Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63397 (KAR)
PAIVALIKE SHAFI @ MLA SHAFI v. THE STATE
CRL.P/201886/2025 · 2025-11-28
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63397 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63397 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#& ##
#
'( ')*+ ' ** ,
!"
#$$ % " $ $
" $ $$$
&'%
"%" ""
$%%
%()( *"
" %
"
$
%$! %
$ $$ + ! "
# $ % " %"
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$ $$ $() % ' $ ,) """ $ $ $$ +
" " !!*, $ % $ $$ $- &' $ %
'$
% $ *% * !( !, !* * !*! ,( ,! $ % $
" $
& % $ $ % $ $$-
$
+ $
" )** $ *" "*!"%$$
$$
" !!*,
$
$
$$
" )**"
$ $$
$
'
$
.%
"& $
.%
"& $
/ 0123 4502026/ 015 788935: 23 355;2/< =97312/< 6> 015 4?6855:2/<3 2/ 6" !!*, 7?232/< 690 6> ?2@5 6" )** 6> 5A6<2 6A285 07026/ 230" 7A7B9?7<2 >6? 0156>>5/85349/2317BA59/:5? 58026/3 *% *!( !,!** !*!,(7/: 58026/,!6>/:27/5/7A 6:5 )* 45/:2/< B5>6?5 ?A" 230?280 7/: 53326/3 &9:<5 7A7B9?7<2 BC 4A782/< ?5A27/85 6/ 015 D9:<@5/0
- 3 -
?5/:5?5: BC 015 53326/3 69?0 2/ ""6" (* 015?5BC78=92002/<788935:63" *06 (*7/: "
" $15>7803A57:2/<0601587357?573>6AA6E3 $15 4?535/0 4502026/5? 2/ 015 4502026/ 7A6/< E201 6015? 86+788935: E73 39BD5805: 06 8?2@2/7A 4?63589026/ 7AA5<2/< 0170 6E2/< 06 4?26? 7/2@6320C B50E55/ 788935:
6" 7/: :585735: $73A2@ 6/ ! "* "** 70 7B690 ,!* 4"@"6/ + ((70%5A9?2AA7<5788935:63"06 2/ >9?015?7/856>0152?86@@6/6BD5807/:7?@5:E201:57:AC E5746/3 7??2F5:2/ 0E6 %?5GG787?3 >6?@5: 7/ 9/A7E>9A 7335@BAC 01?5705/5: 7/: ;2:/7445: 015 :585735: 7/: 86@@2005::78620C6>015F5128A5"023>9?015?7AA5<5:0170 700152/307/856>788935:63" 06,788935:63" !7/:
, ?5852F5: 3947?2 170815: 7 86/342?78C 06 86@@20 015 6>>5/857/:015?5BC86@@2005:6>>5/85349/2317BA59/:5? 58026/3 *% 7/: * ?57: E201 58026/ , 6> " 6/35=95/0AC 7AA 788935: E5?5 817?<5: E201 6>>5/853 9/:5? 58026/3!*7/:* ?57:E201 58026/ ,6>"
- 4 -
3 015 4?535/0 4502026/5? E73 7B386/:2/< 7 34A20 817?<5 31550 E73 >2A5:" $15 ?5@72/2/< 788935: /7@5AC 788935:
63" * 06 ( * 7/: E5?5 0?25: 7/: 946/ 86/8A9326/ 6> >9AA+>A5:<5: 0?27A 015 53326/3 &9:<5 5H5?8232/< 46E5? 9/:5? 58026/ !( ?""" 78=92005: 015@ 6> 6>>5/853 9/:5? 58026/3 ,! *% * !( !!!** ,(7/:,!?57:E201 58026/ ," !" /015B78;:?646>01578=92007A?586?:5:BC015 53326/369?02/ ""6" (* 0154?535/04502026/23 >2A5: 6/ 015 4?5@235 0170 015 4?2/8247A 788935: 17F5 7A?57:CB55/78=92005:6>015F5?C6>>5/8537/:0170015 4?63589026/87357<72/300154502026/5?232/3547?7BA5>?6@ 01706>01578=92005:86+788935:"02386/05/:5:0170015 6/AC 7AA5<7026/ 7<72/30 015 4502026/5? 45?072/3 06 015 7AA5<5: 8?2@2/7A 86/342?78C 9/:5? 58026/ *% 7/:
0170 2/ F25E 6> 015 8705<6?287A >2/:2/<3 ?586?:5: BC 015 53326/3 &9:<5 015 4502026/5?
