Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63374 (KAR)
MANJUNATH AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201343/2024 · 2025-07-16
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63374 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63374 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$#
%&$!'!! &
( ()*+ (!!** ,
! " #
$
% &
'
(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
! $
%
&
(
)
(
'
(*
(&
' !*
(&'
$
" !!" ( ((
+* "# !" !"#
(
(
( (
(
(
,
& , '
-./0/1.2345.315-./2-064728-594/:;- <-:1:142-/8 .20 /1 .=.0./ ;.;.>70012 5-./2-0 13; 47/:4?-/2=-2:5-.0-/94/:;-/-8<420-2:4
- 3 -
-./2-0 64728-5 94/ :;- /-8<420-2: 4 18 .>8-2:
;18<-:1:14218915-0720-/-6:142*49/ @1:;:;-94554@123</.A-/
!" # $ ! %%" # & '"( !&$ !&) !&* $ $ $ & $#+ %#& %#+
( !&, -. /
0 012 1
3
4
(.6:8 12 :;- 27:8;-55 94/ 018<48.5 49 :;- </-8-2: <-:1:142./-.8720-/
64=<5.12:6.=-:4>-5403-0>A:;-/-8<420-2:
4 B =: --5.==. .3.128: :;- <-:1:142-/8 ;-/-12 @1:; 700->1;.5 <4516- 8:.:142 42 !"" @;16; @.8 /-318:-/-0 12 /1=- 4" 18: 49 :;- 64=<5.12: .?-/=-2:8/-?-.5:;.::;-<-:1:142-/8;-/-12;.0.</4<-/:A 018<7:-.2064=<5.12.2:18@4/C123.8.;1-944C12
6;44512</-<./123:;-9/-8;944094/:;-6;150/-2;-;.0. - 4 -
9.:;-/>A2.=- .2.=.<<../51-/:4:;-12610-2:/-<4/:-0 12:;-6.8-42"":;-/-@.8.018<7:-@1:;/-3./0 :4:;-5.20.20:;-/-@.8.2.5:-/6.:142.20:;-<-:1:142-/8 ;-/-12;.0.88.75:-0:;-64=<5.12.2:;-/9.:;-/.2084249 :;- 64=<5.12.2: .20 :;-A ;.?- :.C-2 :/-.:=-2: 12 :;- ;48<1:.5
;-/-@.8.<.26;.A.:642?-2-0>A:;--50-/849 :;- ?155.3- .20 :;-/-94/- 24 94/=.5 <4516- 64=<5.12: @.8 5403-0@1:;/-3./0:4:;-8.1012610-2:
2""@;-2 64=<5.12.2: ;.0 >--2 :4 700->1;.5 12 /-8<-6: 49 :;- :/.12123 </43/.= 12 2.2. ;./.:1 10A.=.201/ 6;445 .:
700->1;.5 .: .>47: "" <= 42 :;- 8.=- 0.A 8;- /-6-1?-0 :;- 1294/=.:142 9/4= ;-/ 842 :;.: ;-/ 9.:;-/ 18 =1881239/4=:;-;478-
==-01.:-5A8;-/-:7/2-0:4:;-?155.3-.20:;-A 8-./6;-094/;1=.20;-@.824:.?.15.>5-;-2:;-=.::-/ 8:440 :;78 42 "" .: .>47: +"" .= :;- 64=<5.12.2: /-6-1?-0 . 6.55 9/4= 42- .D>75 4
766;-8.> 8:.:123 :;.: 2-./ .23.0.31 >/103- :;-/- ./-
- 5 -
84=- ./:165-8 94720 .5423 @1:; . 01./A 12 :;- 8.10 <5.6- 84=->40A ;.8 :-5-<;42-0 :4 ;1= :;.: :;-8- ./:165-8 @-/- 947202-./:;- .23.0.31>/103-
==-01.:-5A :;- 64=<5.12.2: .5423 @1:; .D>75 @-2: :4 :;- .23.0.31 >/103- .20 24:16-0 :;- .=8723 =4>15- 8-: 01./A 49 :;- 9.:;-/ 49 :;- 64=<5.12.2: .20 4. 1=46;.2. ;.57?.51 4/.:.3././. 126;.21 78:.C. .20 . <.1/49345064547/85--<-/8;-10-2:191-0:;.::;48-./-.55 >-5423123 :4 ;-/ 9.:;-/ .20 8;- -2D71/-0 @1:; :;- ?155.3-/8 .>47::;-</-8-26-49;-/9.:;-/12.20./4720:;-<5.6-49 12610-2:4=-49 :;-?155.3-/81294/=-0;-/:;.:;-;.0. :-. 12 . ;4:-5 2-./ --5.=>1C. -=<5- .20 ;- @.8 81::123 2-/?478
! 2:-/:.12123.047>::;-12610-2:@.8/-<4/:-0:4 :;-<4516-.20:;-91/->/13.0- ;-91/->/13.0-8-./6;-094/ :;->40A49:;-9.:;-/49:;-64=<5.12.2:.20:;-A@-/-.>5- :4 8<4: . 0-.0 >40A .>47: ;.59 . C154=-:-/ .@.A :4 :;- @-8:-/2 810- 49 --5.=>1C. -=<5- 42 !"" @;16;
- 6 -
@.8 10-2:191-0 >A :;- 64=<5.12.2: .20 . 94/=.5 64=<5.12: 6.=-:4>-5403-0.3.128::;-<-:1:142-/8
# 4516- .9:-/ :;4/473; 12?-8:13.:142 915-0 :;- 6;./3-B8;--: .20 :;- =.::-/ 18 24@ <-20123 >-94/- :;- 5-./2-0-881428703-
+ .C123 24:- 49 :;- 64321E.26- 97/:;-/ </46--01238186;.55-23-0>A:;-<-:1:142-/8;-/-12
!
