- 1 - !" # $ % %% &"' ( ! " #$ $ % & $ #$ % '$ $ & ! ( & ( !&'!) & & * " #$ + % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & )!# % $ ( ! ! $ ( ')& $ $ $ ( * * ,( $ -./ 011203 ./ 142524426 78 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:80?0.:/99-2(;6?>2:90:60@04660926! ! 10//26.: =')& 789-2 66.9.=:032:.=4.A.3 (;6?20:6 0307;40?.#5=4/-=49B9-294.7;:03C%=:9-2 ?4=;:6=53.07.3.98 -2 .:D;426 <30.>0:9 0?26 ' 8204/ >29 @.9- 0<<.62:9 =: 0:6 5.326 <30.> 129.9.=: /22E.:? <=>12:/09.=: =5 / )& 725=42 9-2 94.7;:03 -2 94.7;:0305924<=:/.624.:?9-22:9.422A.62:<2=:42<=46-0/ 0@04626 0 /;> =5 /F & 03=:? @.9- .:9242/9 09 9-2 4092 =5 'G 124 0::;> 54=> 9-2 6092 =5 129.9.=: 9.33 - 3 - 4203.H09.=:-294.7;:03-0/-2369-0942/1=:62:9 =/ 0:6 042 D=.:938 0:6 /2A240338 3.0732 9= 108 9-2 <=>12:/09.=: 0:6 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8 .2 42/1=:62:9 = ./ 6.42<926 9= 621=/.9 9-2 <=>12:/09.=: 0@04626 78 9-2 94.7;:03 2.:? 0??4.2A26 78 9-2 /0.6 (;6?>2:9 0:6 0@046 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8-0/1425244269-2142/2:9011203=:9-2?4=;:6=5 3.07.3.98 ! :9-2142/2:9011203.9./>0.:38<=:92:6269-09 9-264.A24=59-2=552:6.:?A2-.<32@0/:=9-=36.:?A03.60:6 2552<9.A264.A.:?3.<2:<20/=:9-26092=59-20<<.62:99./ 5;49-24 <=:92:626 9-09 9-2 9.1124 3=448 7204.:? 42?./9409.=: = !&'!) @0/ .:/;426 @.9- 9-2 0112330:9:/;40:<2 <=>10:8 7;9 9-2 1=3.<8 @0/ <0:<23326 .: A.2@ =5 9-2 6./-=:=;4=5<-2I;27204.:? =!'640@:780:0109. 0:.E 09.E04 =: 0:E .>.926 0307;40?. 5=4 0: 0>=;:9=5/ &-2/0.6<-2I;2@0/;:<3204260:6 .:9.>09.=:07=;99-26./-=:=;4=59-2<-2I;2-0/722:/2:9 9=9-2=@:24=59-2A2-.<320:0109.0:.E 09.E0407=;99-2 <0:<23309.=:=51=3.<80:603/=.:9.>09.=:-0/722:?.A2:9= 9-2 2?.=:03 40:/1=49 55.<24 =/1292 07=;9 9-2 - 4 - <0:<23309.=: =5 =3.<8 =5 9-2 A2-.<32 7204.:? 42?./9409.=: = !&'!);99-2:/;426.2=@:24=59-2A2-.<32 -0/ :=9 /;442:62426 9-2 1=3.<8 .//;26 9= -.> J 9= J' 0:6 J -0A2 722: 14=6;<26 0:6 >04E26 789-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8 9= /-=@ 9-09 0/ =: 9-2 6092 =5 9-2 0<<.62:9 9-242 @0/ := <=A240?2 =5 9-2 :/;40:<2 1=3.<8 JF ./ 9-2 <=>>;:.<09.=: 9= 9-2 42?046.:? <0:<23309.=:=59-21=3.<80//;<-9-2<=:940<9=5:/;40:<2 /90:6/42/<.:6266;29=50.3;42=5<=:/.62409.=:=:14.:<.132 =5 30@ 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8 ./ :=9 3.0732 9= <=>12:/092 9-29-.46104985=49-20<<.62:925;49-24/;7>.99269-090/ 124 2<9.=: #% =5 9-2 2?=9.0732 :/94;>2:9/ <9 9-2 108>2:9 =5 <-2I;2 -236 ./ =46.:048 0<<21926 0/ 0 A03.6 92:6247;9.9.//;7D2<99=2:<0/->2:9=5<-2I;22:<2.9 ./ <3204 A.=309.=: =5 9-2 :/;40:<2 <9 -2 94.7;:03 423.26 ;1=: J' .2 <<=;:9/ J940<9 0:6 -236 9-09 9-2 :/;40:<21=3.