Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63344 (KAR)
ANANDRAYA @ ANANTRAJ v. ANNAYYA AND ANR
MFA/200980/2022 · 2025-08-29
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63344 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63344 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"## $$
%#& '( $$ )
$$ )
$$ *)
'
(
! " # #$
%
&'(')*
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
#
# , &'('*+ ! "
#+-
$
) "$ # ,
*' * +*++
#
# ++*+*. )'
(
! " # #$
- 3 -
%
&'(')*
+
#
# , &'('*+ ! "
#+-
$
) "$ # ,
*' * +*++
#
# +.+*. )
'
(
#
(
! " # #$
- 4 -
%
&'(')*
+
#
# , &'('*+ ! "
#+-
$
) "$ # ,
*' * +*++
#
# +(+*. *)'
(
'
#
! " # #$
- 5 -
%
&'(')*
+
#
# , &'('*+
! "
#+-
$
) "$ # ,
*' * +*++
#
# ++*. /
#
- 6 -
0 # #
" 1 +**.+*++ 23 42567 89 :;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: 366A2>B 6>;<>?6@6>: 14 ?1@=6>3<:21> <3 <C<D76789:;6D28E><52>:;6FE7B@6>:<>7<C<D77<:67 *' * +*++ =<3367 2> # 1 ++*+*. 89 :;6 772:21><56>21D2G25E7B6<>7<5<8ED<B2
*+ 1 +**.(*+*++234256789:;6<==655<>:& ?5<2@<>: 366A2>B 6>;<>?6@6>: 14 ?1@=6>3<:21> <3 <C<D767 89 :;6 D28E><5 2> FE7B@6>: <>7 <C<D7 7<:67 *' * +*++ =<3367 2> # 1 +.+*. 89 :;6 772:21><56>21D2G25E7B6<>7<5<8ED<B2
*) 1 +**.(+*++234256789:;6<==655<>:& ?5<2@<>: 366A2>B 6>;<>?6@6>: 14 ?1@=6>3<:21> <3 <C<D767 89 :;6 D28E><5 2> FE7B@6>: <>7 <C<D7 7<:67 *' * +*++ =<3367 2> # 1 +(+*. 89 :;6 772:21><56>21D2G25E7B6<>7<5<8ED<B2
- 7 -
* 1 +**'(+*++234256789:;6<==655<>:& ?5<2@<>: 366A2>B 6>;<>?6@6>: 14 ?1@=6>3<:21> <3 <C<D767 89 :;6 D28E><5 2> FE7B@6>: <>7 <C<D7 7<:67 *' * +*++ =<3367 2> # 1 ++*. 89 :;6 772:21><56>21D2G25E7B6<>7<5<8ED<B2
*' 55:;6?5<2@=6:2:21>3;<G6866>42567=6D:<2>2>B :1 :;6 <??276>: :<A6> =5<?6 1> +H * +*. ;6 7<:6 14 <??276>:52<8252:914:;62>3ED<>?6?1@=<>9<>7<B614:;6 ?5<2@<>:3I2>FED67<D6>1:2>723=E:6
*H 6<D7 56<D>67 ?1E>365 41D :;6 <==655<>:3 I ?5<2@<>:3 <>7 56<D>67 ?1E>365 41D D63=1>76>: 1 + & 2>3ED<>?6?1@=<>9
* 6<D>67 ?1E>365 41D :;6 <==655<>:3 & ?5<2@<>:3 C1E57 ?1>:6>7 :;<: 6J?6=: :;6 <==655<>: I ?5<2@<>: 2> 1 +**.(*+*++ :;6 1:;6D ?5<2@<>:3 2> 1:;6D *) <==6<53<D6@2>1D3<>7:;69<D66>:2:567:1?1@=6>3<:21> <3=6D:;6FE7B@6>:14:;61>/856E=D6@61ED:2>:;6 ?<36 14
! " #$ %& '() *'+ +
- 8 -
!D6=1D:672>,-./
0C2:;63?<5<:21> <: *K 6 4ED:;6D 3E8@2:3 :;<: :;6 D28E><5 ;<3 :<A6> :;6 723<8252:9 1> :;6 51C6D 3276 6 4ED:;6D 3E8@2:3 :;<:
:;6 <==655<>: I ?5<2@<>: 2> 1 +**.(*+*++ 23 <B67 '96<D3<>7723<8252:9:<A6>=6D:<2>2>B:1:;6<==655<>:I ?5<2@<>:<:*K<3<B<2>3::;66G276>?61471?:1D<:)(K 231>:;651C6D3276 2:;:;636;6=D<93:16>;<>?6:;6 ?1@=6>3<:21>
*( 6<D>67 ?1E>365 41D D63=1>76>: 1 + & 2>3ED<>?6 ?1@=<>9 3E8@2:3 :;<: :;6 ?1@=6>3<:21> <C<D76789:;6D28E><523FE3:<>7=D1=6D<>7:;6D6<D6 >1BD1E>7341D6>;<>?6@6>:14?1@=6>3<:21>
)'
*.
