- 1 - ! " #! $%!!&!& !!'' (& ) * ! "# $ $" % # $ &$" $ '() ( "# $( $" % # $ &$ $ '(* Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * "# $( $" % # $% &$ $ '(* ) # $() $ # $ &$" $ '() # $ $ # $ &$" $ '() )+ ! ,* ! -#(, " *(- -#(, . " $ - 3 - $ / % % 012 344536 12 71658 9: ;05 1<2=>3<?5 ?@A43<: ?03665<B1<B ;05 C=8BA5<; 3<8 3D3>8 83;58 *(- 4322581< @-#(,9:;055<1@>1E16=8B53<8 =88591036 ( 524@<85<;2 @ ;@ ) 3>5 ?631A3<;2 3<8 >524@<85<; @ 12 @D<5> @7 ;05 E501?65 D01?0 D32 1<2=>58D1;03445663<;'1<2=>3<?5?@A43<: * 0573?;265381<B;@7161<B@7?631A45;1;1@<23>5 32=<85>$ 03; @< ((( >524@<85<; @ 36@<B D1;0 03059B@=83 0@=83>1 5E5<8>3443 1>383> 3<8 @;05>2 D5>5 ;>3E561<B 1< >=125> 554 953>1<B 1;2 5B @%(* -*- 956@<B1<B ;@ >524@<85<; @ ;@ E121; 012 B>3<8 A@;05> 3; %3>193E1 E1663B5 7>@A 323<=> ; 39@=; - 4 - 3AD05<;05:D5>5@<361F@;1'363B3<=>>@38<53>;05 63<8@7>13<?03;5>524@<85<; @951<B;058>1E5>@7 ;05 2318 E501?65 8>@E5 ;05 23A5 1< 3 >320 3<8 <5B61B5<; A3<<5> 6@2; ?@<;>@6 @E5> ;05 E501?65 8=5 ;@ D01?0 1; ;=><583<8;=>;658@<;05>@3823>52=6;@7;053??185<; 03059B@=83 0@=83>1 2=2;31<58 B>15E@=2 1<C=>152 3<8 81580523185E5<8>34431>383>3<8@;05>22=2;31<58 1<C=>152 05 65B36 >54>525<;3;1E52 @7 ;05 85?53258 ' 03059B@=83 0@=83>1 03E5 71658 ;05 ?631A 45;1;1@< ?631A1<B?@A45<23;1@<1<>5245?;@7853;0@7;0585?53258 '03059B@=830@=83>1D0@A5;D1;0;>3771?3??185<; ) 05 3445663<; ' 1<2=>3<?5 ?@A43<: ?@<;52;58 ;052318?631A45;1;1@<053445663<;'1<2=>3<?5?@A43<: 038 ;3F5< =4 ;05 ?@<;5<;1@< ;03; ;05 ?@<81;1@<2 @7 ;05 1<2=>3<?54@61?:03E5955<E1@63;583<8;05>57@>51;12<@; 613965;@43:3<:?@A45<23;1@< - 5 - 05>19=<360327>3A58122=5 @*D01?0>5382 ;0=2$ 05 >19=<36 37;5> >5?@>81<B ;05 5E185<?5 3<8 463?1<B >5613<?5 @< ;05 85?121@< @7 ;05 1E121@< 5<?0 @7 ;012 @=>; 3<2D5>58 ;05 2318 122=5 1< ;05 <5B3;1E5 3<8 0568 ;03; ;05 >524@<85<; @( ' 1<2=>3<?5 ?@A43<: 12 613965;@43:;05?@A45<23;1@<;@;05?631A3<;2 , BB>15E58 9: ;05 2318 C=8BA5<; 3<8 3D3>8 4322589:;05>19=<36;053445663<;'1<2=>3<?5?@A43<: 12957@>5;012@=>; - 6 - 053445361271658@<;057@66@D1<BB>@=<8$ ; 12 2=9A1;;58 ;03; ;05 85?53258 3<8 @;05>2 D5>5 =<3=;0@>1G58 43225<B5> ?3>>158 1< ;05 1<2=>58 4>1E3;5 E501?651<E1@63;1@<@7;054@61?:;5>A23<8D1;0@=;3E3618 45>A1; 05 4>@E121@<2 @7 5?;1@< ), @7 ?; 8@ <@; >5H=1>5 ;05 >12F ;@ 95 ?@E5>58 =<85> ;05 4@61?: <@> ;05 4@61?:?@E5>58;05>12F05>136@=>;731658;@344>5?13;5 ;0573?;3<8432258;053D3>8 - 05 ?@<;5<;1@< @7 ;05 3445663<; ' 1<2=>3<?5 ?@A43<:;03;;0585?53258'03059B@=830@=83>1D32 4318 43225<B5> 1< 3 4>1E3;5 E501?65 3<8 ;05>57@>5 ;05 1<2=>3<?5?