- 1 - !"# ## $%& ' ! !! "##$ % !! ! & !"'"(# )* ! "##$ ! ! ! ! "##$ % !&+ $,$,$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & !,& !!& ,$$& ! & ! ! * ! !! ! & * $$$ ,$$ ! ! * ! & ,#$$" (- ,#$$$$" - & * ) ! & * ! . . /! * " 0123 450 12678094: ;< =012903 >;79:0= <;2 ?;45 450 @124A0: 5A: 1@@01= A: <A=03 161A9:4 450 B7368094 ;< 450 2A?791=A9 ;,$$31403$$$@1::03?C450 33A4A;91= 09A;2 ADA= *7360 193 08?02 14 1=1?7216A 50 <1>4: ;< 450 >1:0 120 4514 ;9 ($$ @04A4A;902 20E70:403 20:@;93094 ; 4; 32;@ 5A8 4; 1A=F1C 414A;9 4; ?;123 450 421A9 1: 50 F1: :02DA96 A9 136A2 ;D4 ;:@A41= 4 4514 4A80 1 8;4;2 >C>=0 ?012A96 206A:4214A;9 ;'(# >180 A9 1 21:5 193 906=A6094 819902 9012 - 3 - !15;4A 042;= 78@19331:5034;45032AD0214($$ 3704; F5A>5 50 <0== 3;F9 ;9 450 62;793 193 :7:41A903 62A0D;7: A9B72A0:50201<40250F1::5A<4034;1:1D0:5F121;:@A41= 1=1?7216A 193 450201<402 :5A<403 4; 0941= ;:@A41= 512F13 <;2 5A6502 420148094 04A4A;902>=1A8194 F5; F1: 1603 1?;74 # C012: F;2GA96 1: 1 ;>4;2 ;D0298094 08@=;C00 <A=03 1 >=1A8 1@@=A>14A;9 >=1A8A96 >;8@09:14A;9 ;< :,#$$$$"502A?791=>;9:A302A96450094A2081402A1=;9 20>;236219403:,#$$"FA45A94020:4144502140;<(-@02 19978<2;84503140;<@04A4A;94A==201=AH14A;9 662A0D03?C450:1A3B7368094;<4502A?791=450 A9B7203>=1A8194<A=03191@@01=F5020A9A4A: >;94093034514 80160218;794F1:6219403793024505013=;::;<1809A4A0: =;::;<>;9D0C19>01939;18;794A:6219403793024505013 =;::;<A9>;80372A96=1A37@@02A;319345018;794:6219403 793024505013:=;::;<&74720 9>;80193@1A9193:7<<02A96 120 ;9 450 =;F02 :A30 193 4;F123: =;:: ;< &74720 03A>1= I@09:0: :$$$$" 4; :#$$$$" A: 20E7A203 4; ?0 6219403 1: 450 :180 F1: 9;4 6219403 ?C 450 2A?791= - 4 - 5020<;2020E70:403<;209519>080941931>>;23A96=C:;7654 4;1==;F4501@@01= # 5;765450@04A4A;90251::41403451450:7:41A903 =;::;<:1=12C5051:9;4@2;37>0319C20>;23A945A:206123 : @02 I # J 450 F;793 >024A<A>140 50 :7:41A903 <;==;FA96 A9B72A0:. A &21>4720;<2A654HC6;814A>2>5 AA A654A9<21;2?A41=8126A9 AAA =003A96A9B72C;92A654:A30;<<;205013 50>=1A8194F1:5;:@A41=AH03<;2$31C:193I (193 I ,"4503A:>51260123:;<450>=1A8194F020@2;37>03 ( 50@04A4A;902F1:0I18A9031: 19350:41403 451450804FA45191>>A3094;9($$ 9A4A1==C50F1: 6AD09<A2:41A314450 2A812C01=4512009420193F1:=1402 :5A<4034;512F130F1:19A9@14A094<2;8$$4; #$$193:72602CF1:@02<;2803;9$$$A019 ;@09 2037>4A;9 193 A940291= <AI14A;9 ;< <21>47203 <2168094: 7:A96 93A19 4A419A78 @=140: 0 F1: 13DA:03 4; 