;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:C<3<B67'96<D3<3 1> :;6 7<:6 14 <??276>: ;6 <??276>: ;<3 :<A6> =5<?6 2> :;696<D+*. 3=6D:;61AI7<5<:;;<D::;6>1:21><5 2>?1@6233 )+'*I=6D@1>:; ;6D28E><5;<3:<A6> :;6>1:21><52>?1@6<??1D72>B59 +23:;671?:1D2>;23 6G276>?6<>72>:;6723<8252:9?6D:242?<:6<:J .;6;<3 1=2>67:;<:?5<2@<>:;<33E3:<2>6741551C2>B2>FED263
- 9 -
! "#$
#$ #
% &$
- 10 -
* 1>3276D2>B :;6 3<@6 :;6 71?:1D & + ;<3 3:<:67:;<::;6723<8252:923)(K14:;66>:2D68179 G6> :;1EB;:;671?:1D;<33:<:6731:;6D28E><5;<36DD672> :<A2>B723<8252:9<:*K
1>3276D2>B :;6 3<@6 :;6 723<8252:9 ;<3 :1 86 :<A6><:'K ;6D28E><5;<3D2B;:59:<A6>:;6@E5:2=526D <: >G26C14:;63<@6:;65133144E:ED66<D>2>B23<3 E>76DI
3 )+'*IJ+JJ'KL3 ))).**I
+ 1>3276D2>B :;6 4D<?:ED63 3E3:<2>67 :;6 <C<D7 14 ?1@=6>3<:21> 41D =<2> <>7 3E446D2>B 2> < 3E@ 14 3 ****I231>:;651C6D3276 ;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:
236>:2:56741D3 '***I:1C<D73:;6=<2><>73E446D2>B
) ;6 D28E><5 ;<3 D2B;:59 <C<D767 :;6 @672?<5 6J=6>363143 .+'.HI5133142>?1@67ED2>B:;65<27E= =6D217 14 3 ).'*I >E:D2:21E3 4117 <>7 <::6>7<>:
?;<DB632><3E@143 )****I
- 11 -
1>3276D2>B:;64D<?:ED63<>72>FED2633E3:<2>67 89 :;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: :;6 5133 14 4E:ED6 <@6>2:263 <C<D76789:;6D28E><52><3E@143 )****I231>:;6 51C6D3276 ;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:236>:2:567:1<3E@14 3 H****I:1C<D735133144E:ED6<@6>2:263
' 1>3276D2>B :;6 <81G6 <3=6?:3 :;6 <==655<>: I ?5<2@<>:236>:2:567:1?1@=6>3<:21><3E>76DI
+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74
133144E:ED66<D>2>B3 3 ))).**I + <2><>73E446D2>B 3 '***I ) 672?<56J=6>363 3 .+'.HI
133 14 2>?1@6 7ED2>B :;65<27E==6D217 3 ).'*I ' E:D2:21E3 4117 <>7 <::6>7<>:?;<DB63 3 )****I H 133144E:ED6<@6>2:263 3 H****I
4-+ /<=* <'
H ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: 23 6>:2:567 :1 :1:<5 ?1@=6>3<:21> 14 3 H)+HI <3 <B<2>3: 3 '.HI <3<C<D76789:;6D28E><5
- 12 -
'
)
'
*)'
%
11 :;6 2>FED67 & ?5<@<>:23<B67+96<D3
:;6 2>FED67 & ?5<2@<>: 23 <B67 H 96<D3 <>7
:;62>FED67&?5<2@<>:23<B67) 96<D3<31>:;67<:614<??276>:
( ;6 71?:1D C;1 6J<@2>67 :;6 ?5<2@<>: & 2>FED67 2> 1 +**.+*++ ;<3 3:<:67 :;<: :;6 ?5<2@<>: & 2>FED67 ;<3 3E3:<2>67 723<8252:9 <: )*K 2> 1 +**.(+*++:;6?5<2@<>:&2>FED67;<33E3:<2>67 723<8252:9 <: )+K <>7 2> 1 +**'(+*++ :;6 ?5<2@<>:&2>FED67;<33E3:<2>67723<8252:9<:+'K
. 1>3276D2>B:;63<27<3=6?:3<55:;6<==655<>:3 &?5<2@<>:3;<G63E3:<2>67:;6723<8252:9@1D6:;<>*K 3 =6D :;6 76?2321> 14 :;6 1>/856 E=D6@6 1ED: 2> :;6 ?<36 14 "3E=D<$ :;6 <==655<>:3 &
- 13 -
?5<2@<>:3 <D6 6>:2:567 :1 ?1@=6>3<:21> 14 3 )*****I :1C<D73 =<2> <>7 3E446D2>B3 @6>:<5 <>7 =;932?<5 3;1?A ;<D73;2= 2>?1>G6>26>?6 <>7 723?1@41D: <>7 5133 14 <@6>2:2632>52461><??1E>:14=6D@<>6>:723<8252:9 >:;6 ?<36 14 "3E=D<$ :;6 <??276>: ;<3 :<A6>=5<?62>:;696<D+**H<>7<??276>:2>:;6=D636>:
?<36 23 :<A6> =5<?6 2> :;6 96<D +*.
