- 1 - ! " # $$ %&'% (&( ) !"!#" $ % & ' !"!'# ( ) ) !"('#' $ % '* & Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '+ %& ',#,#! ''+ #'! '#%'& # %'& % & %&%& ) ) '!'#! - ) . * / ) *# 0123456701160839:3867;576<6=2345'+%&4:2>6 =>67;867 09269 057 =>67;867 <3?69 %<6@652345 4: 2<4=32369& =2 966A35B ?038 35 <6916=2 4: 4::65=69 1;539>0?86;576<6=23459'#%'&4:2>6>0<023C0C0C0 05>320 # 057 6=23459 %'&%<& 057 %&%@& 4: 2>6 %&=2',", - 3 - >6 =096 4: 2>6 1<496=;2345 39 2>02 2>6 76=609674D35B24E0<3208739=4<7D32>>6<>;9?057>07 @48;520<38C86:2>6<E02<3E45308>4E6560<8C63B>2E452>9 1<34< 24 2>6 35=37652 0845B D32> >6< E354< 70;B>26< 239 0886B67 ?C 2>6 =4E18035052 D>4 39 2>6 ?<42>6< 35 80D 4: 2>676=609672>029>6>0776@684167=84965699D32>2>6 011688052 5 2>6 7026 4: 2>6 35=37652 2>6 011688052 39 0886B67 24 >0@6 0990;8267 2>6 76=60967 D32> 05 3<45 <47 057 2>6<60:26< 20A65 >6< 24 2>6 4@6<5E652 4913208 145 35:4<E02345 <6=63@67 :<4E 2>6 1483=6 2>6 =4E18035052 847B67 2>6 1<69652 =4E180352 082>4;B> >6 D0935323088C35:4<E67?C2>61483=62>022>676=60967>07 7367350<4072<0::3=0==37652 60<567 =4;5968 :4< 2>6 011688052 <6326<0235B 2>6 B<4;579 ;<B67 9;?E329 2>02 2>6<6 39 0?948;268C 54 E026<3082435:6<E423@6 6:6<<35B242>6 >6=4526579 2>02 2>6 1483=6 35916=24< >07 =860<8C 35:4<E67 2>6 =4E180350522>022>676=609677367350<4070==376522 39:;<2>6<9;?E322672>022>6=>0<B6 9>662E026<308<6@6089 - 4 - 2>0232D092>6011688052>3E968:D>4244A2>676=6096724 2>6 >4913208 D>3=> =457;=2 39 35=459392652 D32> 2>6 ?6>0@34;< 4: 0 16<945 D>4 >09 0886B678C =4EE32267 E;<76< 4;5968 :;<2>6< =4526579 2>02 2>6 0886B67 =45:69934508 92026E652 4: 2>6 011688052 39 3507E3993?86 35 @36D 4: 6=2345 ! 4: 2>6 @3765=6 =2 057 458C 2>6 739=4@6<C 3: 05C ;576< 6=2345 F =05 ?6 844A67 3524 @65 9;=> 739=4@6<C >6 9;?E329 =05542 =459232;26 9;?920523@6 6@3765=6 02 2>39 920B6 :4< 2>6 1;<1496 4: 765C35B?038 + 60<567 =4;5968 180=69 <68305=6 45 2>6 92026E6524:2>6=>387D325699<6=4<767;576<6=2345'(+ < D>6<635 2>6 @6<9345 022<3?;267 24 2>6 E354< =452<073=29 2>6 1<496=;2345 =096 >386 2>6 1<496=;2345 0996<292>022>60116880520990;82672>676=60967D32>05 3<45<472>6=>387D325699>099202672>022>60990;82D09 =4EE32267D32>0?<3=A3B>83B>235B2>69635=45939265=369 =4;59689;?E3292>022>601168805207<3@6<?C4==;102345 0572>6458C945352>6:0E38C>09?66535G;73=308=;9247C - 5 - 935=6 ##,#! 057 >39 =45235;67 35=0<=6<02345 D4;87 @348026>39<3B>22483:605773B532C;576<<23=86'4:2>6 459232;23454:5730 ! 860<567 3B> 4;<2 4@6<5E652 86076<=45265792>022>6<6=4@6<C1;<9;052242>60886B67 =45:69934508 92026E652 :;<539>69 9;::3=3652 35=<3E350235B E026<308 6 9;?E329 2>02 2>6 E026<308 45 <6=4<7 3573=0269 E423@6 057 35@48@6E652 4: 2>6 011688052 0572>6<6:4<66580<B6E65245?038D4;87?6762<3E6520824 2>61<496=;2345=096 ( 0@35B >60<7 2>6 860<567 =4;5968 057 45 16<;908 4: 2>6 <6=4<7 2>6 :4884D35B 14352 0<3969 :4< =459376<02345 F >39 4;<2 39 =459=34;9 2>02 02 2>6 920B6 4: =459376<35B ?038 0 76203867 011<6=302345 4: 6@3765=6 39 - 6 - 5632>6< D0<<05267 54< 16<E3993?86 >6 4;<2 39 <6H;3<67 458C24099699D>62>6<<609450?86B<4;5796I39224?6836@6 