Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63349 (KAR)

NINGAPPA AND ANR v. SHAILA AND ANR

MFA/200548/2025 · 2025-11-14

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $ % & && '#( ) !"#$ % & ' ( !"# Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "$$ % & ! ) $$ ' *&' ! $("$"$( ! " ! * $ ! $ + !, - ! % ./0122314/025363553789:.3;41/<1=:01>1/=0::.3 ?@7><3=: 1=7 1A157 71:37 $($$( 210037 89 :.3 5/=;/214 3=/B5 /C/4 !@7>3 1=7 B:B5 ;;/73=: 41/<0 5/8@=14" /?1912@51 D6B5 0.B5: +5/8@=14,E /= B* $033F/=>3=.1=;3<3=:B6;B<23=01:/B= =3533:1<<3:A/:.1=1;;/73=:B=$G$ 1=7 7/37 /0 2153=:0 6/437 ;41/< 23:/:/B= ;41/</=> - 3 - ;B<23=01:/B=B60$$$$$ ".35/8@=14;B=0/73537 :.33=:/53<1:35/140B=53;B571=7>51=:370#$$$$ " A/:./=:3530:1::.351:3B6#H2351==@<65B<:.371:3B6 23:/:/B= :/44 5314/01:/B= >>5/3C37 89 :.3 01/7 B5735 ;41/<1=:06/437:./0122314 3157 15>@<3=:0 B6 8B:. :.3 215:/30 1=7 235@037:.3<1:35/1401C1/41843B=53;B57 ( : /0 ;B=:3=737 89 :.3 4315=37 ;B@=034 6B5 :.3 1223441=:0 :.1: :.3 73;31037 A10 1 85/44/1=: 0:@73=: 1=7 .342/=> :.3 2153=:0 /= :.3/5 719":B"719 1;:/C/:/30 : /0 ;B=:3=737:.1::.3;B<23=01:/B=1A15737895/8@=141: 0$$$$ " :BA1570 4B00 B6 7323=73=;9 1=7 0$$$$ " @=735 ;B=C3=:/B=14 .3170 =337 :B 83 3=.1=;37 A/:. /=:3530: 1: GH 235 1==@< /=0:317 B6 #H 2351==@< : /0 0@8</::37 89 :.3 4315=37 ;B@=034 6B5 5302B=73=: B I =0@51=;3 B<21=9 :.1: :.3 - 4 - ;B<23=01:/B=1A1573789:.35/8@=14/0?@0:1=725B235 1=7/:=3370=B/=:356353=;3 # 315=37;B@=0346B5:.31223441=:0/=0@22B5:B6 ./0;103.10534/37@2B=73;/0/B=B6 @253<3B@5:/=:.3 ;103B6 /=A./;./:A10.347:.1: A.3= 1 </=B5 ;./47 0@663537 1 235<1=3=: 7/018/4/:9 ;B<23=01:/B= 6B5 :.3 4B00 B6 /=;B<3 0.B@47 83 81037 B= @0/=>:.3</=/<@<A1>36B510F/4437AB5F35/=:.1: :1:3 1: :.3 5343C1=: 2B/=: B6 :/<3 B5 3109 536353=;3 151 BB6:.301/773;/0/B=/03J:51;:3710.353@=735 ! ! " # /C31A& '* - 5 - $ % & * 315=37 ;B@=034 6B5 5302B=73=: B I =0@51=;3 B<21=9 534/37@2B= ?@7><3=: B6 B"57/=1:3 3=;. B6 :./0 B@5: /= :.3 ;103 B6 1=7 0@8</::37 :.1: :./0 B@5: 6B44BA/=> :.3 01/7 73;/0/B= B6 73;/0/B= B6 @253<3 B@5: /= :.3 ;103 B6 ! "# $% %&#" '% ! ## ("# )"("#%" %'%#!