Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63460 (KAR)
THE SHRIRAM GEN. INS. CO. LTD v. SYED KHALEEM AND ANR
MFA/202523/2022 · 2025-11-06
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63460 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63460 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
$$
%!&
'
! "
#
$%
$ #"! ! &""" '
&&""
# %"(#"
' $&"&&
! !)"* !#(+&
))
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
))
"%") ! ) ! " ! #" ! ! )
) )
!$
$ ,
#
" -./ 011203 ./ 4.325 67 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 0?0.9/88-2:5?>2980950@0;550825"10//25.9 ! =#" 67 8-2 29.=;
.A.3 :5?2 095 -.9<-=3. 4=; /-=;8 B8-2 8;.6:903C =9 8-2 ?;=:95 =4 D:098:>
-2 .9E:;25 <30.>098 0?25 720;/ @=;F.9? 0/ 2<-09.< >28 @.8- 0<<.5298 =9 "G 2 /:/80.925 .9E:;.2/ .9 8-2 0<<.5298 095 8==F 8;208>298 .9 8-2 =/1.803 2 4.325 <30.> 128.8.=9 624=;2 8-2 8;.6:903 /22F.9? - 3 -
<=>129/08.=9=4/"(#03=9?@.8-4:8:;2.982;2/808 8-2;082=4"H12;099:>4;=>8-25082=48-2128.8.=98.33 8-2 5082 =4 ;203.I08.=9 -2 8;.6:903 <=9/.52;.9? 8-2 298.;2 2A.529<2 =9 ;2<=;5 0@0;525 0 /:> =4 /&%&# 03=9? @.8-.982;2/8088-2;082=4GH12;099:>4;=>8-25082=4 128.8.=9 2.9? 0??;.2A25 67 8-2 /0>2 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 -0/ 4.325 8-2 1;2/298 011203 =9 8-2 ?;=:95 =4 2J<2//<=>129/08.=9
20;925 <=:9/23 4=; 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 /:6>.88258-082A298-=:?-8-2;2/1=95298=.//2;A25 @.8-9=8.<2-0/;2>0.92506/298-28;.6:903-0/2;;25.9 80F.9?8-25./06.3.87=48-2<30.>09808%H-2<30.>098-0/ /:/80.925 4;0<8:;2 =4 8.6.03 <=95732 :112; 295 =4 3248 8.6.0 @-.<-./-2032529<2-2./9=8298.83254=;<=>129/08.=9 :952; 8-2 -205 =4 3=// =4 4:8:;2 20;9.9?/ -2 8;.6:903 -0/ 0@0;525 0 /:> =4 /"%G# @-.<- ./ 2J<2// -:/ ;2D:2/8254=;;25:<8.=9=48-2<=>129/08.=90>=:98
+ -2 <30.>098 /:/80.925 4;0<8:;2 =4 8.6.03 <=95732 :112;295=432488.6.0@-.<-./-20325J&./8-2@=:95
- 4 -
<2;8.4.<082 J" ./ 8-2 5./<-0;?2 /:>>0;7-2<30.>098 @0/ -=/1.803.I25 4=; 4.A2 507/ 0/ 12; J" -2 <30.>098 2J0>.9258-2=<8=;0/095-20 258-25./06.3.87 08 "H 0/ 12; 5./06.3.87 <2;8.4.<082 08 J% 2 =6/2;A25 8-088-2<30.>098-0/5.44.<:3878=@03F<3.>6/.8095/D:08 0958-2;2./;2/8;.<8.=9=43248F922>=A2>2980958-2=<8=;
-0/ 0 25 8-2 5./06.3.87 08 "H -2 8;.6:903 -0/ 80F29
"#;5=4" @-.<-./%H8=8-2 @-=326=57@-.<-./<=;;2<8 095;20/=906320959225/9=.982;42;29<2
& -=:?- 8-2 128.8.=92; -0/ /80825 8-08 -2 @0/ 20;9.9? 0 /:> =4 /"# 12; >=98- -2 -0/ 9=8 1;=5:<25097.9<=>21;==48=1;=A2-./.9<=>22>28@.8- 0<<.5298 .9 8-2 720; "G / 12; 8-2 ?:.523.92/ .//:25 67 8-20;9080F080822?032;A.<2/:8-=;.87-./.9<=>2./ 8=6280F2908/%=;8-2720;"G-28;.6:903-0/ ;.?-837 0@0;525 0 /:> =4 /"# 8=@0;5/ 3=// =4 4:8:;2.9<=>2-29<29225/9=.982;42;29<2
G 20;925 <=:9/23 4=; 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 /:6>.8825 8-08 8-2 >25.<03 2J129/2/ .9 0 /:> =4
- 5 -
/"%G# 0@0;525 67 8-2 8;.6:903 ./ 2J<2// 9 ?=.9? 8-;=:?- 8-2 ;2<=;5/ .8 ./ 4=:95 8-08 8-2 <30.>098 -0/ 1;=5:<25 >25.<03 6.33/ =937 8= 09 2J8298 =4 /"(# :88-28;.6:903-0/0@0;5250/:>=4/"%G#@-.<- ./.92J<2//0>=:98=4/+%#-2/0>2./;25:<258= /"(#29<28-28=803<=>129/08.=9./0/:952;$ ( )*+,-./)0,*120 .301
" 0.9095/:442;.9?/ /#
88295098<-0;?2/4==5095 <=9A2709<22J129/2/ /"&#
=//=44:8:;2.9<=>2 /"# + 25.<032J129/2/ /"(# & =// =4 .9<=>2 5:;.9? 8;208>298 /"%&# G =// =4 0>29.8.2/ 095 9:8;.8.=94==5 /"#
1*( ,45
% -2 <30.>098 -0/ 9=8 4.325 097 011203 /22F.9? 29-09<2>298=48-2<=>129/08.=933=8-2;-205/2J<3:5.9?
>25.<03 2J129/2/ 0;2 <=;;2<8 095 1;=12; 095 9225/ 9= .982;42;29<2
<<=;5.9?378-24=33=@.9?$
. -2 011203 4.325 67 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097./033=@25.910;8*
- 6 -
.. -2 <=>129/08.=9 0>=:98 0@0;525 67 8-2 8;.6:903 .2 /&%&# ./ >=5.4.25 095 ;25:<258=/"&#* ... -2 <30.>098 ./ 298.8325 8= 8=803 <=>129/08.=9=4/"=9?@.8-.982;2/8 08 8-2 ;082 =4 GH 12; 099:> 4;=> 8-2 5082 =4 128.8.=98.338-25082=4;203.I08.=9* .A -2 0>=:98 03;2057 521=/.825 67 8-2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 /-033 62 8;09/>.8825 8= 8-2 8;.6:903* A -2 9/:;09<2 <=>1097 ./ 5.;2<825 8= 521=/.8 298.;2 <=>129/08.=9 0>=:98 03=9? @.8- .982;2/8 @.8-.9 =92 >=98- 4;=> 8-2 5082 =4 8-./ =;52;* A. 9 /:<- 521=/.8 8-2 <30.>098 ./ 12;>.8825 8= @.8-5;0@ 8-2 298.;2 0>=:98 03=9? @.8-.982;2/80<<;:258-2;2=9
,+5 %$& #
! ./8=$"3=$"&