- 1 - ! - 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( !" " # $% " & % " ' "&% !" %( & %)*%%*% +# Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ),!# + " + **$%*%$ " " & %*%% + - - ." # /01233425016054789:/4;520<2=:2>20=1::/4 ?@7><4=: 2=7 2A2B7 72:47 **$%*%$ 321147 89 :/4 B0=;0325 4=0CB 0D05 @7>4 2=7 & 0?2923@B2 E6CB 1/CB: FB08@=25GH 0= C %*%% 144I0=> 4=/2=;4<4=:C6;C<34=12:0C= % /4 0=?@B47 ;520<2=: 2>47 $ 942B1 7C0=> 2>B0;@5:@B4 <4: A0:/ 2= 2;;074=: C= %)*)%*%% 2=7 1@1:20=47>B04DC@10=?@B041460547;520<34:0:0C=846CB4 :/4B08@=25144I0=>;C<34=12:0C=C6 1****** &/4 B08@=25 26:4B ;C=1074B0=> :/4 4=:0B4 4D074=;4 C= B4;CB7 2A2B747 :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= C6 1,*** & A0:/ 0=:4B41: 2:J34B2==@<6BC<:/472:4C634:0:0C=:055B4250K2:0C= 2=770B4;:47B413C=74=:C%&=1@B2=;4 C<32=9 :C 329 - 3 - ;C<34=12:0C= >>B04D47 89 :/4 1207 2A2B7 :/4 2334552=:&;520<2=:/213B464BB47:/01233425 , 42B7 2B>@<4=:1 C6 8C:/ :/4 32B:041 2=7 34B@147:/4<2:4B02512D2052854C=B4;CB7 $ 42B=47;C@=145 6CB :/42334552=: ;520<2=: /21 ;C=:4=747:/2::/4;C<34=12:0C=2A2B74789:/4B08@=25 01 0=274L@2:4 ;C<34=12:0C= A/0;/ B4L@0B47 :C 84 4=/2=;47 B421C=2859 4 251C ;C=:4=747 :/2: :/4 2334552=:1@1:20=47>B04DC@10=?@B041:B42:47210=32:04=: 6CB , 7291 0=0:02559 6BC< %)*)%*%% :C %*)%*%% 2=7 :/4B426:4B2>20=6BC<,**)%*%%:C* *%*%%=130:4 C6:B42:<4=:/484;2<47012854=1@33CB:C6/01;214/4 4M2<0=47:/4C;:CB21+,A/C702>=C147:/2:;520<2=: 01 1@664B0=> 6BC< ;C<<0=@:47 6B2;:@B4 C6 B0>/: :0802 2=7 608@52 2=7 C30=47 :C:25 34B<2=4=: 0<320B<4=: 0= B452:0C= :C B0>/: 5CA4B 50<8 2: J :C %*J /4B46CB4 /4 B4L@41:476CB4=/2=;0=>:/4;C<34=12:0C= - 4 - : 01 1@8<0::47 89 :/4 542B=47 ;C@=145 6CB B413C=74=:C%=1@B2=;4C<32=9:/2::/40<3@>=47 ?@7><4=: 2=7 2A2B7 321147 89 :/4 B08@=25 01 ?@1: 2=7 3BC34B2=7=4471=C0=:4B64B4=;4 1 34B M$ +C@=7 4B:060;2:4 2334552=: 1@1:20=47 3@=;:@B47 AC@=7 CD4B B0>/: 54> 2=7 1@134;:47 6B2;:@B4C6B0>/::0802N&B29C6B0>/:54>1/CA16B2;:@B40= 701:254=7C68C:/8C=41C6B0>/:54>4A21/C130:250K47 6CB , 7291 +, C;:CB C30=47 :/2: 0=?@B041 2B4 >B04DC@1 0= =2:@B4 2=7 C30=47 :/2: ;520<2=: /21 1@664B47 J :C %*J 70128050:9 "@: :/4 B08@=25 /21 ;C=1074B47 :/470128050:92:J:C:/4A/C548C79:011@8<0110C=C6 :/4 542B=47 ;C@=145 6CB :/4 2334552=: ;520<2=: :/2: ;520<2=: 1@1:20=47 6B2;:@B4 C6 8C:/ :/4 8C=41 2=7 :/@1 B4L@41:47 :C :2I4 %J 70128050:9 42B=47 ;C@=145 6CB B413C=74=:C%=1@B2=;4C<32=9C33C141:/412<4 2=7 1@8<0::47 :/2: :/4 C;:CB B0>/:59 21141147 :/4 70128050:9 2: :C %*J 2=7 ,B7 C6 0: ;C<41 :C J - 5 - /4B46CB4 :/01 C@B: 60=71 0: ?