- 1 - !" #!$!! %% &%' ( !! " ! # " !$ ! " #% & ' #! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( " " #) " ## ( ""* + $$ + + ' $ %$% $ + "' ' $$) )$# $ + " ' + , +" + ++ ' + + ++ ' " -' "' " #$ * % $ - 3 - $! -' ./0123456/7122/1849:;3./8/<18./4=95>5=4<4618 2814634>>?@/9345646<3./A@7<B/631677/0=//=/67/=/7:; 3./ 5@=39 :/85C C./=/46 2814634>>-9 9@43 >5= 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ C19 21=38; 7/0=//7 :; 3./ =418 5@=3 5=7/=46< =/>@67 5> 9 #$%$$ D C.48/ 81=</= =/84/> 5> 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ 5> 0563=103 C19 =/>@9/7 56 3./ <=5@673.133./2814634>>.19>148/7352=5E/.49=/1746/99 167C48846<6/99352/=>5=B.4921=35>0563=103 ./ 7/>/671639 ?@/9345646< 3./ 7/0=// >5= =/>@67 5> B56/; 2=/>/==/7 16 122/18 46 5 ) $ ./2814634>>.19>48/70=599122/18465 $./ +4=93 22/8813/ 5@=3 .19 749B499/7 3./ 122/18 167 1895 3./0=599122/18>48/7:;3./2814634>> +5= 3./ 91F/ 5> :=/E43; =16F 5> 3./ 21=34/9 49 =/>/==/735192/=3./4==16F:/>5=/3./=4185@=3 # +10398/1746<353./019/1=/19>5885C9 - 4 - ./ 2814634>> 469343@3/7 5 $$) 0563/6746< 3.13 3.5@<. 7/>/67163 5 10F65C8/7</7 =/0/423 5> 9 #$%$$ D56%$ $$./>148/7352/=>5=B.4921=3 5> 3./ 0563=103 :; /G/0@346< 3./ =/056E/;160/ 7//7 005=746< 35 3./ 2814634>> 7/9243/ 3./ 7/13. 5> 19C163=1;13./>13./=5>3./7/>/671639461=0. $$ 167 7/9243/ >@88 =/21;B/63 5> 3./ .167 8516 C43.46 3./ 9342@813/7 2/=457 3./ 7/>/671639 056346@/7 35 2593256/ /G/0@3456 5> 3./ 918/ 7//7 /60/ 3./ 2814634>> C19 05693=146/7 35 >48/ 3./ 2=/9/63 9@43 9//F46< 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ ! 256 =/<493=13456 5> 3./ 9@43 9@BB569 C/=/ 499@/7 35 3./ 7/>/671639 ./ 7/>/671639 /63/=/7 122/1=160/167>48/71C=433/69313/B/63935@38;7/6;46< 3./2814631E/=B/639463535 & 63./:1949 5>=4E18 28/1746<93./ =418 5@=3 >=1B/7 499@/9 167 2=50//7/7 35 =/05=7 /E47/60/ ./ 2814634>> /G1B46/7 .4B9/8> 19 167 1895 /G1B46/7 - 5 - 9 35 ! C.48/ 2=57@046< 3C5 750@B/639HG 1<=//B/63 713/7 )$ ))) 167 G 10F65C8/7<B/63 1<=//B/63 713/7 %$ $$ 6 =/:@33187/>/6716357/259/719/G1B46/7>5@= 1774345618C436/99/91672=57@0/7 750@B/639B1=F/7 19G935 .48/ 169C/=46< 499@/ 59 167 # 3./ =418 5@=3./873.13183.5@<.3./2814634>>2=5E/7/G/0@34565> G9 167 499@/ 5 .17 35 :/ 169C/=/7 46 3./ 6/<134E/167499@/5#463./1>>4=B134E/./=4185@=3 05608@7/7 3.13 3./ 2814634>> >148/7 35 /931:849. 