Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63321 (KAR)
YALLAPPA AND ORS v. SHANTABAI AND ANR
CRL.RP/200083/2022 · 2025-07-30
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63321 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63321 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#!##
#$
%&'()*+
(*,
-
! " #$
! %
! &
'
! (
)$ # *
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
"'
# $ ! "
# $ #
# $ ! (
)$ #
"'!"!"+ ,
"# $*
#
+ '%)*
+
$
# % "!' '!%"!" $ #+!"!'#
" "! # + )*)$*)+*)* ')*)*)*)*)* "! "" +
+ # + # #
"!!$
$+
#+
#
" "! - 3 -
# + +
#
# -$###
) -$###*
./0/012.3 14 /1 & 53. 3.46127.2/ 14" /1 02 38#0491" "! 12/:.;08.1;/:.8.532.70<08=7>. 527 #+ 0275>0 ?;13 4:13/ @/:. 3058 1=3/AB 527 566.8852/14"/10230C025866.581% "!'12/:. ;08. 1; /:. 8.532.7
770/01258 .440124 =7>. 0D5E56=35 ?;13 4:13/ @/:. +034/ 66.885/. 1=3/AB 53. 4..F02> /1 G=54: /:. D=7>C.2/ 1; /:. 3058 1=3/ 75/.7 !"!'5881H02>/:.6./0/012;08.7IE3.46127.2/1 :.3.02=27.3.9/0124 )*)$*)+*)*')*)*)* )* )* "! 527 "" 1; /:. 31/.9/012 1; 1C.2 ;31C 1C.4/09 018.29. 9/ "!! ?;13 4:13/ @/:. 9/AB 703.9/02> /:. 3.46127.2/4 /:. 6./0/012.34 :.3.02 527 3.46127.2/ 1 /:.3.02 /1 65E 91C6.245/012 1;
- 4 -
4"!!!! 527 3.4/350202> 6./0/012.3 14 527 " ;31C 580.25/02>/:.8527C.2/012.702/:.137.3
" +59/4 1; /:. 954. 02 I30.; 53. /:5/ 3.46127.2/ 14 527 " :.3.02 54 6./0/012.34 ;08.7 38#0491
" "! I.;13./:.30581=3/5>5024/6./0/012.314/1 &:.3.02527521/:.3=27.3.9/0124 )*)$*)+*)* ')*)*)*)*)*"!527""1;9//044/5/.7 /:5/3.46127.2/1:.3.0204/:.8.>588EH.77.7H0;.1; 4:1F2>58.4:H53H:104/:.4121;6./0/012.314527
" 527 I31/:.3 1; 6./0/012.3 14 527 & :.03 C53305>. H54 6.3;13C.7 12 !"! / /:. /0C. 1; C53305>. >1875271/:.353/098.4H.3.>0<.2+1341C./0C./:.E8.7 C530/58 80;. 527 /:.E I.>1//.2 3.46127.2/ 1" / 04 588.>.7 /:5/ /:. :=4I527 H54 57709/.7 /1 <09.4 527 :. /3.5/.7 3.46127.2/ 1 H0/: 93=.8/E =302> "! 4:. H54 1=4/.7 ;13C /:. C5/30C12058 :1=4. 029. /:.2 3.46127.2/1H543.40702>02:.3653.2/4A:1=4.5812> H0/: 3.46127.2/ 1" 029. 3.46127.2/ 1 H54
- 5 -
4=ID.9/.7 /1 71C.4/09 <018.29. H0/:1=/ 65E02> C502/.2529.4:.;08.7/:.6./0/0124..F02><5301=4137.34
