Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63309 (KAR)

HDFC ERGO GENERAL INS. CO. LTD v. GURUNATH AND ANR

MFA/202033/2018 · 2025-09-19

Ashok S Kinagi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $% "" &'( )* "" +&'( ) * ! " # !! ! $ $% ! & '$ !!!( ()* !! $ +$ +$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $' !$! ' & ! !$!$ $ $ ,$'' ! " $ # ! $ $'- $ $ % ' ' $$ *(#%' $ $ $ $ $$ $'' * $ $$! $ $ !)* ( $ $ $ $ $ $ $ ! ) + * $' !!$ ' & !$!$ $ # $ ,$ % " # ! $ $% ! - 3 - ) ! ! & '$ !!( ()* !! $ +$ +$ ! " $ # ! $' $ $ % ' ' $ $ *(#% ' $ $$$$ $$ ! ! * !)* ( $ $$! $$ ' $ ! ' ' $ $ $ $ $ $ .! ! - 4 - % /010213044560781'291:;;0541<240=86=09 03:276 *(#% 7< :/0 7:79 0/23401 3: ) #/090265<:09 90<0990= :7 51 >:/0 3:? <79 1/79:% 59210 78: 7< :/0 @8=AB06: 56= 5C59= =5:0= ! ! * ;5110= 26 7!)* ( DE :/0 ==2:27654 06279 2F24 8=A0 56= 7:79332=06:452B192D86545:545D895A2! ! '53:1A2F26A9210:7<2426A7<:/0105;;0541D920<4E 1:5:0= 590 :/5: 76 *! G! 5: 5D78: ! ;!B! :/0 ;0:2:27609 C51 ;97300=26A 76 097 76=5 B7:793E340 D05926A90A21:95:2767!( &*G!/06/0C516059 :/05332=06:1;7:5::/5::2B076009776=5BD2:276 B7:793E340 D05926A 90A21:95:276 7!!( ()* 35B0 <97B D53H 12=0 26 5 /2A/ 1;00= 56= 951/ 56= 60A42A06: B56609 56= =51/0= :7 :/0 B7:793E340 7< :/0 ;0:2:27609! $80 :7 C/23/ :/0 ;0:2:27609 181:5260= A920F781 26@89201! 0630 :/0 ;0:2:27609 <240= 5 3452B ;0:2:276 86=09 03:276 II 7< :/0 3: 100H26A 37B;0615:276 76 533786: 7< :/0 26@892011:5260=26:/0975=:95<<235332=06:! - 5 - (! /0 92D8654 21180= 67:230 :7:/07C609 7< :/0 7<<06=26A F0/2340! 61;2:0 7< 109F230 7< 67:230 :/0 7C609 90B5260=8690;90106:0=56=/0C51;4530=0J;59:0! G! /0 61895630 7B;56E <240= 1:5:0B06: 7< 7D@03:2761 =06E26A :/0 5F09B06:1 B5=0 26 :/0 3452B ;0:2:276 56= 376:06=0= :/5: :/0 92=09 7< :/0 7<<06=26A B7:793E340C5167:;71101126AF542=56=0<<03:2F0=92F26A 42306305176:/0=5:07<:/05332=06:56=:/090<790:/090 21 D9053/ 7< ;7423E 376=2:276! 0630 76 :/21 A9786=1 ;95E0=:7=21B211:/03452B;0:2:276! ! /0 92D8654 76 :/0 D5121 7< :/0 ;405=26A1 7< :/0;59:201<95B0=:/09040F56:211801! I! /0 ;0:2:27609 :7 18D1:56:25:0 /21 3510 0J5B260=/2B104<51!0J5B260=:/0=73:7951! 56= A7: B59H0= ( =738B06:1 51 J! :7 J!(! 6 90D8::54 :/0 61895630 7B;56E 0J5B260= 2:1 7<<2309 51 !D8:67=738B06:1C090B59H0=! - 6 - *! /0 92D8654 5<:09 90379=26A :/0 0F2=0630 /05926A D7:/ 12=01 56= 76 511011B06: 7< :/0 F09D54 56= =738B06:59E 0F2=0630 5447C0= :/0 3452B ;0:2:276 26 ;59: C2:/ 371:1 56= 5C59=0= 37B;0615:276 7< 1!)G C2:/ 26:0901: 5: :/0 95:0 7< IK ;!5! <97B :/0 =5:0 7< ;0:2:276:2442:190542L5:276!/092D8654/04=:/5::/07C609 56=:/0 618956307B;56E590@726:4E56=10F09544E425D40 :7 ;5E :/0 37B;0615:276 5B786: 56= =2903:0= :/0 61895630 7B;56E :7 =0;712: :/0 06:290 37B;0615:276 5B786:C2:/533980=26:0901:! ! /0 61895630 7B;56E 5AA920F0= DE :/0 2B;8A60=@8=AB06:56=5C59=;5110=DE:/092D865426 <51:0626A :/0 425D242:E /51 <240= 5;;054 26 ' 7! (( 56=:/0;0:2:27609D026A=2115:21<20=C2:/ :/037B;0615:2765C59=0=DE:/092D8654<240=5;;05426 ' 7! ((* * 100H26A <79 06/5630B06: 7< 37B;0615:276! - 7 - )! 