- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## # ' '() ' (( )* # ' '() ' (( ) * !" # $% &" '" #( ") Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (# # " " !(*" # '" "" (# # # $% + # " !(*" # $% &" ' "(, #() " ( % ( "') % ( ' ) " " ! " % ' - ( " " ) " ((( " - -( " " ( ( (*" ) * # !" # $% . # # - 3 - ! # $% # % ! # # - ! # # % ! # $% + &" '" #( ") (# # " " !(*" # '" "" (# # # $% + # " !(*" # $% &" ' "(, #() - 4 - " ( % ("') %( " " ! " - ( " " " % ( (( " - -(" % " (( ((*" " (( / # '" / # ) 0121 345 6137375829:1 39;18 35<1301: 92 =5>>58 722?129:178@5A@1B78C530301613737582 01 6:9D1: 78 C530 30121 613737582 72 35 E?920 3016:5=11B78<278 5% 9:7278<5?35F:7>1 5- :1<7231:1B CD 301 1@9A9<98<96?: "5A7=1 393758 F5: 301 5FF18=12 6?87209CA1 ?8B1: 1=37582 - - 5 - 98B :19B 4730 1=3758 - 5F 301 8B798 "189A 5B1% :7>789A "1373758 5 + 72 F7A1B CD 9==?21B 5235+4059:130169:183298B:1A937@125F 9==?21B 598B4059:19AA1<1B3509@169:37=76931B78 301 21=58B >9::79<1 297B 35 09@1 C118 =583:9=31B CD 9==?21B 5B?:78<3012?C272318=15F301F7:23>9::79<1 :7>789A"1373758 5 % 72F7A1BCD9==?21B 5 G 3010?2C98B5F :12658B183 5 B1F9=35=5>6A978983G 98B9==?21B 5298B%35 :71FF9=325F301=9219:192F5AA542 12658B183 5 =5>6A978983 782373?31B 9 6:7@931 =5>6A978378" 5 9AA1<78<30939==?21B 5G 9AA7;9:H?8 =583:9=31B 9 21=58B >9::79<1 B?:78< 301 2?C272318=1 5F 072 F7:23 >9::79<1 301:1CD =5>>73378< 301 5FF18=1 6?87209CA1 ?8B1: 1=3758 - 5F 301 " 01 69:1832 98B :1A937@12 5F 9==?21B 5 41:1 9A25 7>6A7=931B01A19:81B9<723:931:1F1::1B301=5>6A9783 - 6 - ?8B1: 1=3758 ') 5F 301 :" 6?:2?983 35 407=0 :7>1 5- 492:1<7231:1BF31:78@1237<93758301 8@1237<9378<FF7=1:2?C>7331B301=09:<120113 01 A19:81B 9<723:931 301:19F31: 355; =5<87I98=15F3015FF18=126?87209CA1?8B1:1=37582- 98B :19B47301=3758-5F301" 09@1019:B301A19:81B=5?821A96619:78<F5: 301 613737581:2 78 C530 613737582 301 A19:81B =5?821A F5: :12658B183 5 =5>6A97898398B301A19:81B7<05?:3 5@1:8>183"A19B1:F5:3013931 + 01 205:3 657832 3093 9:721 F5: =5827B1:93758 9:1 ! " # $%& ' " " ()*+& - 7 - !"#$ %%&& ', - ! " # $%& # $%& ,. +,-+,./,+,0/+1,-++ /0 1F5:130725?:39B@1:3235301=92158098B B11>2 73 F73 351J3:9=3301 :1A1@983 65:37585F 3016:7@931 =5>6A9783"9:9<:960 5298B 9:11J3:9=31B407=0 :19B92?8B1: !0 1 20# 3 3 & 3 " 3 0 1 3 ' 0 ( 3 " & % ' 3 0 4 & - 8 - 3 0 ( 5' 6 0 1 3 0 * 74 08009 "" 3 ' %00$0& % 3 01 ' & 0 20/:; #! !< !<; #! 20# = > 9:0/* = ? @:" = #0%0&0 = > 50%0 * 0 * 3 " = 3 5' 6 ' 3 3 <#;<; #!0 # 0 1 " 20# 3 0020;;<#;<; #/ " 20 > ! 