<8>04E2609J./A03.654=>' 9= 0:69-20<<.62:9-0/=<<;4426=: ;9 9-2 1=3.<8 @0/ :=9 .: 2J./92:<2 0/ =: 9-2 6092 =5 9-2 - 5 - 0<<.62:9 0:6 42I;2/926 9= /29 0/.62 9-2 (;6?>2:9 0:6 0@046 F 204:26 <=;:/23 5=4 9-2 42/1=:62:9 = /;7>.9926 9-09 .: A.2@ =5 9-2 (;6?>2:9 10//26 78 9-2 =:C732 ;142>2 =;49 .: 9-2 <0/2 =5 421=4926.: !"9-2:/;40:<2<=>10:8@0/ -236 3.0732 9= 108 9-2 <=>12:/09.=: 0>=;:9 @-242.: 9-2 :/;40:<2=3.<8@0/<0:<23326059249-26092=50<<.62:90:6 04?;26 9-09 .9 @0/ 5=4 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8 9= <=>>;:.<0929-2/0>29=9-2=@:24=59-2A2-.<327;99-28 50.3269=6=/= <<=46.:?38-2/;7>.9/9-099-2011203>08 726./>.//26 20469-204?;>2:9/54=>7=9-/.62/ ' 204:26 <=;:/23 5=4 9-2 42/1=:62:9 = <=:92:6269-090/1249-2/9092>2:9/=50<<=;:9/5;4:./-26 78 -.> ;:624 J =: 05924 626;<9.=: =5 0: 0>=;:9 =5 / & 9-242 @0/ 7030:<2 =5 / )F& 0:6 .9 @0/ 23.<.926 .: 9-2 <4=//2J0>.:09.=: =5 - 6 - -2425=42 -2 /90926 9-09 9-2 142>.;> @0/ 0342068 626;<92654=>9-20<<=;:9=59-2=@:240:69-21=3.<8@0/ .: 2J./92:<2 7;9.:9-2 6=<;>2:9 5.326 725=42 9-2=;49 =: .9@0/=7/24A269-099-2<-2I;2@0/429;4:26 =4 ;:<30.>26 6;2 9= .:/;55.<.2:9 7030:<2 0:6 .: A.2@ =5 6./-=:=;4=5<-2I;29-21=3.<8@0/<0:<23326=: 0:6 .:9.>09.=: @0/ /2:9 9= 9-2 =/1292 : 9-2 2A.62:<2=5 -2<320438/909269-09=: 9-28 /2:9 .:9.>09.=: 9= 9-2 =@:24 =5 9-2 A2-.<32 42?046.:? <0:<23309.=:=59-21=3.<80:642I;2/926-.>9=/;442:6249-2 1=3.<80:60104954=>9-099-28-0A203/=/2:9.:9.>09.=:9= 9-2 =/1292 -2 1=3.<8 @0/ .: 2J./92:<2 54=> '9= 0:69-2=@:24=59-2A2-.<32-0/ 9=1089-2142>.;>0>=;:9=:'7;99-2<-2I;2 .//;2678-.>5=4108>2:9=5142>.;>@0/6./-=:=;4260:6 9-2 1=3.<8 @0/ <0:<23326 =: -2 0<<.62:9 =<<;4426 =: -2 =@:24 =5 9-2 A2-.<32 -0/ :=9 90E2: 0:8 /921/ -2 -0/ :=9 .//;26 0:8 :=9.<2 9= 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8 42?046.:? @.9-640@03 =5 / & 9=@046/142>.;>:50<99-2=@:24=59-2A2-.<32@0/:=9 - 7 - 2J0>.:26725=429-294.7;:03 /1249-2>0924.03=:42<=46 9-2 1=3.<8 @0/ :=9 .: 2J./92:<2 0/ =: 9-2 6092 =5 9-2 0<<.62:90//;<-9-2:/;40:<2=>10:8./:=93.07329=108 9-2<=>12:/09.=: ) <<=46.:?389-25=33=@.:?* #.% -2 011203 5.326 78 9-2 :/;40:<2 <=>10:8./033=@26+ #..% -2(;6?>2:910//26789-294.7;:03./ >=6.5.26+ 9-2 3.07.3.98 ./ 5.J26 =: 9-2 42/1=:62:9 ==@:24 =5 9-2 A2-.<32 0:6 9-2 0112330:9 :/;40:<2<=>10:8./2J=:24092654=>108>2:9=5 <=>12:/09.=:+ #...% -2 42/1=:62:9 ==@:24 =5 9-2 A2-.<32 ./ 6.42<926 9= 621=/.9 9-2 <=>12:/09.=: 0>=;:90@04626789-294.7;:0303=:?@.9-.:9242/9 @.9-.:=:2>=:9-54=>9-26092=59-./=4624+ - 8 - #.A% : /;<- 621=/.9 9-2 42/1=:62:9 = <30.>0:9 ./ 124>.9926 9= @.9-640@ 9-2 0>=;:9 03=:?@.9-.:9242/90<<4;26=:.9 )*+ &% ' $ ./9 =* 3 =*