1 ! "# $ #%% & ' '(%)&*+')) , !" # $% & &%% %% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA 2 #'#(#$ )% " % % * % % % %% + %+ & $% % % ) %% **' % $% , % % $% (#* " )% % % +- #" +* ' % % ) % (#* % %#% % % %# % % +- #"+* ' %$%"% % % & & . $ % # &. $ % /01- 12 3450650770831 7/019/-:;396/7 <;1 =5/088/7709= ;>0?3>=009-120@0-08317/019/- :;396/7<;1=5/1/68;9-/9=0::36/- 3 * ;>0?3>=0 26 =5/ 088/7709= :5077/9A29A =5/ B3-A@/9= 09- ;1-/1 ;< 0:C32==07 8066/- 29 8706/ ;(#**-0=/-**' + 0:=6 29 412/< D52:5 01/ 3=@;6= 9/:/6601? <;1 -268;607;<=5/81/6/9=088/0701/0639-/1& + :;@87029=:0@/=;4/7;-A/-D2=5 ;>0?3>=0 ;72:/ 0704310A24?"4?90@/12060D010B" ;9 *( :;9=/9-29A =50= 5/ D06 D;1>29A 06 6626=09=/0:5/1290;E/19@/9=2A5/112@01?:5;;7 29 070>0@40 2770A/ 29 /-0@ 073> 09- 0 :06/ D06 1/A26=/1/- 0A0296= 52@ 29 /-3@ ;72:/ =0=2;9 ;9 '*+ 29E;>29A =5/ 81;E262;96 ;< # 1/E/9=2;9 ;<=1;:2=2/6:=<;165;1=F#:=G +* 9 '*+ =5/ :;@8702909= D06 =0>/9 =; B3-2:207 :36=;-? 29 1/68/:= ;< =5/ 602- :06/ 09- ;9 *(*+=5/%/83=?%21/:=;1;<=5/3472:96=13:=2;96 0704310A2 <;1 65;1= F%%G 8066/- 09 ;1-/1 ;< 4 6368/962;9 0A0296= =5/ :;@8702909= D2=5 /<</:= <1;@ *(*+ ++ = 26 076; <;39- <1;@ =5/ :;@87029= 0E/1@/9=6 =50= ;9 '**+ :;@8702909= @;E/- 09 08872:0=2;9 4/<;1/ =5/ %/801=@/9= 1/C3/6=29A =; 29E;>/ =5/ ;1-/1 ;< 6368/962;939=27<29070-B3-2:0=2;9;<=5/602-:06/ +( 9 ;1-/1 :0@/ =; 4/8066/- 29 =50= 1/A01- ;9 **+09-=5/:;@8702909=B;29/-526-3=2/6"5/9 =5/@0==/16=;;-=536;9'*(=5/1/D0609;1-/1 8066/- 4? =5/ 8/:207 ;31= 0:C32==29A =5/ 088/7709= <;1 =5/ ;<</9:/6 077/A/- 0A0296= 52@ 39-/1 =5/ 81;E262;96 ;< #:= + 5/1/0<=/1 :;@8702909= 602- =; 50E/ <27/- 09 08872:0=2;9 4/<;1/ =5/ %% 07;9A D2=5 =5/ :;8? ;< =5/ B3-A@/9= 09- 1/C3/6=/- =; -/=/1@29/ =5/ 60701? 80?047/ =;52@-3129A6368/962;98/12;- +H 9 **( :;@8702909= D/9= =; =5/ ;<<2:/ ;<=5/%%09-@/==5/7/1>09-1/C3/6=/-52@=;83= 5 38 =5/ <27/ 1/70=29A =; 526 6368/962;9 8/12;- 09- A/= 2= :7/01/- + ==50=B39:=31/2=26=5/1/68;9-/9=D5;506 29<;1@/-=5/:;@8702909==50=2<4124/0@;39=29063@;< 6*#26802-526D;1>D;37-4/0==/9-/- + 29:/ =5/ :;@8702909= D06 9;= 29=/1/6=/- 29 801=29A 0D0? =5/ 4124/ @;9/? 