA8> 2/5E12- ;5:/ E0<<@534 E0=0E5:@ACK!038=<29579=058;0>:AEAB2<<5>DAC<5B2< A387E:A<038 12032<?7:3A:EAA152> ( :;0>C7<:/2<>7?95::28:/A74/=2<90323:=0<:501 =/@>5E0185>0?515:@>7>:05328?@E105903:>;0>0>>2>>280:"H 038 'H <2>=2E:5B21@ 5: C05128 :A 0EEA73: CA< >092 ;/512 E01E710:534EA9=23>0:5A3<2>71:534532GE2>>5B20;0<83B52; AC0?AB2>7?>:03:501L72>:5A3>AC10;0?A7:150?515:@0>;2110> L703:79 AC EA9=23>0:5A3 ?2534 A==A>28 :A 10; 0<A>2 CA< EA3>582<0:5A3 3 A:/2< /038 <5 0340304A780 5<080< A==A>280==201> - 7 - ! 20<8 120<328 EA73>21 =2<7>28 59=74328 6784923:0380;0<80>;2110><2EA<8> * <A90?AB2>7?>:03:501L72>:5A3AC10;:/0:;A718 0<5>2CA<EA3>582<0:5A30<2 ! " 5:/EA3>23:AC120<328EA73>2190::2<;0>/20<8 A3>058>7?>:03:501L72>:5A3>AC10; % /0112342A3150?515:@5>A3:;A4<A738>5<>:1@:/0: E105903:> ;2<2 4<0:75:A7> =0>>2342<> 038 3A: 29=1A@22> 038 2B235C:/2@;2<2EAA152>:/2@;2<23A:EAB2<287382<GF 3>7<03E2A15E@ ' 3A<82<:A2>:0?15>/:/25<<210:5A3>/5=;5:/A;32<AC B2/5E12 E105903:> 3A: A31@ <21528 A3 :/25< 0>>2<:5A3> 53 =1208534> ?7: 01>A A3 0895>>5A3 ?@ A;32< 53 =1208534 53E2 C538534 AC A995>>5A32< :A :/5> 2G:23: 5> ?0>28 A3 E120< - 8 - 0895>>5A3038;A718?2C538534ACC0E:3A>7?>:03:501L72>:5A3 AC10;;A7180<5>2CA<EA3>582<0:5A3 , 7<:/2< :/A74/ GF3>7<03E2 A15E@ ;A718 3A: EAB2< <5>D AC EAA152> 038 =<29579 =058 ;0> :A EAB2< <5>D AC 8<5B2<EA387E:A<038E12032<0895::281@B2/5E1253L72>:5A35> 0 712 (( AC A:A< 2/5E12 712> ;A718 07:/A<5I2 E0<<5042 AC :/<22 EAA152> 53 CA< =7<=A>2> AC 1A08534 038 731A08534 AC 4AA8> 895::281@ B2/5E12 ;0> :<03>=A<:534 4<0=2>;/235:92:;5:/0EE5823: & >59510< 5>>72 0<A>2 CA< EA3>582<0:5A3 ?2CA<2 0 5B5>5A3 23E/ AC :/5> A7<: 53 E0>2 AC ! "<2=A<:2853 +,+- ./ ;/2<2535:;0>/218 "#$%& ' ( ' ) * + , %, - . / 0 1 2 . , , 2 0 3 2 4 2 & 14 % /2 - 2 ., / % - 9 - #5%6 - - % #)%, 7682 /+%9 %' : ; ' :** ' :*** % : ' /' ** . ' : < / 3 + %= #>%, - ? % , %* < < , *+, > ! !$ #) $@ < *+,#) *+,% %& *+,>9$@ % *+, ! < - % *+, !$ % - - < : % 4 - 10 - % 0 - :< ' $> // % , A BB/) 3 A !!) C - + A % DDD $B%, : %, ' :**: / ' $> , -E F% %* % , % , : % 0- % % , <%A:! %= + >53412 7842 AC :/5> A7<: 53 E0>2 AC /,-+0.1 +23/.+4-056.5,,+7.88.<2=A<:2853#$ %& /0>:/2<20C:2</218 - 11 - "#%,? . " $% , : - % 5%, ? 4 6 +(& G% )55) )55> )55@ )55H !BB) G * 0 %' + *0A!BC&A$#H % )% I ? : %= !( 3B52;AC0?AB2217E580:5A3>7?>:03:501L72>:5A3AC 10;3A5>03>;2<28530CC5<90:5B2 ! 3L703:795:5>3A:5385>=7:2:/0: A995>>5A32< /08 0>>2>>28 =2<90323: =0<:501 =/@>5E01 85>0?515:@ J- CA< >/A<: 0: "H 038 'H <2>=2E:5B21@ ?7: C05128 :A 0==1@ >092 ;/512 EA9=7:534 EA9=23>0:5A3 /2<2CA<2 EA9=7:0:5A3 AC - 12 - EA9=23>0:5A3 ;A718 ?2 EA3:<0<@ :A >:0:7:2 038 ;A718 E011 CA< <2FEA9=7:5340>CA11A;> 0 3 3A'&!("53EA92E1059285>%(((FK%( =2< 80@ 0> ?/0:0 ;/5E/ ;A718 ?2 '%((F 0E:A< 0==15E0?12 :A 042 82:2<95328 0: & ;A718 ?2 !!'*& 038 0: "H /7> EA9=23>0:5A3 :A;0<8> 1A>> AC 20<3534E0=0E5:@;A718?2 '%((FG'(HG"HG!!'*&M*%*%F ? 3 3A,(!("53EA92E1059285>%(((FK%( =2< 80@ 0> ?/0:0 ;/5E/ ;A718 ?2 '%((F 0E:A< 0==15E0?12 :A 042 82:2<95328 0: + ;A718 ?2 !!%!! 038 0: 'H /7> EA9=23>0:5A3 :A;0<8> 1A>> AC 20<3534E0=0E5:@;A718?2 '%((FG'(HG'HG!!%!!M%!,(F !! 7?>:03:501L72>:5A3AC10;3A!5>:/7>03>;2<2853 0CC5<90:5B2<2>=2E:5B21@ !* EEA<85341@CA11A;534 F 5 ==201>0<2011A;2853=0<:A31@A3L703:79 55 784923:0380;0<880:28+(&!(+=0>>28?@ 885:5A301235A< 5B517842038 A995>>5A32<CA< - 13 - 9=1A@22> A9=23>0:5A3 560@0=7< 53 3A>'&!("038,(!("0<29A85C528 555 ==21103: 53 3A'&!(" 5> /218 23:5:128 CA< :A:01 EA9=23>0:5A3 AC *%*%F 038 0==21103: 53 3A,(!(" 5> /218 23:5:128 CA< :A:01 EA9=23>0:5A3 AC %!,(F ;5:/ 53:2<2>: 0: <0:2 AC !H =2< 03379 C<A9 80:2 AC 0EE5823: 52 !"(*!(! :511 82=A>5: ;/5E/ >/011 ?2 82=A>5:28 ;5:/530=2<5A8AC>5G;22D>C<A980:2AC<2E25=:AC E2<:5C528EA=@AC:/5>6784923: 5B 382=A>5:23:5<2EA9=23>0:5A35>:A?2<2120>28 5( &$$' " 5>:A 1A %'