:.6./0/012.34:.3.02:5<.566.53.7I.;13./:. 3058 1=3/ 527 7.20.7 /:. 912/.2/0124 /5F.2 IE /:. 3.46127.2/4 :. H0;. .J5C02.7 :.34.8; 54 .J5C02.7 " 527 >1/ C53F.7 J4 /1 :. 6./0/012.34 .J5C02.7 /1 527 >1/ C53F.7 J4 /1 02 4=6613/ 1; /:.03 912/.2/012 :. 3058 1=3/5;/.3/5F02>02/1912407.35/012588/:.4.C5/.3058412 3.91376544.7/:.137.375/.7!"!'IE5881H02>/:. 6./0/012 5>5024/ /:. 6./0/012.34 527 703.9/02> /1 65E 91C6.245/012 1; 4"!!!! +=3/:.3 6./0/012.3 14 527 " :.3.02 H.3. 3.4/3502.7 ;31C 580.25/02> /:. 8527 I.5302> E1" C.54=302>
593.4 527 E1& "$ C.54=302> 593.4 40/=5/.7 5/
1F5/2=3 <0885>. 0275>0 $.02> 5>>30.<.7 IE /:. 45C. /:. 6./0/012.34 :5<. 63.;.33.7 30C0258 66.58 1% "!' :. +034/ 66.885/. 1=3/ 12 3.5663.905/012 1; C5/.30584
- 6 -
123.9137704C044.7/:.566.58$.02>5>>30.<.7IE/:. 45C./:.6./0/012.34:5<.63.;.33.7/:046./0/012
& .537304:1F#=85>.8.532.791=24.8;13/:.
6./0/012.35273053=25/08C09=4=305.;133.46127.2/ 1.3=4.7/:.C5/.30584123.9137
2 <0.H 1; /:. 30<58 912/.2/0124 =3>.7 IE /:. 8.532.791=24.8;13I1/:/:.653/0.4/:.6102//:5/H1=87 5304.;13CE912407.35/01204
! "#"$%
#E 524H.3 /1 /:. 5I1<. 6102/ 04
;13/:.;1881H02>
:. 3.85/0124:06 I./H..2 /:. 653/0.4 04 21/ 02 7046=/. ./0/012.3 1 04 /:. ;5/:.3 6./0/012.3 1" 04 /:.C1/:.35276./0/012.314527&53./:.I31/:.341;
- 7 -
/:.:=4I5271;3.46127.2/1.46127.2/1"04/:. 75=>:/.31;3.46127.2/1
% .532.7 91=24.8 ;13 /:. 6./0/012.34 912/.27.7 /:5/ /:. :=4I527 :57 ;08.7 #1 "! 4..F02> 70<139. H:09: 04 4/088 6.2702> 912407.35/012 I.;13. /:. +5C08E 1=3/ .46127.2/ 1 :.3.02 :57 ;08.7 5 91C68502/ 3.>04/.3.7 02 30C. 1"% "! 1; 5735C0
1809. /5/012 21H 6.2702> I.;13. /:. 8.532.7 #+ .H53>0 02 1! "! ;13 /:. 1;;.29.4 6=204:5I8. =27.3 .9/0124 &' !& ! 1; :. :54 ;08.7 /:. 4=0/
1 "! ;13 653/0/012 527 4.6535/. 6144.44012 2 /:. C.52/0C. 38#0491" "! 04 584195C./1I.;08.74..F02>3.80.;=27.39/
:. 128E >30.<529. 3504.7 IE /:. 8.532.7 91=24.8 ;13 /:. 6./0/012.34 04 H0/: 3.>537 /1 /:. 137.3 3.4/350202> 6./0/012.3 14 527 " :.3.02 ;31C 580.25/02> /:. 8527 I.5302> E1" C.54=302> 593.4 527 E1& "$ C.54=302> 593.4 40/=5/.7 5/
1F5/2=3
- 8 -
<0885>.0275>0/58=F.>53702>/:.1/:.3137.346544.7 IE/:.30581=3/8.532.791=24.8;13/:.6./0/012.34:54 21/3504.752E1ID.9/012540/6.3/5024/1/:.137.321//1 91CC0/71C.4/09<018.29.13/:.137.36544.75>5024//:. :=4I5271;3.46127.2/1:.3.02
