- 1 - !"#$ ! % $&!! % $&!#&' # (!!) ! " # $%&'''" ( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #"* #(! # ((& ((+ # # # "'&('( ('""('(, - . ('""('(,# # /) 0 0 0 ! " 12345267862629:23;2<8=>1?<<8:@2:@61895=85=?68= "'&('( 7?338= AB ?5:?6?C? 6?68 =D2:2365?62E8 52AF:?< ?6 ?<?AF5?@2 ;95 31956 /618 52AF:?<)! 2: 77<2>?629: 9('""('(, 41858AB 618 ?77<2>?629: ;2<8= AB 618 ?77<2>?:67862629:85 1?3 A88: =23D2338= ?:= 618 78:?<6B 2D7938= AB 618 =23>27<2:?5B ?F619526B 1?3 A88: >9:;25D8= - 3 - ( #956183?C89;>9:E8:28:>86187?56283?5858;8558= 69?3785618255?:C2:@A8;95861852AF:?< , 528; ;?>63 9; 618 >?38 ?58 61?6 618 ?77<2>?:6 23 495C2:@ ?3 ? 5?=8" ?132<=?5 ?6 ?<2C968 2G?B?7F5? 23652>618:3184?3495C2:@?3?5?=8(?132<=?5? >9D7<?2:6 4?3 <9=@8= AB 9:8 8:6?58==B 39: 9; ?<?58==B 8<<F5? 2<<?@8 2=?5 A8;958 618 9C?BFC61? ?<<8@2:@ 61?6 18 ;2<8= ?: ?77<2>?629: ;95 DF6?629: ?:= ;95 233F2:@ "" 3C86>1 ?:= ?<39 7?2= 58HF23268 ;88 837268 <?738(B8?53,D9:613618""3C86>14?3:96233F8= : 618 A?323 9; 618 >9D7<?2:6 58379:=8:6 9( =258>68= 618 =87?56D8:6 69 58=5833 618 @528E?:>8 9; 618 >9D7<?2:?:6 D?=8 AB 233F2:@ "" 3C86>1 ?:= ?>629: 6?C8:5879561858?;68561858379:=8:69"AB2:E9C2:@ F<8 " 9; 18 ?5:?6?C? 2E2< 85E2>83 <?332;2>?629: 9:659<?:=778?<!F<83"%+8:65F368=6188:HF25B69 ==2629:?< 8@23685 9; :HF2583, ?:= 233F8= 562><83 9; 1?5@839:(''('"+18:HF25B;;2>851?33FAD2668= - 4 - 618 587956 69 618 58379:=8:6 9( 9: ','('" 8379:=8:6 9( ?<9:@ 4261 618 58>9DD8:=?629: 3FAD2668=?5879566961858379:=8:69"9:'%'('" 8379:=8:6 9" 1?3 233F8= :962>8 69 618 ?77<2>?:6 9: (%'(('('F53F?:66961?6618?77<2>?:61?33FAD2668= ? 5879:32=852:@ 618 58727<2:?5B ?F619526B 1?3 2D7938= ? 78:?<6B 9; 58=F>629: 9; ;9F5 2:>58D8:63 4261 >FDF<?62E8 8;;8>6 AB 95=85 =?68= (I'I('(, 82:@ ?@@528E8= AB 618 3?D8 618 7862629:85 1?3 ;2<8= ?:?77<2>?629: A8;958 61852AF:?< 2: 77<2>?629: 9('""('(, 18 52AF:?< AB 95=85 =?68= "'&('( 1?3=23D2338=618?77<2>?629:@@528E8=AB6183?2=95=85 9;61852AF:?<618?77<2>?:623A8;9586123>9F56 8?5:8= >9F:38< ?778?52:@ ;95 618 7862629:85 ?77<2>?:6 1?3 >9:68:68= 61?6 418: 61?6 ?77<2>?:6 4?3 495C2:@ ?3 5?=8( ?132<=?5 ? >9D7<?2:6 1?3 A88: <9=@8=AB9:88:685?==B?<<8@2:@61?6618?77<2>?:61?3 :96233F8= "" 3C86>1 ?3 58HF8368=AB 618>9D7<?2:?:6 18<8?5:8=>9F:38<>9:68:=8=61?6>9:=F>62:@3F5E8B?:= - 5 - 233F2:@ 618 "" 3C86>1 23 :96 618 =F6B 9; 5?=8( ?132<=?5 623618=F6B9;618F5E8B;;2>8541923F:=85 618 >9:659< 9; ?132<=?5 18 ?77<2>?:6 1?3 :9612:@ 69 =9 4261 618 ?77<2>?629: ;2<8= AB 618 >9D7<?2:?:6 9 61?6 8;;8>6181?3759=F>8=618G9A>1?5658<?68=69?132<=?5 ?:=5?