- 1 - !" #$% %% &!' ( ! " # # $ # %&'( !) #*' (+'" , ))# # !##" )) - Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) '( ! ),. " ))+*!") ) $ '+, $ &$ '(,' ) +*'''/ ) $ 0 $ $ 123324 5678394: ;<= ><==97 24 '+, ?4 2='*,' <47 '(,' @A :B9 77?:?24<C 94?2D ?E?C$6789&$ <4777?:?24<C <:?7<D!F2D=B2D: G:B9D?@64<CH"B?=<>>9<C?=F?C97@A:B91C<?3<4:?4 2'(,' , B9 1C<?3<4: <897 ( A9<D= ;2DI?48 <= :9<1B9D 39: ;?:B <4 <11?794: 24 *,+ <47 =6=:<?497 8D?9E26= ?456D9= B9D9F2D9 B9 F?C97 < 1C<?3 >9:?:?24 @9F2D9 :B9 D?@64<C 1C<?3?48 123>94=<:?24 2F =** <C248 ;?:B ?4:9D9=: <: '/ >< B9 - 3 - D?@64<C 124=?79D?48 :B9 94:?D9 9E?79419 24 D912D7 8D<4:97123>94=<:?242F=+*'';?:B?4:9D9=:<:/ >< FD23 :B9 7<:9 2F >9:?:?24 :?CC D9<C?=<:?24 <47 7?D91:97 D9=>24794:2,4=6D<41923><4A:279>2=?::B9=<39 * 88D?9E97@A:B9=<?75678394:<47<;<D7:B9 ?456D97 1C<?3<4: B<= >D9F9DD97 :B?= <>>9<C ?4 ;B?1B ?: ?= 124:94797 :B<: B9 ;<= 9<D4?48 =* >9D 324:B @6: ?4 :B9 1D2==9J<3?4<:?24 B9 =:<:97 :B<: B9 ;<= 89::?48=<C<DA2F=('>9D324:B=>9DJ *B9 ;<= <73?::97 ?4 :B9 B2=>?:<C 24 *,+ <47 7?=1B<D897 24 ,+ 9 =>94: =* :2;<D7= 397?1<C 9J>94=9= @6: :B9 D?@64<C B<= 8D<4:97 24CA ='*'' 6479D :B9 =<?7 B9<7 <47 :B9 <3264:= <;<D797 6479D 2:B9D B9<7= <D9 39<8D9 9 <C=2 6479D;94: =6D89DA F2D D932E<C 2F :B9 ?3>C<4:= @6: 42 <3264:;<=<;<D797F2DF6:6D9397?1<C9J>94=9=9;<= @97D?7794F2D:;2324:B=@6::B9D?@64<CB<=<;<D797 39<8D9<3264:6479D:B9B9<7GC2==2F?4123976D?48C<?7 - 4 - 6>>9D?27H<47:B9?4:9D9=:?=:2@9<;<D797<:,/>< B9D9F2D9D9K69=:97F2D94B<419394:2F123>94=<:?24 ( 9<D7:B9<D86394:=2F@2:B=?79= = >9D J , L 2647 9D:?F?1<:9 <>>9CC<4: =6FF9D97><?4<47=;9CC?482FD?8B:C98<4764<@C9:232E9 :B9D?8B:C2;9DC?3@456DA?=8D?9E26=?44<:6D94:B9 ?=1B<D89 6339DA ?: ?= 394:?2497 :B<: <>>9CC<4: ;<= 7?<842=97FD<1:6D92FF936D*D72@=9DE97:B?8B ><?4 79F2D3?:A <47 =6D89DA ;<= 7249 F2D ?4:9DC21I?48 4<?C?48 F936D D?8B: 6479D =>?4<C <4<9=:B9=?< ?4 C<:9D<C >2=?:?24>>9CC<4:B<=42:9J<3?497:B921:2D:2>D2E9 :B9 7?