Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63347 (KAR)

ASHOK v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.RP/200012/2019 · 2025-08-28

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "! #$!%!$$ $&! '(')*+ '!!** , ! " # $ $$ $ ! "# " $ % & $ !# % $ ' ((( $ ' Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %(($ ' " $ )%(( ' $ %( $ $$ ( % $ * * $ $ & + + , ' !+, ' # -. /.012134 5.616134./ 7.148 6-. 9::;2.< 14 3%(346-.=1>.3=6-.>.9/4.< <<161349> ' $ 9>97;9/81 !-./.149=6./ /.=.//.< 63 92 ?6-. /19> 3;/6@#121A5;841486-.B;<8A.463=:3401:613494<3/<./ 3=2.46.4:.<96.<)%((:3401:61486-.9::;2.<=3/ 6-.3==.4:.25;412-97>.;4<./.:61342(94<%3= 6-. 4<194 .49> 3<. ) !=3/ 2-3/6 ? @# 94< 2.46.4:148 -1A 63 ;4<./83 21A5>. 1A5/1234A.46 =3/ % A346-2 94< 63 59C 9 =14. 3= 2D 63 ;4<./83 21A5>. 1A5/1234A.46 =3/ C.9/ 94< 63 59C 9 =14. 3= - 3 - 2E16-<.=9;>62.46.4:.2E-1:-E92:34=1/A.<14 /1A149> 55.9> 3%(( 7C 6-. >.9/4.< <<> .221342';<8.9>97;9/81!-./.149=6.//.=.//.<6392?6-. $1/26 55.>>96. 3;/6@# 7C <12A122148 6-. 955.9> 01<. B;<8A.46<96.<((( ( -. =9:62 3= 6-. :92. 14 7/1.= 9/. 6-96 6-. 14=3/A946 >3<8.< 6-. =1/26 14=3/A96134 E16- /9==1: 3>1:. 696134 ;>79/89 9>>.8148 :3AA122134 3= 6-. 3==.4:.2 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:61342 ( 94< % 3= =6./ 140.261896134 6-. =149> /.53/6 :9A. 63 7. =1>.< 6 12 6-. :346.461343=6-.5/32.:;61346-9634()(96 5A E-.4 6-. <.:.92.< E92 5/3:..<148 34 -12 34<9 :610. A363/:C:>. 7.9/148 .8 3%() 6-. 9::;2.< :9A. =/3A 6-. 3553216. <1/.:6134 34 -12 9B9B -.69F :336./ 7.9/148 .8 3%(% 14 9 /92- 94< 4.8>18.46 A944./ 94< <92-.< 63 6-. A363/:C:>. /1<<.47C6-.<.:.92.<929/.2;>63=E-1:-<.:.92.<=.>> <3E494<2;26914.<=969>14B;/1.20.46-3;8-6-.14B;/.< E92 69F.4 63 6-. -325169> -. E92 <.:>9/.< 92 ?7/3;8-6 - 4 - <.9<@ 6 12 6-. :346.46134 3= 6-. 5/32.:;6134 6-96 6-. <.96-3=6-.<.:.92.<E92<;.636-./92-94<4.8>18.46 /1<1483=6-.2:336./7C6-.9::;2.< % 3 5/30. 162 :346.46134 6-. 5/32.:;6134 -92 .G9A14.<&26394<836A9/F.<G263% -. 9::;2.< -92 <.41.< 9>> 6-. 14:/1A1496148 A96./19>2 9091>97>. 34 /.:3/< 7;6 -92 436 :-32.4 63 >.9< 94C .01<.4:.142;553/63=-12<.=.4:. -. /19> 3;/6 9=6./ 69F148 1463 :3421<./96134 9>> 6-. A96./19>2 34 /.:3/< 5922.< 6-. 1A5;84.< B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 94< 3/<./ 3= 2.46.4:. <96.< )%(( :3401:6148 94< 2.46.4:148 6-. 9::;2.< 92 2696.<9730. .148988/1.0.<7C6-.29A.6-.9::;2.<-92 5/.=.//.</1A149>55.9>3%(( -.$1/2655.>>96. 3;/6 34 /.955/.:196134 3= 6-. A96./19>2 34 /.:3/< <12A122.