/1 .2345.31 5-./2-0 64728-5 94/ :;- <-:1:142-/8 /-1:-/.:123 :;- 3/47208 7/3-0 12 :;- <-:1:142 ?-;-=-2:5A 642:-20-0 :;.: :;-/- 18 24 =.:-/1.5 42 /-64/0 @;16; @4750 .::/.6: .55 123/-01-2:8 94/ :;- 499-26- 720-/ -6:142"#4994/@;16;:;-.>-:=-2::464==1:871610- 18.0-6181?-9.6:4/
#
- @4750 97/:;-/ 642:-20 :;.: :;- 12610-2: 8.10 :4 ;.?- 4667//-0 42 "" .20 :;- 12610-2: :;.: ;.8 4667//-042!"";.8242-F78@;.:84-?-/.20:;-/- 1824.>-:=-2:64==1::-0>A:;-<-:1:142-/8442>-94/-:;-
- 7 -
0-.:; .20 :;-/-94/- <-20123 6/1=12.5 6.8- 2--08 :4 >- D7.8;-0
+ . /1 .=.0./ ;.;.>70012 5-./2-0
13; 47/: 4?-/2=-2: <5-.0-/ 642:-20-0 :;.: .0=1::-05A :;-/-@.8.D7.//-5.20.<.26;.A.:;.8>--2642?-2-042
"".20:;-12G7/-0<-/8428;.0:.C-2:/-.:=-2:12 :;- ;48<1:.5 .20 :;- 8.10 <.26;.A.: @.8 642?-2-0 @1:; /-3./0:4.018<7:-12/-8<-6:49:;-?.6.2:5.20
*
-@475097/:;-/642:-20:;.:876;<-/8428;.?- >--2-2D71/-0>A:;-<4516-.20:;-1/8:.:-=-2:8;.?->--2 /-64/0-0 @;16; ;.8 75:1=.:-5A /-875:-0 12 . A-./8 450 <-/842 64==1::123 871610- >A G7=<123 12 :4 :;- 954@123 /18;2./1?-/2-./ .23.0.31>/103-.20:;-3/472087/3-0 12 :;- <-:1:142 ./- :4 >- .0G7016.:-0 >A :;- 5-./2-0 :/1.5 703-.9:-/07-:/1.5
- ;.8 97/:;-/ 642:-20-0 :;.: </1=.B9.61- =.:-/1.58./-8799161-2:-2473;:4-8:.>518;:;-.>-:=-2:42 >-;.59 49 :;- <-:1:142-/8 :4 64==1: :;- 871610- >A 9.:;-/ 49 :;-64=<5.12.2:.208473;:94/018=188.549:;-<-:1:142
- 8 -
"
.?123;-./0:;-./37=-2:89/4=>4:;810-8:;18 47/:<-/78-0:;-=.:-/1.542/-64/0=-:16754785A
2 876; <-/78.5 49 :;- =.:-/1.5 42 /-64/0 6;./3-B8;--: =.:-/1.58 </1=.B9.61- @4750 34 :4 8;4@ :;.: :;-/- @.8 . 8-/1478 018<7:- @1:; /-3./0 :4 . ?.6.2: 5.20 >-:@--2:;-64=<5.12.2:.20:;-.6678-0
2 :;.: /-3./0 :;-/- @.8 .2 12610-2: :;.: ;.8 4667//-0 42 "" <-61916 =.:-/1.58 ./- 6455-6:-0 >A :;- </48-67:142 @;16; @4750 </1=.B9.61- 12016.:- :;.: 0-6-.8-0 @.8 9/78:/.:-0 >-6.78- 49 :;- 018<7:- :;.: ;.8 >--2/.18-0@1:;/-3./0:4:;-?.6.2:5.20
;-:;-/ .: .55 :;- =.:-/1.5 42 /-64/0 12 :;- 6;./3-B8;--:@4750>-8799161-2:-2473;:4>-:/-.:-0.8.2 .>-:=-2::464==1:871610-4/24:6.224:>-0-610-0>A:;18 47/:.::;188:.3->A;450123.=121:/1.5;.?123/-3./0:4 :;-864<-49-6:142*49/
- 9 -
79916- :4 8.A :;.: :;- </1=.B9.61- =.:-/1.5 .?.15.>5- 42 /-64/0 @4750 >- 8799161-2: -2473; 94/ :;- <-:1:142-/8:49.6-:;-:/1.5
! 664/01235A 12 ?1-@ 49 :;- 94/-34123 01867881428 @1:;47:-F</-88123.2A97/:;-/4<1214242:;-=-/1:849:;- =.::-/94554@1234/0-/18<.88-0
&1' -:1:14218)
&11' 55:;-.?.15.>5-0-9-26-8./-<-/=1::-0 :4>-6.2?.88-0>A:;-<-:1:142-/812:;-<-20123 :/1.5 12 .664/0.26- @1:; 5.@ .20 :;- 5-./2-0 :/1.5 703-18-2:1:5-0:4642810-/:;-8.=-7212957-26-0 >A018=188.549:;-</-8-2:<-:1:142
!-+ ('!! * $
18:454!