3 " 8 " 13 1 *0%0 3 " 3( A 3 20??! ;/#=0B 3 " 3 3 20# " 20;0 2" 3 " 20# 0 ( 3 " 5' 6 ##< <; # ' - 9 - 3 0 4 5' 6 3 ' 3 & 0B " 3 3 & #< <; #0 1 " 33 3 3 20# " 20; 3 " 00 3 0 1 ' 3 0( ' 33 9:0 @:" 0#$0%0&0. - 89=9:1F?A:19B78<5F69:9<:960 5298B 5F 301 6:7@931 =5>6A9783 =1:3978 27<87F7=983 9261=32 1>1:<1 01 =5>6A978983 ':12658B183 5) 261=7F7=9AAD 239312 3093 9F31: C1=5>78< 6:1<8983 201 A1F3 301 >93:7>5879A05>198B092C118:127B78<473001:69:1832 F5: 301 A923 F5?: D19:2 78=A?B78< 9F31: 301 C7:30 5F 301 =07AB 8 69:9<:960 5 301 9AA1<937582 :1<9:B78< 301 9AA1<1B 21=58B >9::79<1 9:1 =5?=01B 78 @9<?1 5>87C?2 98B<181:9A31:>201:172859:37=?A937585F98D5@1:39=3 5:261=7F7=:5A1933:7C?31B35301:1A937@125F9==?21B 5 - 10 - 405 9:1 301 613737581:2 78 :7>789A "1373758 5 + 01=5>6A978983>1:1AD9221:323093K9AA 3019==?21B41:16:12183L933019AA1<1B21=58B>9::79<1 ":1218=1 93 9 >9::79<1 =1:1>58D 47305?3 98D F?:301: B12=:7637585F78237<937589=37@169:37=76937585:9C13>183 72 782?FF7=7183 78 A94 35 933:9=3 A79C7A73D 69:37=?A9:AD 4018 =5<87I98=1092853C11839;18F5:3015FF18=15F9C13>183 ?8B1:1=3758 -" 0121 5>7227582 78 301 =5>6A9783 922?>1 7>65:398=1 C1=9?21 301 A19:81B 9<723:931 092 39;18 =5<87I98=158ADF5:3015FF18=12?8B1:1=37582- 98B :19B 4730 1=3758 - " 539CAD =5<87I98=1 092853C11839;18F5:3015FF18=1?8B1:1=3758-:19B 4730 1=3758 - " 407=0 9A581 45?AB 09@1 >9B1 301 :1A937@12 A79CA1 F5: 9C13>183 5F C7<9>D 1=3758 - " 6189A7212 58AD 301 61:258 405 =583:9=32 9 21=58B >9::79<1B?:78<3012?C272318=15F301F7:23 - 11 - 8 69:9<:960 5 5F 301 =5>6A9783 301 58AD 9AA1<937589<97823301:1A937@1298B3019AA1<1B21=58B47F1 723093301D41:1K6:12183L40189==?21B 572297B35 09@1=583:9=31B30121=58B>9::79<1072C9:19221:3758 ?82?665:31B CD 69:37=?A9:2 B512 853 B72=A521 301 78<:1B71832 5F 17301: 9C13>183 5: =5>>58 5CH1=3 01 =5>6A9783 B512 853 1@18 B12=:7C1 054 301 =5>6A978983 =9>135;8545F 3019AA1<1B21=58B>9::79<11J=163CD :1F1::78<35@9<?178F5:>93758297B3509@1C118209:1BCD 581 7BB9669 ?<9: 0?2 78 301 9C218=1 5F 261=7F7= 9@1:>1832 92 35 69:37=7693758 78237<93758 5: =5>>58 5CH1=3301A19:81B9<723:931=5?AB85309@16:5=11B1B35 39;1 =5<87I98=1 9<97823 301 :1A937@12 98B 301 9AA1<1B 21=58B 47F1 F5: 301 5FF18=1 ?8B1: 1=3758 - " 01 >931:79A258:1=5:B>9;173=A19:309358AD9==?21B 5 7F939AA=5?ABC16:521=?31BF5:301297B5FF18=1 01 =5<87I98=1 5:B1: 69221B CD 301 A19:81B 9<723:931:1FA1=323093=5<87I98=1092C11839;18F5:301 5FF18=12 ?8B1: 1=37582 - 98B :19B 4730 - 12 - 1=3758 - " 541@1: 301 >1:1 78=A?2758 5F 1=3758 - " 78 301 =09:<1 20113 =98853 78 301 9C218=1 