- 1 - !" # $%& # $%& % ## ' ( ) ## ** ' ( ## ' ( !"# $ % & ! """! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # """! ' !"# !"# !"# $ % ()!* & #""!#"! #"##"! ( ## ** ' ( !"# $ % & - 3 - ! !"# # """! ' """! ' !"# !"# $ % !* ()#& + ( #""!#"! %)&#"##"! ( - 4 - ( , ( , ( &% % , ( & -./0 12- /-34-5167- 8-./9-0 5:;93-8 <:/ 12- .44-88.91 .90.83:8-./9-05:;93-8.44-./69=<:/12-1.1- # 2-3- 1>: .44-.83 ./- <68-0 52.88-9=69= 12- :/0-/ 4.33-0 ?@ 1263 :;/1 69 :#""!#"! >2-/-69 12- 69=8- (;0=- 2.769= 5:9360-/-0 12- A.1-/6.8 :9 /-5:/0 4./165;8./8@12-?;68069=>.35:931/;51-0.90>2-912-<69.95- >.3A.0-?@12- @0-/.?.0./9.1.B.-7-8:4A-91:./06- ?@ .90 /A@ :/4:/.16:9 2-80 12.1 61 ?-8:9=3 1: 12- 12 /-34:90-91 :/4:/.16:9 1 63 .83: :?3-/7-0 12.1 12-/- 63 9: 0634;1- 12.1 4-1616:9-/ 63 ;1686C69= 12- ?;68069= <:/ . 6=2-/ -5:90./@ 52::8 </:A 58.33-3 ! 1: !" 69 1-/A3 :< 12- 4-/A6336:9.903.9516:9.55:/0-0?@12-0;5.16:9-4./1A-91 ;90-/12-./9.1.B.0;5.16:951!D ';/12-/:?3-/7.16:9 63 A.0- 12.1 61 63 ;9<.6/ 1: 06/-51 12- 4-1616:9-/ 1: 2.90:7-/ 4:33-336:9 :< 12- 3.60 ?;68069= 1: 12- 12 /-34:90-91) - 5 - :/4:/.16:9 B--469= 69 A690 12- 691-/-31 :< 12- 352::8 =:69= 52680/-9.0A611-01:12-352::8 ' 2- 8-./9-0 69=8- (;0=- .83: 69 4./.=/.42 : 2.769=1.B-99:1-:<12633.60<.51691:5:9360-/.16:906/-51-06< 4-1616:9-/ A.B-3 .9 .44865.16:9 <:/ 12- .88:1A-91 :< 12- 3.60 6AA:7.?8- 4/:4-/1@ ?@ >.@ :< 8-.3- :/ :12-/>63- 12- 12 /-34:90-91 63 06/-51-0 1: 5:9360-/ 12- 3.A- .90 A.B- .44/:4/6.1- /-5:AA-90.16:93 1: 12- 1.1- :7-/9A-91 ;90-/ -516:9!E:<12-./9.1.B. ;96564.8:/4:/.16:951!DE .90 6< 3;52 . /-5:AA-90.16:9 63 A.0- 12- !31 /-34:90-91 ) 1.1-:7-/9A-911:5:9360-/12-3.A-.90-7-9.4/:1-516:9 >.3=67-9;91683;5216A-12-/-34:90-913./-06/-51-09:11: =67--<<-511:12-:/0-/0.1-0#""!#"!99-F;/-) .769=5:9360-/-012-:/0-/4.33-0?@12-8-./9-0 69=8-(;0=-.90.83:12-=/:;903;/=-069 #""" #"! .90 3.A- 63 ?@ 12- 4-1616:9-/ ?-<:/- 12- 69=8- (;0=- .90 .9:12-/.44-.863?@12-:/4:/.16:9 .769= 5:9360-/-0 =/:;903 ;/=-0 ?@ ?:12 12- .44-88.9136-4-1616:9-/.3>-88.3:/4:/.16:9.90.83:2.769= 5:9360-/-012-/-.3:93=67-9?@12-69=8-(;0=-4./165;8./8@69 - 6 - 4./.=/.429:1-.901.B-99:1-:<12-.A:;91697-31-0 ?@12-:7-/9A-913695-12-?;68069=-/-51-0:912-3.608.90 63<69.95-0>612 @0-/.?.0./9.1.B.-7-8:4A-91:./0.90 5:931/;51-0?@12-.90/A@:/4:/.16:9.90.83:5:9360-/69= 12-<.5112.1352::8>.3?-69=/;96912-3.60?;68069=.90.83: .9:?3-/7.16:963A.0-12.16<.9@3;52.44865.16:963=67-9<:/ 12- .88:1A-91 :< 3.60 6AA:7.?8- 4/:4-/1@ ?@ >.@ :< 8-.3- :/ :12-/>63- 4-56<65 06/-516:9 >.3 =67-9 1: 5:9360-/ 12- 3.A- .90 A.B- .44/:4/6.1- /-5:AA-90.16:9 1: 12- 1.1- :7-/9A-91.901.B69=9:1-:<12-:/0-/4.33-0?