< 6-. 955.9> 94< :34=1/A.< 6-. B;<8A.46 3= :3401:613494<3/<./3=2.46.4:.5922.<7C6-. /19>3;/6 - 5 - .148 988/1.0.< 7C 6-. 29A. 6-. 9::;2.< 12 7.=3/. 6-12 3;/6 ) .9/</1;<-../;>F9/41>.9/4.<:3;42.>=3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ 94< /1 359>F/12-49 9<90 >.9/4.< 18- 3;/6 30./4A.46 >.9<./ =3/ 6-. /.2534<.46696../;2.<6-.A96./19>234/.:3/< 4 01.E 3= 6-. /109> :346.461342 ;/8.< 7C 6-. >.9/4.<:3;42.>=3/736-6-.59/61.26-.531466-96E3;>< 9/12.=3/AC:3421<./9613412+ C 942E./ 63 6-. 9730. 53146 12 =3/6-.=3>>3E148+ !! 6 12 6-. :346.46134 3= 6-. 5/32.:;6134 6-96 E-1>. <.:.92.< E92 5/3:..<148 34 -12 34<9 :610. - 6 - A363/:C:>.6-.9::;2.</3<.-129B9B-.69F2:336./149 /92- 94< 4.8>18.46 A944./14-18- 25..< 94< <92-.< 63 6-. A363/:C:>. 3= 6-. <.:.92.< 92 9 /.2;>6 3= E-1:- -. 2;26914.< =969> 14B;/1.2 94< 2;::;A7.< 63 6-. 29A. 3 5/30.6-12:346.461346-.5/32.:;6134.G9A14.<&6-. :3A5>914946E-3126-..C.E164.22636-.14:1<.46&2 94< 9/. 9>23 6-. .C.E164.22.2 & E92 6-. 51>>134 /1<./>>6-.6-/..E164.22.2-90.<.532.</.89/<1486-. 9::1<.4694<6-./92-94<4.8>18.46/1<1483=6-.2:336./ 7C6-.9::;2.<G(126-.14H;.26A9-9I9/G%126-. 5326A3/6.A/.53/6G126-. " /.53/694<G12 6-. 2536 A9-9I9/ G2( 63 E./. A9/F.< 7.=3/. 6-. /19>3;/6E16-6-.:342.463=6-.>.9/4.<:3;42.>=3/6-. 9::;2.< -./.=3/. 16 12 :>.9/ 6-96 6-. 9::;2.< 12 436 <.4C1486-.=9:6;A3=9::1<.462;269141483==969>14B;/1.2 7C 6-. <.:.92.< 94< -12 <.96- <;. 63 6-. 14B;/1.2 2;26914.<146-.9::1<.464<./2;:-:1/:;A2694:.2 <3 436 =14< 94C /.9234 63 /.B.:6 6-. .01<.4:. 3= 6-. .C.E164.22.2&294< -.9::;2.<-924363==./.< - 7 - 94C.G5>9496134639:H;16-1A=3/6-.9730.291<3==.4:. 4<./ 2;:- :1/:;A2694:.2 6-. 9::;2.< 12 >197>. =3/ :3401:6134=3/6-.3==.4:.25;412-97>.;4<./.:61342( 94<%3= .9/4.< :3;42.> =3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ :346.4<.< 6-96 14 01.E 3= :3401:6134 3= 6-. /.012134 5.616134./=3/6-.3==.4:.5;412-97>.;4<./.:6134% 3= 6-. 3==.4:. 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:6134 ( 3= A./8.2E16-6-.A9143==.4:.94<6-./.=3/.-.:3;><436 -90. 7..4 :3401:6.< =3/ 736- 6-. 3==.4:.2 =14< :3421<./97>.=3/:.146-.:346.4613469F.47C6-.>.9/4.< :3;42.>=3/6-./.0121345.616134./ -. 34@7>. 5.G 3;/6 14 1459/9 3294<-92-.><92;4<./+ !"# $ % & '() *+ 1 (2012) 8 SCC 734 - 8 - # , % # - $ # & '()*+ # !.# * # # * # # * / 0 #/ 0 1!)).2 '&.!34-5 & 3." + & 3.3 - 9 - # & 3)61!2 $ $ % $ # * $ % # #7 -;26-.34@7>.5.G3;/6-92A9<.16:>.9/ 6-96.0.46-3;8-6-.9::;2.<-927..4:3401:6.<=3/6-. 3==.4:.25;412-97>.;4<./.:61342(94<%3= 214:.6-.3==.4:.;4<./.:6134%3= 126-.A9B3/ 3==.4:.6-.