Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63333 (KAR)
BASAMMA v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
WP/202312/2025 · 2025-11-10
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63333 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63333 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%$&!$!$
'!(
!"!#$
$ %
!"
!"!#$
&
'
%
!"!#(
$
!"!#(
)
%
!"!#(
# )
%
%
!"!#(
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! *
$*
%'
!(((
&
+'* $
*
$$ $$ *
*
*
$(,$($$(($($#%) **
*
-+
'
-+
'
./0/012.34 56708029 /1 :. /;. 1<2.34 1= /;. 672> 02 ?1! 8.74@3029 ( 753. " 9@2/74 40/@7/.> 7/ 729.8A@3%06679.@37>
76@B72>0>7304/305/73. :.=13. /;04 1@3/ 4..B029 /1 044@. 7 <30/ 1= 872>78@4 >03.5/029/;.3.4A12>.2/4/151240>.3/;.033.A3.4.2/7/012 >7/.> $(,$($ 72> $(($($# 74 A.3 22.C@3.4 D*E D*E72>DE/1/;.<30/A./0/012
- 3 -
$ 74.1=/;.A./0/012.3404/;7/3.4A12>.2/1# ;7> 044@.> 7 6.//.3 /1 3.4A12>.2/ 1 12 $($( 3.F@.4/029/175F@03./;.672>:.6129.>/1A./0/012.34=13 /;. A@3A14. 1= 5124/3@5/012 1= :73379. 2.73 729.8A@3 %06679.02@37>
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
- 4 -
$,(,$($ :.=13. 3.4A12>.2/ 14 72> 3.F@.4/029 /;.8 /13.6.74. 72>A7?/;. 518A.247/012 781@2/4025. /;.03 672> ;74 :..2 75F@03.> =13 /;. A@3A14. 1= 5124/3@5/012 1= :73379. 02 /;. ?.73 $( $("
;. 470> 3.A3.4.2/7/012 =1661<.> :? 721/;.3 3.802>.3 >7/.> (!(#$($#1<.G.3/;.3.;74:..22151240>.37/0121= /;. 3.F@.4/ 3.A3.4.2/7/012 87>. :? /;. A./0/012.34 /066 >7/..25./;.A./0/012
.732.> >>0/01276 1G.328.2/ >G157/. @2>.3/7B029/17AA.73=133.4A12>.2/14/1!4@:80/4 /;7/ 90G.2 418. /08. /;. 3.F@.4/ 3.A3.4.2/7/012 1= /;. A./0/012.34<066:.51240>.3.>0275513>725.<0/;67< # .73>.3@4.>/;.3.513>4 ! ./0/012.3456708/1:./;.1<2.341=?1! 8.74@3029 ( 753. " 9@2/74 1@/ 1= <;05; $# 9@2/74 75513>029 /1 /;. A./0/012.34 ;7G. :..2 @4.> =13 /;. A@3A14. 1= 5124/3@5/029 :73379. <0/; 3.4A12>.2/ 7@/;130/0.4.3@4761=22.C@3. 02>057/.4/;7//;.;0.=
- 5 -
2902..3021333097/012;7>5188@2057/.>/1/;.;0.= .53./73? 1G.328.2/ 1= '7327/7B7 0213 33097/012 A31A14029 /.2/7/0G. A7?8.2/ 1= /;. 514/ 1= $# 9@2/74 1= 672> 1<.G.3 02 /;. 470> 5188@2057/012 /;.3. 04 21 3.=.3.25..0/;.3/14@3G.?2@8:.31=/;.470>672>13/;. 278.41=/;.A./0/012.34/0421/56.73/;.3.=13.<;./;.3 /;.672>1=/;.A./0/012.34;74:..275F@03.>1321/
;1@9; 3.A3.4.2/7/0124 ;7G029 :..2 90G.2 :? /;. A./0/012.34 74 =1@2> 7/ 22.C@3. * 4.30.4 /;.3. ;74 :..2 21 3.4A124. :? /;. 3.4A12>.2/ 7@/;130/0.4 02 /;04 3.973>.0/;.3
2 /;. 5035@84/725.4 A./0/012 04 >03.5/0293.4A12>.2/1 .A@/?188044012.3<;14;766 .C7802. <;./;.3 /;. 672> 02 ?1! 8.74@3029 $# 9@2/74 40/@7/.> 7/ 729.8A@3 %06679. @37>
76@B 0>73 04/305/ :.029 56708.> :? /;.
A./0/012.34 ;74 :..2 75F@03.> 72> @/060H.> =13 /;. A@3A14. 1= 5124/3@5/012 1= :73379. 7=/.3 90G029 1AA13/@20/? /1 A./0/012.34 /1
- 6 -
4@:4/72/07/./;.0356708:?7==13>029A.341276;.73029<0/;
A301321/05. "
251240>.37/0121=/;.574.1=/;.A./0/012.34 /;. .A@/? 188044012.3 4;766 A744 3.7412.> 13>.3 12. <7? 13 /;. 1/;.3 0. <;./;.3 /;. 672> 1= /;. A./0/012.3 ;74 :..2 75F@03.> 13 21/ = 0/ 04 75F@03.> /;. .A@/? 188044012.3 ;084.6= 13 /;. 1==05.3 5125.32.> 4;766 :. >03.5/.>/1A7?/;.518A.247/012 , =/;.672>1=/;.A./0/012.340421/75F@03.>0/ 4;766 044@. 7 5188@2057/012 02 /;04 3.973> /1 /;. A./0/012.34 ( ;. 7=13.470> .C504. 4;766 :. @2>.3/7B.2 72> 518A6./.><0/;027A.301>1==1@3812/;4=318/;.>7/.1= 3.5.0A/1=5.3/0=0.>51A?1=/;0413>.3
!)* '$!$( &
04/161# '