Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63477 (KAR)
SHIVANNA v. THE STATE BY LOKAYUKTHA POLICE STATIO
CRL.RP/200037/2025 · 2025-08-07
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63477 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63477 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $ ##
#
%
& %'() &% (( )* #+ ,
%,-%'()
,&% ((
)
*
!"##$" %
&
'
$ ()( ( ( (
(( ) ( !!$#*
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
,! (
( !$#$ % &
(( '
( ) !+ )+#+-' ( $-++#$* ( ) ) (()( )) (
#, #" +# +#$ - )
$-&$'&')
$" )
,+#$ ( )
+ ' (
) ( (. ( )
)(
,)
*
(
(()) ,+
( !$$$ ( ( !$$, % &
'
( ( ( !$#$ &(
( (( ) % & (( '
- 3 -
( ) -"* #$)
&'
-)
(
+-
$#
+#+
$-++#$*( ( ( ( ( ( (. ) ( )
)(
( ) ) ( ( (
(/
&(/
'
01 2134345617 46 748469: 1343456 5
+##*#,+#+! ;146< 9==>?1@ 5
+ 46 7481 5
,+#+ 5A 5B9C>B39 5:4=1393456 94=0>7 46 2:
9?1 5
$-++#$* 216@46< 56301A4:15A301:19761@@@434569:96@1??456?>@<1 D 21=49: 5>73 93 94=0>7 4? ?11B46< 35 E>9?0 301 =748469:275=11@46<?46434931@9<946?3048A573015AA16=1? 2>64?09;:1 >6@17 1=3456? #, #" +# +#$ 7F - 5A 3016@496169:5@1&A57?0573G.'96@>6@171=3456 $-&$'&=' 5A 71H163456 5A 577>23456 =3 &A57 ?0573 G =3.'
- 4 -
01 2134345617 46 748469: 1H4?456 1343456 5
+###-*+#+!;146<9==>?1@5
463019;5H1=9?14? ?11B46<35?139?4@130157@17@931@+-
$#
+#+29??1@46 2:
9?1 5
$-++#$* 71A1771@ 35 9;5H1 71I1=346< 04? 922:4=93456A57@4?=097<1 + (197@7496I9C
934::19761@=5>6?1:A57301 21343456179==>?1@ 5
+ 74
>7>79I 529: 95 :19761@ =5>6?1: A57 301 21343456179==>?1@ 5
96@ 74
>;09?0
9::92>7 :19761@ 21=49: >;:4= 75?1=>357 A57 301 71?256@163? 17>?1@3018931749:?5671=57@ - 6 H41F 5A 301 74H9: =563163456? >7<1@ ;C 301 :19761@=5>6?1:A57;530301297341?30125463?3093F5>:@ 974?1A578C=56?4@1793456971
!" #$
%
" & ' ( ) * $ &" $ &+ ,+ -( + . )&&/01
- 5 -
,2
3,
#$
%
" & ' ( ) * $ &" $ &+ ,+ -( + . )&&/014
C 96?F17 35 301 9;5H1 25463? 4? 46 301 A57301A5::5F46<
! 3 4? 301 =563163456 5A 301 2134345617? 46 ;530 21343456? 3093 7481 5
,+#$ 5A 5B9C>B39 5:4=1 393456 94=0>7 =981 35 ;1 71<4?3171@ 9<946?3 9==>?1@ 5? $35*
6H1?34<93456F9?>6@1739B1696@A469:712573 =981 35 ;1 A4:1@ A57 301 9;5H1 ?94@ 5AA16=1? 19761@
9<4?37931 355B =5<64J96=1 5A 301 5AA16=1? 5F 301 893317 4? 216@46< 46 2:
5
$-++#$* 56 301 A4:1 5A :19761@ @@434569: 96@ 1??456? >@<1 D 21=49: 5>73 93 94=0>7
530 9==>?1@ 5? + 96@ 922197? 35 09H1 A4:1@ ?1297931 922:4=93456?
