Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63425 (KAR)
VIDYAVATI v. SHIVASHARANAPPA
RSA/200332/2025 · 2025-12-05
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63425 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63425 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#"$ %
!"!! # $ %
&
! '
&
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! "
! "'! &( ' ! !"!! ! ) !"!'
#
$ * +
!&&&! ! %
*
* %
%,
,
&& &&&&
*
,
-./0 &&&& * **
*
,
1,
- 3 -
! $ 1, %
234 566758 34 9: ;27 6853<;3== 7>?77 @8A7? 3<
@'" & B23>2 B54 =387A =@? ?7837= @= A7>85?5;3@< 5<A 6@447443@< 27 453A 4C3; B54 A7>?77A 54 4@CD2; =@? @<&&27453AA7>?7725E3<D977<>25887<D7A9:
;27A7=7<A5<;4 ?746@<A7<;4 3<@! & ?74C8;7A 3< A34F34458 @< &"&&& 27?7 973<D <@ =C?;27? >25887<D7 ;@ ;27 45F7 254 5;;53<7A =3<583;: 77G3<D 7H7>C;3@< @= ;27 453A ICADF7<; 5<A A7>?77 ;27 6853<;3== 3<3;35;7A7H7>C;3@<6?@>77A3<D43<
@ & & C?3<D 67<A7<>: @= ;27 453A 7H7>C;3@< 6?@>77A3<D4 @<7 7<CG5 ;27 ?746@<A7<; @ =387A 56683>5;3@<C<A7? ?A7?JJC87(?75AB3;27>;3@<! >853F3<D A7;7?F3<5;3@< @= 27? ?3D2; 3< ;27 4C3; 6?@67?;:@<;276?7F347;25;;2745F7B546C?>2547A9:
27? =5;27? ?3F5<;25665 4 4C>2 427 34 7<;3;87A =@? ;27 425?7 3< ;27 453A 6?@67?;: 27 H7>C;3<D @C?; ?7I7>;7A ;27453A56683>5;3@<9:5<@?A7?A5;7A&&&73<D
- 4 -
5DD?37E7A453A 7<CG5 ?746@<A7<; @27?73<6?7=7??7A 5 ?7DC85? 566758 3< @ && : @?A7? A5;7A &&&&;27*3?4;667885;7@C?;588@B7A;277DC85? 667585<A588@B7A;27453A56683>5;3@<73<D5DD?37E7A ;276853<;3== A7>?772@8A7?3497=@?7;234@C?;
' 547 @= ;27 6853<;3== 34 ;25; 427 6C?>2547A ;27 6?@67?;: 975?3<D
8@; @! 43;C5;7A 3< :@&( ' @= 565<@@? 7E5<543AA742B5?5 @8@<: C895?D5 F754C?3<D &K H !K L27?73<5=;7? ?7=7??7A ;@ 54 ;27 M4C3;
6?@67?;: M =@? 9?7E3;:N 3< ;7?F4 @= A77A @= 4587 A5;7A &(!& =@? E58C5987 4587 >@<43A7?5;3@< =?@F 7E5<543A5665 @?3F5<;25665C947OC7<;;@;27453A 5 4C3; 3<
@ &! >5F7 ;@ 97 =387A 9:
23E5425?5<5665 5<A
?592C83<D 54 6853<;3== @4 5<A & 5D53<4;7E5<43AA566554A7=7<A5<;@5<A;276?747<;
6853<;3== A7>?772@8A7? 5667885<;27?73<54A7=7<A5<;@& =@? ?7837= @= A7>85?5;3@< 5<A 3<IC<>;3@< ; B54 >@<;7<;7A ;25; ?3F5<;25665 5<A 234 B3=7 5D5FF5 D5E7 93?;2 ;@ ;2?77 4@<4 5<A 5 A5CD2;7? <5F78: 23E5425?<5665
- 5 -
?592C83<D$6853<;3== @4 5<A& ;27?73<% 7E5<43AA5665 P ;27 A7=7<A5<; @ ;27?73< 5<A 7<CG5 5<A ;27 4C3;
6?@67?;: B54 ;27 I@3<; =5F38: 6?@67?;: 5<A 54 4C>2 7E5<43AA5665 A7=7<A5<; @ >@C8A <@; 25E7 4@8A ;27 45F73<=5E@C?@=A7=7<A5<;@&P$;276853<;3==27?73<%3< ;7?F4 @= A77A @= 4587 @< &(!& 54 4C>2 4@CD2; =@? A7>85?5;3@< 27 453A 4C3; >5F7 ;@ 97 A34F3447A @< & 4 5D53<4; B23>2 5 ?7DC85? 566758 3< @ &>5F7;@97=387AB23>2B54584@A34F3447A @< '&( 27 453A ICADF7<; A7>?77 65447A 9: ;27 ?358 @C?; >@<=3?F7A 9: ;27 *3?4; 667885;7 @C?; 254 5;;53<7A=3<583;: < ;27 F75<B2387 6853<;3== A7>?77 2@8A7?