=8(?132<=?5233F8=AB6189E85:D8:6AB5=85 =?68=',"(('""8>9:=<B181?3>9:68:68=61?62:618 8:HF25B5879563FAD2668=AB618:HF25B;;2>85?;2:=2:@ 1?3 A88: @2E8: 61?6 26 23 618 =F6B 9; 618 ?77<2>?:6 69 >9:=F>6 3F5E8B 9; 618 <?:= 9; 618 >9D7<?2:?:6 ?:= 233F8 "" 3C86>1 123 ;2:=2:@ 23 >9:65?5B 69 618 9A >1?56 233F8=AB61?69E85:D8:6#F5618518>9:68:68=61?62: 618 8:HF25B 587956 61858 23 ? ;2:=2:@ 61?6 618 ?77<2>?:6! ;2:=2:@ 61?6 618 ?77<2>?:6! 1?3 >9:=F>68= 3F5E8B 2: 58378>6 9; <?:= 2: F5E8B 9 ?:= 233F8= "" 3C86>1 F6 618 58<8E?:6 =9>FD8:631?E8:96A88:233F8=AB618?77<2>?:68:>8 618 3?2= ;2:=2:@ 9; 618 :HF25B ;;2>85 23 >9:65?5B 69 618 D?6852?<3 ?E?2<?A<8 9: 58>95= :85 1?3 18<= 61?6 618 >1?5@83 ?@?2:36 618 - 6 - ?77<2>?:61?E8A88:759E8=:618A?3239;6185879569; 618:HF25B;;2>85618=23>27<2:?5B?F619526B1?32D7938= 61878:?<6B ?36<B181?3>9:68:68=61?6618?77<2>?629: 1?3A88:;2<8=9:"',('""*?77<2>?:61?36?C8:>1?5@8 ?3 5?=8( ?132<=?5 9: (I"(('"( ?:= 495C8= 62<< '&',('" ?:= >9D7<?2:6 1?3 A88: <9=@8= 9: (&'+('", 18 1?3 :96 58>82E8= ?:B ?77<2>?629: ;95 233F2:@ 618 3C86>1 ?:= 318 1?3 495C8= ?3 ?: :>1?5@8 ?132<=?5 9:9:32=852:@ ?<< 61838 ?378>63 618 =23>27<2:?5B ?F619526B 1?3 2D7938= 78:?<6B E8: 618 52AF:?<1?38558=2:58G8>62:@618?77<2>?629:;2<8=AB618 ?77<2>?:6 388C2:@ ;95 HF?312:@ 618 95=85 9; 78:?<6B 8:>81839F@16;95?<<942:@61845267862629: % 85 >9:65? <8?5:8= ?778?52:@ ;95 6?68 1?3 >9:68:68= 61?6 618 :HF25B ;;2>85 1?3 >9:=F>68= ? =86?2<8= 8:HF25B ?:= 3FAD2668= ? 587956 61?6 >1?5@83 ?@?2:36 618 ?77<2>?:6 1?E8 A88: 759E8= : 618 A?323 9; 61858795678:?<6B1?3A88:2D7938=81?3:96=237F68= - 7 - 618 G9A >1?56 233F8= AB 618 9E85:D8:6 AB 5=85 =?68= ',"(('"" 2: 58378>6 9; 618 495C 9; ?132<=?5 ?:= 5?=8(?132<=?5 & 8?5:8= >9F:38< ?778?52:@ ;95 9C?BFC61? 1?3 3FAD2668=61?69:618A?3239;618>9D7<?2:6<9=@8=AB9:8 528:6?58==B 618 9C?BFC61? 1?3 58>9DD8:=8= 618 9E85:D8:6 69 2:262?68 =87?56D8:6?< 2:HF25B ?:= =258>68= 69 6?C8 ?>629: ?@?2:36 618 ?77<2>?:6 18 =23>27<2:?5B ?F619526BAB8J85>232:@61879485F:=85F<8"9; ! F<83 1?3 8:65F368= 618 8:HF25B 69 9C?BFC61? 9C?BFC61? 1?3 ?7792:68= 618 33236?:6 8@2365?5 9; :HF25283"(6919<=?:8:HF25B?:=3FAD26?58795618 :HF25B ;;2>85 ?;685 >9:=F>62:@ ? =86?2<8= 8:HF25B 18<= 61?6>1?5@83?@?2:36618?77<2>?:61?E8A88:759E8=?:= 3FAD2668=?58795669 9C?BFC61?1858?;685 9C?BFC61? ?<9:@ 4261 618 587956 1?3 38:6 ? 58>9DD8:=?629: 69 2D7938 78:?<6B 9; 426119<=2:@ 2:>58D8:63 4261 >FDF<?62E8 8;;8>6 ?38= 9: 618 587956 618 =23>27<2:?5B ?F619526B1?32D7938=61878:?<6B - 8 - + 8?5= 618 <8?5:8= >9F:38< ;95 618 7?56283 85F38= 61845267?7853 I 623:962:=237F6861?6?77<2>?:67862629:851?36?C8: >1?5@8 ?3 5?