5/ 0881;0:5/- =5/ ;72:/ 09-7;-A/-=5/:;@87029= ( 316309==;=5/:;@87029= ;>0?3>=0968/:=;1 1/A26=/1/- 0 :06/ <;1@/-0102-=/0@ 09- 0<=/1 6/:3129A =5/ 809:506 -/@;96=10=/- :5/@2:07 1/0:=2;9 ;< 85/9;785=507/29 8;D-/1 D2=5 6;-23@ :014;90=/ 6;73=2;9 6/:31/- =5/ 4124/ @;9/? 6@/01/- =5/ 85/9;785=507/29 8;D-/1I-10<=/-/9=136=@/9=@050J01I=5/9296=13:=/-=5/ :;@8702909= 09- =5/ 650-;D D2=9/66=; E262= =5/0::36/- 09-;9-/@09-=;509-;E/1=5/=029=/-:311/9:?=;52@ 6 8/1 =5/ 296=13:=2;96 0 =108 D06702- 09- 0::36/- D06 =1088/- 5;3A5 =5/1/ 01/ 6/12;36 -26:1/809:2/6 29 =5/ =108=108@05J01:;9=029/-1/C321/--/=0276 6 5/ 401A029/- 4124/ 0@;39= ;< 6*# :;@812629A ;< * :311/9:? 9;=/6 ;< 6# -/9;@290=2;9 D06 076; 1/:;E/1/- <1;@ :36=;-? ;< =5/ 0::36/-;7;31=/6=6=;;-8;62=2E/5/1/0<=/10::36/- D06011/6=/-09-6/9==;B3-2:207:36=;-? H <=/1 :;@87/=29A =5/ -/=027 29E/6=2A0=2;9 :501A/65//=:0@/=;4/<27/- <=/1 6/:3129A =5/ 81/6/9:/ ;< =5/ 0::36/- :501A/6 D/1/ <10@/- <;1 =5/ ;<</9:/6 839265047/ 39-/1 /:=2;96 09- +- 1/0- D2=5 /:=2;9 +* ;< =5/ 1/E/9=2;9 ;< ;1138=2;9 := <;1 65;1= F :=G ::36/-87/0-/-9;=A327=?=5/1/<;1/=1207D065/7- 9 ;1-/1 =; 4129A 5;@/ =5/ A327= ;< =5/ 0::36/- D2=9/66/6 D/1/ /K0@29/- 09- +' -;:3@/9=6 D/1/ 870:/-;91/:;1-06K6=;+'@0=/1207-;:3@/9=6 D/1/076;870:/-;91/:;1- 7 ' 9 :;9:7362;9 ;< 1/:;1-29A ;< =5/ /E2-/9:/ 0::36/- 6=0=/@/9= 06 26 :;9=/@870=/-39-/1 /:=2;9++ ;<1D061/:;1-/-D5/1/290::36/-506-/92/-077 =5/ 29:12@290=29A @0=/12076 ::36/- -2- 9;= :5;;6/ =; 870:/09?-/</9://E2-/9:/;91/:;1- 5/1/0<=/1 =5/ 7/019/- 1207 $3-A/ 5/01- 01A3@/9=6 ;< =5/ 801=2/6 29 -/=027 09- 0:C32==/- =5/ 0::36/-5;7-29A29010;6(=;0639-/1& ! " ! ! #$#%# &' 8 &' ( ) ' * $ +,& )%#&###-. )%&###-. & & & ! ,! !! /# % .)01 ,! & )0 & +2 % %# & / % )0 9 ,! * 3 4 /% + 5 6+57 89 / : & '*2/67 ; , + 5 , * 55" . +5 & + 5 10 /3 * " 9< " .& . & ! ! < / = % 3 !! ' *%# +, . 11 " %)0 ' *3 & % 3 ; > . " & 12 // ". . " 9& #$#%# = * ;3# #$#%# " " 9 & ! ! /2 ". *+-* + !& 55" & & 13 ? /$ , = & ;%( ! @ /29A 0AA12/E/- 4? =5/ 60@/ ;>0?3>=0 506 <27/-=5/81/6/9=088/07D2=5=5/<;77;D29AA1;39-6& 0 & 0 + '& 0 14 ! 3( 0 + .