@A43<:12<@;613965;@43:;05?@A45<23;1@< 32;05?@<81;1@<2@7;054@61?:03E5955<E1@63;58 05 >19=<36 D0165 ?@<2185>1<B ;05 2318 122=5 032 B1E5< 1;2 >532@<2 1< 3>3 @2) 3<8 )( D01?0 >538 ;0=2$ ! " # $% " &''# ()$ '(*+$,-.*/'# ( ) . 0 1 023 ++4)+, 056)7)+48 - 7 - ' 91 9 9 9 91 99 " 1 :"1 ; < =>" # $3(33 ' ? @1 9 # 8 19 A.B 9 " 9 9 # C ' 1 9 ;0 5 3 D = 1 % 9 " " " # C "% 1 " "'919 19 " 1 "E - 8 - * 9">" 1 " 1 9 " % 9 " 9 " " "' " >" # 3 ' 03 3<F5 C3 <&*3 /C3'(? @1< = # 9 " 3 1 1 % 1 " 1 1 ' 1 % .1 $3. '=3' 3 < G F*. ? @1 # 1 D 3 19 9 % ) # 3 03 3<F5C3 <&*3 /C3'(? @ $3. '=3' 3 < G F*. ? @ 3 "1 " ) " " ' 1 % -))+H 3 " ) %" 1 )-)+H" +)-)+4 *: : D " 1 9 " - 9 - % 9 " 9 " " " 1 I 9 "" 1' 93 "1' , 05# H74 H76 +6 9 "E 051E121@<5<?0@7;012@=>;1<;05?325@7 >54@>;58 1< ! " D01?0 032 955< >56158 =4@< 9: ;05 >19=<36 1; 12 0568 ;03; 17 ;05 E501?65 12 3 4>1E3;5E501?6546158@<01>5;05@D<5>A3:956139657@> 45<36 3<8 712?36 ?@<25H=5<?52 =<85> ;05 @;@> 501?652 ?; 7@> 43:A5<; @7 45<36;: 3<8 ;3I52 34461?3965 ;@ ;05 ?@AA5>?136 E501?652 =; 7>@A ;05 2;3<84@1<; @7 ;05 1<2=>5>A3F52<@81775>5<?5D05;05>;051<A3;51234318 43225<B5>@>B>3;=1;@=243225<B5>"05<;054@61?:122=58 123@A4>505<21E5@61?:?@E5>1<B;05>12F@7;051<A3;52 @7 3 4>1E3;5 E501?65 ;05 1<2=>5> ?3<<@; 3E@18 6139161;: @< ;05B>@=<8;03;;051<A3;5123431843225<B5> - 10 - ( 051E121@<5<?0@7;012@=>;1<;05?325@7 # $ % & # >54@>;58 1< ' ! ((" ?@<2185>1<B ;05 21A163> 4@1<; D05>51< 1; 032 @925>E581<3>3 @2)3<8D01?0>538;0=2$ " " I" (# ' 91 ' " ' # 9" # * 3 . G / *1 > ' * . 1 # 1 " 9 I $ "# G ' # ( 3I% 0 5 31 7-- ; % " """9 9' >" " H198 '(*++$3*,7- 7773#>77 - 11 - H'9 "9D # "# $1 0 0 C 1 ' 9 3 ; % " " " "9 9E H' 2 = $ " # 3I% " 1 , I"19 98 '" 9 D " . 6 0 5 31 7--1 # . 6 9 9 9 " . 7H1 . 6C 9 # 9 I ! ! . " 1D" I - 12 - " D " 9 9 " 1 % ! ! # 9 % " 9 9 # ! ! # 9 % " 99 " " 3H 77 9 " # 3 9 . # 099G '# (17773#>.#1 9 " 9 " ' 9 19; 9 " # - 13 - '* # =."17-- 3#> + .#1 9 ,H " " 9 " . 7H 1 "" ; . 7H 9 ' 9 9 " . 7H9 " 1 9 ! ! 9 I . # 1 ' 9 . 7H" " 1 9 " . 7H 1 9 " " 3 9 9 D " . 7H 1317--1" # % - 14 - " 939 9%0C "# G ' # ( * *1 777 3#> H0C ' 9 3 . 6 9 > 9 9 9 ,1 1"99 %3 %!1" " 3 . 6 0 5317--E &". 4"99D # *. 2 = $ " # 3I $ . 21 "# 0 9'3# (5I% 3 G, " # 0 C G'# (**B %9E ,++,3#>H, 7773#>H - 15 - * @<2185>1<B ;05 39@E5 85?121@<2 3<8 ;05 85?121@<2>56158 =4@<9:;05 >19=<36 ;05>5 12 <@B>@=<8 7@>1<;5>75>1<BD1;0;05C=8BA5<;3<83D3>84322589:;05 >19=<36<;05>52=6;;0534453612 !+, (!&!&) % % 12; @$6 @$)- ;$F