- 1 - ! "# $ %& $ %& "&'" $$ (') * !"# $ % & ' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ( )*()+, " -#,**#+ ( $ -#+#* % & (! *# ' ( ( "&' ( ( ** ( *" ( #**) ( . ( ( ( / 012 / - 3 - & &/ ' 345 066708 9127: 7;<4=1 "&' => <37 =<=: 734;875;<++&37:7410><7::7>7::72<=05?<37;<@>=: 53=:<' 305 A771 >4872 AB <37 ;804C01<5 ;308871D41D <37 E92DC71< 012 0F0:2 20<72 ** 605572 AB <37 :41;4608 45<:4;< 92D7 012 04;39: 41 =*"577G41D71301;7C71<=>;=C67150<4=1 (0;<5 D4H41D :457 <= <37 >4841D => <37 066708 A:47>8B 5<0<72 0:7 <30< **" 27;70572 - 9:753 722B 012 =<37: <3:77 >:47125 F7:7 6:=;77241D <=F0:25 9A84 41 0 F4>< 0: A70:41D 7D=),)*"# <37 F4><0:F052:4H71AB=1701D0230:F371<37B;0C7 =1 01H4)04;39: C041 :=02 0< ,** 0C 170: 4:730880 A:42D7 0<<30< <4C7 :756=1271< = A741D<37 2:4H7:=> 11=H0 0: A70:41D 7D=)*>)+, ;0C7 >:=C =66=54<724:7;<4=1>:=CF:=1D5427410:05301217D84D71< C0117:F4<334D356772012205372<=<37F4><0:50 :7598<=><370>=:750420;;4271<F4><0:<9:172<9:<87012 - 4 - 41C0<75 => <37 0: 595<04172 D:47H=95 41E9:475 37 27;70572 - 9:753 722B 012 =<37:5 F7:7 <0G71 <= =H7:1C71<=564<0801H401227;70572-9:753722B 59;;9CA72 <= <37 41E9:475 71;7 <37 27671201<5 => 27;70572 >4872 67<4<4=1 9127: 7;<4=1 ,, => <37 ;< 577G41D;=C67150<4=1>=:<37270<3=><3727;7057208=1D F4<341<7:75< 3=9D3 1=<4;7 57:H72 :756=1271< = :7C04172 0A571< 012 F05 680;72 7I60:<7 756=1271< =>4872F:4<<715<0<7C71<271B41D<370H7:C71<5C027 41<37;804C67<4<4=1 1<37A0545=><376870241D5=><3760:<475<37 804C5 :4A9108>:0C72<37455975012<37:70><7::7;=:272 <37 7H4271;7 37 :4A9108 AB 4C69D172 E92DC71< 012 0F0:230560:<8B088=F72<37;804C67<4<4=10123782<30< <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= 0 ;=C67150<4=1 => 5""#**)08=1DF4<341<7:75<0<<37:0<7=>,J60 01224:7;<72<37:756=1271<5<=276=54<<37;=C67150<4=1 - 5 - 0C=91< 08=1D F4<3 41<7:75< 741D 0DD:47H72 AB <37 K901<9C => ;=C67150<4=1 <37 6:7571< 066708 305 A771 >4872 # 37 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 ;804C01<5 305 :04572<37>=88=F41D;=1<71<4=15 0' < <37 <4C7 => 0;;4271< 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5"#***)67:C=1<3>:=C<376:=>7554=105012H=;0<7 012085=30H41D0D:4;98<9:741;=C7=F7H7:<37 :4A9108 3050557557241;=C7=><3727;705720<5#***)6C F34;345=1<378=F7:5427 A' 7;=128B 05 67: <37 E92DC71< => <37 =1@A87 96:7C7 =9:< 41 <37 ;057 => # ! " 70;3 => <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= ;=C67150<4=1 => 5****) 9127: <37 3702 ;=15=:<49C - 6 - ;' 05<8B;=15427:41D<370D70120H=;0<4=1=><37 27;70572 <37 =H7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A9108 45 41027K90<7 012 =1 <37 8=F7: 5427 4<3 <37 0A=H7;=1<71<4=15<37870:172;=915785=9D3<<=088=F<37 066708 , 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 :756=1271< = - 4159:01;7 ;=C601B :04572 <37 >=88=F41D ;=1<71<4=15 0' H71 <3=9D3 <37 ;804C01<5 ;804C72 <30< 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5"#***) 67: C=1<3 <37B 30H7 1=< 6:=29;72 01B 2=;9C71<5 <= 53=F <37 0;<908 41;=C7 >:=C 345 6:=>7554=1 05 01 2H=;0<7 012 41;=C7 27:4H41D >:=C <37 0D:4;98<9:7 37:7>=:7 :4A9108 305 :4D3<8B 055755721=<4=10841;=C7=>27;705720<5#***)6C A' 7;=128B 870:172 ;=91578 ;=1<7125 <30< 541;7 <37 ;804C01<5 30H7 1=< 75<0A845372 <37 41;=C7 => 27;70572<37 :4A9108415<702=>02241D#J=><37>9<9:7 - 7 - 6:=567;<5 305 7::72 41 