=8( ?132<=?5 9: (I"(('"( ?:= 1?3 495C8= 62<< '&',('" :1?5@8 ?132<=?5 :8 8:6?58==B 1?3 ;2<8= ?: ?77<2>?629: 9: "',('"" ?==58338= 69 618 ?132<=?5 ;95 >9:=F>62:@ 3F5E8B ?:= ;95 233F2:@ 9; "" 3C86>1 3 9: 61?6 =?B 618 ?77<2>?:6 4?3 :96 495C2:@ ?3 :>1?5@8 ?132<=?5 95 5?=8( ?132<=?5 2: 618 ;;2>8 9; 618 ?132<=?5 2=?5 18 1?3 6?C8: >1?5@8 ?3 5?=8( ?132<=?5 9: (I"(('"( 3 785 618 G9A >1?56 =?68= ',"(('""618=F6283?:=58379:32A2<262839;6185?=8" ?132<=?5?:=5?=8(?132<=?51?3A88:=23652AF68=?:= ?<<9668=183?D8238J65?>68=A8<94;958?3B58;858:>8 !"#$%&& - 9 - '()*+ ,,- ," ./ ! ," 0#12 ,"3"45 - 6 7 ,"89 :;'<3 0#1.= ," '()*+3> :;' , !?*@+ 0#1 ."A B C !DE0 F89.'()*+G > ," ;C3"'"< ;C '()*+H 0 F%89 2#DI:7J ' D ," ( K 3,7 )J $ ;$ $ (" + ,":.3" ( K 3,C*0#1 " % '()*+ "- $ '-!9" C#1 .!." 3"'< "33 L$ $ JMN # %$ O".3P 5$ !3" Q!R M #1JD ," " STJ* > ' 6$ > Q"." UP (! ='"< 0.#1V' W'"<3> ."A' 3X !H"3X"$ 4$ ./ !"P 0#12 ,"3" 3S< M"3 *9 :;F "&D ," " Y$ ( 3"'"< .> MQ" 3"'"< ;(33( D ," " Z$ .3"+R M #1JD ," " $ !" $ 3""Q["3"'"<!3,:.(! !\* $ 0]13V#1+ , !Q. 0."DE.$ ;C '()*+ $ . 3"^# ; $ 3,?;' ," , !Q. " %$ _R 3"'"< ," (! (3J :;3,F:'; ."A2C"30#1 5$ * =2` (! F5E2E?< :;3,F :'; ."A2C"30#1 6$ )DIO 4$ 3Q2" " !' Y$ . a@ !: (! 03 :>( b M #1JD ," " Z$ 0]1* - ,"c"<3> - 10 - #59D 618 ?A9E8 G9A >1?56 26 23 E85B ><8?5 61?6 >9:=F>62:@?3F5E8B95233F2:@""3C86>123:96618=F6B 9;5?=8(?132<=?5E8:2:618;2:=2:@58>95=8=AB618 :HF25B ;;2>85 26 23 36?68= 61?6 2: 58378>6 9; F5E8B 9 3F5E8B 4?3 >9:=F>68= F:=85 618 3F785E2329: 9; 618?77<2>?:6?:=""3C86>11?3A88:233F8=?:=6961?6 8;;8>6618B1?=759=F>8=#95D"'?:=3C86>1?6J12A26+ 69 J12A26 69 3194 61?6 618B 4858 :96 233F8= AB 618 ?77<2>?:6183?2=;2:=2:@23?<39>9:65?5B69618D?6852?<3 ?E?2<?A<89:58>95= 623:96618=F6B9;618?77<2>?:6419 4?3495C2:@?35?=8(?132<=?569233F8""3C86>195 >9:=F>6 3F5E8B ?:= 318 4?3 :96 495C2:@ ?3 :>1?5@8 ?132<=?5 95 5?=8( ?132<=?5 418: 618 ?77<2>?629: 4?3 ;2<8=289:"',('""18;2:=2:@9;618:HF25B;;2>85 61?6 618 ?77<2>?:6 1?3 :96 233F8= "" 3C86>1 ?:= 18<= 61?6>1?5@831?3A88:759E8=23>9:65?5B69618D?6852?< ?E?2<?A<89:58>95=2619F6>9:32=852:@?<<61838?378>63 618=23>27<2:?5B?F619526B1?32D7938=78:?<6B - 11 - "' :E2849;618?A9E848?589;618972:29:61?6618 45267862629:23<2?A<869A8?<<948=?:=95=859;78:?<6B23 <2?A<869A8HF?318= "" >>95=2:@<B618;9<<942:@95=85237?338= ?! 5267862629:23?<<948= A! 18 95=85 =?68= "'&('( 7?338= AB 618 52AF:?< 2: 77<2>?629: 9('""('(, 23 386 ?32=8 >! 18 78:?<6B 95=85 =?68= (I'I('(, 233F8= AB 61858379:=8:69"23HF?318= !*+ (!) & !*+ (#&' #) & 2369"<9+'

KEERTI CHALAK v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR

Judgment text