2>6B;3824:2>60==;967D>62>6<=;92473083526<<4B023454< :;<2>6<7626523453956=6990<C057D>62>6<2>60==;96739 83A68C2420E16<D32>6@3765=64<0?9=457 " >61<496=;2345=0969;?920523088C<6929452>6 0886B67 =45:69934508 92026E652 057 2>6 =803E67 <6=4@6<C ;576<6=2345F4:2>6@3765=6=2239D68896228672>02 0 =45:69934508 92026E652 E076 24 0 1483=6 4::3=6< 39 3507E3993?86 6I=612 242>683E3267 6I2652 4:739=4@6<C 2 2>660<83692143524:23E62>6G;<3973=2345081483=635916=24< 35:4<E672>6=4E180350522>022>676=60967>077367350 <4072<0::3=0==37652>0<B6 9>662E026<3080894739=84969 2>02 2>6 011688052 244A 2>6 76=60967 24 2>6 >4913208 3EE6730268C0:26<2>635=37652399;?96H;652=457;=239 0894<686@052:4<=459376<02345022>6920B64:?038 , :26< 20A35B 2>6 76=60967 24 2>6 >4913208 2>6 0116880523992026724>0@67<411672>6E354<70;B>26<02 - 7 - >39 93926<.9 <693765=6 >386 2>6 1<496=;2345 0996<29 2>02 2>6 76=60967 D09 0990;8267 D32> 05 3<45 <47 2>6 =>387 D325699 35 >6< 6=2345 '(+ 92026E652 0886B69 2>02 2>6 0990;82 D09 D32> 0 ?<3=A >696 =452<073=23459 =4;1867 D32> 2>6 :0=2 2>02 2>6 =096 <6929 1<674E350528C 45 =3<=;E92052308 6@3765=6 =088 :4< =0<6:;8 9=<;235C 7;<35B 2<308 '# >6<6 39 54 E026<308 180=67 ?6:4<6 2>39 4;<2 3573=0235B2>022>60116880523:6580<B6745?0383983A68C24 0?9=457 4< 20E16< D32> 1<496=;2345 D32569969 >6 32968: D09 847B67 45 2>6 ?0939 4: 35:4<E02345 35323088C 769=<3?35B 2>6 7602> 09 0 <407 2<0::3= 0==37652 057 2>6 =4E180352D09847B67?C2>6?<42>6< 35 80D057542?C2>6 >;9?057 542D32>9205735B 2>6 76=60967 >0@35B 86:2 2>6 E02<3E45308>4E6560<8C63B>2E452>960<836< '' >6 011688052.9 35@48@6E652 3: 05C 39 24 ?6 6920?839>67458C7;<35B0:;88 :867B672<3080572>6?;<765 <6E0359 45 2>6 1<496=;2345 24 1<4@6 2>6 =>0<B69 492 - 8 - :3835B4:2>6=>0<B6 9>662:;<2>6<35=0<=6<02345D4;87542 96<@6 05C :<;32:;8 1;<1496 5C 011<6>659345 4: 2>6 1<496=;2345 <6B0<735B 3526<:6<65=6 D32> D32569969 4< 83A683>447 4: 0?9=45735B =05 ?6 077<69967 ?C 3E14935B 92<35B652=457323459 ' 52>6=459376<67@36D4:2>394;<2=45235;67 7626523454:2>601168805239542D0<<05267>614352:4< =459376<02345390==4<735B8C059D6<67352>6 ' 4< 2>6 :4<6B435B <609459 2>39 4;<2 1<4=6679 2410992>6:4884D35B >6<3E350811608390884D67 >6 3E1;B567 4<76< 109967 ?C 2>6 4;<2 4: 773234508392<3=20576993459);7B6080?;<0B335<3E6 4''+ #!% % &4F# #!&70267',#,#! 3996209376 - 9 - >6 011688052 39 73<6=267 24 ?6 6580<B67 45 ?038 35 <3E6 4''+ #! 4: 6<>020?07 483=6 202345 080?;<0B3 <6B3926<67 :4< 2>6 4::65=69 1;539>0?86 ;576< 6=2345'#%'&4:2>6>0<023C0C0C005>320#057 ;576< 6=23459 %'&%<&%9& 057 %&%@& 4: 2>6 =>67;867 09269057=>67;867<3?69%<6@6523454:2<4=32369&=2 ',", 165735B ?6:4<6 2>6 4;<2 4: 773234508 392<3=2 057 6993459 );7B6 080?;<0B3 9;?G6=2 24 2>6 :4884D35B =457323459 0& 116880529>0886I6=;2616<94508?457:4<0 9;E4: 9'##### D32>2D49;<62369:4< 2>6 83A69;E 24 2>6 90239:0=2345 4: 2>6 G;<3973=2345084;<2 ?& 11688052 9>088 01160< <6B;80<8C 45 088 2>6 70269 4: >60<35B ?6:4<6 2>6 <308 4;<2 ;58699 2>6 <308 4;<2 6I6E129 >6< 01160<05=6:4<@0837<609459 =& 11688052 9>088 542 73<6=28C 4< 3573<6=28C 2><60265 4< 20E16< D32> 2>6 1<496=;2345 D32569969 - 10 - 7& 11688052 9>088 542 35@48@6 35 93E380< 4::65=6935:;2;<6 +& % ( # 3924'84'+