E16 307/:3 6/ 015 37@5 >6602/< 73 015 78=92005: 788935: 7?5 5/020A5: 06 32@2A7? - 5 -
?5A25>BC5H5?82356>0152/15?5/0D9?23:28026/6>012369?0 9/:5? 58026/,)?""" ," %601 A57?/5: 869/35A >6? 015 4502026/5? 7:6402/<2:5/0287A7?<9@5/0317F5:?7E/0157005/026/6> 0123 69?0 06 015 ?5A5F7/0 >2/:2/<3 6> 015 53326/3 &9:<5 E12A5 78=92002/< 015 86+788935:" 7?0289A7? 5@417323 23 4A785: 6/ 47?7<?7413 ,! 06 , 6> 015 D9:<@5/0 06 :5@6/30?705 0170 015 4?63589026/ >72A5: 06 5307BA231 015 8172/6>82?89@307/027A5F2:5/85/585337?C06B?2/<16@5 015 <92A0 6> 015 788935:" 0 23 39B@2005: 0170 015 7AA5<7026/3 7/: 6F5?0 7803 700?2B905: 06 015 4502026/5? A2@205:060157AA5<7026/6>86/342?78C7?52/:2302/<92317BA5 >?6@01635A5F5AA5:7<72/3001578=92005:788935:7/:015 5F2:5/85 7::985: 2/ 015 8735 23 2/3547?7BA5 7/:
2/:2F232BA5" $15?5>6?5 6/ 015 4?2/824A5 6> 47?20C 015 4502026/5?237A365/020A5:06015B5/5>206>78=92007A"023 >9?015?7?<95:01705F5/2>0154?63589026/2345?@2005:06 4?6855:015A2;5A2166:6>86/F28026/235H0?5@5AC?5@605 7/:39BD5802/<0154502026/5?0674?6A6/<5:8?2@2/7A0?27A
- 6 -
E69A: 7@69/0 06 7B935 6> 015 4?68533 6> A7E" 0 23 7A36 B?69<10 06 015 /60285 6> 0123 69?0 0170 015 D9:<@5/0 6> 78=92007A 2/ ""6" (* 173/60B55/ 817AA5/<5: BC 015 0705 7/: 173 70072/5: >2/7A20C 7/: 86/35=95/0AC 86/02/97026/ 6> 4?6855:2/<3 7<72/30 015 4502026/5? 23 9/E7??7/05:" (" 5? 86/0?7 015 A57?/5:
E12A5 /60 :234902/< 015 D9:<@5/0 6> 78=92007A 2/ ""6" (* 86/05/:3 0170 015 4502026/5? E73 7B386/:2/< ?539A02/< 2/ 015 >2A2/< 6> 7 34A20 817?<5 31550 7/: 0170 15 @930 >785 0?27A2/:545/:5/0AC"0237?<95:01702/F25E6>015<?7F5 /709?56>7AA5<7026/3 2/8A9:2/< 0156>>5/859/:5? 58026/ !* ?57: E201 58026/ *% 015 4?6855:2/<3 87//60 B5=97315:9/:5? 58026/,)?"""@5?5ACB587935015 86+788935:17F5B55/78=92005:"
"
7F2/<157?:A57?/5:869/35A>6?0154502026/5? 7/:015A57?/5: >6?015 0705012369?086/32:5?320 /585337?C B5>6?5 4?6855:2/< >9?015? 06 5H7@2/5 015
- 7 -
8?9827A >2/:2/<3 ?586?:5: BC 015 53326/3 &9:<5 E12A5 78=92002/< 015 86+788935:" 7?7<?7413 ) 06 , 6> 015 D9:<@5/0 7?5 015?5>6?5 ?5A5F7/0 7/: 7?5 ?5=92?5: 06 B5 5H0?7805:>6?4?645?86/32:5?7026/"
!!!! "
!!!! #
"$% &
"'%&(&!&
# )
*
#
"%
)
# ++,
-
&. #
. ( &
. /
*0 *
1
0
)
"$ 0
2 &
"%
- 8 -
* **0
# +.'' *
3 &
# # *
# 0
!+
#
.(2
-
+. &
/
4 & )
5
"
&
0
+.% ! #
1
&
$% )
+.5
6! 6
&
&
&.! )
-
4 )
#
/
- 9 -
&
"
0
+.&% !