3.13 3./ =/<493/=/7 918/ 7//7 713/7 )$ ))) C19 /G/0@3/7 B/=/8; 19 9/0@=43; >5= 3./ 188/</7 .167 8516 5> 9 #$$$$ D/8;46<563./=/043189463./918/7//7167 1228;46< /03456 ) 5> 3./ 67416 E47/60/ 03 3./ =418 5@=3 ./87 3.13 5=18 5= 0563/B25=16/5@9 750@B/631=; /E47/60/05@87653:/177@0/7350563=174033./3/=B95>1 =/<493/=/7 056E/;160/ .@9 43 ./87 3.13 3./ 7/>/671639 .172=5E/73.133./918/C19165@3D167D5@33=169103456 - 6 - /<1=746<499@/53./=4185@=3./873.133./2814634>> >148/7 35 2=5E/ =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 5C/E/= 499@/ 5 C19169C/=/7463./1>>4=B134E/=/05<64946<3.133./ 2814634>>.17/931:849./7/G/0@34565>G167=/21;B/63 5> 9 #$%$$ D @67/= G 713/7 %$ $$ /9243/ 3.49 3./ =418 5@=3 7/0846/7 3./ 7490=/34561=; =/84/> 5> 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ 167 21=38; 7/0=//7 3./ 9@43 568; 35 3.//G3/635>74=/0346<=/>@675>9 #$%$$ D % ./ 22/8813/ 5@=3 749B499/7 :53. 3./ 122/18 >48/7 :; 3./7/>/671639 0.188/6<46< 3./ 7/0=// >5==/>@67 1673./0=599D122/18>48/7:;3./2814634>>9//F46<92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ ) ;5=7/=713/7 $& $ #3.495@=317B433/7 3./ 9/0567 122/18 167 >=1B/7 3./ >5885C46< 9@:93163418 ?@/9345695>81C - 7 - !" " " # " )*+)*,*-./-01*0)123.4-0)*-215&)'6&))' $ 63./2=/9/63019/3./2814634>>.19/931:849./7 3.13 3./ .167 8516 1B5@63 C19 46 >103 =/2147 56 - 8 - %$ $$ C/88 C43.46 2/=457 5> 3C5 ;/1=9 9342@813/7 @67/= 0563/B25=16/5@9 =/D056E/;160/ 1<=//B/63 E47/ G.495@=37//B943>4335/G3=103G./91B/ 49/G3=103/7C.40.=/17919@67/= ! " !" #$$% & ' ()&* + , - . /( $01-0%--2-- !,3 4 & #( ,5 67 8" 9:;) ; -- ,3 < ;= $01-0%--2-- > ?)0 9:;) @ /( 0 /( ' A B5 C 3 & DEFG &$ D6F !" ' @ H #I) /( J#C? 9K D5 C L* $M0---2-- 67 ' ,3 <= @ /( 5 C= N& L* 0O--2-- !LP #( Q 67 " GR LS 3 & DEFG &$ ;T= /( U L* !$01-0%--2--" 5 C : : P - 9 - P # DE0F @ =? 6K # 4 VC A/( &$W ./ =418 5@=3 C.48/ 169C/=46< 99@/ 5 46 3./ 1>>4=B134E/ 013/<5=40188; ./87 3.13 3./ 2814634>> .17 2=5E/7:53.G167G 60/3./0563/B25=16/5@9 1<=//B/63 713/7 )$ ))) G 49 >5@67 35 :/ 7@8; 2=5E/7167560/=/21;B/635>9 #$%$$ D@67/=G 713/7%$ $$491895./8735://931:849./73.495@=3 49 5> 3./ 056947/=/7 E4/C 3.133./ 2=460428/9 /B:574/7 46 /03456 &0 5> 3./ 2/04>40 /84/> 03 2/=314646< 35 =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 .1E/ 65 12284013456 35 3./ 2=/9/63>103@18B13=4G./2814634>>I90814B75/96531=49/ 5@35>1056E/63456180563=1035>918/:@3=/939/634=/8;56 1 05E/6163 >5= =/D056E/;160/ 0563146/7 46 1 0563/B25=16/5@9 750@B/63 /G/0@3/7 56 3./ E/=;71; 5> 3./=/<493/=/7918/7//7 ./ 2814634>> @6/?