02241D *J <= <37 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 ;' 05<8B=1066:7;40<4=1=>=:080122=;9C71<0:B 7H4271;7 012 ;=15427:41D <37 0D7 012 0H=;0<4=1 => <37 27;70572 <37 =H7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A9108 45 E95< 012 :705=10A87 4<3 <37 0A=H7 ;=1<71<4=15 <37 870:172 ;=91578 5=9D3< <= 245C455 <37 066708 " 70:2 <37 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 60:<475 012 67:9572<37E92DC71<0120F0:2=><37 :4A9108 + < 45 1=< 41 24569<7 <30< 27;70572 - 9:753 722B 2472 41 <37 :=02 <:0>>4; 0;;4271< =;;9::72 =1 **"297<=:05301217D84D71<2:4H41D=><372:4H7: => <37 =>>71241D 11=H0 0: A70:41D =)*()+, H71 <3=9D3 <37 ;804C01<5 ;804C72 <30< 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5"#***) 6C A9< 1= 2=;9C71<5 30H7 A771 6:=29;72 <= 75<0A8453 <37 0;<908 41;=C7 0G41D 41<= ;=15427:0<4=1 <30< 27;70572 F05 01 2H=;0<7 AB - 8 - 6:=>7554=1 012 F05 085= 2=41D 0D:4;98<9:08 F=:G 05 ;=1<71272 F7 0:7 => <37 =6414=1 <30< 4< F=982 C77< <37 7125=>E95<4;74>C=1<38B41;=C7=>27;7057245<0G710< 5****) 67: C=1<3 012 50C7 45 <0G71 05 C=1<38B 41;=C7=>27;70572 =<370>=:7504241;=C7#J305<=A702272 =10;;=91<=>>9<9:76:=567;<541H47F=><3780F80422=F1 AB <37 =15<4<9<4=1 71;3 => <37 96:7C7 =9:< 41 +# $%&596:0'41;7<37:70:7*27671271<5 <37 :4A9108 305 :4D3<8B 2729;<72 <3 <=F0:25 67:5=108 7I671575=>27;70572 3727;70572F050D720A=9<* B70:50<<37<4C7=><370;;4271<012C98<46847:06684;0A87 <=3450D7D:=9645?#@ * 395 <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= ;=C67150<4=1 => 5"#***) &5****) L #J &5#***)'M5#***)II#I'=10;;=91<=> ?8=55=>27671271;B@ - 9 - 1 0224<4=1 <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= ;=C67150<4=1=>5#***)=10;;=91<=>?8=55=>75<0<7@ 012 ;=C67150<4=1 => 5#***) =1 0;;=91< => ?>917:08 7I671575@ 1 H47F => <37 80F 8042 2=F1 AB <37 96:7C7 =9:< 41 <37 ;057 => & '%&596:0';804C01<=F4>7=>27;705724571<4<872 >=:;=C67150<4=1=>5****)9127:<373702=>/8=55=> >48408 ;=15=:<49C/ ;804C01< =5 012 ;3482:71 => 27;705720:771<4<872<=;=C67150<4=1=>5****)70;3 9127: <37 3702 => ?8=55 => 60:71<08 ;=15=:<49C@ 012 ;804C01< = C=<37: => 27;70572 45 71<4<872 <= ;=C67150<4=1 => 5****) 9127: <37 3702 => ?8=55 => >48408;=15=:<49C@ 395<37;804C01<50:771<4<872<=<37>=88=F41D ;=C67150<4=1 - 10 - ,-./0123/4/5.6 53.6./2.150 ,4/23/ (0) =55=>27671271;B "#*** (917:087I671575 #*** =55=>75<0<7 #*** =55=>56=9508;=15=:<49C **** =55=>0:71<08;=15=:<49C +**** =55=>(48408;=15=:<49C **** 217 ## 1<37:7598<<37>=88=F41D=:27:45605572 3706670845 ( A' 37 E92DC71< => <37 804C5 :4A9108 45 C=24>472 ;' 37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= 0 <=<08 ;=C67150<4=1=>5#,#***)050D0415< 5""#**)0F0:272AB<37 :4A9108 2' 756=1271< = - 159:01;7 ;=C601B 45 24:7;<72 <= 276=54< <37 ;=C67150<4=1 0C=91<08=1DF4<341<7:75<0<,J60>:=C - 11 - <37 20<7 => >4841D => <37 ;804C 67<4<4=1 <488 <37 20<7 => :7084N0<4=1 F4<341 0 67:4=2 => 54IF77G5>:=C<3720<7=>:7;746<=>0;=6B =><345E92DC71< 7' 37 066=:<4=1C71< 276=54< 012 :787057 => 0C=91< 53088 A7 C027 41 0;;=:201;7 F4<3 <37<7:C5=><370F0:2=><37 :4A9108 >' 1 H47F => <=20B@5 =:27: 47 20<72 *# 605572 AB <345 =9:< <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 1=< 71<4<872 >=: 41<7:75< =1 <3771301;72;=C67150<4=1>=:<372780B72 67:4=2=>20B541>4841D<37066708 58 ($ ) & 58 ("&'") & 45<=8=