#
1
#
6
&
. . #
# #
*
-6
6 '&
" *
"& )
' +
#
. 3
6
.44#
3
/
# &# !!! +.'% ++'( 3
)
6('0
)
&
6('
#
- 10 -
$.7
+$%,
-
!!!! # *
"
8
)
1
"
0
% . &
#
0
#
# )
+
#
. '
#
"$ , #
( 0
0
#
9 # #
. # #
- 11 -
#
0
"
#
"
# !! # , #
#
! 9
. 4
:96
"
1
7 /
"
"'&
" (
"
)
"' %
#
"
9 #
. .%
"
- 12 -
*
& #
"$ !& & & & '& ! &
%6#
9 &
#
#
#
#
&
#
0 &
#
#
;&
# #
#
# '6#
9
0
#
++ 8+
&
!$0 6#
9
!6#
9
9
)
& - &<
0<
# #
- 13 -
-#&
#
*
5
#
' 0
#
# 5
#
# )
#
&
##
#
#
)
*
$ 0 &
#
*& 0
##
5
#
;<
#
+
/
"$%!'&! - 14 -
/
=
& 0
"
" #
" / 7 87?5>9A ?57:2/< 6> 015 :5072A5:
6B35?F7026/3 @7:5 BC 015 A57?/5: 53326/3 &9:<5 E1281 >6?@5: 015 B7323 >6? 78=92007A 6> 015 86+788935: 20 B586@537B9/:7/0AC8A57?01700157AA5<7026/37<72/30015 4?535/0 4502026/5? 307/:3 6/ 015 37@5 >6602/< 73 01635 A5F5AA5:7<72/3001578=92005:788935:"/36>7?73788935:
63" 7/: 2/ ?2@2/7A 502026/ 6"* ()*( 7?5 86/85?/5:0156/AC7AA5<7026/45?072/3060152?7AA5<5:?6A5 2/ 170812/< 7 8?2@2/7A 86/342?78C" 2;5E235 2/ ?2@2/7A 502026/ 6"**(*( 7?232/< 690 6> ""6"**, 015 7AA5<7026/3 7<72/30 788935: 63" 7/: ! ?5A705 06 7/ 7AA5<5: 7/2@6320C 17?B69?5: BC 788935: 6" E16 E73 ?532:2/< 2/ 015 /205: ?7B @2?7053 06E7?:3 '" 73 E5AA730157AA5<5:7806>5/<7<2/<788935:63" !7/: , 06;2:/747/:@9?:5?015:585735:"$15357AA5<7026/37?5 E16AAC 2/05?E6F5/ E201 015 B?67:5?
4?63589026/ 0156?C
- 15 -
E1281 173 7A?57:C B55/ :23B5A25F5: 2/ 203 5/02?50C BC 015 53326/369?0" )" $15 5H0?7805: >2/:2/<3 >?6@ 47?7<?7413 ) 06 ,6>015 53326/369?0D9:<@5/0:238A63535F5?7A8?9827A :5>2825/8253E1281:2?580AC2@4780015393072/7B2A20C6>015 4?63589026/ 7<72/30 015 4?535/0 4502026/5?" $15 53326/3 &9:<51738705<6?287AAC/605:01700154?2/8247AE20/53353 /7@5AC '" 06 '"( E16 7AA5<5:AC A730 37E 015 :585735:2/01586@47/C6>788935:63"06 70%5A9? 17F5 09?/5: 86@4A505AC 16302A5" 9?015? 015 53326/3 &9:<5 E12A5 7/7AC32/< 015 8?633+5H7@2/7026/ 6> '" , 015 86@4A72/7/0 173 12<1A2<105: 0170 0123 E20/533 34582>287AAC :5/25: 015 86?5 7AA5<7026/ 0170 015 :585735:
E73;2:/7445:700152/307/856>788935:63" 06,"$15 53326/3 &9:<5 173 7A36 7:F5?05: 06 015 F6A9/07?C 30705@5/036>788935:63" * , (*7/:
7/: 173 86/8A9:5: 0170 015 4?63589026/ 173 >72A5: 06 5307BA231 015 5335/027A 2/<?5:25/03 6> 58026/ 6> 015 /:27/ F2:5/85 80 7/: 0170 015 7AA5<5: ?586F5?253 7?5
- 16 -