@12-69=8- (;0=->-0:9:1<690.9@=/:;9031:-91-/1.6912-.44-.8<68-0 ?@12--612-/?@12-4-1616:9-/.3>-88.312-:/4:/.16:9.90 12-69=8-(;0=-2.769=.4486-0613A6905:9360-/-012-<.51;.8 .34-51 .90 .83: .A:;91 34-91 ?@ 12- :7-/9A-91 <:/ 5:931/;516:9 :< 12- ?;68069= .90 .83: 06/-516:9 >.3 =67-9 1: 5:9360-/ 12- .44865.16:9 2-9 3;52 06/-516:9 >.3 =67-9 12.1 1:: 69 :/0-/ 1: 4/:1-51 12- ?;68069= .3 >-88 .3 =-9-/.1- 12- /-7-9;-3;5206/-516:9>.3=67-9 -95-12-3.A-63.83:69 12-691-/-31:<12-52680/-9>2:./-4;/3;69=12-6/-0;5.16:969 12-3.60352::890-/12-56/5;A31.95-31263.44-.8.83:<68-0 - 7 - 6912-@-./#"!.90.8A:31.0-5.0-63-8.43-0.902-95-9: =/:;903./-A.0-:;1.90>2-9.9:44:/1;961@>.3=67-91: 12-4-1616:9-/6912->/614-1616:9.90.83::?3-/7.16:963A.0- 69 4./.=/.42 : 6931-.0 :< .448@69= <:/ 12- 8-.3- 12- .44-88.91 <68-0 :#""" #"! 2.769= 1.B-9 9:1- :< 12- .07.91.=-:<12-3.A-.9012-69=8-(;0=-1.B-99:1-:<12- 3.A- 69 3461- :< 12- 3.A- <68-0 .44-.8 1 63 9:1269= ?;1 .9 .?;3- :<4/:5-33 .90 2-95- 61 63 . <61 5.3- 6A4:3--F-A48./@ 5:31 -95- 1263 .44-.8 63 063A633-0 >612 -F-A48./@ 5:31 :< 3#""") 2- :/4:/.16:9 63 .83: .44/:.52-0 1263 :;/1 >2-912-06/-516:9>.3=67-91:5:9360-/12-3.A-6<.9@3;52 .44865.16:9 63 <68-0 .90 :98@ :9 12- =/:;90 12.1 12- 48.5- 69 >2652?;68069=635:931/;51-0.903.A-63:98@.88:11-0<:/12- 4;/4:3-:<4./B;13;525:9360-/.16:95.99:1?-5:9360-/-0 .90:912.1=/:;90:98@52.88-9=-12-3.A-?-<:/-1263:;/1 .90 >2-9 3;52 06/-516:9 >.3 =67-9 1: 5:9360-/ 12- 3.A- .90 12-/->.39:.9@4:36167-06/-516:92-8-./9-069=8-(;0=- .83:5:9360-/69=12-A.1-/6.85:A-31:12-5:958;36:912.16163 :98@.56765.A-961@361-694./.=/.42:.909:15:A-31: 12- 5:958;36:9 12.1 3.A- 63 . 4./B :>-7-/ >2-9 12- 06/-516:969=67-94./.=/.42:63:98@6<3;52.44865.16:963 - 8 - =67-9 12- 12 /-34:90-91 1: 5:9360-/ 12- 3.A- < 3;52 .9 /-5:AA-90.16:963A.0-6306/-51-01:5:9360-/12-3.A-.90 A.B- .44/:4/6.1- /-5:AA-90.16:93 1: 12- 1.1- :7-/9A-91 ;90-/ -516:9 !E :< ./9.1.B. ;96564.8 :/4:/.16:9 51 !DE.90:93;52/-5:AA-90.16:963A.0-12-!31/-34:90-91) 1.1-:7-/9A-911:5:9360-/12-3.A-.903;5206/-516:9>.3 =67-99:A-/616912-.44-.8<68-0?@12-:/4:/.16:9.83:.90 2-95->-0:9:1<690.9@=/:;901:-91-/1.6912-.44-.8<68-0 ?@ 12- :/4:/.16:9 .83: 9 76-> :< 12- 0635;336:93 A.0- .?:;1>-4.3312-<:88:>69= :1212-.44-.83./-063A633-0 2- .44-.8 <68-0 ?@ 12- .44-88.91 4-1616:9-/ 69 >/61 4-1616:96306/-51-01:4.@5:31:<3#""") :/4:/.16:9 1: 5:A48@ 12- 06/-516:9 .3 06/-51-0 ?@ 12- 69=8-(;0=-6<.9@.44865.16:963<68-0?@12-.44-88.91:/6=69.8 >/614-1616:9-/ 2-.A:;91:<5:31634.@.?8->61269#>--B3</:A1:0.@ 1: 12- :/4:/.16:9 6< 12- .A:;91 63 9:1 4.60 >61269 # >--B3 - 9 - :/4:/.16:963=67-986?-/1@1:/-5:7-/12-3.A-69.55:/0.95- >6128.> +) '# ( & +) '%( & 631:!8:#D