5667885<; 27?73<584@ 25A =387A 5 4C3; 3< @'" & 477G3<D A7>85?5;3@< 5<A 6@447443@< 5D53<4; 5=@?7453A ?3F5<;25665 23E5425?<5665 ?592C83<D 7E5<543AA56655<A5D5FF527453A4C3;>5F7;@97 A7>?77A @< && A7>85?3<D ;27 6853<;3== A7>?77 2@8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< ;@ 97 ;27 594@8C;7 @B<7? 973<D
- 6 -
7<;3;87A=@?6@447443@<@=;276?@67?;:45D53<4;;27453A ICADF7<; 5<A A7>?77 5 ?7DC85? 566758 B54 =387A 9: ;27 A7=7<A5<;4 3< @! & B23>2 584@ >5F7 ;@ 97 A34F3447A@<&"&&&2C49:E3?;C7@=;275=@?7453A ;B@ICADF7<;45<AA7>?77465447A3< @ &!5<A
@'" & ?3D2; ;3;87 5<A 3<;7?74; @= ;27 6853<;3== A7>?77 2@8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< 254 977< >@<=3?F7A 5<A ;2745F72545;;53<7A=3<583;:
! 23<D4 4;@@A ;2C4 @<7 7E5<43AA5::5 @?;3 25A =387A 4C3; 3< @&" & >853F3<D ;@ 25E7 7<;7?7A 3<;@ 5< 5D?77F7<; @= 4587 3< ?7467>; ;@;27 E7?: 45F7 6?@67?;:B3;2;27 5=@?7453A 67?4@<4 5<A 4@CD2; =@? ?7837= @= 467>3=3> 67?=@?F5<>7 27 453A 4C3; 584@ >5F7 ;@ 97 A34F3447A @< &(& < 566758 =387A 5D53<4; ;27 453AICADF7<;5<AA7>?773<@'! &584@>5F7;@ 97A34F3447A@<&&'2C4;27>8@CAB23>24@CD2;
;@ 97 >?75;7A 9: E3?;C7 @= =383<D ;27 453A 4C3; 584@ D@; >875?7A
- 7 -
853<;3== 7>?77 @8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< 4@CD2;
7H7>C;3@< @= ;27 ICADF7<;
5<A A7>?77 65447A 3<
@'" & A5;7A && 3< H7>C;3@<
7;3;3@< @ & 3< B23>2 7<CG5 ?746@<A7<; @ 27?73< =387A;2759@E756683>5;3@<C<A7? ?A7?JJC87(@= 477G3<DA7;7?F3<5;3@<@=27??3D2;@<;276?7F347;25;;27 4C9I7>;F5;;7?@=;27A7>?7765447A3< @'" &34 5<>74;?58 6?@67?;: 5<A 427 254 5 ?3D2; 3< ;27 453A 6?@67?;: 27 ?358 @C?; ;5G3<D <@;7 @= ;27 5=@?7453A 6?@>77A3<D4 A7>83<7A ;@ =5E@C? ;27 453A 56683>5;3@< 5<A ?7I7>;7A ;27 45F7 4 5D53<4; B23>2 ?746@<A7<; @ 6?7=7??7A ?7DC85? 566758 3< @ && 27 *3?4; 667885;7@C?;9:;273F6CD<7A@?A7?588@B7A;27453A 56675854B78854;2756683>5;3@<=387A9:27?C<A7? ?A7? JJC87(
B3;2@C;5<:=C?;27?A3?7>;3@<;34;234 @?A7?B23>2346C;3<>25887<D7 75?<7A >@C<478 =@? ;27 67;3;3@<7? ?73;7?5;3<D ;275=@?7453A=5>;44C9F3;4;25;B27<;276853<;3== 7>?77 @8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< 254 4C>>77A7A 85B=C88: 3< 588 ;27
- 8 -
6?@>77A3<D4 ;25; B7?7 ;2?C4;7A C6@< 27? 9: ;27 E7<A@? 5<A 234 =5F38: F7F97?4 27 ?746@<A7<; @ B2@ 254 <@B 4@CD2; ;@ @9I7>; ;27 7H7>C;3@< 6?@>77A3<D4 @< ;27 6?7F347 @= 427 25E3<D 5 ?3D2; 34 5D53< 5; ;27 3<4;5<>7 @= ;27 E7?: =5F38: F7F97?4 >875?8: 5F@C<;3<D ;@ 59C47 @= 6?@>744@= 85B7 4C9F3;4;25; ;27 *3?4; 667885;7 @C?;
254 <@; ;5G7< 3<;@ >@<43A7?5;3@< ;2747 5467>; @= ;27 F5;;7? 7 4C9F3;4 ;25; 3< 5<: 7E7<; 7E7< 544CF3<D 3= ;276?@67?;:B545I@3<;=5F38:6?@67?;:54587A77A;25; 254977<7H7>C;7A@<&(!&3<=5E@C?@=3A:5E5;23 34 45E7A 3< ;7?F4 @= 6?@E34@ ;@ 7>;3@< @= ;27 3<AC C>>7443@< >; (! 7<>7 477G4 =@? 588@B3<D ;27 5667589:5<4B7?3<D4C94;5<;358OC74;3@<@=85B3<=5E@C?
