- 1 - !" # $ % !" # & $' ' ( ! ( # ( ( " ( % ") ") !# ") * !# Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( $ ( ) " ( $ ( ( "%) * ! (# ) + , ( $% - ") * ! ( # ( $ ( ) - 3 - ( $ ( ( "%) !" ( # ( ( ") ( % ") !.# ") * ! ( # ) + # , "" ( $% - " # / # 0/ ' ' - 4 - !' # 1232425656&73892:7;29956<=23)87;+&>512 &73565:56&7 &> 7;68 ?@ 512 5852 <8==67A 67 B:2356&7 512 &9;29 ;852; 67 44=6<856&7 & $% 48332; ?@ 512 897858C8 5852 ;D676359856E2 96?:78= 8==8?:9A6 !096?:78=/ >&9 31&95# F1292?@ 512 96?:78= 8==&F2; 512 844=6<856&7 >6=2; ?@ 512 496E852 9234&7;275 325567A"836;2 512 &9;29 6D4:A72; 5129267 ;852; %E6;2772G:92"%633:2;?@9234&7;2757& 673&>89 83 512 844=6<875 63 <&7<2972; 87; ;692<52; 512 9234&7;275 H8:51&965623 5& 48@ 8== <&732B:275=@ ?272>653 67<=:;67AD&765&9@?272>6535&512844=6<8755&F16<11263 =2A8==@27565=2;F65167856D2?&7;&9;29&>51922D&7513 289; D58@8 =28972; 6A1 &:95 &E297D275 =28;29 87; 96 :?1831 8==84:9 =28972; <&:732= >&9 425656&7293 67 ?&51 512 425656&73 87; 96 - 5 - 1:3892 =28972; <&:732= 84428967A >&9 9234&7;275 67 ?&51512425656&7329:32;275692F965425656&7484293 12489562389292>2992;5&8342951269987C67A3 ?2>&9251296?:78= ?962> &:5=672 &> >8<53 =28;67A 5& >6=67A &> 5163 425656&789283:7;29' 12844=6<875F83F&9C67A83824:5@692<5&992" 76E29365@;:<856&785(6I8@4:98 78<&D4=8675>6=2;?@ &72 96 2248C 852= ;852; 8==2A67A 72A=6A27<2=28;67A5&;2768=&>?272>655&5122G2D456&7&> >223 5& 512 2=6A6?=2 35:;2753 >&9 8;D6336&7 5& 27A6722967A$D2;6<8= <&:9323 A98752; 655:96 876 18778DD898516?8:93C898<1&&= 832;&7512<&D4=86758924&95:7;292<56&7 ! #F833:?D6552;5&512&E297D275?@512 897858C8 &C8@:C58>&92759:35D275&>27B:69@69359234&7;275&7 ) 48332; 512 &9;29 2759:3567A 512 27B:69@ 5& 9234&7;275 & 897858C8 &C8@:C58 :7;29 :=2 " - 6 - 928; F651 :=2 &> 512 897858C8 6E6= 29E6<23 !=8336>6<856&7 &759&= 87; 4428=3# :=23 J+ !1292678>529<8==2;830/:=23#5&1&=;27B:69@8A86735 512844=6<87587;87&5129H:518=6C967<648=5& &D4&365292" 76E29365@&==2A2518762=A8E663596<5 :?32B:2755&5122759:35D275&>27B:69@8<189A2D2D& <8D2 5& ?2 633:2; &7 + 87; 8>529 1&=;67A 27B:69@8924&95F833:?D6552;1&=;67A5185189A2& 63 4895=@ 49&E2; 87; 512 9235 &> 512 <189A23 892 7&5 49&E2; ) 4&792<2645&>512924&95832<&7;31&F<8:32 7&56<2 F83 633:2; ?