- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %& %'() %(( * !"#"$%& ' () * $ + "#"$%, " "#"$% ' ( * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "# # + $"%" $$"(* $, ,"$(* ," %, + - )()*) $"%" $(* + . ) ( . ) * /010123/4 15 5//6137 89:5;137 2< 0;/ =42>//?1375 13 41@/ 2$"%" <24 0;/ 2<</3>/5 =9315;:AB/ 93?/4 />01235 $$"(* $, ,"$(* :3? ," 2< ;:4:01C: C:C: :3;10:%,=/3?137230;/<1B/2<??B1D1B)9?7/()93124 1D15123*:3?)2940:B:A94:71 - 3 - ;/ 7150 2< 0;/ =425/>90123 >:5/ 15 0;:0 4/5=23?/30 2>2@=B:13:30 E;2 15 : =2B1>/ 2<<1>1:B B2?7/? : >2@=B:130 23 $$%" :BB/7137 0;:0 0;/ =/010123/4 ;:? :55:9B0/? =2B1>/ =/45233/B E10;13 0;/ F:1B =4/@15/5:5/?230;/5:1?>2@=B:130:>:5/>:@/02A/ 4/7150/4/?1341@/2$"%"<240;/:BB/7/?2<</3>/5 , /:43/? >2935/B :==/:4137 <24 0;/ =/010123/4 4/10/4:0/?0;/74293?5947/?130;/=/010123:3?59A@100/? 0;:0 0;/ /3014/ >41@13:B =42>//?1375 :4/ :3 :A95/ 2< =42>/55015>230/3?/?0;:00;/=/010123/4E:5241713:BBC :44/50/?13>233/>0123E10;41@/2$G%%,4/7150/4/? AC 5;263:7:4 2B1>/ 0:0123 :3? E:5 59A5/89/30BC 4/@:3?/?02F9?1>1:B>9502?C:0/304:B41523:B:A94:71 ;/ 23-AB/=/H2940AC24?/4?:0/?$I$$%"E:5 =B/:5/? 02 /3B:47/ 0;/ =/010123/4 23 130/41@ A:1B <24 : =/412?2<0;4//E//65;/5:1?24?/4E:5>2@@931>:0/? 020;/413>1=:B15041>0:3?/551235)9?7/:B:A94:7123 %$$%"E;2:<0/4?9/D/41<1>:01232<594/01/51559/? - 4 - 0;/4/B/:5/1301@:0123020;//304:B41523:B:A94:71:0 :4293?%%=@ /5=10/ 0;15 B/:43/? >2935/B >230/3?5 0;:0 1350/:? 2< <:>1B10:0137 ;15 4/B/:5/ 0;/ =/010123/4 E:5 :BB/7/?BC:55:9B0/?ACF:1B:90;24101/5A/0E//3$$,%=@ :3? $%% @1?317;0 23 $$$%" 0 15 <940;/4 :BB/7/? 0;:0E;/30;/=/010123/4:00/@=0/?02@//00;/;1/<):1B 9=/4130/3?/30 02 :==415/ ;1@ 2< 0;/ 323>2@=B1:3>/ 2< 0;/ A:1B 24?/4 ;/ E:5 ?/31/? :>>/55 :3? E:5 1350/:? @:3;:3?B/?AC=2B1>/=/45233/BE;20;/4/:<0/4B2?7/?: <:B5/>2@=B:130>9B@13:01371341@/2$"%" " 3D1/E2<0;/5/41295:BB/7:01235@:?/AC0;/ =/010123/4:3?3201370;/59A@15512352<B/:43/?>2935/B 0;15 2940 /H=4/55/? 504237 4/5/4D:01235 :A290 0;/ >23?9>0 :BB/7/? :7:1350 0;/ F:1B :90;24101/5 >>24?137BC B/:43/? ??10123:B E:5 ?14/>0/? 02 2A0:13 ?/0:1B/? 135049>01235 :3? 