- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %&'%()*&'%)) + ! " # $ % & & % # '( ) & * ' # Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "* ) ' $ ! "** % + % ) '$ * % '( % " $ ' % "&$ & % % # % %% '" $ , "$"$ ' & '"$ % ' " $"$ % * (( % * ,- & & % - * % . * % / * % & * 0* # ** - 3 - , 12323451678439:66:;1<:9:==>91<4 8:9?3@1<2839 A1232345 >5<16 1=2345 ' 4? 8:6:23;: :B:63C >6:C98: :5832: ' 911C35B 61B>@:6 D:3@ 35 4 ":63935B 4>2 4? 63E1 4,- 4? 17 475 4@3=1 2:23453<:639263=2$A15<35B45281?3@14?635=3A:@39263=2 :5<1993459#><B13<:6?462814??15=19A>5398:D@1>5<16 1=23459 '" $ , "$":$ ' 61:< 7328 1=2345 '"$ 4? 8:6:23;:;:;::5832:':5<1=2345" $"$:5< 4?5<3:56E9=2 (( 631?@;92:21<281A6491=>2345:@@1B1928:24735B24 :51:6@316 =:9135783=8:==>91<478439281945 4? :==>91< 4 :5< D642816 4? A619152 A123234516:==>91< 4 7:9 :661921< :==>91< 49 , :5< - =459A361< 24 1@3E35:21281<1=1:91<81=:914?281A6491=>23453928:2 45 :?216 281 <1=1:91< 8:< @>5=8 :2 : 8:D: :==>91<49:5<':@@1B1<@;:22:=C1<83E7328:=84AA16 4>293<1 :5< :?216 : =8:91 :99:>@21< 83E :B:35 619>@235B 35 - 4 - 839<1:2881A1232345167:9:661921<45 ((:5<39 35F><3=3:@=>924<;935=12815 ' 392 4? 281 =4EA@:352 @4<B1< D; 281 D642816 4? 281 <1=1:91< 5:E1@; :F> 39 28:2 281 <1=1:91<:3F35:28 D6428164?281=4EA@:35:527:9:E1ED164?A:5=8:;:2:5< 7:9:=23G1@;35G4@G1<3594=3:@916G3=1:5<4?215:9939235B281 A>D@3= 35 61<619935B 28136 B631G:5=1 :5< ?61H>152@; G393235B 281A4@3=192:2345239:@@1B1<28:2-E45289A634624281 35=3<152 :==>91< 4 784 39 281 D642816 4? A123234516:==>91< 4 8:< 1523=1< 281 E3546 <:>B8216 4? 4513<<:AA:4?2819:E1G3@@:B13<<:AA:399:3<248:G1 94>B82 :99392:5=1 ?64E 281 <1=1:91< :5< 281 <1=1:91< :==4EA:531<83E24281A4@3=192:2345>69>:5224783=8: =:91 >5<16 281 A64G393459 4? =2 =:E1 24 D1 61B392161<:B:3592:==>91<4:5<?17428169:5<:==>91< 47:9:661921<61@:235B24281=63E1=4EE3221<>5<16281 A64G393459 8161?461 281 A6491=>2345 =:91 39 28:2 4735B 24 2839 281 ?:E3@; 4? :==>91< 4 :5< :61 :@@1B1< 24 8:G1 <1G1@4A1< 3@@73@@ :B:3592 281 <1=1:91< :5< - 5 - 28161?461 281; 8:G1 =459A361< 24 1@3E35:21 281 D642816 4? 281=4EA@:35:52 1:651< =4>591@ :AA1:635B ?46 281 A123234516 613216:235B 281 B64>5<9 >6B1< 35 281 A1232345 =45215<9 28:2 281 446<35:21 15=819 4? 