@=;275667885<;
" 875?<7A>@C<478=@?;27?746@<A7<;4 E727F7<;8: IC4;3=:3<D ;27 @?A7? 65447A 9: ;27 *3?4;
667885;7 @C?; 4C9F3;4 ;25; 7<CG5 ?746@<A7<; @ 5AF3;;7A8: 254 <@; 977< F5A7 65?;: ;@ 5<: @= ;27 6?@>77A3<D4 5<A 588 ;27 A7>?774 25E7 977< @9;53<7A
- 9 -
9723<A27?95>G5<A42725A<@@66@?;C<3;:;@685>727? >547=@?>@<43A7?5;3@<74C9F3;4;25;;2@47A7>?7745?7 <@; 93<A3<D @< 27? 27?7=@?7 ;27 *3?4; 667885;7 @C?;
B54 IC4;3=37A3<588@B3<D;2756683>5;3@<6?@E3A3<D27?5< @66@?;C<3;:;@6?747<;27?>54754=383<D5=?7424C3;34<@;
67?F3443987 5; ;234 4;5D7 27?7=@?7 27 4C9F3;4 ;25; ;27 4C94;5<;358OC74;3@<@=85B<77A4;@975<4B7?7A3<=5E@C? @=;27?746@<A7<;@ ( 75?A
7?C47A;27?7>@?A4 *5>;4 <5??5;7A 59@E7 A@ <@; ?7OC3?7 5<: ?73;7?5;3@<274C3;3< @ &!B545<5;;7F6;9:
;27 =5F38: F7F97?4 @= ;27 E7<A@? @= ;27 6853<;3== A7>?77 2@8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< 477G3<D A7>85?5;3@< @= 4C3; 6?@67?;: 973<D ;27 I@3<; =5F38: 6?@67?;: 5<A ;27 >@<47OC7<; ?7837= ;25; ;27 4587 A77A A5;7A && 7H7>C;7A9:7E5<43AA56653<=5E@C?@=3A:5E5;23P;27 6853<;3==5667885<;27?73<<@;973<D93<A3<D@<;27F5<A ;27 45F7 254 977< <7D5;7A < ;27 453A 4C3; ?3F5<;25665=5;27?@=;27?746@<A7<;425A5665?7<;8: 87A7E3A7<>7@<97258=@=;27A7=7<A5<;4
- 10 -
@;B3;24;5<A3<D ;27 45F7 3< ;27 4C947OC7<;
4C3; 3< @'" & =387A 9: ;27 6853<;3== 7>?77 @8A7? 5667885<; 27?73< 5D53<4; =5;27? 5<A 9?@;27?4 @= 7<CG5 ?746@<A7<; @ 254 584@ ?74C8;7A 3< 65443<D A7>?77 3< =5E@C? @= 6853<;3== 7>?77 @8A7? 5667885<; 27?73<A7>85?3<D27?;@97;27@B<7?@=;276?@67?;:
& 2C4 ;27 @C?;4 3< 9@;2 ;27 4C3;4 3<
@ &! 5<A @'" & 25E7 >@F7 ;@ >5;7D@?3>58>@<>8C43@<;25;;276?@67?;:<@;973<D;27I@3<;
=5F38: 6?@67?;: 54 >853F7A 27 453A ICADF7<;4 25E3<D 5;;53<7A=3<583;:B@C8A93<A;2765?;3745<A5<:@<7B2@34 >853F3<D;2?@CD2@?C<A7?;27F ' 7<CG5746@<A7<;@B2@>853F4;@97;27 A5CD2;7? @= ?3F5<;25665 5<A 434;7? @= 23E5425?<5665 ?592C83<D 5<A 7E5<43AA5665 >5<<@; >853F 5<: 7H>76;3@<3<54FC>25427?=5;27?5<A9?@;27?4>853F3<D;@ 97;27F7F97?4@=I@3<;=5F38:25E7977<C<4C>>744=C83< 6?@E3<D;276?@67?;:;@97I@3<;=5F38:6?@67?;:<@;3<@<7 4C3; 9C; 3< ;B@ >@<47>C;3E7 4C3;4 5<A ;27 5667584 =387A ;27?725E7977<A34F3447A
- 11 -
<;25;E37B@=;27F5;;7?;27@?A7?65447A9:
;27 ?358 @C?; @CD2; <@; ;@ 25E7 977< 3<;7?=7?7A 9: ;27 *3?4;667885;7@C?;>>@?A3<D8:;274C94;5<;358OC74;3@< @=85B345<4B7?7A7<>7;27=@88@B3<D
$3% 7DC85?7>@<A6675834 $33% F6CD<7A ICADF7<; 5<A @?A7? A5;7A &&&& 65447A 9: ;27
?3<>3658 7<3@? 3E38,CAD75; 5859C?5D33<@ && 3447;543A7 $333% 27@?A7?65447A9:;27H7>C;3<D@C?;3< @ &34>@<=3?F7A
< E37B @= A346@458 @= ;27 566758 67<A3<D 3<;7?8@>C;@?:56683>5;3@<43=5<:4;5<AA346@47A@=
&' #$ ! ,, 34;@8@&'