/60 4?6F5: 2/ 7886?:7/85 E201 A7E" / 7::2026/ 015 53326/3 69?0 173 2:5/02>25: @705?27A 86/0?7:28026/3 6@23326/3 7/: 35?2693 A74353 2/ 015 2/F5302<7026/ 9A02@705AC16A:2/<01700158172/6>82?89@307/027A5F2:5/85 ?5A25:946/BC0154?63589026/:653/60>6?@786@4A505 7/:9/B?6;5/A2/;462/02/<06015<92A06>015788935:"/ 0123 6F5?7AA 733533@5/0 015 86+788935: /7@5AC 788935:
63" * 06 ( * 7/: E5?5 78=92005: 6> 7AA 817?<53 9/:5? 58026/3 ,! *% * !( !! !* * ,(7/:,!?57:E201 58026/ ,6>"
" $15 A57?/5: 869/35A >6? 015 4502026/5? 173 4A785: ?5A27/85 6/ 015 D9:<@5/0 6> 015 6/IBA5 94?5@5 69?02/
73 E5AA73015D9:<@5/06>0156+6?:2/705%5/812/
! "!" #$ %!!"!!&'%'("$154?2/824A53A72::6E/ 015?52/ 47?0289A7?AC 0170 E15?5 015 5F2:5/85 7<72/30 86+ 788935: 23 2/3547?7BA5 7/: 2/:2F232BA5 7/: 015 @72/ 788935: 17F5 B55/ 78=92005: 6/ @5?203 86/02/97026/ 6>
- 17 -
4?6855:2/<3 7<72/30 015 7B386/:2/< 788935: E69A:B5 7/ 7B935 6> 4?68533 3=97?5AC 744AC 06 015 4?535/0 8735"
5?5 015 4?63589026/ 8735 ?5303 36A5AC 6/ 82?89@307/027A 5F2:5/85"$15@6308?9827A82?89@307/85/7@5AC015JA730 355/K 0156?C 173 86AA7435: 2/ F25E 6> ;5C E20/53353 09?/2/< 16302A5" /85 015 39B30?709@ 6> 015 4?63589026/ 8735173B55/86@4A505AC:23A6:<5:BC015>2/:2/<32/ "" 6" (* 012369?0236>01586/32:5?5:F25E0170015 4?535/0 4502026/5? E16 >785 7AA5<7026/3 6> 2:5/0287A 7/:
2/3547?7BA5 /709?5 87//60 B5 86@45AA5: 06 9/:5?<6 7 >9AA+>A5:<5: 0?27A" 886?:2/<AC 015 4502026/ :535?F5 06 B5 7AA6E5: 7/: 015 4?6855:2/<3 45/:2/< 7<72/30 788935: 63" 7/: 788935: 63" 7/: !
7/: 788935: 6"( 7?5A27BA506B5=97315:" *"37A?57:C:2389335:5F5/2>015353326/387353 E5?5 06 B5 2/:545/:5/0AC 4?6358905: 015 A2;5A2166: 6> 86/F28026/6>0154502026/5?235H0?5@5AC?5@605"/>7802/ A2<10 6> 015 8705<6?287A >2/:2/<3 ?586?:5: BC 015 53326/3
- 18 -
69?0 2/ ""6" (* 015 46332B2A20C 6> 86/F28026/ 23 F2?097AAC /6/+5H2305/0" 9BD5802/< 015 4502026/5? 06 7 4?6A6/<5: 8?2@2/7A 0?27A 2/ 3981 82?89@307/853 E69A:
7@69/0 06 45?@2002/< 7/ 7B935 6> 015 D9:2827A 4?68533 E1281 0123 69?0 87//60 869/05/7/85" $15?5>6?5 86/02/97026/6>0154?6855:2/<323E16AAC9/E7??7/05:7/: A27BA506B5=97315:"
" / F25E 6> 015 >6?5<62/< :23893326/ 0123 69?0 4?6855:3064733015>6AA6E2/<
2$154502026/2315?5BC!#)" 22 $15 4?6855:2/<3 45/:2/< 2/
6" !!*,7?232/<6906>?2@56" )**6> 5A6<2 6A285 07026/ 230" 7A7B9?7<2 >6? 015 6>>5/85349/2317BA59/:5? 58026/3 *% * !(!,!** !*!,(7/: 58026/,!6>
- 19 -
/:27/ 5/7A 6:5 )* 45/:2/< B5>6?5 ?A" 230?280 7/: 53326/3 &9:<5 7A7B9?7<2 7?5 15?5BC=97315:2/36>7?730154502026/5?15?52/ 2386/85?/5:"
-+ ' ##* &
& 2306" A6" $