2839 4>62 8:G1 B6:521< 281 61B>@:6D:3@24:==>91<4,:5<-783@1:==>91<4784 39281?:28164?A619152A123234516:971@@:9:==>91<439 B6:521< :523=3A:246; D:3@ 1 74>@< A4352 4>2 28:2 281 :@@1B:2345 4? =459A36:=; 8:9 D115 =4593<161< D; 281 4 46<35:2115=8194?28394>62:5<:==>91<49,:5<-784 :61 A:62 4? =459A36:=; :61 :@61:<; 15@:6B1< 45 281 D:3@ 1 74>@< 28161?461 9>DE32 28:2 281 A123234516 :B:3592 784E 9:E19124?:@@1B:23459:61:2263D>21<3954745@;:@@1B1<24 D1 : =4=459A36:246 7328 54 4G162:=2 4? :99:>@29 :2263D>21< 2483E81=8:6B198112E:2163:@9281E91@G19<39=@49128:2 817:9542A619152:22819=15181152361A6491=>2345=:91 835B19 45 281 92:21E152 4? & 35 78491 84>91 32 39 :@@1B1< 28:2 :==>91< 49 , :5< - 8:G1 8:2=81< : A@:5 - 6 - 8161?4618174>@<61H>19228394>62241I16=391<39=612345 :5<B6:52D:3@24281A123234516 @1:651<3B84>624G165E152@1:<16 4AA4919 D:3@ =45215<35B 28:2 4??15=19 :61 B6:G1 81 A123234516 39 : @1:< :==>91< 4? :@@1B1< =459A36:=; :5< 839 61@1:91E:;@1:<242:EA1635B7328281732519919 , 1:651< =4>591@ :AA1:635B ?46 619A45<152 4=4EA@:35:524AA4935B281B6:524?D:3@A@:=1<61@3:5=1 45 281 61B3926:2345 4? 63E1 4 =45215<35B 28:2 :==>91<4 8:<2861:2151<281=4EA@:35:52/9?:E3@;783=8 :@@1B1<@;619>@21<3528161B3926:23454?2819:3<=63E127:9 ?>62816 9>DE3221< 28:2 281 A123234516 8:9 =63E35:@ :521=1<1529 35=@><35B 35G4@G1E152 35 : =:91 :5< 28161?461327:9>6B1<28:2281A1232345163954215232@1<24 281<39=612345:6;61@31?4?D:3@ - 16 =4526: @1:651< =4>591@ :AA1:635B ?46 281 A1232345168:961?>21<281:?4619:3<9>DE3993459D;<6:735B 281 :22152345 4? 2839 4>62 24 281 =4521529 4? 63E1 4 :5< 74>@< 9>DE32 28:2 281 A619152 - 7 - A123234516:==>91<4 39542:66:;1<:9:5:==>91<2816135 2 39 =45215<1< 28:2 281 % 35 63E1 4 39 61B392161<45@;:B:359228161@:23G194?:==>91<4-:5<542 :B:3592 281 A619152 A123234516 1:651< =4>591@ 8:9 ?>62816 A43521<4>228:2549>=84DF1=23457:96:391<D;619A45<152 4=4EA@:35:52 7815 2839 4>62 B6:521< D:3@ 24 :==>91< 4- 35 63E35:@ 1232345 4( 542732892:5<35B 281?:=228:263E148:<:@61:<;D11561B392161< :B:3592281?:E3@;E1ED1694?:==>91<4-23928161?461 =45215<1<28:22814DF1=23455476:391<39E39=45=13G1<:5< =:5542 D1 : G:@3< B64>5< 24 <15; D:3@ 24 281 A619152 A123234516 :G35B 81:6< 281 @1:651< =4>591@9 45 61=46< ?4@@4735BA4352974>@<:6391?46=4593<16:2345 - 8 - ( 81 61=46<9 :9 A@:=1< ?46 =4593<16:2345 4? 