@4E50188; 10F65C8/7</9 3.13 ./ /G/0@3/7 1 =/<493/=/7 918/ 7//7 56 )$ ))) - 10 - 5C/E/=.4992/04>40019/493.133./918/C1950019456/7 :;>461604186/0/9943;1673.13./9/0@=/71.16785165> 9 #$$$$ D >=5B 19C163=1;1 3./ >13./= 5> 3./ 7/>/671639H167 3.13 G C19 94B@8316/5@98; /G/0@3/7 19 1 058813/=18 1<=//B/63 5:84<1346< 19C163=1;1 35 =/D 056E/;3./2=52/=3;@256=/21;B/635>3./1B5@63C43.46 3C5 ;/1=9 60/ G 49 ./87 2=5E/7 167 560/ 43 49 100/23/7 3.13 3./ 7/>/671639 =/0/4E/7 9 #$%$$ D 56 %$ $$167/E/6/G/0@3/7G 10F65C8/7<46<9@0. =/0/423 3./ E/=; >5@6713456 56 C.40. 3./ 5@=39 :/85C 46E5F/7 /03456&0:/05B/9@69@931461:8/ 3 49 1895 =/8/E163 3.13 3./ 7/0=// 74=/0346< =/>@67 5> 9 #$%$$ D C.40. 6/0/991=48; 2=/9@2259/9 2=55> 5> =/21;B/63 .19 ://6 1>>4=B/7 :; 3./ +4=93 22/8813/ 5@=3 /9243/ 3.49 :53. 5@=39 .1E/ B4974=/03/7 3./B9/8E/9 :; 1228;46< 3./ 7503=46/ 5> =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 35 1 019/ C./=/ 3./ 2814634>>I9 01@9/ 5> 103456 /B1613/9 >=5B 1 05E/6163 35 =/D056E/; @67/=10563/B25=16/5@91<=//B/637@8;103/7@256:; - 11 - 100/23160/5>=/21;B/63C43.4634B/./=/21;B/63C19 467492@31:8; B17/ 56 %$ $$ 1 71; 2=45= 35 3./ /G24=; 5> 3./ 9342@813/7 3C5D;/1= 2/=457 /6746< 56 )$ $$ 167 3./ 7/>/671639 E58@631=48; 100/23/7 3./ 1B5@63 .@9 3./ ?@/93456 5> 3./ 2814634>> 2=5E46< 056346@5@9 =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 =/8/E163 46 1 931671=71<=//B/63D35D9/8894B28;75/96531=49/ # ./ 7503=46/ 5> =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 49 133=103/7 C./=/ 3./ 2814634>> 9//F9 /6>5=0/B/63 5> 16 /G/0@35=; 0563=103 >5= 918/ C./=/ 3./ 7/>/67163I9 5:84<13456 35 /G/0@3/ 1 918/ 7//7 1=49/9 568; @256 3./ 2814634>>3/67/=46<3./:18160/918/056947/=1345669@0. 943@134569 3./ 2814634>> B@93 7/B5693=13/ 3.13 ./ C19 18C1;9 =/17; 167 C48846< 35 2/=>5=B .49 =/042=5018 5:84<134569 ./ 2=/9/63 019/ 49 >@671B/63188; 74>>/=/63 3./ 05E/6163 35 =/D056E/; C19 05674345618 568; @256 =/21;B/63 C43.46 3./ 9342@813/7 2/=457 167 3./ 2814634>> .19>@88;05B284/7C43.3.13=/?@4=/B/63 - 12 - ! 6 3./ 019/ 13 .167 3./ 3=169103456 49 /99/634188;56/5>85163.5@<.0193463./>5=B5>1918/ C43. 1 0563/B25=16/5@9 1<=//B/63 35 =/D056E/; ./ /G/0@3456 5> 3./ =/<493/=/7 918/ 7//7 49 653 46 7492@3/ .13 3./ 2814634>> 199/=39 49 3.13 G /G/0@3/7 56 3./ E/=;91B/71;=/2=/9/6391:46746<5:84<13456@67/=31F/6 :; 19C163=1;1 35 =/D056E/; 3./ 9@43 2=52/=3; @256 =/21;B/63 5> 3./ 8516 1B5@63 C43.46 3C5 ;/1=9 '@=492=@7/60/ 49 C/88 9/338/7 3.13 C./=/ 1 918/ 49 1005B2164/7 :; 16 1<=//B/63 35 =/D2@=0.19/ 3./ E/675=I9 =/B/7; 35 /6>5=0/ 3./ 05E/6163 >5= =/D 056E/;160/ 931679 56 1 74934603 >55346< 167 3./ 3=174345618 =/?