- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %&' () "" ( ) !"#$%$&'#' ( )&#%* Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #! # ( %!%*$%$ #+%*$%$ #* '$%$* " ( ( , ( ) !"#$%$&'#' ( )&#%* , - 3 - #! # ( %!%*$%$ - ( #* '$%$* ( , ( . ( . ( $ . ( /0$% ''#$%$ 12 31456 78 9:5 ;/;<1/< 1=5>90=03 ;/6/0$% ##$%$1231456789:5 >4;1?;/9 ;2 ;<;1/29 9:5 @A6<?5/9 ;/6 ;B;=6 6;956 %!%*$%$ 1/ 0#* '$%$* C;2256 78 090= >>165/9 4;1?=17A/;4 ;/66645/10= 1D14 (A6<5 ;4;7A=;<1:5=51/;395==535==5690;2E=17A/;4F - 4 - $ :5 ?;1/ >0/95/910/ A=<56 1/ 9:5 ;CC5;4 31456 78 9:5 ;/;<1/< 1=5>90=";CC544;/9 1/ /0$% ''#$%$ 12 9:;9 9:5 ;>>165/9 0>>A==56 0/ %+%$%$* B:5/ 9:5 >4;1?;/9 B;2 =59A=/1/< 90 :12 B0=GC4;>5;/6B;229;/61/<7521659:5=0;6;99:52C0903 1/>165/999:;991?59:56=1D5=039:5 7A275;=1/< 5</0 " &"###>;?53=0?A?/;7;62165;9;:1<: 2C5561/;=;2:;/6/5<41<5/9?;//5=;/66;2:56;<;1/29 9:5>4;1?;/9B19:0A9740B1/<:0=/0=9;G1/<C=5>;A910/;=8 ?5;2A=52 ;/6 9:5 7A2 :19 :1? ;/6 ;2 ; =52A49 :5 2A29;1/56<=15D0A21/@A=152 :5?;1/>0/95/910/039:5;CC544;/9129:;99:5 9=17A/;4>0??19956;/5==0=1/9;G1/<612;714198;9*H;/6 0A<:9 90 :;D5 9;G5/ # =6 612;714198 ;2 ;2252256 78 9:5 60>90=5/>59:52;?5=5IA1=52?06131>;910/ * / /0$% ##$%$ 9:5 >4;1?;/9 D5:5?5/948>0/95/69:;99:5=17A/;4>0??19956;/5==0= 1/ >0/2165=1/< 9:5 /;9A=5 03 1/@A=152 /;?548 6133A25 J0/;4 1/@A=8 ;>A95 5?0==:;<1> >0/9;<10/ 1/D04D1/< - 5 - ;/<410/ >;C2A4;= ;/6 4539 :1<: C;=159;4 4075 =5<10/ 3=;>9A=5031/95=10=B;44;/6C0295=04;95=;4B;44039:54539 ;J144;=8 21/A2 ;/6 9:5 ;2252256 +&H /5A=040<1>;4 612;714198:5=17A/;4652C1952A>:5D165/>55==0/50A248 900G 9:5 612;714198 ;9 0/48 *H 90 9:5 B:045 7068 :5 ;CC=0;>:039:5=17A/;4125==0/50A2B:5/9:5>4;1?;/9 12 ;6?1995648 2A335=1/< 3=0? +&H 612;714198 :5 =17A/;4 ;420 3;1456 90 9;G5 /095 03 9:5 60>90=F2 5D165/>5 9:;9 9:5 >4;1?;/9 =5IA1=52 >0/29;/9 /A=21/< >;=5 9:=0A<:0A9 :12 4135 :5 =17A/;4 0A<:9 90 :;D5 >0/2165=56 #%%H 3A/>910/;4 612;714198 ;/6 >0??19956 ;/ 5==0= 1/ /09 ;B;=61/< @A29 >0?C5/2;910/ 5/>5 19 =5IA1=52 1/95=35=5/>5 03 9:12 0A=9 09: 9:525 ;CC5;42 ;=5 1/ =52C5>9 03 IA;/9A? 03 >0?C5/2;910/ 5/>5 9:58 ;=5 >0/2165=5690<59:5= ;D1/<:5;=69:545;=/56>0A/2540/709:21652 ;/6 :;D1/< >0/2165=56 9:5 <=0A/62 A=<56 1/ 2ACC0=9 03 709: 9:5 ;CC5;42 9:5 30440B1/< C01/92 ;=125 30= >0/2165=;910/039:12 0A=9 - 6 - # :59:5= 9:5 =17A/;4 >0??19956 ;/ 5==0= 1/ ;B;=61/<5J0=719;/9>0?C5/2;910/;2>0/95/656 78 9:5 ;CC544;/9";/;<1/< 1=5>90= 03 ;/6B:59:5=2A>:;B;=6>;44230=1/95=35=5/>578 9:12 0A=9K $ :59:5= 9:5 =17A/;4 >0??19956 ;/ 5==0= 1/ >0/2165=1/<9:5612;714198;9*H;2;<;1/299:5 ?561>;4 5D165/>5 ;/6 0A<:9 90 :;D5 >0/2165=56 9:5 2;?5 ;2 #%%H 3A/>910/;4 612;714198 ;2 >0/95/656 78 9:5 >4;1?;/9K :59:5= 19 =5IA1=52 1/95=35=5/>5039:12 0A=9K :;90=65=K "*+,+-.+/ ' ;D1/< :5;=6 9:5 =52C5>91D5 >0A/254 ;/6 0/ C5=A2;4 03 9:5 ?;95=1;4 0/ =5>0=6 0>>A==5/>5 03 ;>>165/9 ;/69:5=52A49;/91/@A=1522A335=56789:5>4;1?;/9;=5/09 1/612CA95:5612CA95120/48B19:=5<;=6909:5;B;=603 @A29>0?C5/2;910/ ! :5 J'B0A/6 >5=9131>;95 122A56 78 9:5 60>90= >45;=48 612>40252 <=15D0A2 1/@A=152 15 6133A25 J0/;4 1/@A=8 ;>A95 5?0==:;<1> >0/9;<10/ 1/D04D1/< - 7 - ;/<410/ >;C2A4;= ;/6 4539 :1<: C;=159;4 4075 =5<10/ 3=;>9A=5031/95=10=B;44;/6C0295=04;95=;4B;44039:54539 ;J144;=8 21/A2 2 C5= 9:5 612>:;=<5 2A??;=152 J2& ;/6 + :5 B;2 ;6?19956 1/ /1956 02C19;4 ;4;7A=;<1 3=0? %+%$%$* 90 $#%'$%$* ;/6 0/>5 ;<;1/ 3=0? #*%+$%$*90#!%+$%$*1/909;430=*&6;82:560>90= 12;4205J;?1/567530=59:5 0A=9;/6612;714198>5=9131>;95 12 C=06A>56 ;2 J#% B:5=51/ 612;714198 03 +&H 03 /5A=040<1>;4 612;714198 12 ;2252256 ;/6 9:5 60>90= 12 ; /5A=02A=<50/;/6:5129:59=5;95660>90=;/6;4200/9:5 6;95 03 ;225221/< 9:5 612;714198 2A7@5>956 9:5 1/@A=56 90 >41/1>;4 ;/6 =;61040<1>;4 5J;?1/;910/ 21/>5 :5 :;6 2A29;1/56 25D5=5 1/@A=8 0>90=F2 5D165/>5 12 D5=8 >45;= 9:;9:5B;2A/;7459029;/6;/6A/;745902C5;G;/69:5 =17A/;4 ;420 9;G5/ /095 03 9:5 3;>9 9:;9 C591910/5= B;2 7=0A<:91/29=59>:5=060A791/9:5>=022"5J;?1/;910/ IA52910/2B5=5CA9909:560>90=65/81/<9:5612;71419803 +&H:52;?5B;265/156A99=17A/;4B:145;225221/< 9:5 612;714198 B:5/ 9:5 /5A=040<1>;4 612;714198 12 - 8 - >0/2165=56900G0/48*H;2;<;1/299:55D165/>5039:5 60>90= B19:0A9 ;221</1/< ;/8 =5;20/ 314? ;/6 =;61040<8 =5C0=9 =5D5;42 9:;9 :=0/1> 4;>A/;= 1/3;=>92 12 255/1/9:54539>5/9=A?25?10D;45;9>:8;=5;203<410212 /09561/D04D1/<=1<:9>;C2A40<;/<410/1>=5<10/5J95/61/<1/ 9:5 C5=1D5/9=1>A4;= B:195 ?;995= A49130>;4 612>=595 ;=5;2 03 $ ;/6 :8C5=1/95/219152 ;=5 /0956 1/D04D1/< 714;95=;4 3=0/9;4 C;=159;4 2A7>0=91>;4 ;/6 C5=1D5/9=1>A4;= B:195?;995=:5/9:5/5A=040<1>;4612;71419812;2252256 90 9:5 5J95/9 03 +&H ;/6 3A/>910/;4 612;714198 12 /091>56 9:5 =17A/;4 >0??19956 ;/ 5==0= >0/2165=1/< 0/48 *H 612;714198 B19:0A9 ;/8 2ACC0=91D5 ?;95=1;42 ;/6 9:5 60>90=F2 5D165/>5 12 D5=8 >45;= B19: =5<;=6 90 /;9A=5 03 1/@A=152 ;/6 9:;9 :5 B;2 1/ ; D5<59;91D5 29;95 5 B;2 A/;745 90 29;/6 ;/6 A/;745 90 2C5;G ;/6 0A<:9 90 :;D5 >0/2165=56 9:5 #%%H 3A/>910/;4 612;714198 ;/6 314? =5C0=9;4202ACC0=929:52;?5:5/2A>:751/<9:5>;25 9:5=17A/;4>0??19956;/5==0=1/9;G1/<*H612;714198 - 9 - & ;D1/<9;G5//095039:53;>9A;4;2C5>92039:5 >;25 19 12 255/ 9:;9 9:0A<: 9:5 >4;1?;/9 >4;1?2 9:;9 :5 B;2 5;=/1/< $%%%" 9:12 ;>>165/9 900G C4;>5 1/ $%$* :5/0910/;41/>0?5;2C5=9:5 >:;=930=9:585;= $%$* 12 #!%" ;/6 9:5 2;?5 12 9;G5/ /095 03 78 9:5 =17A/;4512;<56;70A9$85;=2;/6:5/>50/48#%H >0A4675;6656;23A9A=5C=02C5>92;G1/<9:51/>0?5;9 #!%";661/<#%H3A9A=5C=02C5>92B19:?A491C41>;/6 03 ## ;/6 #%%H 612;714198 >0?52 90 $$&'+%%" A/65= 9:5:5;6033A9A=54022033A9A=51/>0?5 + 0B;=62 C;1/ ;/6 2A335=1/< =17A/;4 ;B;=656 0/48 ;/ ;?0A/9 03 *%%%%" ;/6 9:5 2;?5 12 D5=8 4522 :;D1/<>0/2165=569:5:5;61/@A=8;D1/<>0/2165=569:5 ;<5 9:5 2;?5 12 5/:;/>56 90 #%%%%%" ;2 ;<;1/29 *%%%%" 0B;=62 9:5 ;995/6;/9 >:;=<52 3006 ;/6 >0/D58;/>59:5=17A/;4;B;=656;/;?0A/903*&%%%" 21/>5 :5 B;2 1/ 9:5 :02C19;4 30= ; C5=106 03 *& 6;82 ;D1/< >0/2165=56 09:5= >0/D58;/>5 ;/6 =54;956 5JC5/252 9:5 2;?5 12 5/:;/>56 90 !%%%" ;2 ;<;1/29 - 10 - *&%%%" 0B;=62 ?561>;4 5JC5/252 =17A/;4 ;B;=656 0/48;/;?0A/903'%%%%%";2;<;1/299:560>A?5/92 1/>4A61/<9:571442:0A<:612>A22561/C;=;<=;C:/0$ J# ?561>;4 71442 ;40/< B19: 9:5 ?5?0 03 >;4>A4;910/ ;?0A/956 90 !*+&%%" 9:5 =17A/;4 >;?5 90 9:5 >0/>4A210/ 9:;9 9:5 71442 ;=5 >0?CA95=1L56 2ACC0=956 :;D1/< 25;4 ;/6 21</;9A=52 7A9 /09 2ACC0=956 B19: ?561>;4 652>=1C910/2 ;/6 9:025 71442 ;=5 122A56 78 9:5 :02C19;4 :5 =17A/;4 0A<:9 /09 90 :;D5 656A>956 9:5 2;?5 ;/6 >0??19956 ;/ 5==0= 1/ 0/48 >0/2165=1/< '%%%%%" 5/>5 !