02 5/>94/0;/ =4/5/3>/ 2< 0;/ >23>/43/? F:1B2<<1>1:B5A/<24/0;152940 - 5 - G 3 &$$%" B/:43/? ??10123:B =42?9>/? 0;/ ;1/< ):1B 9=/4130/3?/30 A/<24/ 0;15 2940 ;/ ;1/< ):1B 9=/4130/3?/30 59A@100/? : /3?41D/ >230:13137 <220:7/ 2< 0;/ 4/B/D:30 13>1?/30 ;/ D1?/2 >B1=5 E/4/ =B:C/? 13 2=/3 2940 42@ 0;/ ?/@23504:0123 10 :==/:4/? 0;:0 0;/ =/010123/4 E:5 A/;:D13713:3:774/551D/@:33/4:3?E10;290E:10137<24 =/4@155123 <42@ 0;/ 59A24?13:0/ 50:<< :00/@=0/? 02 <24>1ABC /30/4 0;/ 2<<1>/ 2< 0;/ ;1/< ):1B 9=/4130/3?/30 ?94137E;1>;5>9<<B/;/155:1?02;:D/:55:9B0/?:=2B1>/ 2<<1>/4<0/4D1/E1370;/<220:7/0;152940?14/>0/?0;:0 0;/ @:00/4 A/ B150/? <24 <940;/4 >2351?/4:0123 :3? :>>24?137BC:?F2943/?10020;/=4/5/30?:0/ & :D137;/:4?B/:43/?>2935/B<240;/=/010123/4 :3? 0;/ B/:43/? ??10123:B :3? 9=23 =/495:B 2< 0;/ D1?/2<220:7/5;2E3230;/=4/D1295?:0/0;152940<13?5 0;:00;/>23?9>02<0;/=/010123/4:54/<B/>0/?130;/5:1? <220:7/ =41@: <:>1/ ?2/5 320 F9501<C /H/4>15/ 2< 13;/4/30 =2E/4502130/4?1>00;/13D/5017:0123;297;0;/=/010123/4 - 6 - E:5 :4@/? E10; :3 130/41@ A:1B 24?/4 74:30/? AC 0;/ 23-AB/=/H294059>;B1A/40C?1?320/3010B/;1@02:>0 130;/@:33/4?/=1>0/?130;/<220:7//D/40;/B/550;15 29404/<4:135<42@@:6137:3C>23>B951D/2A5/4D:0123523 0;/ :90;/301>10C 24 /D1?/301:4C D:B9/ 2< 0;/ D1?/2 4/>24?1375 :5 0;/ 5:@/ :4/ @:00/45 02 A/ 5>490131J/? 13 ?/0:1B?94137041:B00;1550:7/0;/@:0/41:B=B:>/?A/<24/ 0;/ 2940 ?2/5 320 E:44:30 130/4</4/3>/ 24 89:5;137 2< 41@/ 2$"%" 2E/D/4 0;/ =/010123/4-5 741/D:3>/ 0;:00;/F:1B:90;24101/5?/B1A/4:0/BC?/B:C/?24<:1B/?02:>0 9=23 0;/ 130/41@ A:1B 24?/4 1559/? AC 0;/ 23-AB/ =/H 2940 :3? 0;/ >235/89/30 4/B/:5/ 24?/4 2< 0;/ 413>1=:B 15041>0 )9?7/:B:A94:71 15 :@:00/40;:0 >:3 A/4:15/? A/<24/ 0;/ >2@=/0/30 59=/4D1524C :90;24101/5 E;2 5;:BB /H:@13/0;/5:@/1<:>2@=B:13015B2?7/? # 015@:?/>B/:40;:0:3C2A5/4D:01235@:?/AC 0;152940E;1B/?15=251372<0;15=/010123:4/=94/BC<240;/ =94=25/ 2< >2351?/4:0123 2< 0;/ =4/5/30 @:00/4 :3? 5;:BB - 7 - 32013:3C@:33/4=4/F9?1>/2413<B9/3>/0;/041:B2940 13:?F9?1>:01370;/>:5/23105@/4105 I 240;/:<24/5:1?4/:5235:3?2A5/4D:012350;/ =/01012350:3?5 +) %!!( $ ) 1502B2,