5F F5?8B937589AF9=329?35>937=9AAD1J318B=:7>789AA79C7A73D35 301:1A937@125F3010?2C98B5:353019AA1<1B21=58B47F1 01=5>6A9783B512853933:7C?311@18>787>9A9AA1<937582 F9: A122 261=7F7= 5@1:3 9=32 9<97823 301 613737581:2 78 :7>789A"1373758 5 + 5:9==?21B 5298B% 35 78 :7>789A "1373758 5 % 018 301 =5>6A9783 7321AF 72 C1:1F3 5F >931:79A 69:37=?A9:2 98B 301 =5<87I98=15:B1:B51285378B7=93178B1618B183966A7=93758 5F >78B 35 301 :5A1 5F 19=0 9==?21B 301 =58378?93758 5F 6:5=11B78<2 F5: 301 5FF18=1 ?8B1: 1=3758 - 5F " 9<9782330121613737581:2C1=5>12A1<9AAD?82?239789CA1 3 72 85 B5?C3 3:?1 3093 301 =5>6A978983 72 18373A1B 35 6:521=?31 01: 0?2C98B F5: 301 9AA1<1B 9=3 5F C7<9>D 98B 301 E?123758 401301: 9==?21B 5 =583:9=31B921=58B>9::79<1B?:78<3012?C272318=15F9 @9A7B>9::79<1729>9331:3093>?23C11239CA7201B933:79A CD A19B78< =5<183 1@7B18=1 01 C?:B18 :1232 58 301 - 13 - 6:521=?3758 35 1239CA720 301 =1:1>58712 5F 301 9AA1<1B 21=58B>9::79<198B3012?C272318=15F301F7:23>9::79<1 789==5:B98=147302133A1B6:78=76A125FA94541@1:3072 :7<035F6:521=?3758=98853C11J318B1B3578B72=:7>78931AD 9::9D :1A937@12 5: 301 9AA1<1B 21=58B 47F1 92 9==?21B 47305?3 261=7F7= 9AA1<937582 29372FD78< 301 2393?35:D 78<:1B718325F1=3758-"5:7329AA71B6:5@727582 83019C5@1=7:=?>2398=12301=58378?937585F 6:5=11B78<2 9<97823 301 :1A937@12 98B 9<97823 301 9AA1<1B 21=58B47F14018301=5>6A9783A9=;2261=7F7=9AA1<937582 4018 =5<87I98=1 F5: 9C13>183 092 853 C118 39;18 98B 4018 1=3758 - 5F " B512 853 18@729<1 3017: 6:521=?3758 45?AB 9>5?83 35 98 9C?21 5F 301 6:5=122 5F A9481J1:=7215F7801:183H?:72B7=3758?8B1:1=3758% 5F 301 09:937D9 D9D9 980739 3072 5?:3 72 301:1F5:1 78=A781B 35 7831:B7=3 301 6:5=11B78<2 7825F9: 92 301D 61:3978 35 301 613737581:2 78 :7>789A "1373758 5 + 98B 9==?21B 52 98B % 35 78 :7>789A "1373758 5 % 541@1: 301 - 14 - 6:521=?37589<978239==?21B 5 0?2C98BF5:3015FF18=1 ?8B1: 1=3758 - 5F " >?23 81=1229:7AD 6:5=11B 78 9==5:B98=14730A94==5:B78<AD65783 577298241:1B78 301 M "()"/ 98B 65783 577 72 98241:1B 78 301 M*))"/ (5: 301 F5:1<578< :192582 3072 5?:3 6:5=11B2 356922301F5AA5478< '7) 01 :7>789A "1373758 5 + 72 9AA541B '77) 01 :7>789A "1373758 5 % 72 69:3AD 9AA541B '777) 01 6:5=11B78<2 78737931B 78 5% '9:7278<5?35F:7>1 5- :1<7231:1BCD 1@9A9<98<96?: "5A7=1 393758 F5: 301 5FF18=12 6?87209CA1 ?8B1: 1=37582 - :19B 47301=3758-5F3018B798"189A5B1% 7825F9: 92 301 613737581:2 78 :7>789A "1373758 5 + 98B 613737581: 52 35 - 15 - '9==?21B 5298B%35 )78:7>789A"1373758 5 % 9:1 =58=1:81B 9:1 01:1CD E?9201B -) ' ##( & "