@ 512 &E297D275 &7 %+ &7 512 ?8363 &> 92<&DD27;856&73 &> 9234&7;275 & " 897858C8 &C8@:C58 8=&7A F651 924&95 &> 512 27B:69@ &>>6<2912844=6<8753:?D6552;8;2586=2G4=87856&7835& F1@ 512 >67;67A &> 512 27B:69@ 8:51&965@ 31&:=; 7&5 ?2 8<<2452;67163924=@;852;J+234652512924=@ 2G4=86767A5129283&73F1@51227B:69@924&9531&:=;7&5 ?2 8<<2452; 512 9234&7;275$5852 E6;2 &9;29 ;852; - 7 - % 92I2<52; 512 924=@ 6D4&32; 8 4278=5@ &> F6511&=;67A K &> 42736&7 429D87275=@ &7 512 844=6<875 F16=2 2G&7298567A (:518=6C AA962E2; ?@ 512 386; &9;29&>4278=5@512844=6<875F83?2>&9251296?:78= + :?32B:275 5& 633:87<2 &> 7&56<2 &E297D275 =28;29 F651&:5 >6=67A 35852D275 &> &?I2<56&7 &98==@ &?I2<52;5&512844=6<856&7358567A518551292637&D296567 512844=6<856&787;512844=6<875637&527565=2;5&87@&> 51292=62>33&:A15>&967512844=6<856&787;512844=6<856&7 6532=>637&5D86758678?=226512967=8F&9&7>8<53:95129 8 3:?D6336&7 F83 D8;2 5185 &7=@ 8>529 <&736;2967A 512 924=@ 5& 512 32<&7; 31&F <8:32 7&56<2 8 ;2<636&7 F83 58C27 67 8<<&9;87<2 F651 =8F 87; 8<<&9;67A=@ 3&:A15 5& ;63D633512844=6<856&7 % 2>&92 512 96?:78= 84895 >9&D 512 D29653 &> 512<832512=28972;<&:732=84428967A>&9512844=6<875 512926798632;8=2A8=633:25185512844=6<875925692;>9&D 329E6<2 &7 + 87;512 4278=5@&9;29 <8D2 5& ?2 - 8 - 48332; 3:?32B:275 5& 512 925692D275 F16<1 63 ;852; % J 5638=3&163<&752756&7518551292637&>67;67A ?@ 512 ;63<64=6789@ 8:51&965@ 5185 512 D63<&7;:<5 386; 5& 18E2 ?227 <&DD6552; ?@ 512 844=6<875 63 8 A98E2 D63<&7;:<5 1292 63 7& ;634:52 92A89;67A 512 ;852 &> 925692D275 87; 6D4&3656&7 &> 4:7631D275 12 96?:78= 18E67A2G598<52;51292=2E87549&E636&762:=23:? :=2 !#!8# &> 3 F16<1 358523 8?&:5 F6511&=;67A &9 F651;98F67A 42736&7 >&9 A98E2 D63<&7;:<5 &9 72A=6A27<2 12 275692 A635 35852; 67 512 386; :=2 <=289=@ 4&35:=8523 5185 512 &E297D275 92329E2; F651 4&F29 265129 F6511&=;67A &9 F651;98F67A 8 42736&7 &9 4895 51292&> F125129 429D87275=@ &9 >&9 8 342<6>62; 4296&; 6> 67 87@ ;24895D2758= 27B:69@ 512 42736&729 63 >&:7; A:6=5@ &> A98E2 D63<&7;:<5 &9 72A=6A27<2 ;:967A 512 4296&; &> 163 329E6<2 12 96?:78= 92>29967A 5& 512 I:;AD275 &> 512 &"&9;6785227<1&>51296?:78=67512<832&> E3 924&952;67JJ J+&8=3&;2<636&7&>512 - 9 - &7?=242G&:9567512<832&> E3 !# >&:7; 5185 <&:732= >&9 512 844=6<875 F83 I:356>62;67D8C67A 5123:?D6336&7 &7 =2A8= 8342<5&>:=2!#!8#51855124278=5@&9;296532=>7&5 3:358678?