?11B46< 30147 @4?=097<1
01
- 6 -
?94@922:4=93456?=98135;1@4?84??1@;C301749:5>73 ;C 29??46< ?484:97 57@17? ==>?1@ 5
+ A4:1@ 748469:
1343456>6@171=3456+5A7
?11B46<35E>9?0301 =748469: 275=11@46<? 46434931@ 9<946?3 048 F04:1 9==>?1@ 5
A4:1@ 71H4?456 21343456 =09::16<46< 301 57@17 5A @4?84??46<301922:4=93456A57@4?=097<1 , 0156:C<75>6@>7<1@;C;5303012134345617? 143017 35?11BE>9?046<5A 301 =748469: 275=11@46<? 5735 ?139?4@130157@1729??1@;C301749:5>7371I1=346<301 922:4=93456A57@4?=097<1
01=47=>:974??>1@;C3013931 5H1768163@931@+
#-
+#+-F04=0719@?9?>6@17K
!"# $%&''(
!"#$
$%& '($)* '$+ ,- ./-0123445
62. 3473
8 -
.9.:
; < => -? '$>- 347@ $A. ) (,5 -B ;
( -
9) B 9$BC
- ./- '$-
-
D $ ) (E 777 &) '$ 347@ = '
F -E4GH4GH347I -J% K ;
D $ -. L- ?B
H
F
D $ M '$-
- -N $ 'OP Q RC - %
9) S B
D $T HU
- 7 -
* 6 217>?9: 5A 301 275=11@46<? 5A 301 5H1768163 43 4? =:197 3093 301 5H1768163 F9? 922794?1@ F430 301 275;:18? 3093 971 ;146< A9=1@ ;C 301 6H1?34<9346< AA4=17 46 46H1?34<9346< ?>=0 5AA16=1? F04=0 97104<0:4<031@9?>6@17 &4' 3 4? 04<0:4<031@ 3093 301 I5; =97@? 4??>1@ >6@17 301 ?=0181 F171 $# 35 $! C197? 5:@ ?46=1 301 217?56? F05 F57B1@ >6@17 301 ?=0181 09H1 9:719@C 84<7931@ 35 53017 2:9=1? H16 301 6H1?34<9346<AA4=17F9?65346925?4345635H174AC ?>=0I5;=97@? &44' 01F57B=97741@5>346301:96@5A969<74=>:3>74?3 9;5>3 $#$! C197? 197:417 09? :5?3 43? 574<469:
=56@43456 96@ 30171A571 301 F57B >6@1739B16 9;5>39@1=9@19<5=5>:@653;1H174A41@ &444' 71@<46< 9 :9B1 @1H1:528163 5A 759@ 971 301 F57B>6@17301?=0181F04=0971=97741@5>3:56<
- 8 -
;9=B96@651H4@16=1=5>:@;189@19H94:9;:135 =75??H174AC3011L1=>34565AF57B &4H' )758 301 C197 +##*# 35 +#$$$+ A>:: A:1@<1@
?C?318 F9? 653 46 A57=1 96@ 30171A571 301 46A578934569;5>3301?9814?6539H94:9;:1 &H' 56?37>=3456 5A =01=B @98 96@
759@? 09H1 :5?3 30147 4@16343C @>1 35 693>79: =9:98431? 96@ 30147=56?37>=3456:56<;9=B4?653H174A49;:1 &H4' 46=130146=4@1634?85713096$#$!C197?;9=B 301 :9;5>717? 971 653 46 9 25?43456 35 <4H1 30147 ?39318163 71=5::1=346< 301 F57B >6@1739B16 ;C 3018 &H44' 96C 5A 301 96=09C93 1=7139741? F57B46< 46 H9745>? 798 96=09C93? 971 143017 713471@ 57 2758531@9?96=09C931H1:528163AA4=17?96@ 3796?A1771@35530172:9=1?5746896C=9?1?301C 09H1 @41@
(16=1 30147 9??4?396=1 =5>:@ 653 ;1 39B16
- 9 -
&H444' 01 574<469: 71=57@?