=<@?C?:A B9D9F2D9 K69=:?24 2F <==9==?48 7?=<@?C?:A 729=42:<D?=9 B268B :B9 <>>9CC<4: =:<:97 :B<: B9 ;<= ;2DI?48<=9<1B9D<479<D4?48=<C<D?97?41239B9F<?C97 :2>D2E9:B9=<39B9D9F2D9<=>9D:B91B<D:>D9><D97 @A :B9 #<D4<:<I< :<:9 98<C 9DE?19= 6:B2D?:A :B?= - 5 - 26D:F?47=?:D9<=24<@C9:2:<I9:B942:?24<C?412392F:B9 <>>9CC<4:<:=,F2D:B9<11?794:2F:B9A9<D,+ + B9 <>>9CC<4: ;<= B2=>?:<C?M97 F2D * 7<A= 24=?79D?48 :B9 >9D?27 2F B2=>?:<C?M<:?24 <47 4<:6D9 2F ?456D?9=:B?=26D:F?47=?:D9<=24<@C9:2<;<D7<4<3264: 2F =, F2D ?456DA <47 =* F2D :D<4=>2D:<:?249J:D<426D?=B394:<47<::947<4:1B<D89= >>9CC<4:B<7F?C97397?1<C@?CC=:2:B9:6492F=+ <= >9D J ( 9419 :B?= 26D: F?47= ?: D9<=24<@C9 :2 <;<D7=+:2;<D7=397?1<C9J>94=9=B268B?4 :B9 1C<?3 >9:?:?24 ?: ;<= =:<:97 :B<: :B9 1C<?3<4: ;<= ;2DI?48 <= 9<1B9D @6: 42 7216394: ;<= >D276197 :2 >D2E9:B9=<39B9D9F2D9:B?=26D:F?47=?:D9<=24<@C9 :2 <;<D7 <4 <3264: 2F =*+ F2D C2== 2F ?41239 76D?48C<?76>>9D?27<=B93?8B:42:B<E9<::94797<4A ;2DI <:C9<=: F2D < >9D?27 2F * 324:B= 769 :2 ?456D?9= =6FF9D97 @A B?3 :B9 <11?794: 2;9E9D 123>94=<:?24 <;<D797 @A :B9 D?@64<C <: =, F2D ><?4 <47 =6FF9D?48=<47=F2DC2==2F<394?:?9=?=56=:<47 - 6 - >D2>9D ;B?1B 4997= 42 ?4:9DF9D9419 112D7?48CA :B9 123>94=<:?24 ?= 94B<4197 FD23 =+*'' :2 =',++ B9D9 ;?CC @9 94B<419394: 2F =*, ;?:B ?4:9D9=: <: / >9D <4463 FD23 :B9 7<:92F>9:?:?24:?CCD9<C?M<:?24 ' 9=>24794: 2, L 4=6D<419 23><4A B<= <CD9<7A 79>2=?:97 :B9 123>94=<:?24 <3264: <;<D797 @A :B9D?@64<C 4:B9D9=6C::B9F2CC2;?482D79D?=><==97 !?" >>9<C?= !??" B9 1C<?3<4: ?= 94:?:C97 F2D :B9 94B<4197 123>94=<:?24 2F =*, ;?:B ?4:9D9=: <: / >9D <4463 FD23 :B9 7<:9 2F >9:?:?24:?CC:B97<:92FD9<C?M<:?24 !???" 9=>24794: 2, L 4=6D<419 23><4A ?= 7?D91:97 :2 79>2=?: :B9 94B<4197 123>94=<:?24<3264:<C248;?:B?4:9D9=:;?:B?4 249324:BFD23:B97<:92F:B?=5678394: - 7 - !?E" 4 =61B 79>2=?: :B9 <>>9CC<4:1C<?3<4:?=>9D3?::97:2;?:B7D<;:B9 94:?D9<3264:<C248;?:B?4:9D9=:<11D69724?: )*+ &%' $ ?=:2C2