% +& .3 * ;%%(89 A / : 0 B-*%# + , 15 , + C 4 C-* * 0 %#/637 *++ %# & ! B-* %# +, C 0 A & . & * 12 345065 0770831 7/019/- :;396/7 <;1 =5/ 088/7709= ;>0?3>=0 1/2=/10=29A =5/ A1;39-6 31A/- 29 =5/ 088/07 @/@;109-3@ :;9=/9-/- =50= =5/ 7/019/- 1207 $3-A/5069;=81;8/17?0881/:20=/-=5/@0=/1207/E2-/9:/ ;91/:;1-09-6;3A5=<;1077;D29A=5/088/07 + / D;37- <31=5/1 :;9=/9- =50= 8129:287/6 /939:20=/- 4? =5/ ;9G47/ 8/K ;31= 29 =5/ :06/ ;< 16 1/8;1=/- 29 9//-6=;4/:;962-/1/-4?=526;31=09-29E2/D;< 1/:;E/1? ;< =5/ =029=/- :311/9:? <1;@ =5/ :36=;-? ;< =5/ 0::36/-0=7/06=<;1=5/;<</9:/839265047/39-/1/:=2;9 ;<=5/:==526;31=261/C321/-=;1/:;1-09;1-/1 ;<:;9E2:=2;94?077;D29A=5/088/0729801=09-6;3A5=<;1 632=047/;1-/16 ( 12 0@0-0831 7/019/- :;396/7 <;1 =5/ 1/68;9-/9=0::36/- ;88;6/6 =5/ 088/07 A1;39-29=;=; / D;37- <31=5/1 :;9=/9- =50= =5/ :06/ ;< =5/ 81;6/:3=2;926@;=2E0=/-=5/1/269;81;;<;<-/@09-9;1 =5/ 0::/8=09:/ 06 26 1/C321/- =; 1/:;1- 09 ;1-/1 ;< :;9E2:=2;909-=5/1/<;1/=5/;1-/1;<0:C32==0726B36=09- 81;8/109-6;3A5=<;1-26@26607;<=5/088/07 H 0E29A5/01-=5/01A3@/9=6;94;=562-/6=526 ;31=8/136/-=5/@0=/1207;91/:;1-@/=2:37;367? 17 963:58/13607;<=5/@0=/1207;91/:;1-=5/ <;77;D29A 8;29=6 D;37- 0126/ <;1 :;962-/10=2;9 29 =526 088/07& "5/=5/1 =5/ @0=/1207 /E2-/9:/ 870:/- ;9 1/:;1- D;37-4/63<<2:2/9=/9;3A5=;09937=5/<29-29A;< 0:C32==07 09- 1/:;1-29A ;< 09 ;1-/1 ;< :;9E2:=2;9 ;< =5/ 1/68;9-/9= <;1 =5/ ;<</9:/6 839265047/ 39-/1/:=2;9609-+-1/0-D2=5/:=2;9 +*;<=5/:=L * "5/=5/1=5/2@83A9/-B3-A@/9=2663<</129A<1;@ 7/A07 29<21@2=? ;1 8/1E/162=? 09- :0776 <;1 29=/1</1/9:/4?=526;31=L + < =5/ 096D/1 =; 8;29= ;6 09- * 01/ 29 =5/ 0<<21@0=2E/D50=26=5/0881;8120=/6/9=/9:/L ( "50=;1-/1L -./(012.31245/20 9 =5/ :06/ ;9 509- :;@8702909= 506 9;= 6388;1=/-=5/:06/;<=5/81;6/:3=2;929/9=21/7?50-;D D2=9/66 "* 0B3 076; -2- 9;= 6388;1= =5/ :06/ ;< =5/ 81;6/:3=2;9 18 ' = 26 <;39- <1;@ 526 /E2-/9:/ =50= =5;3A5 5/ D06 296=13:=/- =; 0::;@809? =5/ :;@8702909= 09- =; ;46/1E/ =5/ 0:=2E2=2/6 =50= D;37- =0>/ 870:/ 09- 5/01 -/@09-09-=;6//=5/0:=307509-29A;E/1;<=5/=029=/- :311/9:? =; =5/ 509-6;< =5/ 0::36/-5/ 50668/:2<2:077? -/8;6/- 4/<;1/ =5/ ;31= =50= ;9 =5/ -0? ;< =108 :;@8702909=09-0::36/-=;A/=5/150-=/02965;>;=/7 =5/1/0<=/1=5/?:0@/;3=;<=5/5;=/7=5/1/<;1/5/:;37- 9;=6//D50==1096821/-2962-/=5/5;=/7 * 9 ;=5/1 D;1-6 =5/ ;107 =/6=2@;9? ;< =5/ :;@8702909= D06 9;= :;11;4;10=/- D2=5 =5/ =/6=2@;9? ;< =5/650-;DD2=9/66"* * = 26 8/1=29/9= =; 9;=/ =50= -/682=/ =5/ 1/07 0:=2E2=? =5/ =108 @050J01 :;9=029 0 -2<</1/9= :;9=/9=6 5/1/<;1/ 2= :09 4/ 60</7? 