A5>6@ 46 301 ;96B 96@ 25?3 5AA4=109H19:719@C;116@1?375C1@96@?981971 6539H94:9;:1A57H174A4=93456 &4L' 976939B9 5B9C>B39 5:4=1 971 46H5:H1@ 46 46H1?34<93456 4635 301 =9?1? >6@17 301 71H163456 5A577>23456=396@301C97165346925?4345635 =582:13130146H1?34<9345646301271?163=9?1?;C H174AC46< 9:: ?>=0 F57B? >6@1739B16 @>746< 301 21745@5A!C197? &L' >746< 301 21745@ 5A ! C197? >6@17
?=01819;5>3"
,9B0?F57B?F171>6@1739B16 46-#4?374=3?5A393196@H174A4=934565A9::305?1 F57B? 96@ @5=>8163? F4:: 39B1 ?>AA4=4163:C :56< 21745@5A3481 &L4' 9B46< 4635 =56?4@1793456 9:: 301?1 @4AA4=>:341? A9=1@ ;C 301 6H1?34<9346< AA4=17 301 46H1?34<93456 3093 F9? 1637>?31@ 35 5B9C>B39 5:4=1F9?F430@79F6
- 10 -
19761@ =5>6?1: A57 301 2134345617? =56316@1@ 3093 46 H41F 5A =47=>:97 @931@ +
#-
+#+- 301 =9?1 71<4?3171@ ;C 5B9C>B39 5:4=1 217394646< 35 909389 96@04 934569: >79: 82:5C8163 >9796311 =3 & ' ?=0181 F9? F430@79F6 96@ 30171A571 301 2134345617? 971 16343:1@ 35 ?11B E>9?046< 5A 301 =748469:
275=11@46<? 57 35 ?13 9?4@1 301 57@17 5A 301 749: 5>73 @4?84??46<301922:4=93456A57@4?=097<1
01?981=96653 ;19==1231@9?65?>=0819646<=5>:@;189@15>3A758 301 =47=>:97 @931@ +
#-
+#+-
6 301 53017 096@ 43 89B1?=:197309356:C30146H1?34<9345646?>=0=9?1?F171 F430@79F6
46=1301F57@46<?46301=47=>:974?H17C=:197 35?3931309330146H1?34<9345656:C46305?1=9?1?71A1771@ 35 3017146 09H1 ;116 F430@79F6
6 301271?163 =9?1 301 46H1?34<93456 4? =582:131@ 96@ =097<1 ?0113 4? 9:719@C A4:1@
5F3018933174?216@46<;1A571301749:5>73A57 3749:
0171A57143=96653;1;75><03F430463012>7H41F5A 301=47=>:97@931@+
#-
+#+-
- 11 -
" 6=1 301 6H1?34<9346< AA4=17 A4:1? 301 A469: 71257396@301749:5>7339B1?=5<64J96=15A3015AA16=1 9?04<0:4<031@46301A469:7125733016H1?34<9346<AA4=17 ;1=581? A>6=3>? 5AA4=49: 96@ 01 =96653 ;1 21784331@ 35 F430@79F ?>=0 275=11@46<? F4305>3 71=5>7?1 35 301 275=1@>719?=563182:931@463013016748469:75=1@>71 5@157301271?163097934C99<974B>79B?09960439 $# 01 6H1?34<9346< AA4=17 46 301 271?163 =9?1 09? 9:719@C A4:1@ A469: 712573 F430 H5:>8465>? @5=>8163? F04=0 89B1? 5>3 27489A94=1 =9?1 ;9?1@ 56 F04=0 301 =5<64J96=1F9?39B16
6@17?>=0=47=>8?396=1?985A 3015246456 3093 43 4? 6539 A43 =9?135 E>9?0 301=748469:
275=11@46<?5735?139?4@130157@17
01749:5>739A317 39B46< 4635 =56?4@1793456 9:: 301 8931749:? 56 71=57@ 29??1@ 301 57@17 @931@ +-
$#
+#+
@5 653 A46@ 96C 719?56?35E>9?0301=748469:275=11@46<?5735?139?4@1 301 57@17 5A 301 749: 5>73 71I1=346< 301 922:4=93456 A57 @4?=097<1
6H41F5A3019;5H196?F179;5H12546346 30161<934H196@275=11@3529??301A5::5F46<
- 12 -
530 301 748469: 1343456 5
+##*#,+#+! 96@ 748469: 1H4?456 1343456 5
+###-*+#+! 971 0171;C @4?84??1@
.) %##( $
4?35
$:5
-!