- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! "# $ %& %!'" & & $ ( %##!) * $&+ &")"&)&&! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ !,! $ !' $ !))&)&) )&)! * $ #")))% !")))))% !")))))% - $ $ . $ / # / ! 012345012678094:;2<8=<45:>30: & 5>: 1??01@ >: ?20;02203 161>9:4 450 7368094 193 1A123 31403 !))&)&) ?1::03 >9 <)&)! =B 450 09><2>C>@7360193@193;<2:5<24D45042>=791@E 50F@1>8194A1:3<>9681:<9A<2G193A1:1603 # B012: 1: <9 450 3140 <; 450 1FF>3094 0 804 A>45 19 1FF>3094 <9 &!)&)!, 0 ;>@03 F@1>8 ?04>4><9 =0;<20 450 - 3 - @193 :00G>96 F<8?09:14><9 <; :&")))))% 50 42>=791@ 1;402 F<9:>302>96 450 094>20 0C>309F0 <9 20F<23 1A12303F<8?09:14><9<;:#")))%1@<96A>45>94020:414 450 2140 <; H- ?02 19978 ;2<8 450 3140 <; ?04>4><9 4>@@ 450 3140 <; 201@>I14><9 662>0C03 =B 450 :1>3 <2302 450 F@1>8194 ?20;0220345>:1??01@19381>9@BF<9409303J ,193J 120 450 A<793 F024>;>F140 193 3>:F51260 F123+ 50 :7:41>903 5013 >9K72B 193 >4 20:7@403 >9 !))- ;79F4><91@ 3>:1=>@>4B 0 1@:<0J18>903 &% <F4<2193501::0::033>:1=>@>4B14"- 4<450A5<@0=<3B=7445042>=791@02203>941G>964503>:1=>@>4B 14 !)- 50 42>=791@ 51: 02203 >9 F1@F7@14>96 450 803>F1@ 0J?09:0: 193 457: 20L70:403 ;<2 09519F08094 <; F<8?09:14><9 " : ?02 450 3>:F51260 :78812B 50 A1: 3>169<:03 A>45 $ 219>0F4<?8B 30;0F4 A>45 ;2<941@ :7=3721@ 5B62<8150?04>4><9020J18>903 & &>95>:0C>309F0 C02>;>03450A<793F024>;>F1401933>:F51260F12319350@34514 450?04>4><90251::7;;020362>0C<7:4217814>F=21>9>9K72B193 2>654 :>30 508>?120:>: <9 1FF<794 <; 9072<@<6>F1@ 3>:1=>@>4B 2>654:>30;1F>1@193@0;4:>30173>4<2BF219>1@902C0:3181603 - 4 - F17:>96 30;<2803 @<<G 193 @<:: <; 5012>96 20:?0F4>C0@B 193 >91=>@>4B 4< 014 ;2<8 @0;4 :>30 193 <?09 450 8<745 >: 370 4< ;>=2<:>:<;K<>941FF<794:193457:50:7:41>903?02819094 ?124>1@?5B:>F1@3>:1=>@>4B1931::0::034503>:1=>@>4B14"-4< 450A5<@0=<3B4A1:;1>2@B:41403451450F<7@39<43<19B @1=<72A<2G>9;747204>:1@:<:4140345145020L7>20:19<4502 :#))))% ;<2 ;74720803>F1@ 0J?09:0: 74 450 42>=791@ 51: 41G09 3>:1=>@>4B 14 !)- A>45<74 19B =1:>: <9:>302>96 450 914720<;450>9K72>0::7:41>903=B450?04>4><9021931@:<450 ;1F4451450A1:5<:?>41@>I03;<2"31B:1934500C>309F0<; &45>:<724;>93:>4201:<91=@04<F<9:>3024503>:1=>@>4B14 "- 1: ?02 450 803>F1@ 0C>309F0 04>4><902 :41403 4514 50 A1: 0129>96 :!#)))%?02 8<945 =74 50 51: 9<4 ;>@03 19B >9F<80?2<<; 0804A>45191FF>3094<9&!)&)!, 09F0 5>:>9F<8051:4< =041G0914:!)&#)%?028<9451:?02 450 67>30@>90: <; 450 129141G1 061@ 02C>F0: 745<2>4B 50 @<::<;;74720>9F<80F<80:4<:!)&#)%(!&(!#("-M :#H))% # 50 18<794 1A12303 79302 450 5013 <; 803>F1@ 0J?09:0:>0:&H,',H%9003:9<>9402;0209F0<9:>302>96 - 5 - 450 914720 <; >9K72>0: 193 450 ?02><3 <; 5<:?>41@>I14><9 45>: <724;>93:>4201:<91=@04<1A1231:78<;:,#)))%79302 4505013<;?1>9193:7;;02>96::&#)))%793024505013<; @<::<;1809>4>0:50F<8?09:14><91A12303793024505013<; 3>04;<<39<72>:58094144093194193F<9C0B19F0F51260:>0 :#)))% 9003: 9< >9402;0209F0 50 F@1>8194 8>654 9<4 51C0 14409303 450 A<2G 14 @01:4 ;<2 1 ?02><3 <; ;<72 8<945: 09F0 1 :78 <; :"!)))% :!)&#)% ( " 8<945: >: 1A12303793024505013<;@<::<;>9F<80372>96@1>37??02><3 504<41@F<8?09:14><91A12303=B45>:<724>:1:79302 ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /0*1-+231 +4+5,*, ! <::<;;747200129>96 :#H))% & 1>9193:7;;02>96 :,#)))% 03>F1@0J?09:0: :&H,',H% " <A123: 3>04 ;<<3 9<72>:58094 144093194 193 F<9C0B19F0F51260: :#)))% # <:: <; >9F<80 372>96 @1>3 7? ?02><3 :"!)))% H <::<;1809>4>0: :&#)))% 2+) - 67 H 50 F@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 ;<2 4<41@ F<8?09:14><9 <; :!&'#,H% 1@<96 A>45 >94020:4 14 450 2140 <; H- >94020:4 ;2<84503140<;?04>4><94>@@201@>I14><91:161>9:4:#")))% 1A12303=B45042>=791@ - 6 - , 012903F<79:0@;<245020:?<93094<&%9:7219F0 F<8?19B:7=8>4:451445018<7941A12303=B45042>=791@51: =00930?<:>403=0;<2045042>=791@ FF<23>96@B450;<@@<A>96 > 501??01@>:1@@<A03>9?124+ >> 50 F@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 4< 4<41@ F<8?09:14><9 <; :!&'#,H% 1@<96 A>45 H- >94020:4 ;2<8 450 3140 <; ?04>4><9 4>@@ 450 3140 <; 201@>I14><9+ >>> 5020:?<93094<&%9:7219F0F<8?19B >:3>20F4034<30?<:>445009519F03F<8?09:14><9<; :,H#,H%1@<96A>45H->94020:4A>45>91?02><3 <;<908<945+ >C 9 :7F5 30?<:>4 =B 450 9:7219F0 F<8?19B 450 F@1>8194 >: ?028>4403 4< A>45321A 450 094>2018<7941@<96A>45>94020:4 ,7 %$ ' # >:4<!@<#H