>.22./3==.4:.14.:6134(3= E1>>A./8. E16-1694<432.59/96.2.46.4:.12637.1A532.<.4:. 6-./.0121345.616134./146-.5/.2.46:92.12436>197>.=3/ - 10 - 2.59/96. 2.46.4:. =3/ 6-. 3==.4:. 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:6134(3= ( .9/4.< :3;42.> =3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ :346.4<2 6-96 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ 12 2;==./148 =/3A 09/13;2 91>A.462 94< .:6134 % 3= <3.2 436 4.:.221696. 2.46.4:. E16- 1A5/1234A.46 =3/ 94C 5./13< .4:. -. 5/9C2 =3/ >.41.4:C 7C 9>>3E148 6-. /.012134 5.616134E16-3;61A53214894C2;72694610.2.46.4:.94<63 2.46.4:.6-.9::;2.<34>CE16-=14. % <3 436 =14< 94C 2;553/6 =3/ 6-. :346.46134 69F.4 7C 6-. >.9/4.< :3;42.> =3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ &-.46-.5/32.:;6134122;::.22=;>145/301486-./92-94< 4.8>18.46</101483=6-.0.-1:>.7C6-./.0121345.616134./ E-1:- /.2;>6.< 14 <.96- 3= 6-. <.:.92.< E-3 E92 -9/<>C 98.<(C.9/2966-.61A.3=-12<.96--.12436.4616>.< =3/ 2;:- A125>9:.< 2CA596-C 7C 436 1A532148 94C 2;72694610. 2.46.4:. 3E.0./ :3421<./148 6-. 2;7A122134 A9<. 7C 6-. >.9/4.< :3;42.> =3/ 6-. /.012134 - 11 - 5.616134./ 6-96 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ 12 2;==./148 =/3A 09/13;291>A.462 9A3=6-.35141346-9623A.>.41.4:C A9C 7. 2-3E4 14 -12 =903;/ 7C /.<;:148 6-. 5./13< 3= 2.46.4:.1A532.<7C6-. /19>3;/6 ::3/<148>C 942E./6-.9730.53146 94<5/3:..<6359226-.=3>>3E148+ 1# /1A149>/.0121345.61613412 11# -. B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 <96.< )%(( 5922.< 14 3%( 34 6-. =1>. 3= >.9/4.< <<> ' $ 9>97;/981 =3/ 6-. 3==.4:.2 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:61342 ( 94< % 3= 94< 6-. B;<8A.46 <96.< ((( 5922.< 14 /1A149> 55.9> 3%(( 34 6-. =1>. 3= >.9/4.< <<161349> .221342 ';<8. 9>97;9/81 :34=1/A148 6-. B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 9/. -./.7C:34=1/A.< - 12 - 111# 3E.0./ 6-. 3/<./ 3= 2.46.4:. 5922.< 7C 6-. /19> 3;/6 =3/ 6-. 3==.4:. 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:6134(3= 122.6921<. 10# -./.0121345.616134./122.46.4:.<63;4<./83 21A5>. 1A5/1234A.46 =3/ 21G A346-2 =3/ 6-. 3==.4:.5;412-97>.;4<./ .:6134 % 3= 94<6359C9=14.3=2 4<.=9;>663 59C=14.-.2-9>>;4<./8321A5>.1A5/1234A.46 =3/6E3A346-2 0# -./.0121345.616134./12.4616>.<=3/6-.7.4.=16 3= 2.6 3== 92 5/301<.< ;4<./ .:6134 ( 3= / .8126/C 12 <1/.:6.< 63 2.4< 79:F 6-. /19> 3;/6 /.:3/<2 9>348 E16- 6-. :35C 3= 6-12 B;<8A.46 =3/ 14=3/A9613494<4..<=;>9:6134 !-+ '$$* % 1263+>3+%