* .10 :1F3= :.3 <B=:.49 /=;B<3 B6 73;31037 1>37 93150 1: 0$$$ " 1=7 1224/37 :.3 <@4:/24/35810/=>B=:.31>3B6:.3<B:.35B6:.373;31037 1=7>51=:37:.3;B<23=01:/B==:.301/7;103:.3;B" B57/=1:3 3=;. B6 :./0 B@5: 140B B8035C37 :.3 73;/0/B= B=,843 @253<3B@5:/=:.3;103B6+% "( ! "# ! #, A.353/= :.3 B=,843 2 B$$$ $73;/737B=$G$ 3 /C/422314BGG $(73;/737B=$$$ 4 &$(' (( - 6 - @253<3 B@5: .10 :1F3= :.3 =B:/B=14 /=;B<3 B6 :.3 73;31037;./471:0$$$$ "1=7;B=0/735/=>:.31>3B6 :.39B@=>352153=:0B6:.373;31037=1<349<B:.35A.B A1018B@:#93150B47.101224/37:.3<@4:/24/35B6+, .@0 :.3 4315=37 ;B@=034 6B5 =0@51=;3 B<21=9 /= :.3 /=0:1=: ;103 15>@30 6B5 :1F/=> </=/<@< A1>30 B6 0$$$ "235<B=:.6B5:.3</=B5;./471=7:B12249:.3 <@4:/24/35 89 ;B=0/735/=> :.3 1>3 B6 <B:.35 B6 :.3 73;31037 = :.3 /=0:1=;3 ;103 10 235 J# " B0: B5:3<32B5::.373;31037A109315010B=:.371:3 B61;;/73=:.35/8@=14.10:1F3==B:/B=14/=;B<3B6:.3 73;31037 1: 0$$$$ " 235 1==@< 1=7 >51=:37 ;B<23=01:/B=B60$$$$ "6B54B00B67323=73=;91=7 0$$$$ "6B5B:.35;B=C3=:/B=14.3170 G = :.3 9315 $ </=/<@< A1>30 6B5 0F/4437 AB5F35/= 15=1:1F1/01225BJ/<1:34951=>3765B<(G( :B G 235 719 7323=7/=> @2B= :.3 KB=3 .3 73;31037 A10 1 0:@73=: :.3536B53 :./0 B@5: 6/=70 /: - 7 - 5310B=1843:B:1F3:.3A1>3B6:.373;31037100$$$ " 235<B=:..31>3B6:.3<B:.35B6:.373;31037A10 931501=7:.31225B25/1:3<@4:/24/351224/;1843:B.351>3 /0+*,10235:.341A41/77BA=89:.323JB@5:/=:.3 ;103 B6 -$ .@0 :.3 4B00 B6 7323=73=;9 ;B<30:B0$$$ "JJL'()* +',,,-% $ .3 ;41/<1=:0 83/=> :.3 2153=:0 B6 :.3 73;310371533=:/:4376B50($$$$ "31;.:BA15704B00B6 6/4/14;B=0B5:/@<.39153140B3=:/:4376B51=1<B@=:B6 0$$$$ "@=735:.3;B=C3=:/B=14.3170 = 144 :.3 ;41/<1=:0 153 3=:/:437 6B5 ;B<23=01:/B=B6)* '.',,,-%/=0:317B60#$$$$ " 1A1573789:.35/8@=14 B5:.316B5301/75310B=0:.36B44BA/=> &/' .3122314/0 ".! *Corrected vide court order dated 09.12.2025. - 8 - &//' .3 1223441=:0 153 3=:/:437 6B5 :B:14 ;B<23=01:/B= B6 )* '.',,,-% A/:. /=:3530: 1:#H2351==@<65B<:.371:3B623:/:/B=:/44 5314/K1:/B= &///' 302B=73=: B I =0@51=;3 B<21=9 /0 7/53;:37 :B 732B0/: :.3 ;B<23=01:/B= 1<B@=: A/:./= 6B@5 A33F0 65B< :.371:3B6:./0?@7><3=: &/C' = 0@;. 732B0/: ;41/<1=:0 153 235</::37:BA/:.751A:.33=:/53;B<23=01:/B= 1<B@=:14B=>A/:./=:3530:3M@1449 *+, '& ( % /0:B 4B ! *Corrected vide court order dated 09.12.2025.