- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' ( ) ! ! " # # $ %!# & #' () *!+!( , $ ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # % & **- # # *"! # # ((!!# "& # # *"+(" , $ &. (!(-( ' #& & $' & # # & !(((* $/ # ' 0 # & # -(+( # #-"(+ # & # # # 1 # - 3 - $ 23452 627 89978: ;< :;<67= >3? 8=@;<<;3A B;62 627 C3A<7A63>:78?A7=C34A<7:>3?D36262798?6;7<;6;<68E7A 49>3?>;A8:=;<93<8: 2;< 89978: ;< >;:7= 858;A<6 627 F4=5@7A6 8A= 8B8?= =867= -(+( 98<<7= DG 627 ?;AC;98: 7A;3? ;H;:4=57#8:8D4?85;;A#3-"3>(+ 27 >8C6< 3> 627 C8<7 8?7 6286 3A "( B2;:7627=7C78<7=8F4B8<?764?A;A52;<234<7DGB8:E 8>67? 8667A=;A5 2;< B3?E A78? 8?7 7:: 3<9;68: 8<8?53= 627 =?;H7? 3> 627 8? D78?;A5 ?75;<6?86;3A 3 **- =?;H7A ;6 ;A 2;52 <977= 8A= ?8<2 8A= A75:;57A6 @8AA7? 8A= =8<27= 63 627 <8;= 8F4 =47 63 B2;C2 27 <4<68;A7= 5?;7H34< ;AF4?;7< 63 2;< 278= 8A= 8:: 3H7? 627 D3=G 8A= <4CC4@D7= 63 627 <8@7 =4?;A5 6?786@7A6 27?7>3?7 2;< B;>7 C2;:=?7A 8A= >8627? >;:7= 8 C:8;@ 976;6;3A D7>3?7 627 ?;D4A8: C:8;@;A5 C3@97A<86;3A - 4 - 3> <!(((((* 27 ?;D4A8: C3A<;=7?;A5 627 7A6;?7 7H;=7AC7 3A ?7C3?= C8:C4:867= 6368: C3@97A<86;3A 86 <!"(((*D468<627?7B8<C3A6?;D463?GA75:;57AC7 ;628<27:=627C3A6?;D463?GA75:;57AC73A62798?63>627 =7C78<7= 86 (0 8A= 6286 3> 627 C8? =?;H7? 86 +(0 8A= 627?7DG 8B8?=7= 8 C3@97A<86;3A 3> <(-(((* B;62 ;A67?7<686"098>?3@627=8673>976;6;3A6;::?78:;<86;3A 8A= =;?7C67= ?7<93A=7A6 3* A<4?8AC7 3@98AG 63 =793<;6627<8@7 ! 55?;7H7=DG627<8;=F4=5@7A68A=8B8?=627 C:8;@8A6< 28H7 9?7>7??7= 62;< 89978: ;A B2;C2 ;6 ;< C3A67A=7= 6286 627 ?;D4A8: 7??7= ;A >;I;A5 627 C3A6?;D463?G A75:;57AC7 3A 627 98?6 3> 627 =7C78<7= 86 (0 " 78?A7=C34A<7:>3??7<93A=7A63C3A67A=7= 6286627?7B8<A75:;57AC73A62798?63>627=7C78<7=8< 27 C?3<<7= 627 ?38= B27?7 27 <234:= A36 C?3<< 27 ?;D4A8: 28< ?;526:G C3A<;=7?7= 627 C;686;3A< =;<C4<<7= 86 - 5 - :7A5628A=27:=627C3A6?;D463?GA75:;57AC73A62798?63> 627=7C78<7=86(0B2;C2A77=<A3;A67?>7?7AC7 78?=6278?54@7A6<3>D362<;=7< + 27 ?;D4A8: =;<C4<<7= 6286 627 =7C78<7= 6?;7= 63C?3<<627?38==;H;=7?8A=624<27@76B;628A8CC;=7A6 8A=;6;<8:<3<6867=6286A78?6279:8C73>8CC;=7A6627?7 ;< <6?8;526H;7B3>((@767?<6378<68A=B7<6<;=78A= <6?776 :;526 93<6 B;62 62?77 :78H7< ;A 627 =;H;=7? 8A= 8CC3?=;A5:G 27:= C3A6?;D463?G A75:;57AC7 3A 2;< 98?6 86 (0 6 B8< <6867= 6286 627 ?38= B8< <6?8;526 8A=627?7 B8< <6?776 :;526 27 C8? =?;H7? 8:<3 <77A 627 8F4 >?3@ <4>>;C;7A6=;<68AC7D4627C34:=A36C3A6?3:627H72;C:73 =34D6627?7B8<A75:;57AC73A62798?63>627=7C78<7= 8<27B8<C?3<<;A5627?38==;H;=7?27?7>3?762;<34?6 >;A=< ;6 ?78<3A8D:7 63 23:= 627 A75:;57AC7 3A 627 98?6 3> 627=7C78<7=86(08A=62863>627=?;H7?3>627C8?86 -(027 ?7@8;A;A5 98?6 3> 627F4=5@7A6 98<<7= DG 627 ?;D4A8:;<F4<68A=9?397?27?7>3?762789978:=7<7?H7< 63D78::3B7=;A98?6 - 6 - - A627?7<4:6627>3::3B;A53?=7?;<98<<7= $;' 2789978:;<8::3B7=;A98?6 $;;' 27 C3A6?;D463?G A75:;57AC7 27:= DG 627 ?;D4A8: 3A 627 98?6 3> 627 =7C78<7= 86 (0 ;< @3=;>;7= 8A=;6;<27:=8<(08A=-(0;<27:=3A62798?63>627 =?;H7?3>627C8? $;;;' 24< 627 8997::8A6< 8?7 7A6;6:7= >3? 627 7A28AC7= C3@97A<86;3A 3> <!"((* $(0 3> <!"(((*' 8:3A5 B;62 ;A67?7<6 86 "0 98 >?3@ 627 =867 3> 976;6;3A 6;:: ?78:;J86;3A 3B7H7? 8< 97? 3?=7? =867= (!(-( 627 8997::8A6< 8?7 A36 7A6;6:7= >3? ;A67?7<6 >3? 627 =7:8G7= 97?;3= 3> - =8G< ;A >;:;A5 627 89978: $;H' 6 ;< <6867= 6286 ?7<93A=7A6 3* A<4?8AC7 3@98AG28<8:?78=G=793<;67=6278B8?=8@34A6D7>3?7 627?;D4A8:7AC7 627G 8?7=;?7C67= 63 =793<;6 (03> 627 6368: 8@34A6 ;7 <!"((* B;62 ;A67?7<6 B;62;A 3A7@3A62>?3@627=8673>62;<3?=7? - 7 - $H' 27 7A28AC7= C3@97A<86;3A ;< 63 D7 8B8?=7= 638997::8A63*B;>73>627=7C78<7=3A:G8A=3A=793<;6 3> 627 <8;= 8@34A6 DG 627 A<4?8AC7 3@98AG <27 ;< 97?@;667= 63 B;62=?8B 627 7A6;?7 8@34A6 8:3A5 B;62 ;A67?7<68CC?47=3A;6 *+, &%!! ( $ ;<63:3!"