Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63327 (KAR)
GULDAS SANNA THIMMAREDDY SINCE DEAD BY LRS GULDAS ANIL RAJ v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/201512/2024 · 2025-09-18
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63327 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63327 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%%!""
&'(
! " #
!! $ %
&#
#
! &$
&
# $
' ! !! ( ! Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$! ! "
#
%
) ! & (('
((*&
& #
& ) ! & ! +, ! -. -/01/23- 23-4/05366378/09:;<8-=>:6:=.=.80:- 305-.>:9>35-.3.9>3013-
<8-=>:-:96805:0=9>3?: 366:3-:5.06:-980 ( >:736=.80:5)-.=!:=.=.80.9<.;:59::1.04<8;;8@.04 -:;.:<9 99/:3)-.=.0=>:03=/-:8<:-=.8-3-.=8A/39>=>:
/=3=.80 -5:- B:3-.04 8*( 53=:5 '( .99/:5 BC -:96805:0= 8 ?.5:
00:D/-: 7809:A/:0=;C -:28?: =>: 032: 8<
- 3 -
8?:-02:0=8<#3-03=313<-828;/2089E305 8< =>: ,9 .0 -:96:7= 8< ;3059 B:3-.04 .% C8E''..%C8E'*...%C8E'(.?% C8E'305?%C8E'3;;3-:9.=/3=:5 3=3.7>/-3;/1305 .9=-.7=3.7>/- 99/: 3 )-.= .0 =>: 03=/-: 8< 30532/9 5.-:7=.04 -:96805:0=9 ( =8 =8 -:9=8-: =>: 032: 8< =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9;3=:<3=>:-396:-/=3=.80-5:-53=:5 'EE'?.5: 00:D/-: .03;;-:?:0/:-:78-59 .0 -:96:7= 8< ;3059 B:3-.04 .% C8E'' ..% C8E'* ...% C8E'( .?% C8E' 305 ?% C8E' 3;; 3-: 9.=/3=:5 3= 3.7>/- 3;/1305 .9=-.7=3.7>/-
>:6:=.=.803?:-2:0=93-:39/05:- =.99=3=:5=>3==>:;3059B:3-.04C8E''2:39/-.04 =830:D=:0=8<(/0=39C8E'*2:39/-.04=830:D=:0= 8</0=39C8E'(2:39/-.04=830:D=:0=8< 7-: /0=39C8E'2:39/-.04=830:D=:0=8< 7-:
/0=39 305 C8E' 2:39/-.04 =8 30 :D=:0= 8< * /0=39 3;; 3-: 9.=/3=:5 3= >305-3B3053 835 3.7>/-
8B;. - 4 -
3.7>/- 3;/1 305 .9=-.7= 3.7>/- 3-: 8-.4.03;;C 307:9=-3;
6-86:-=.:9 305 <:;; =8 =>: 9>3-: 8< 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 032:;C /;539 3003 >.223-:55C = .9 93.5 =>3= =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:-<.;:539/.=<8-63-=.=.803059:63-3=:6899:99.80305=>:
932: @39 5:7-::5 305 3 9>3-: =8 30 :D=:0= 8< => @39 4-30=:5 .0 <3?8- 8< =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 0 30 366:3; =>: 932: @39 5.92.99:5 <=:- 5.92.993; 8< =>: 366:3; =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- .0.=.3=:5 &.03; :7-:: !-87::5.049 .0 & !
8EE( 80 =>: <.;: 8< .?.; /54: 3.7>/- >/9 =>: 9/BF:7=;3059@:-:<3;;:0=8=>:9>3-:8<6:=.=.80:-,9<3=>:- =.993.5=>3=3<=:-7807;/9.808<=>:& !6-87::5.049=>: 6:=.=.80:-,9<3=>:-366-837>:5=>:3>9.;53-=82/=3=:>.9032: .0 -:96:7= 8< 6-86:-=.:9 /05:- 5:7-::
778-5.04;C =>: 3>9.;53- 6399:5 30 8-5:- 2/=3=.04 =>: 032: 8< 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:-.03;;=>:-:?:0/:-:78-5939:580=>:2/=3=.808-5:- =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 032: @39 -:<;:7=:5 .0 =>: 7807:-0:5 .05.73=.04398@0:-3056899:998-8<=>:9/BF:7=;3059 9 9/7> >: @39 .0 6:37:</; 6899:99.80 877/63=.80 7/;=.?3=.80 305 :0F8C2:0= 8< =>: 93.5 ;3059 @.=>8/= 30CB85C,9 .0=:-<:-:07:
- 5 -