@1: 2=7 B421C=2854 :C:2I4 :/46@=;:0C=2570128050:92:)J ) 1:/42;;074=:01C6:/4942B%*%%2134B:/4 ;/2B: 011@47 89 :/4 2B=2:2I2 :2:4 4>25 4BD0;41 @:/CB0:9 :/4 B08@=25 /21 B0>/:59 :2I4= :/4 =C:0C=25 0=;C<4 C6 :/4;520<2=:2: 1$)* & 34B <C=:/ 2=721 :/4 ;520<2=: A21 2>47 $ 942B1 2: :/4 :0<4 C6 2;;074=: 2335047:/4<@5:03504BC6F,GA/0;/=4471=C0=:4B64B4=;4 ;;CB70=>59 :/4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:547 6CB 5C11 C6 6@:@B4 42B=0=>21@=74B- 1$)* &M%M,M)JO 1*)* & /4 ;520<2=: A21 27<0::47 0= :/4 /C130:25 6CB ,7291C=1074B0=>:/434B0C7C6/C130:250K2:0C==2:@B4 C6 0=?@B041 2=7 C:/4B B454D2=: 62;:CB1 :/01 C@B: 60=71 0: B421C=2854 :C 2A2B7 2= 2<C@=: C6 1**** & 6CB 320= 2=7 1@664B0=> 1,**** & 6CB 5C11 C6 2<4=0:041 2=7 1,**** & 6CB :B2=13CB:2:0C= 4M:B2 =C@B01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;/2B>41 @B:/4B 7@4 :C 0=?@B041 :/4 ;520<2=: <0>/:=C:/2D42::4=7472=9ACBI2:5421:6CB234B0C7C6$ - 6 - <C=:/1 /4=;4 :/01 C@B: 60=71 0: B421C=2854 :C 2A2B7 1 *** & 6CB 5C11 C6 0=;C<4 7@B0=> 5207 @3 34B0C7 CA4D4B :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= C6 1%* , & 2A2B74789 :/4B08@=256CB<470;254M34=141=4471=C0=:4B64B4=;4 /4 ;C<34=12:0C= 2A2B747 89 :/4 B08@=25 01 <C70604721@=74B- 5 C 4271 A2B789:/4 B08@=25 A2B789:/01 C@B: 20=2=71@664B0=> 1%**** & 1**** & % 470;25M34=141 1%* , & 1%* , & , C11 C6 6@:@B4 42B=0=>;232;0:9 1,** & 1*)* & $ B2=13CB:2:0C= 4M:B2 =C@B01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;/2B>41 1**** & 1,**** & C11C62<4=0:041 1**** & 1,**** & C11 C6 0=;C<4 7@B0=> 5207 @3 34B0C7 1** & 1 *** & C:25 1,*, & 1$*, & /4B4A055844=/2=;4<4=:C6 1$* & - 7 - * 413C=74=: C% =1@B2=;4 C<32=9 /21 25B4279 743C10:47 :/4 ;C<34=12:0C= 2<C@=: 2A2B747 89 :/4B08@=25 =:/4B41@5::/46C55CA0=>CB74B01321147- !0# 3342501 !00# /4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:547 6CB :/4 4=/2=;47 ;C<34=12:0C= C6 1$* & A0:/ 0=:4B41: 2: J 34B 2==@< 6BC< :/4 72:4 C6 34:0:0C=:055:/472:4C6B4250K2:0C= !000# 413C=74=: C% =1@B2=;4 C<32=9 01 70B4;:47 :C 743C10: :/4 26CB41207 ;C<34=12:0C=2<C@=:25C=>A0:/0=:4B41:A0:/0= C=4<C=:/6BC<:/472:4C6:/01?@7><4=: !0D# = 1@;/ 743C10: :/4 ;520<2=: 01 34B<0::47:CA0:/7B2A:/44=:0B42<C@=:25C=> A0:/0=:4B41:2;;B@47C=0: )*+ %$' # " 01:C-5C-$ -