- 1 - ! " #" $ "" " %& %'() &% (( )* " + %& %'() &% (( ) * ! "#$ % % ! "#$ & ' ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) ' ! ( % ! ## ! "#$ & ' ! )* )%( ) %)'( #% ) '( ) + %",$"%,% %#%,% ',,%,%(! !)))) #%#,#,$,-) + ) * ! #, ! % ! ! - 3 - + ! % ! # ! # + , ! $ , ! . %# ! + % ) ! & ' ( ) ) - 4 - "##,% % . ! "#$, & ' ! )* )%( ) %) ) /%.%,% ) )) .%#,#,$-) ))! !) %$%,% ) 0 ! '0 ! ( 1/231 415 654747/89 :;5 <7945= >/; :=?7997/8 @741 415 A/89584 /> <5:;85= A/2895< >/; 415 6:;4759 415B :;5 4:C5826>/;>78:<=796/9:< - 5 - % 15 654747/85;9 78 ;7?78:< 54747/8 /%,%-%,% D5783 :AA295= /9 :8= % :;5 955C783 4/E2:91415A;7?78:<6;/A55=78378747:45=:3:7894415?78 ;7?5 /%#%,% /> 5F:;: 766:;:37 6/<7A5 94:47/8 7G:B:62; =794;7A4 658=783 78 /,,%,% /8 415 >7<5/><5:;85=7F7<!2=35:8=!)78=:37;537945;5=>/; 415 />>58A59 628791:D<5 28=5; 5A47/89 #% #, #,$,-;5:=@7415A47/8/>8=7:858:</=5$, '>/;91/;4HI( 15 654747/85;9 78 ;7?78:< 54747/8 /%,,.%,%D5783:AA295=/94/:;5955C7834/ E2:91 415 A;7?78:< 6;/A55=7839 78747:45= :3:7894 415? 78 ;7?5 /%.%,% /> 5F:;: 766:;:37 6/<7A5 94:47/8 7G:B:62;=794;7A4658=78378/%$%,%/8415>7<5 /><5:;85=7F7<!2=35:8=!)78=:37;537945;5=>/;415 />>58A59 628791:D<5 28=5; 5A47/89 . % #,#,$;5:=@7415A47/8-/> 5:;= ;7 7;:8C2?:; :<<2; :8= ;7 1:74:8B:C2?:; 1:8=;7C7 <5:;85= A/2895< >/; 415 - 6 - 654747/85;9 ;7 !:?:=:; 1:1:D2==78 <5:;85= 731 /2;4 /F5;8?584 <5:=5; >/; ;596/8=584 / J 4:45 ;7 1:74:8B:C2?:; 1:8=;7C7 <5:;85= A/2895< >/; ;596/8=584 /% 78 ;</%,%-%,% :8= ;7 7;:8C2?:; :<<2; <5:;85= A/2895< >/; ;596/8=584 /% 78 ;</%,,.%,% 5;295=415 ?:45;7:<9/8 ;5A/;= # 8 F75@ /> 415 ;7F:< A/845847/89 2;35= DB 415 <5:;85=A/2895<>/;D/414156:;47594156/78441:4@/2<= :;795>/;?BA/897=5;:47/879 !"#$% B:89@5;4/415:D/F56/7847978415 >/; 415>/<</@783 - 7 - $ A:95:8=A/2845;A:95A:?54/D5;537945;5= D54@558 D/41 41595 654747/85;9 78 ;5965A4 /> 415 78A7=584 @17A1 79 9:7= 4/ 1:F5 /AA2;;5= /8 ,.,%%,% :4 # 1/2;98;7?5/%#%,%41578>/;?:8451:?:89:D </=35=415>7;9478>/;?:47/8/8%,%%,%:4.,,1/2;9 @17<5 ;7?5 /%.%,% A:?5 4/ D5 ;537945;5= /8 415 D:979 /> 415 >7;94 78>/;?:47/8 </=35= DB 415 78>/;?:84 1:?:=: 532?/8,%%,%:4-,,1/2;9 . 15 78>/;?:84 78 ;7?5 /%#%,% A/8458=5= 41:4 @158 15 @:9 6;/A55=783 4/@:;=9 179 91/6 :AA295= /9:8=%:D295=17?78>7<41B<:832:354;75=4/:99:2<4 17?@741:94/85:8=A;7?78:<<B 7847?7=:45=17?4/A:295 179 =5:41 1/@5F5; 15 59A:65= 15;5DB 415B 1:F5 A/??7445=415:<<535=/>>58A59 8;7?5/%.%,%415:<<53:47/87941:4/8 4159:?5=:45:8=47?5@15841578>/;?:84:</83@74115; =:23145;@:96;/A55=78378>;/84/>41591/6D5</837834/ - 8 - :AA295=/%@1/7941578>/;?:8478/415;A:95:AA295= /9 4/ >/;?5= 415?95<F59 784/ 28<:@>2< :995?D<B 7<<53:<<B6;5F5845=15;>;/?6;/A55=783>2;415;:8=:D295= 415? 78 >7<41B <:832:35 AA295= / 9<:665= 415 78>/;?:84 :AA295= /# A:2314 1/<= /> 15; 1:8=9 :8= /415;:AA295=:D295=415?78>7<41B<:832:3515B1:F5 :<9/ A;7?78:<<B 7847?7=:45= 4/ A:295 4157; =5:41 :8= 415;5DBA/??7445=415/>>58A59:<<535= - 4 415 47?5 /> :==;599783 415 :;32?5849 <5:;85= A/2895< >/; 415 654747/85;9 78 ;7?78:< 54747/8 /%,%-%,%92D?7445=41:4654747/85;/D5783415 @7=/@ >7<5= 415 9274 78 %%, 658=783 /8 415 >7<5 /> 415 <5:;85= 7F7< !2=35 :8= !) 78=:37 955C783 6:;4747/8 :8= 956:;:45 6/995997/8 :8= 415;5>/;5 :AA295= @5;51:F7837<<"@7<<:8=?/47F5:3:789415;9:;592<4/> 4159:?541578A7=58478E25947/81:=/AA2;;5= /41415 A:95:8=A/2845;A:957978;5965A4/>41578A7=58441:41:= /AA2;;5= :4 415 9:?5 47?5 :8= 9:?5 6<:A5 DB ?:C783 :<<53:47/89 :3:7894 /85 :8/415; 8=5; 92A1 - 9 - A7;A2?94:8A59 =/ 8/4 >78= :8B ;5:9/8 4/ E2:91 415 A;7?78:< 6;/A55=7839 78 :8B /> 41595 A:959 4 79 >/; 415 ;7:</2;44/A/897=5;415F5;:A74B/>415:<<53:47/89:8= 4/>/;?:8/6787/8AA/;=783<B:89@5;415:D/F56/784 78415:8=6;/A55=4/6:99415>/<</@783 15A;7?78:<654747/89:;5 8 F75@ /> =796/9:< /> ?:78 654747/89 658=783 :66<7A:47/8 =/59 8/4 92;F7F5 >/; A/897=5;:47/8 :8= 415 9:?579=79?7995= ,) %""( $ 794/</%