2839 D:3@ A1232345<39=@491928:2?:2:@:99:>@2399A1=3?3=:@@;:2263D>21<24 :==>91< 49 :5< ' 9 61B:6<9 281 A619152 A123234516 ":==>91< 4 $ 281 :@@1B:2345 39 4? =459A36:=; 35 =459462 7328 :==>91< 49, :5< - 2 39 >5<39A>21< :2 2839 92:B1 28:2:==>91<4 39542:@@1B1<248:G1D115A619152:2281 9A42 <>635B 281 35=3<152 :5< 54 4G162:=2 4? :99:>@2 39 3EA>21<2483E81:@@1B1<64@14?:==>91<4 783=839: =459A36:2463:@64@173284>2A61915=1:22819=151:5<73284>2 71:A45 >91 :2263D>2345 39 E:2163:@@; =4EA:6:D@1 24 28:2 4? :==>91<4924-?46281@3E321<A>6A4914?D:3@ 81 450D@1 A1I 4>62 8:9 =459392152@; 81@< :5< =@:63?31< 28:2 A:632; 39 : 61@1G:52 =4593<16:2345 78161 281 64@1:==>9:23459:5<=36=>E92:5=19:61=4EA:6:D@1:5<281 4>629E>9261=46<61:9459783@11I215<35BA:632; 5 281 E:2163:@ A619152@; :G:3@:D@1281 A123234516 92:5<9 93E3@:6@; 932>:21< 24 =4:==>91< 784 8:G1 D115 B6:521< D:3@ 81 92:21E152 4? & 61=46<1< <>635B 281 =4>691 4? 281 35G1923B:2345 8:9 24 D1 21921< <>635B ?>@@ - 9 - ?@1<B1< 263:@ 81 9:3< 92:21E15209 :<E3993D3@32; =61<327462835199 :5< 281 1I2152 4? =4664D46:2345 8:9 24 D1 21921< <>635B 263:@ 35=1 54 E:2163:@ 8:9 D115 A@:=1< 24 9847 A6346 =63E35:@ :521=1<1529 4? A123234516 281 A6491=>2345/9 :AA618159345 4? 2:EA1635B =:5 D1 :<1H>:21@; :<<61991<D;92635B152=45<323459 5 G317 4? 281 ?461B435B 61:9459 :5< D1:635B 35 E35<A635=3A@128:2281D:3@39:6>@1:5<F:3@391I=1A2345:2 A61263:@92:B128394>623935=@351<241I16=391<39=61234535 ?:G4>6 4? 281 A123234516 9>DF1=2 24 3EA4935B 92635B152 =45<323459 ==46<35B@; A4352 ?46E>@:21< 39 :597161< 35 :??36E:23G1 ' %46 281 ?461B435B 61:9459 2839 4>62 A:9919 281 ?4@@4735B 81A123234539:@@471< 81A123234516:==>91<4 98:@@D115@:6B1<45D:3@35 4 ":63935B 4>2 4? 63E1 4,- 4? 17 475 4@3=1 2:2345 3<:6 39263=2$ A15<35B 45 281 ?3@1 4? - 10 - 635=3A:@39263=2:5<1993459#><B13<:6?462814??15=19 A>5398:D@1 >5<16 1=23459 '" $ , "$":$ ' 61:< 7328 1=2345 '"$ 4? 8:6:23;: ;:;: :5832: ' :5< 1=2345 " $"$ :5< 4? 5<3:5 6E9 =2 (( 9>DF1=2 24 281 ?4@@4735B=45<323459 3$ 81A12323451698:@@1I1=>21:A16945:@D45<?46 :9>E4? 9 " >A119 51:C845@;$ 7328 274 9>612319 ?46 281 @3C1 9>E 24 281 9:239?:=23454?281F>639<3=2345:@4>62+ 33$ 81 A123234516 98:@@ 542 2:EA16 7328 281 A6491=>2345 732519919 46 1G3<15=1 132816 <361=2@;4635<361=2@;+ 333$ 81A12323451698:@@61B>@:6@;:AA1:6D1?461281 63:@ 4>62 <>635B 281 =4>691 4? A64=11<35B9 >5@199 1I1EA21< ?46 G:@3< 61:9459 D; 281 9:3< 4>62+ 3G$ 81 A123234516 98:@@ 542 35<>@B1 35 :5; 4??15=1 46 =63E35:@ :=23G32; 4? : 93E3@:6 5:2>61 46 42816739135?>2>61+ G$ 81A12323451698:@@542@1:G1281F>639<3=23454? 281 63:@ 4>62 73284>2 4D2:3535B A6346 - 11 - A16E399345 ?64E 281 9:3< 4>62 >523@ 281 <39A49:@4?281=:91A15<35B:B:359283E -* %!!) $ 3924 @4