*+&%%" 12 ;B;=656 ;<;1/29 '%%%%%" #% :5 IA52910/ 03 ;225221/< 9:5 4022 03 1/>0?5 6A=1/<4;16ACC5=1066052/F9;=1251/D15B039;G1/<#%%H 612;714198 1/90 >0/2165=;910/ :5 =17A/;4 ;B;=656 3A9A=5 /A9=1910/ 3006 ;9 %%%%" ;/6 9:5 2;?5 ;420 >;//09 75 ;B;=656 21/>5 ;4=5;68 >0?C5/2;910/ 90B;=62 ;995/6;/9 >:;=<523006;/6>0/D58;/>512;4=5;68;B;=656 - 11 - ## 0B;=629:53A9A=5?561>;45JC5/252=17A/;4 ;B;=656;/;?0A/903#%%%%%";D1/<>0/2165=569:5 612;714198 ;/6 ;420 9:5 ;<5 19 12 ;CC=0C=1;95 90 ;B;=6 ;/ ;?0A/903$%%%%%";2;<;1/29#%%%%%" #$ :5402203;?5/1915212;B;=6560/48%%%%" ;/6 >0/2165=1/< 9:5 ;<5 03 >4;1?;/9 ;/6 9:5 612;714198 2;?5125/:;/>5690#%%%%%";2;<;1/29%%%%" # 512A/;7459029;/6;/62C5;G;/6:5/5562 ;/ ;995/6;/9 ;/6 9:5 2;?5 B;2 /09 >0/2165=56 78 9:5 9=17A/;4:55D165/>5039:560>90=12D5=8>45;=9:;9:512 2A335=1/< 3=0? ; /5A=040<1>;4 6120=65= :5/ 2A>: 751/< 9:5 >;25 9:5 @A6<?5/9 03 C5J 0A=9 1/ 9:5 >;25 03 =5C0=9561/ B:5=51/;420=5<;=61/<9:5 ;995/6;/9;/;?0A/903%%%"C5=?0/9:B;2;B;=656 15 '%%%%" C5= 85;= ;/6 ;CC481/< 9:5 =545D;/9 ?A491C415=19>;?590#%&%%%%"/9:5>;250/:;/619 >0?5290''%%%%"'%%%%J## - 12 - #* /;449:5>4;1?;/9125/91945690;/;?0A/903 >0?C5/2;910/03*#!#!%%" # :5 >0/95/910/ A=<56 78 9:5 ;CC544;/9" 90B;=62 612;714198 >;//09 75 ;>>5C956 ;/6 :5/>5 9:5 ;CC5;4 03 03 3;142 :5 >4;1?;/9F2 ;CC5;4 6525=D52 90 75 ;440B56 1/ C;=9 ;/6 :5/>5 709: 9:5 C01/92 ;=5 ;/2B5=56;>>0=61/<48 #' /D15B039:5612>A2210/2?;65;70D5B5C;22 9:530440B1/< 1 /0$% ''#$%$ 31456 78 9:5 12 612?12256 ;/6 /0$% ##$%$ 31456789:5>4;1?;/912;440B561/C;=978 ?061381/<9:5@A6<?5/9;/6;B;=66;956 %!%*$%$1/ 0#* '$%$*C;2256 78 090= >>165/9 4;1? =17A/;4 ;/66645/10= 1D14(A6<5 ;4;7A=;<1 78 5/:;/>1/< 9:5 >0?C5/2;910/ 90 *#!#!%%" ;2 ;<;1/29 #+#+%" - 13 - 11 :5 ;?0A/9 1/ 65C0219 2:;44 75 9=;/2?19956909=17A/;430=9:B19: 111 :5 7;4;/>5 ;?0A/9 2:;44 75 65C021956 ;40/<B19:1/95=529;99:5=;9503'HC5= ;//A? 3=0? 9:5 6;95 03 C591910/ 9144 =5;41L;910/ 78 9:5 7530=5 9:5 >0/>5=/56 9=17A/;4 B19:1/ ; C5=106 03 21J B55G23=0?9:56;9503=5>51C903>5=913156 >0C8039:120=65= 1D 5<129=8 12 61=5>956 90 25/6 7;>G =5>0=62 90>0/>5=/56=17A/;430=9:B19: /( %" ' $ /( %' $ ( 1290#40$%