)>:0 9/7> B:.04 =>: 9=3=: 8< 3<<3.-9 30 .0=:-03; 3/5.= 366:3-9 =8 >3?: 7805/7=:5 @.=> -:43-5 =8 -:?:0/: -:7:.6= 3778/0=9 305 .= @39 <8/05 =>3= =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 3= =>: =.2:8<2/=3=.04>.9032:.0=>:-:?:0/:-:78-59>3508=63.5 =>: 9=326 5/=C 39 9/7> 3 5.-:7=.80 @39 .99/:5 =8 -:78?:- 5:<.7.= 9=326 5/=C 8< 9E' = .9 780=:05:5 =>3= =>:
6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- .0.=.3;;C -:9.9=:5 =8 63C =>: 5:<.7.= 9=326 5/=C >:07: =>: -:?:0/: 3/=>8-.=.:9 :0=:-:5 =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0=8<#3-03=313.08;/2089E3058<?.5: /=3=.80 -5:- .0 '( >:-:3<=:- =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 63.5 =>: 5:<.7.= 9=326 5/=C
8@:?:- =>: -:?:0/: 3/=>8-.=.:9 >3?: 08= 5:;:=:5 =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0= 8< #3-03=313 <-82 =>: 05:- =>:9: 7.-7/29=307:9 =>: 6:=.=.80:-.9B:<8-:=>.98/-=
8/09:; <8- =>: -:96:7=.?: 63-=.:9 /-4:5 9:?:-3; 780=:0=.809
:3-5=>:3-4/2:0=93056:-/9:5=>:)-.=636:-9 @.=>73-:
>: <37=9 3-: 9/<<.7.:0=;C 93.5 305 58 08= -:A/.-: -:.=:-3=.80>:.99/:<3;;9@.=>.0303--8@7826399305-:;3=:9 =8 -:28?3; 8< =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0= 8< #3-03=313 <-82
- 6 -
8;/20 89E 305 8< 305 -:9=8-.04 =>: 032: 8< 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- .0 =>: = .9 08= .0 5.96/=: =>3= =>:
9/BF:7= ;3059 @:-: =>: 307:9=-3; 6-86:-=.:9 8< =>: 6:=.=.80:- 305>.9<3=>:-BC=31.049>:;=:-/05:-=>:8/-=8<;3@5:7-::
@39 235: .0 >.9 <3?8- >: 780=-8?:-9C -:?8;?:9 3-8/05 63C2:0= 8< 5:<.7.= 9=326 5/=C 305 .09:-=.80 8< =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0=8<#3-03=313.08;/2089E305858/B= =>:6:=.=.80:-,9<3=>:-3=:3-;.:-68.0=.0=.2:-:9.9=:5=863C=>:
5:<.7.= 9=326 5/=C :73/9: 8< =>: -:9.9=307: =>: -:?:0/: 3/=>8-.=.:9 :0=:-:5 =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0= 8< #3-03=313 .0 8;/20 89E 305
8@:?:- =>: 6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- 235: 48858<=>:5:<.7.=9=3265/=C39.9:?.5:0=<-82 00:D/-:& 07:=>:63C2:0=.9235:3055:<.7.=9=3265/=C.9235:4885 8<=>:-:?:0/:3/=>8-.=.:9>350886=.80:D7:6==85:;:=:=>: 032:8<8?:-02:0=8<#3-03=313305.09:-==>:032:8<=>:
6:=.=.80:-,9 <3=>:- .0 =>: 9 >.9 >39 08= B::0 580: 98 >:-:<8-: =>: 37=.80 80 =>: 63-= 8< =>: :?:0/: 3/=>8-.=C .0 -:=3.0.04 =>: 032: 8< 8?:-02:0= 8< #3-03=313 .0 8;/20 89E305.9/0=:03B;:&8-=>:-:398099=3=:53B8?:=>: /=3=.80 -5:- 3= 00:D/-: .9 ;.3B;: =8 B: 9:=39.5:
778-5.04;C.=.99:=39.5:
- 7 -
' >: )-.= 8< :-=.8-3-.
.9 8-5:-:5 >: /=3=.80 -5:- B:3-.04 8*( 53=:5 '( .99/:5 BC -:96805:0= 8 ?.5:
00:D/-: .9 A/39>:5 30532/9 .9 8-5:-:55.-:7=.04-:96805:0=9(=8=8-:9=8-:=>:032:8<=>: 6:=.=.80:-,9<3=>:-396:-/=3=.80-5:-53=:5'EE'?.5:
00:D/-:
.0 3;; -:?:0/: -:78-59 .0 -:96:7= 8< ;305 B:3-.04 C8E'' C8E'* C8E'( C8E' 305 C8E' 3;; 3-: 9.=/3=:5 3= 3.7>/- 3;/1 305 .9=-.7= 3.7>/- * :9/;=30=;C=>:)-.=!:=.=.80.9 :73/9: 8< 5.96893; 8< =>: )-.= !:=.=.80 6:05.04 .0=:-;87/=8-C 366;.73=.809 .< 30C 3-: 5.9689:5 8< 305 .0=:-.2 5.-:7=.80.<30C9=30595.97>3-4:5
)' &%!""( % # .9=8;8