793026; <;==;F"7@4201480941<4023A:>5126050<A2:4193:0>;932A654 7@@02A9:>A::;2:19319A9040045F020=;:43704;450A9B72A0: - 5 - :7:41A903 A9 450 :1A3 1>>A3094 0 <724502 :41403 4514 50 :7<<0203 =;:: ;< @1C <;2 ;90 193 1 51=< 8;945: A0 <2;8 ($$ 4; $#$ 0 F1: 0129A96 1 :1=12C ;< :($#" @02 8;945 372A96 450 C012 $ 193 457: =;:4 4;41=;<:$(#"0<724502:414034514500I18A903 450 3;>4;2 F5; @2;37>03 450 F;793 >024A<A>140 3A:>51260 :78812C 193 >=A9A>1= <A93A96: :41403 4514 450 3A:1?A=A4C F1: 1::0::03 14 #- 193 4514 450 >=1A8194 20E7A203 19;4502 :72602C <;2 450 208;D1= ;< @=140: F5A>5 F;7=3 >;:4 ?04F009 :$$$$" 193 :#$$$$" 3A:1?A=A4C >024A<A>140 F1: 1=:; A::703 A9 45A: 206123 : 450 @04A4A;902 F1: 1 6;D0298094 08@=;C004502A?791=50=34514 45020F1:9;=;::;<A9>;80 370 4; 450 A9B72A0: :7:41A903 A9 450 1>>A3094 09>0 9; 18;794F1:6219403793024505013K!;::;<&74720 9>;80L 193450:1803;0:9;420E7A20A9402<0209>0 , 9DA0F;<450>;94094A;9;<450=012903>;79:0=<;2 4501@@0==194451450F1:096160319144093194<;2;90C012 45A:;724<A93:4;1F123:$$$$"<;2219:@;2414A;9I421 ;72A:58094 193 44093194 >51260: 38A4403=C 370 4; 450 1>>A3094;>>72203;9($$5020E7A20:19;4502:72602C - 6 - <;2 208;D1=;< 450 A8@=194: 9302 450:0 >A2>78:419>0: 45A: ;724<A93:A4201:;91?=04;1F123:#$$$$"<;2208;D1=;< A8@=194: 9 DA0F ;< 450 1?;D0 450 @04A4A;902 :7:41A903 :A8@=0 193 62A0D;7: A9B72A0: 193 :7<<02A96 4; 3; 31C 4; 31C 1>4ADA4A0: 5020<;20 45A: ;724 <00=: 4; 09519>0 450 18;794 F5A>5A:20"1::0::031:<;==;F:. ()*+ ,-./0.+ 1A9193:7<<02A96 #$$$$" !;::;<1809A4A0: #$$$$" 03A>1=0I@09:0: $$" 219:@;2414A;9 0I421 9;72A:58094 193144093194>51260: $$$$" #&74720 03A>1=I@09:0: #$$$$" ;41= 1 123 >>;23A96=C 450 >=1A8194 A: 094A4=03 <;2 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9 ;< +1 123 1: 161A9:4 :,#$$" 1F12303 ?C 450 2A?791= 193 094A4=03 <;2 >;8@09:14A;9 ;< + 43 945020:7=4450<;==;FA96;2302A:@1::03. A 501@@01=A: - 7 - AA 50 >=1A8194 A: 094A4=03 <;2 450 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9 ;< :$$" FA45 A94020:414(-@0219978<2;84503140 ;<@04A4A;94A==4503140;<201=AH14A;9 AAA 0:@;93094 J 9:7219>0 ;8@19C 51: 1=2013C 30@;:A403 450 >;8@09:14A;9 6219403 ?C 450 2A?791= 5020<;20 20:@;93094 A: 3A20>403 4; 30@;:A4 09519>03 >;8@09:14A;9 ;< :$$$"FA45A94020:4:41403 FA45A9 1 @02A;3 ;< ;90 8;945 <2;8 450 3140;<;2302 AD 9 :7>5 30@;:A4 450 1@@0==194: 120 094A4=03 <;2 FA45321F 450 18;794 1=;96 FA45A94020:41>>2703;9A4 *3 $#& " !A:4;.=;.,.*