;6D641D6 :;6 <==655<>:3 & ?5<2@<>:3 <D6 6>:2:567 :1 63?<5<:21> <: *K ;6D641D6 :;6 <==655<>:3 I ?5<2@<>:3 <D6 6>:2:567 :1 3 )*****I M )**** "*K$ L 3 ))****I :1C<D73 3<27 ;6<7 =<D: 4D1@ :;<: :;6 ?5<2@<>:3 <D6 6>:2:567 41D 5133 14 6<D>2>B 14 :;6 =<D6>:3 7ED2>B :;6 =6D217 14 ;13=2:<52N<:21>2><3E@143 ).'*I"3 )+'*IJ)$ =<D: 4D1@ :;<: :;6 ?5<2@<>:3 <D6 6>:2:567 :1 @672?<5 6J=6>363D63=6?:2G659
+* >G26C14:;6<81G6:;6<==655<>:3&?5<2@<>:3 <D66>:2:567:1?1@=6>3<:21><3E>76DI
- 14 -
'
I
+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74
<2><>73E446D2>B6:? 3 ))****I + 133 14 6<D>2>B 14 :;6 =<D6>:37ED2>B:;6=6D217 14;13=2:<52N<:21> 3 ).'*I ) 672?<5J=6>363 3 (+)HHI
4-+ / **<'
)
'
I
+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74
<2><>73E446D2>B6:? 3 ))****I + 133 14 6<D>2>B 14 :;6 =<D6>:37ED2>B:;6=6D217 14;13=2:<52N<:21> 3 ).'*I ) 672?<5J=6>363 3 .'.(I
4-+ /
<=*'
- 15 -
*)'
I
+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74
<2><>73E446D2>B6:? 3 ))****I + 133 14 6<D>2>B 14 :;6 =<D6>:37ED2>B:;6=6D217 14;13=2:<52N<:21> 3 ).'*I ) 672?<5J=6>363 3 *I
4-+ /
)<*'
+ ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>:
1 +**.+*++ 23 6>:2:567 :1 :1:<5 ?1@=6>3<:21> 14 3 ''+HI<3<B<2>3:3 )*)(HHI<3<C<D76789:;6 D28E><5 ++ ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>:
1 +**.(+*++ 23 6>:2:567 :1 :1:<5 ?1@=6>3<:21> 14 3 H')I<3<B<2>3:3 +'.(I<3<C<D76789:;6 D28E><5 +) ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>:
1 +**'(+*++ 23 6>:2:567 :1 :1:<5 ?1@=6>3<:21> 14 3 *.(HI<3<B<2>3:3 ')I<3<C<D76789:;6 D28E><5
+ >G26C14:;6<81G6:;641551C2>B-
- 16 -
55:;6<==6<53<D6<551C672>=<D: ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: 2> 1 +**.(*+*++ 23 6>:2:567:1:1:<5?1@=6>3<:21>143 H)+HIC2:;
2>:6D63: <: :;6 D<:6 14 HK = < 4D1@ :;6 7<:6 14 =6:2:21>:2552:3D6<52N<:21> ;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:2> 1 +**.
+*++23 6>:2:567:1:1:<5?1@=6>3<:21>143 ''+HIC2:;
2>:6D63: <: :;6 D<:6 14 HK = < 4D1@ :;6 7<:6 14 =6:2:21>:2552:3D6<52N<:21> # ;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:2> 1 +**.( +*++23 6>:2:567:1:1:<5?1@=6>3<:21>143 H')IC2:;
2>:6D63: <: :;6 D<:6 14 HK = < 4D1@ :;6 7<:6 14 =6:2:21>:2552:3D6<52N<:21> # ;6<==655<>:&?5<2@<>:2> 1 +**'( +*++23 6>:2:567:1:1:<5?1@=6>3<:21>143 *.(HIC2:;
2>:6D63: <: :;6 D<:6 14 HK = < 4D1@ :;6 7<:6 14 =6:2:21>:2552:3D6<52N<:21>
- 17 -
# 63=1>76>: 1 +&2>3ED<>?6?1@=<>93;<55=<9:;6 <C<D7 <@1E>: C2:; 2>:6D63: 2> <55 :;6 <==6<53 <>7 76=132::;63<@68641D6:;6D28E><5C2:;2><=6D217 14*(C66A34D1@:;237<94<252>BC;2?;2:2352<856:1 =<92>:6D63:<::;6D<:614.K= < # ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: 2> 1 +**.(*+*++ 23 6>:2:567:1D656<36146>:2D6?1@=6>3<:21><@1E>: # ;6 <==655<>:3 & ?5<2@<>:3 2> 1 +**.(+*++ <>7 2> 1 +**'(+*++ ;<G6 <::<2>67 :;6 <B6 14@<F1D2:9<>7:;6D641D6:;69<D66>:2:567:1D656<36 146>:2D6?1@=6>3<:21><@1E>: , ;6 <==655<>: & ?5<2@<>: 2> 1 +**.+*++ 23 3:255<@2>1D<>7:;61D76D1476=132:=<336789:;6 D28E><523D6@<2>67E><5:6D67
.' %##&
"
23: 1 5 1 +. #