Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63384 (KAR)

BASAWARAJ AND ORS v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ANR

WP/201284/2019 · 2025-11-12

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!" !#$% & %'"%"% ()"* ! ! " "# $ " %& ' (% $%' Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! % % %& ) % % * $' % % " +% , $' % " +% , $' " % $' - %% "" %, % (% $ ./ .$'$'' % . 0 . . % 1' . , &!))0 % %% 0) ) %% % +&/ ' . - 3 - % . . % .. * ! $% * ' %231314526178294623:174;638215<=<<612>2?8@3:2 46?26?=32?!))0A=772?15AA2=B 40)49) 453:291B2493:2=65=3=C=AA2BB=32618;5=B=5<=B462 D:26215=93266292662?34=73:2E618;5=BF946862>13@G:2 7=1?=AA2=B1791B2?8@627A45?253 4:26215H:=BB25<15< 3:2 46?26 ?=32? 0) )! 82=615< 4 ) )&! 177;2? 8@ 627A45?253 4 & 2A;3@ 4II177145261J=@=A;6==HH46?15<H:=5<249B=5?;7=<2 964I =<61H;B3;6=B 34 545&=<61H;B3;6=B A;6A4727 15 ;6>2@ 4 I2=7;615< ) =H627 0 <;53=7 :2 A61>=32 627A45?253 :26215 :=? H:=BB25<2? 3:2 7=1? 46?26 H45325?15<3:=33:27=1?2K325349)=H6270<;53=7=B74 15HB;?2? =5 2K3253 49 =H627 82B45<15< 34 3:2 A61>=32 - 4 - 627A45?2537 7 7;H: <6=53 49 H:=5<2 49 B=5? ;7=<2 15 9=>4;6 49 A231314526 8@ 3:2 2A;3@ 4II17714526 L=7 ;57;73=15=8B2HH2A315<3:27=1?H4532531453:2618;5=B :=? =BB4L2? 3:2 =AA2=B H=5H2B15< 3:2 46?26 ?=32? 0) )!177;2?8@3:22A;3@4II17714526 %=63127 :=>2 54L 91B2? = I2I4 ?=32? )0) =B45< L13: = H4A@ 49 3:2 7=B2 ?22? ?=32? )) =5? 3:2 62H46?7 49 61<:37 :2 7=1? I2I4 17 71<52?8@3:2627A2H31>2H4;572B343:2A=63127=7L2BB=7 3:2A=63127A26745=BB@:2I2I462=?7=7;5?26 ! "#$%&$'( ! )* ( & ( ( ( + ! &&%&$&#,&' #,$#,&$&#( ( - 5 - ! - ( - - ! . %/!%%0.%'$1%&$&,2 ",$1,&$2 345.567.5( 4 8 0 2, $,&$" ! "#$%&$' ",$1,&$2 . %/!%%0.%'$1%&$&,2 * - 4 9 ! 2=652? H4;572B 946 3:2 A2313145267 =5? 3:2 627A45?2537 =7 L2BB =7 B2=652? ??13145=B 4>265I253 ?>4H=32 J4153B@ 7;8I13 3:=3 15 3:2 B1<:3 49 ?17A;32 823L2253:2A2313145267=5?3:2A61>=32627A45?2537L13: 62<=6?343:22K325349B=5?:=>15<82257233B2?3:28=717 45 L:1H: 3:2 618;5=B :=? 723 =71?2 3:2 46?26 ?=32? 0) )!?4275437;87173:26294623:246?26A=772? 8@3:2618;5=B62M;16273482723=71?2 " 2=652? =3 3:17 J;5H3;62 7;8I137 3:=3 715H23:26217=>=61=3145153:22K325349B=5?=7461<15=BB@ - 6 - 7;8I1332? 34 3:2 2A;3@ 4II17714526 8@ 3:2 A231314526 722C15< H:=5<2 49 B=5? ;7=<2 =5? 15 >12L 49 3:2 7;872M;253 ?2>2B4AI253 49 A231314526 A;6H:=715< 3:2 =??13145=B2K325349B=5?964I3:2A61>=32627A45?25373:2 2A;3@ 4II17714526 L4;B? 62H4571?26 3:2 H=72 49 3:2 A231314526=9627: ;8I177145173=C254562H46? 613 %2313145 17 6?26 ?=32? !))0A=772?15AA2=B 40)49)453:291B249 3:2 =65=3=C= AA2BB=32 618;5=B 25<=B;6; 17 M;=7:2? %2313145267 =62 B18263@ 34 I=C2 62A627253=3145 829462 3:2 2A;3@ 4II17714526 946 52H277=6@ 46?267 :4;<: 8@ >163;249723315<=71?23:246?26493:2618;5=B3:246?26 ?=32?0) )!73=5?762>1>2?:4L2>2615>12L493:2 7;872M;253 ?2>2B4AI253 15 3:2 5=3;62 49 A2313145267 =HM;1615<=??13145=B2K325349B=5?964IA61>=32627A45?253 47$=' 34 $?' A2313145267 7:=BB I=C2 52H277=6@ =AAB1H=3145 829462 3:2 2A;3@ 4II17714526 L:4 7:=BB - 7 - 62H4571?26 3:2 I=3326 3=C15< 1534 H4571?26=3145 3:2 7;872M;253 ?2>2B4AI253 =7 6292662? 34 =84>2 =5? 7:=BB 177;29627:46?26H4661<25?;I46HB=6191H=3145=73:2H=72 I=@8262<=6?15<H:=5<249B=5?;7=<2L13:15=54;326 B1I13493:622I453:7964I3:2?=324962H21A349H2631912? H4A@493:1746?26 "+) (%"%* '! 173 4B 4 %