- 1 - ! "# ! $ #%!! $ #%!"%& " '!( ! " # # $ % % Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &$ # ! " # ' %%$ %%( ' ) *%% + # %%%%% , & ) ' # - ) ' .+ ' /- /- -# - 3 - /- 01234156751518912:1;7<=0>;;79?19?50784<74<>57< *%%6>227<@A507 >49>5>B>5>57<C191254>51D7 41@E9>; >5 >;>@E4>?1 :84 20845 .507 41@E9>;+ 19 66;1=>5189 8%%%%% 30747@A 507 >66;1=>5189 :1;7< @A 507 6751518974&>66;1=>95 0>2 @779 <12C1227< >9< 507 79<8427C795<>57<%%*122E7<@A507472689<795& >E508415A 47F7=519? 507 47GE725 8: 507 6751518974 :84 47?E;>41H>51890>2@779=89:14C7< % 845072>B78:=89D79179=75076>45172>4747:7447< 58 >2 674 50714 4>9B19? @7:847 507 41@E9>; 19 '8%%%%% 417: :>=52 8: 507 =>27 >47 50>5 6751518974&>66;1=>95 3>2 >6681957< >2 > E;; 1C7 377674 19 507 8;1=7 76>45C795@A472689<795889!**%195076>A 2=>;7 8: 2(!&I 3150 >;; ><C1221@;7 >;;83>9=72 ;1B7 75= 12 6>A >9< >;;83>9=72 3747 790>9=7< >2 >9< - 4 - 3079 507 5>57 47D127< 507 6>A 2=>;7 8: 152 7C6;8A772 19=7507274D1=78:507>66;1=>953>298547?E;>41H7<19> 6792189>@;7 6825 07 0>< 2E@C1557< > 476472795>5189 89 %$%( 07 472689<795 >E508415A 0>2 122E7< >9 79<8427C79589%*%I47F7=519?50747GE7258:507 6751518974719?>??417D7<@A5072>C7507>66;1=>950>2 >6648>=07<50741@E9>;1966;1=>51898($*%(07 41@E9>; @A 84<74 <>57< %$%* 0>2 >;;837< 507 >66;1=>5189J 79<8427C795 <>57< %*%I 122E7< @A 472689<795 8 0>2 @779 GE>207< >9< 507 472689<7952 3747<147=57<5847?E;>41H7507>66;1=>9519>6792189>@;7 682531507::7=5:48C507<>5789301=0073>2>6681957< 17 89 !**% 07 2>1< 84<74 <>57< %*%I >55>197< :19>;15A 19=7 507 472689<795&>E508415A 0>2 985 122E7< >9A 84<74 8: 47?E;>41H>5189 507 >66;1=>95 :1;7< > 8957C65 8: 41@E9>; 66;1=>5189 19 8I%%%% @7:84750741@E9>;E419?507679<79=A8:507=8957C65 648=77<19?2 507 472689<795&>E508415A 0>2 6>227< >9 84<74<>57<%%*79=7507=8957C65>66;1=>5189 - 5 - 3>2<126827<8:3150;1@745A58507>66;1=>9558=0>;;79?7 507 84<74 <>57< %%* 19 >==84<>9=7 3150 ;>3 0747>:574 507 6751518974 :1;7< >9 >66;1=>5189 @7:847 507 41@E9>; 19 66;1=>5189 8%%%%% =0>;;79?19? 507 84<74<>57<%%*0741@E9>;@A1C6E?97<84<74 <>57< *%% 0>2 <12C1227< 507 >66;1=>5189 719? >??417D7<@A5072>C7507>66;1=>9512@7:84750128E45 I 7>497< =8E927; >667>419? :84 507 6751518974& >66;1=>950>2=8957957<50>519507:142548E9<8:;151?>5189 @7:847 507 41@E9>; 19 66;1=>5189 8($*%( 507 41@E9>; 0>< 267=1:1=>;;A <147=57< 507 472689<7952 58 47?E;>41H7 507 >66;1=>95 19 > 6792189>@;7 6825 3150 7::7=5 :48C507<>5789301=0073>2>6681957<17!**% E42E>95 58 50>5 @A 84<74 <>57< %%* 6>227< @A 472689<795&>E508415A 507 >66;1=>95+2 274D1=7 0>2 @779 47?E;>41H7< 19 > 6792189>@;7 6825 3150 7::7=5 :48C *%% 07 2>1<84<74 <>57<%%* 12 =8954>4A 58 507 <147=51892 122E7< @A 507 41@E9>; 7 :E45074 =8957957< 50>5 19 47267=5 8: 21C1;>4;A 215E>57< 6742892 - 6 - 9>C7;A->A>3>95>9<0>4>9>>2>66>507472689<795& >E508415A0>247?E;>41H7<50714274D1=7196792189>@;76825 :48C 507 <>57 507A 3747 >6681957< 9;A 19 =>27 8: >66;1=>95507A0>D7<7917<21C1;>447;17:58507>66;1=>95 072>C7>C8E95258<12=41C19>5189>9<1219D18;>51898: 451=;7 I 8: 892515E5189 8: 9<1> 79=7 07 28E?05 :84 >;;8319?507341567515189 7>497< >667>419? :84 507 5>57 0>2 =8957957< 50>5507>66;1=>953>2>6681957<>2E;;1C737767419 8;1=776>45C79589!