=2 1296?:78=8>529429:367A512275692D852968= 18E67A>&:7;518551292637&67A92;627583<&752D4=852; :7;29:=2!#!8#35852;3:4988==&F2;512844=6<856&7 325"836;2512&9;29 673&>8983 512844=6<87563 <&7<2972; ;692<52; 5& 48@ 8== <&732B:27568= ?272>653 67<=:;67A 512 D&765&9@ ?272>653 5& 512 844=6<875 5& F16<1 12 63 =2A8==@ 27565=2;5635163&9;2948332;?@51296?:78=63<8==2;67 B:2356&7675163425656&7 D5 8@8 =28972; F651 8== E212D27<23:?D6552;518583429512924&953:?D6552;?@ 512 27B:69@ &>>6<29 51292 63 8 <=289 >67;67A &> A98E2 72A=6A27<2 &7 512 4895 &> 512 844=6<875 F16<1 <=289=@ 2D4&F293 512 5852 5& 6D4&32 4:7631D275 F65167 512 4&F2927I&672;:7;29:=2!#!8#&> :=2312 - 10 - 96?:78= 183 D6332; 5163751638342<5 &>512 D85529 67 512492327<2 &> >67;67A3 &> 512 27B:69@ &>>6<29 3&:A15 5& 8==&F512425656&787;325836;2512&9;2951292?@;63D633 512844=6<856&7<&7>69D67A5124278=5@633:2;?@5125852 3 429 512 27B:69@ 924&95 F16=2 873F2967A 189A2&51227B:69@&>>6<2912=;5185367<2512 183 7&5 <&D2 &:5 F651 87@ 2G4=87856&7 2G4=86767A 512 9283&7>&9;63485<167A512=25529&7)51&:A1512 =25529 F83 C245 928;@ &7 6532=> 87; 512 &D6336&7&75124895&> &677&558C67A6DD2;6852 8<56&73&&78>52992<2645&>512=25529>9&D512692<5&9852 ;852; 8D&:753 5& 72A=6A27<2 &7 163 4895 <<&9;67A=@ 189A2 & 12=; 5& ?2 4895=@ 49&E2; &7=@ 8A86735 "62512844=6<875 163 83 429 512 =28972; ;2496E2; 512 35:;27535&322C>22<&7<2336&7:7;295123<12D283512 =835;852>&98;D6336&7F83&E29?@51256D2512=25529F83 ;63485<12;?@512844=6<875163638A98E272A=6A27<2&7 4895&>512844=6<8755163638<<&9;67A5&512=28972; - 11 - 63 512 A98E2 72A=6A27<2 &7 163 4895 F16<1 <&D23 F65167 5124:9E62F&>:=2!#!8#&> 3 7 B:29@ &> 5163 &:95 5185 F125129 512 35:;2753 F292 7&5 512928>529 49&E6;2; >22 <&7<2336&7 =28972;>869=@3:?D6552;518551235:;2753F292486; 512 8D&:75 F16<1 512@ 18E2 ?227 <189A2; F651&:5 87@ ;63<&:753:?32B:275=@ 96:?18318==84:93:44&952;51289A:D2753 8;E87<2;?@=28972;6A1&:95&E297D275=28;2987; 498@35&8==&F425656&787;;63D633512844=6<856&7 ) 2>:567A5123:?D6336&73&>=28972;6A1&:95 &E297D275 =28;29 83 F2== 83 96 :?1831 8==84:9 67 <&772<52; F965 425656&7 96 1:3892 F651 8== E212D27<2 3:?D6552; 5185 512 96?:78= 48332; 512 &9;29 8==&F67A512844=6<856&7&7<&736;2967A512275692D852968= &792<&9;5&?:55923316389A:D2751218392=62;&7512 I:;AD275 &> 512 &&9;67852 27<1 &> 5163 &:95 67 &))$ 35923367A &7 4898A9841 F129267 - 12 - 512 <&"&9;67852 ?27<1 183 <=289=@ 12=; 5185 83 429 512 :=2 F16<1 <=289=@ 67;6<852 5185 512 42736&729 D:35 ?2 >&:7;A:6=5@&>A98E2D63<&7;:<5&972A=6A27<2;:967A512 4296&;&>163329E6<212386;>67;67A638492<&7;656&7>&9 2G29<632&>4&F295&F651;98F51242736&787;518563512 6752756&7&>512:=2E2751227B:69@F8367656852;F127 512844=6<875 F83 67 329E6<2 5124278=5@ &>6D4&367A 512 F6511&=;67A &> 42736&7 F83 &9;292; 3:?32B:275 5& 925692D275&7=@?@92<&9;67A8>67;67A518551242736&729 63>&:7;A:6=5@&>A98E2D63<&7;:<5&972A=6A27<2 + 2 18E2 A&72 519&:A1 512 275692 7B:69@ 24&95 F2 322 7& 3:<1 >67;67A &> A98E2 D63<&7;:<5 &9 72A=6A27<2 2G<245 F&9; 72A=6A27<2 35852; 67 512 27B:69@ 924&95F16=2873F2967A<189A2& % 3<&:=;?23227>9&D51227B:69@924&9551292 63 &7=@ 3&D2 ;2=8@ 67 >&9F89;67A 512 =25529 3 <&:=; ?2 3227>9&D512924=@5&51232<&7;31&F<8:327&56<2512 844=6<875 183 2G4=8672; 512 9283&7 >&9 512 38D2 48956<:=89=@ 67 4898A9841 &J 358567A 5185 512 35:;2753 - 13 - 8<5:8==@92<26E2;?272>653>9&D512&E297D27583429512 A:6;2=6723 &> 512 876 12778DD8 98516?8 :983C89 <12D23429512<69<:=8912183A&5 ;8@35&327; 512 92<&DD27;856&73 <<&9;67A=@ 12 183 3275 512 92<&DD27;856&7D:<1289=6295&5124296&;&> ;8@387; 65 63 7&5 67 ;634:52 5185 512 35:;2753 18E2 92<26E2; 512 ?272>65 2E27 83 429 512 35852D275 D8;2 ?@ 512 =28972; J 7;29 51232 <69<:D3587<23 2E27 8<<&9;67A 5& 512 8956<=23 &> <189A23 512 =25529 F16<1 &:A15 5& 18E2 ?227 >&9F89;2; &7 183 ?227 >&9F89;2; &7 )F16<167>8<57&5<8:32;87@492I:;6<25&512 35:;275383512@18E292<26E2;512?272>653 7 512 42<:=689 >8<53 87; <69<:D3587<23 &> 512 <832 &7 187; F2 >&:7; 5185 51292 63 7265129 87@ A98E2 D63<&7;:<5 &9 72A=6A27<2 83 <&752D4=852; :7;29 :=2 !#!8# 3 F16<1 63 85596?:58?=2 5&F89;3 512 844=6<8753&5185512&E297D275<&:=;6D4&324278=5@ - 14 - 7;29 51232 <69<:D3587<23 F2 >67; 7& 67>69D65623 67 512 &9;29 48332; ?@ 512 96?:78= 12 F965 425656&733873D296587;8<<&9;67A=@;63D6332; 12 425656&7293 67 & $ 892 ;692<52; 5& <&D4=@ F651 512 &9;29 &> 512 96?:78= F65167 &72 D&751 >9&D 512 ;852 &> 92<2645 &> 512 <&4@ &> 5163 &9;29 F651&:5 <8:367A 87@ >:95129 ;2=8@ 367<2 512 &9;29 &>51296?:78=F83;852; 87;56D24923<96?2; 51922D&7513=8432;?@51227;&>496=87;7&FF2 892 67 <&736;2967A 512 8A2 &> 512 8442==875 F83 ) @2893 83 &7 % 7&F 12 63 7289=@ + @2893 87; 67 163 2E2767A;8@3 &&9;29835&<&35 !" #$% !&'" #$% 7$635&'=&')$'