' #E5//.2/012H54735H2IE/:.8.532.791=24.8 ;13/:.6./0/012.34/1J/:.3.91371;30>:/46.3/50202> /1 /:. 85274 3.;.33.7 /1 5I1<. 4 6.3 /:.4. 719=C.2/4 E1" 4/5274 02 /:. 25C. 1; 6./0/012.3 1 527 E1& "$ C.54=302> 593.4 4/5274 02 /:. 25C. 1; 6./0/012.3 1" / 04 /:. 912/.2/012 1; 6./0/012.3 14 527 " /:5/ /:.4. 6316.3/0.4 53. /:.03 4.8; 59G=03.7 6316.3/0.4 527 /:. :=4I527 1; 3.46127.2/ 1 :54 21 30>:/H:5/41.<.31<.3/:.45C.7=302>/:.0380;./0C.:. 0C6=>2.7 D=7>C.2/ 6544.7 IE /:. 3058 1=3/ 7049814.4 /:5//:.1=3/:543.;.33.7/1/:.3.91371;30>:/4J 527 5271I4.3<.7/:5/ 6./0/012.314527 " :.3.02 53./:.1H2.341;/:.45076316.3/0.4$=/02460/.1;/:5/ 6319..7.7 /1 6544 /:. 0C6=>2.7 137.3 3.4/350202> /:.C
- 9 -
;31C 580.25/02> /:. 6316.3/0.4 6.3C52.2/8E 1 1/:.3 3.54125I8.>31=27453.5440>2.7IE/:.30581=3/13IE /:.+034/66.885/.1=3//14=4/5024=9:137.3
! .532.7 91=24.8 ;13 /:. 6./0/012.34 6859.4 3.80529.12/:.7.90401202/:.954.1;
H:.3.02 /:.6.J1=3/912407.3.7/:.30>:/1;5H0;./1>./3.80.; =27.39/.;.3302>/1.9/0124&527" 1;027= 716/012 527 #502/.2529. 9/ H:09: 04 :5<02> 52 1<.330702> .;;.9/ 1<.3 /:. 9/ /:. 6.J 1=3/ :54 :.875/6535"&54=27.3
"& &'
(
)! *
+
,! & ' ! ,
&
-
-. -/"##0112. - 10 -
(
(! 3(
(! ! (
(
&%
:=4 /:.
6140/012 1; 85H 04 <.3E H.88 4.//8.7 :.0C6=>2.7D=7>C.2/6544.7IE/:.30581=3/527IE /:. +034/ 66.885/. 1=3/ 3.4/3502 6./0/012.3 14 527 " :.3.02 I.02> /:. 1H2.34 1; /:. 85274 02 G=.4/012 ;31C 580.25/02>/:.45C.H:09:04=24=4/5025I8..29.5C 1; /:. 1602012 /:5/ /1 /:5/ .J/.2/ /:. 0C6=>2.7 137.3 6544.7IE/:.30581=3/912;03C.7IE/:.+034/66.885/. 1=3/ 95884 ;13 02/.3;.3.29. 9913702>8E 524H.3 /:. 5I1<.6102/653/8E02/:.5;;03C5/0<.5276319..7/16544 /:.;1881H02>
)0* :..<04012./0/01204
)00* :. 137.3 75/.7 !"!' 6544.7 02 38#0491" "! 12 /:. ;08. 1; /:. 0<08 =7>. 527 #+ 0275>0 3.4/350202>
- 11 -
6./0/012.314527":.3.02;31C580.25/02> /:.8527I.5302>E14" C.54=302> 593.4 527 E1& "$ C.54=302> 593.4 40/=5/.75/
1F5/2=3<0885>.0275>0/58=F04
)000* :. 1/:.3 613/012 1; /:. 137.3 1; /:. 3058 1=3/04912;03C.7
.>04/3E 04 703.9/.7 /1 4.27 I59F /:. 3058 1=3/ 527 66.885/.1=3/3.91374
.+ (##* ! 04/181