@4=/B/63 5> 2=5E46< 056346@5@9 =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 B1; 653 1228; 21=340@81=8; C./=/ 3./ 2814634>> .19 46 >103 =/2147 3./ 1B5@63 C43.46 3./ 34B/ /G2=/998;>4G/7@67/=3./1<=//B/63 & 6 3./ 2=/9/63 019/ 3./ =/21;B/63 C19 B17/ C43.46 3./ 9342@813/7 2/=457 10F65C8/7</7 :; 3./ 7/>/671639I>13./=@67/=G 167813/==/1>>4=B/7:;1 - 13 - 7/0=// >5= =/>@67 53. 5@=39 .5C/E/= >148/7 35 122=/0413/ 3./ 3=@/ 613@=/ 5> 3./ 3=169103456 167 /==56/5@98; 12284/7 3./ 7503=46/ 5> =/1746/99 167 C48846<6/99 3./=/:; =/05=746< >46746<9 3.13 1=/ 21821:8; @69@931461:8/./122=510.5>:53.5@=39463=/1346<3./ B133/= 19 4> 43 C/=/ 1 056E/6345618 9@43 >5= 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/ 5> 16 1<=//B/63 35 9/88 =13./= 3.16 /6>5=0/B/63 5> 1 =/056E/;160/ 05E/6163 @67/= 1 0563/B25=16/5@9 1<=//B/63 =/>8/039 1 08/1= B49122=/./694565>81C 569/?@/638; 3./ >46746<9 5> :53. 3./ =418 5@=3 167 3./ +4=93 22/8813/ 5@=3 56 99@/ 5 9@>>/= >=5B2/=E/=943;1671=/841:8/35:/9/31947/005=746<8; 9@:93163418 ?@/93456 5> 81C 54 49 169C/=/7 46 3./ 6/<134E/ 167 9@:93163418 ?@/93456 5> 81C 544 49 1895 169C/=/7463./6/<134E/ )*+)*,*-./-01*0)123.4-0)*215-&)))'1*+&)7' % ./ =418 5@=3 C.48/ 169C/=46< 99@/ 5 46 3./1>>4=B134E/.19013/<5=40188;./873.133./2814634>>.19 - 14 - 2=5E/7 3./ 7@/ /G/0@3456 5> 3./ 0563/B25=16/5@9 750@B/63 713/7 )$ ))) G @67/= C.40. 19C163=1;1 3./ >13./= 5> 3./ 7/>/671639 /G2=/998; @67/=355F35=/D056E/;3./9@4381679@256=/21;B/635> 3./ 1B5@63C43.4612/=457 5>3C5 ;/1=9 ./=4185@=3 .19 >@=3./= ./87 3.13 G 3./ =/0/423 10F65C8/7<46< =/21;B/63 5> 9 #$%$$ D 49 1895 7@8; 2=5E/7 60/ 3./9/ 3C5 750@B/639 C.40. 84/ 13 3./ E/=; 05=/ 5> 3./ 2814634>>I90814B1=/./8735:/2=5E/73.495@=3490188/7 @25635/G1B46/C./3./=:53.5@=39:/85C05BB433/716 /==5=467/084646<3./81=</==/84/>5>92/04>402/=>5=B160/ ) ./ >46746< 56 99@/ 5 169C/=/7 46 3./ 6/<134E/ 35 3./ 7/3=4B/63 5> 3./ 2814634>> 49 08/1=8; 2/=E/=9/167@69@931461:8/./=4185@=32=50//7/756 3./ /==56/5@9 199@B23456 3.13 560/ 3./=/ /G4939 1 =/<493/=/7 918/ 7//7 2@=25=3/78; 056E/;46< 3./ 2=52/=3; 1:958@3/8;16;28/13.133./3=169103456C19463./613@=/ 5> 1 8516 05@28/7 C43. 1 =4<.3 35 9//F =/D056E/;160/ :/05B/94617B4994:8/46E4/C5> /03456) 5>3./67416 - 15 - E47/60/ 03 @0. 16 122=510. =/E/189 1 >@671B/6318 B4974=/03456 46 81C ./ =/84160/ 2810/7 :; 3./ 5@=39 :/85C 56 /03456 ) 49 C.588; B492810/7 5=/ 4B25=31638; /03456)$5>3./67416E47/60/03C.40. 