81/63@/- =50= =5/ =108 @050J01 50-4//9 81/801/- @3:5/0172/1=108 2=6/7< =509 D50=0:=3077?=1096821/-2965;>;=/7 19 ** 31=5/1 29 =5/ 046/9:/ ;< 09? -/@09- 09- 0::/8=09:/;<=5/=029=/-:311/9:?@/1/:;7;1=/6=4/29A 8066/-D;37-9;=4/63<<2:2/9=/9;3A531=5/1=5/E/1? <0:= =50= =5/ :;@8702909= 0881;0:5/- =5/ 0::36/- 29 526 ;<<2:/ <;1 81/8010=2;9 ;< =5/ 808/1 2=6/7< 26 -;34=<37 06 =5/ *9- :=;4/1 *( 26 0 /9/107 ;72-0? ;90::;39=;<F09-52$0?09=52G *+ 5/1/<;1/ =5/ E/1? <0:= =50= :;@8702909= E262=/- =5/ 0::36/- 09- /9C32129A 04;3= =5/ 8/9-29A 4277 2=6/7<26-;34=<37 *( 0>29A9;=/;<=5/6/068/:=6;<=5/@0==/1;9 :3@370=2E/ 09- :01/<37 :;962-/10=2;9 ;< =5/ @0=/1207 ;9 1/:;1- =5/ 7/019/- 1207 $3-A/ 506 <;39- =50= @0=/1207 /E2-/9:/ 870:/- 501-7? 63<<2:2/9= =; 1/:;1- 09 ;1-/1 ;< :;9E2:=2;9 * 31=5/1 2= 26 6/==7/- 8129:287/6 ;< 70D 09- 1/C321/6 9; /@850626 =50= D5/9 =5/1/ 26 09 ;1-/1 ;< 20 0:C32==07 8066/- 4? =5/ -37? :;96=2=3=/- ;31= 0<=/1 -3/ =1207=5/299;:/9:/;<=5/0::36/-A/=61/29<;1:/- *H /=09;=5/1:/7/410=/-:12@2907B3126813-/9:/26 =50=2<=D;E2/D601/8/1@266247/;960@/6/=;<<0:=6=5/ E2/D=50=26<0E;31047/=;=5/0::36/-@36=4/81/</11/- * "2=51/A01-=;=5/-/A1//;<81;;<2=266/==7/- 8129:287/6 ;< 70D =50= 81;6/:3=2;9 506 =; =10E/7 0 7;9A -26=09:/4/=D//9=5/@/1/63682:2;909-0:=30781;;< * 887?29A =5/6/ 8129:287/6 =; =5/ :06/ ;9 509- =526 ;31= 26 ;< =5/ :;962-/1/- ;8292;9 =50= =5/ ;1-/1 8066/-4?=5/7/019/-1207$3-A/1/C321/69;29=/1</1/9:/ /E/9 0<=/1 1/0881/:20=2;9 ;< =5/ @0=/1207 /E2-/9:/ ;9 1/:;1- *' 887?29A =5/ 04;E/ :/7/410=/- 7/A07 8129:287/6 ;<<0:=6;<=5/:06/=5/;1-/1;<0:C32==071/:;1-/-4?=5/ 1207 $3-A/ 9//-6 9; 29=/1</1/9:/ /E/9 0<=/1 1/ 0881/:20=2;9;<=5/@0=/1207/E2-/9:/;91/:;1- 21 + ::;1-29A7?8;29=;609-*01/096D/1/-29 =5/9/A0=2E/ -./(012.3124 + 9 E2/D ;< <29-29A ;< =526 ;31= 1/A01- 8;29= ;09-*29=5/9/A0=2E/0604;E/=5268;29=D;37-9;= 0126/<;1:;962-/10=2;9 -./(012.3124* +* /:;1-29A;<=5/<29-29A6;98;29=;6=;+06 04;E/=5/<;77;D29A& 2 5/088/0726@/12=7/6609-2=265/1/4? -26@266/- 22 0274;9-2<09?6=09-6-26:501A/- 0& '$) 26=;&7;&( &