**%:574=8C6;751898: A7>42 012 274D1=7 0>2 @779 47?E;>41H7< 3150 7::7=5 :48C *%% 0747:847 012 274D1=7 0>2 58 @7 =8E957< :84 6792189 :48C *%% 07 41@E9>; >:574 =8921<7419? 507 47>2892 C7951897< 19 50>5 84<74 <>57< %%* 6>227< @A 507 472689<795&>E508415A 0>2 41?05;A 47F7=57< 507>66;1=>518979=70728E?05:84<12C122>;8:5073415 67515189 $ 7>4< 507 7>497< =8E927; :84 507 6>45172 74E27< 50734156>6742 - 7 - ( 51298519<126E5750>5507>66;1=>953>2>6681957< >2 > E;; 1C7 377674 19 8;1=7 76>45C795 @A 84<74 <>57<!**%195076>A2=>;78:2(!&I3150>;; ><C1221@;7 >;;83>9=72 ;1B7 >9< 75= 12 6>A >9< >;;83>9=72 3747 790>9=7< :48C 51C7 58 51C7 3079 507 5>5747D127<5076>A2=>;78:1527C6;8A77D79>:574507 >66;1=>95 =8C6;757< A7>42 8: 274D1=7 012 274D1=7 0>2 985 @779 47?E;>41H7< 0747:847 07 0>2 2E@C1557< > 476472795>5189 89 %$%( 07 472689<795&>E508415A 89 =8921<7419? 507 476472795>5189 0>2 122E7< >9 79<8427C795 <>57< %*%I 47F7=519? 507 47GE725 8: 5076751518974719?>??417D7<@A5072>C7>66;1=>950>2 >6648>=07< 507 41@E9>; @A :1;19? 66;1=>5189 8($*%(>9<50741@E9>;@A84<74<>57<%$%* 0>2 >;;837< 507 >66;1=>5189 07 8674>51D7 6845189 8: 507 84<74 <>57< %$%* 6>227< 19 66;1=>5189 8($*%(47><2>2E9<74 - 8 - ! " # $ "" " % & " " "" " " ' ! 07 84<74 <>57< %$%* 6>227< @A 507 41@E9>; 0>2 >55>197< :19>;15A 07 5>57 0>2 985 =0>;;79?7< 507 2>C7 D79 508E?0 507 41@E9>; 0>2 ?1D79 > 267=1:1= <147=518958507472689<79525847?E;>41H7507>66;1=>9519 6792189>@;7 6825 3150 7::7=5 :48C <>57 89 301=0 07 3>2 >6681957<17!**%=8954>4A585072>1<84<74507 472689<795&>E508415A 0>2 122E7< 79<8427C795 <>57< %%* >9< 274D1=7 8: 507 >66;1=>95 0>2 @779 47?E;>41H7< 19 > 6792189>@;7 6825 3150 7::7=5 :48C *%% 0784<74 <>57<%%*47?E;>41H19? 507 =>27 8: 507 >66;1=>95 :48C *%% 12 =8954>4A 58 507 - 9 - <147=51892 8: 507 41@E9>; E45074 19 =>27 8: 21C1;>4;A 215E>57< 6742892 9>C7;A ->A>3>950 >9< 0>4>9> >2>66> 507 472689<795&>E508415A 0>2 47?E;>41H7< 50714 274D1=72 19 > 6792189>@;7 6825 :48C 507 <>57 507A 3747 >6681957< 8921<7419? 507 2>C7 507 41@E9>; @A 84<74 <>57< %$%* 0>< <147=57< 507 472689<7952 58 47?E;>41H7 507 =>27 8: 507 >66;1=>95&6751518974 19 > 6792189>@;7 6825 3150 7::7=5 :48C <>57 89 301=0 07 0>2 @779>6681957<'1508E5=8921<7419?5077>4;174<147=51892 122E7< @A 507 41@E9>; 89 %$%* 19 66;1=>5189 ($*%( 507 41@E9>; @A 1C6E?97< 84<74 <>57< *%%31508E5?1D19?>9A47>28920>247F7=57<507 >66;1=>5189 * 950>5D1738:507C>5574507341567515189<7274D72 58@7>;;837<==84<19?;A507:8;;8319?84<74126>227< > '4156751518912>;;837< - 10 - @ 07 84<74 <>57< *%% 6>227< @A 507 41@E9>;1966;1=>51898%%%%%12275>21<7 = 07472689<795&>E508415A12<147=57<58=8921<74 507=>278:507>66;1=>95&675151897419574C28:84<74 <>57< %$%* 6>227< @A 507 41@E9>; 19 66;1=>51898($*%(19>==84<>9=73150;>3>2 7K67<1518E2;A >2 68221@;7 985 ;>574 50>9 I C89502 :48C507<>578:47=71658:=86A8:501284<74 !)* '!( % !)* '"%& "( % 1258;8$I