7/189C43.2=/9@B234561935750@B/6393.4=3;;/1=9587 1895.1965B166/=5>12284013456353./2=/9/63019/ $ ./ 2=/9/63 3=169103456 56 1 2=52/= 122=/0413456 5> G 167 9@==5@6746< 04=0@B93160/9 49 56/3.13B@93:/081994>4/7191918/C43.161<=//B/6335 =/D2@=0.19/ ./=/ 3./ 056743456 5> =/D3=169>/= 49 653 4605=25=13/7C43.463./:57;5>3./918/7//7G:@3 49 4693/17 /B:574/7 46 1 9/21=13/ 0563/B25=16/5@9 750@B/63 9@0.19 G/G/0@3/756 3./E/=; 91B/ 71; 16781C75/9653:1=3./17B4994:4843;5>9@0.1750@B/63 69@0.019/9/E47/60//G2814646<3./3=@/613@=/5>3./ 3=169103456 49 2/=B4994:8/ 167 75/9 653 0563=1E/6/ /03456 ) .@9 3./ 2814634>>I9 /E47/60/ 177@0/7 35 /931:849. 3./ =/D056E/;160/ 05E/6163 @67/= G 49 08/1=8;17B4994:8/1678/<188;3/61:8/ - 16 - 53. 3./ =418 5@=3 167 3./ +4=93 22/8813/ 5@=3 122/1= 35 .1E/ ://6 @67@8; 46>8@/60/7 :; 3./ 2814634>>I9199/=34563.133./918/C1950019456/7:;1.167 8516167:;3./0563/B25=16/5@9613@=/5>GC43.5@3 @67/=31F46<3./0=434018/G/=049/5>749346<@49.46<:/3C//6 1B5=3<1</:;05674345618918/1671918/C43.1056743456 35 =/D2@=0.19/ .49 74934603456 49 1 C/88D9/338/7 >10/3 5> 2=52/=3;81C167>148@=/3517E/=3353./9/2=460428/9.19 8/7 :53. 5@=39 :/85C 35 =/05=7 >46746<9 3.13 1=/ B164>/938;2/=E/=9/ ./5@=39:/85C.1E/3./=/>5=/<=5998;/==/7 46=/>@946<3./=/84/>5>92/04>402/=>5=B160/B/=/8;563./ 2=/B49/ 3.13 3./ =/<493/=/7 918/ 7//7 /G/0@3/7 46 >1E5@= 5>3./7/>/671639I>13./=C19165@3D167D5@3918/C43.5@3 056947/=46< 3./ :46746< />>/03 5> 3./ 0563/B25=16/5@9 1<=//B/63 @67/= G 60/ G 49 2=5E/7 167 =/21;B/63 @67/= G 49 /931:849./7 3./ 2814634>> - 17 - 10?@4=/91=4<.335/6>5=0/3./05E/61635>=/D056E/;160/ 3.=5@<.92/04>402/=>5=B160/ 005=746<8;3.495@=3495>3./056947/=/7E4/C 3.13 :53. 5@=39 :/85C >148/7 35 2=52/=8; 122=/0413/ 3./ 613@=/1670.1=103/=5>3./3=1691034561670569/?@/638; /==/7 46 7/084646< 3./ 7490=/34561=; =/84/> 5> 92/04>40 2/=>5=B160/./>46746<9=/05=7/75699@/59167# 1=/ 3.@9 2/=E/=9/ 167 841:8/ 35 :/ 9/3 1947/ @:93163418 @/934565>1C594441674E1=/3./=/>5=/169C/=/7 463./6/<134E/ # +5=3./>5=/<546<=/195693.495@=32199/93./ >5885C46< 4 .//<@81= /056722/1849 44 ./ 0560@==/63 A@7<B/639 5> :53. 3./ 5@=39:/85C1=/./=/:;9/31947/ @435> 3./2814634>>497/0=//7 - 18 - 444 ./7/>/6716391=/0188/7@25635/G/0@3/ 3./ 918/ 7//7 C43.46 1 2/=457 5> 3.=// B563.9>=5B3./713/5>=/0/4235>0/=34>4/7 052;5>3.49A@7<B/63 4E ./ 2814634>> 49 /63438/7 35 /G/0@3/ 3./ 7/0=//4>3./7/>/671639>14835/G/0@3/3./ 918/7//7C43.463./9342@813/72/=457 E =1C7/0=//1005=746<8; +8 &!!' $ ' 4935 85