059= :/0 405960= 3786104 <79 :/0 61895630 7B;56E56=:/0405960=3786104<79:/0;0:2:27609! ! /0405960=3786104<79:/0 618956307B;56E 18DB2:1:/5::/092=097<:/07<<06=26AB7:793E340C5167: ;71101126A F542= 56= 0<<03:2F0 =92F26A 4230630 51 7< :/0 =5:0 7< :/0 5332=06: 56= :/090<790 :/090 C51 D9053/ 7< ;7423E 376=2:2761! /0 18DB2:1 :/5: :/0 92D8654 /51 37BB2::0= 56 09979 26 15==426A :/0 425D242:E 76 :/0 61895630 7B;56E 56= 5417 18DB2:1 :/5: :/0 37B;0615:276 5C59=0= DE :/0 92D8654 21 0J79D2:56:! 0630 76 :/010 A9786=1 1/0 ;95E1 :7 5447C :/0 5;;054 <240=DE:/0 618956307B;56E56=:7=21B211:/05;;054 <240=DE:/0;0:2:27609! ! 405960= 3786104 <79 :/0 ;0:2:27609 18DB2:1:/5::/0 618956307B;56E/51:5H065=0<0630 26 :/0 1:5:0B06: 7< 7D@03:2761 :/5: :/0 92=09 7< :/0 7<<06=26A B7:793E340 C51 67: ;71101126A F542= 56= 0<<03:2F0=92F26A42306305176:/0=5:07<:/05332=06:!0 - 8 - 18DB2:1:/5::/0D89=062176:/0 618956307B;56E:7 01:5D421/ :/0 152= <53:! 0 18DB2:1 :/5: :/0 61895630 7B;56E 0J30;: 0J5B2626A 2:1 7<<2309 /51 67: ;97=830= 56E 90379=1 :7 01:5D421/ :/5: :/0 92=09 7< :/0 B7:793E340 C51 67: ;71101126A F542= 56= 0<<03:2F0 =92F26A 4230630 51 76 :/0 =5:0 7< :/0 5332=06:! 0 5417 18DB2:1 :/5: :/0 37B;0615:276 5C59=0= DE :/0 92D8654 21 76 :/0 47C09 12=0! 0630 76 :/010 A9786=1 /0 ;95E1 :7 5447C :/0 5;;054 <240= DE :/0 ;0:2:27609 56= :7 =21B211 :/0 5;;054 <240=DE:/0 618956307B;56E! ! 09810= :/0 90379=1 56= 37612=090= :/0 18DB21127617<405960=3786104<79:/0;59:201! (! /0 ;726: :/5: 592101 <79 37612=095:276 7< :/21 789: 21 26 90A59= :7 425D242:E 56= M856:8B 7< 37B;0615:276! G! /090 21 67 =21;8:0 C2:/ 90A59= :7 :/0 7338990630 7< :/0 5332=06: 56= :/0 26@89201 181:5260= DE :/0;0:2:2760926:/0975=:95<<235332=06:!/0;0:2:27609:7 - 9 - 18D1:56:25:0 /21 3510 0J5B260= /2B104< 51 ! 56= /0 /51 902:095:0= :/0 3452B ;0:2:276 5F09B06:1 26 :/0 0J5B265:276263/20< 56= :7 ;97F0 :/5: :/0 5332=06: /51 7338990= =80 :7 951/ 56= 60A42A06: 92=26A 7< :/0 92=09 7< :/0B7:793E340:/0;0:2:27609/51;97=830=309:2<20=37;E 7<:/03/59A01/00:B59H0=51J!(C/23/=21347101:/5: :/03/59A01/00:21<240=5A5261::/092=097<:/07<<06=26A B7:793E340 <79 :/0 7<<06301 ;8621/5D40 86=09 03:2761 *) (( 7< 56= 03:276 * 7< :/0 3:! '97B ;098154 7< :/0 3/59A0 1/00: 2: =21347101 :/5: :/0 ;74230 /5F0 67: <240= 3/59A0 1/00: <79 :/0 7<<0630 ;8621/5D40 86=09 03:276 ( 7< :/0 3:! /0 D89=06 21 76 :/0 618956307B;56E:701:5D421/:/5:517<:/0=5:07<:/0 5332=06::/092=097<:/0B7:793E340C5167:;71101126A F542=56=0<<03:2F0=92F26A4230630!/0 618956307B;56E 0J30;: 0J5B2626A 2:1 7<<2309 51 ! /51 67: ;97=830= 56E 7:/09 =738B06:1 :7 01:5D421/ :/5: :/0 92=09 7< :/0 7<<06=26A B7:793E340 C51 67: ;71101126A F542= 56= 0<<03:2F0 =92F26A 4230630 51 7< :/0 =5:0 7< :/0 5332=06:! - 10 - /090<790 :/0 92D8654 C51 @81:2<20= 26 <51:0626A :/0 425D242:E@726:4E56=10F09544E76:/07C60956=:/02618909 7<:/07<<06=26AB7:793E340!0630 =767:<26=56E09979 26 :/0 2B;8A60= @8=AB06: 56= 5C59= ;5110= DE :/0 92D8654! 376389C2:/:/0<26=26A90379=0=DE:/092D8654 76 :/0 ;726: 7< 425D242:E! 0630 561C09 :/0 ;726: C2:/ 90A59=:7425D242:E53379=26A4E! ! 617<59 51 M856:8B 7< 37B;0615:276 21 37630960= 5=B2::0=4E :/0 ;0:2:27609 C51 5A0= 5D78: G E05915176:/0=5:07<:/05332=06:! :21376:06=0=:/5: :/0 ;0:2:27609 C51 56 5A92384:8921: 56= 059626A 1! ;09 5668B! 7 18D1:56:25:0 :/0 15B0 :/0 ;0:2:27609 /51 67: ;97=830= 56E 2637B0 ;977<! 6 :/0 5D10630 7< ;977< 7< 2637B0 :/0 92D8654 /51 :5H06 :/0 2637B0 5: 1!I C/23/ 21 76 :/0 47C09 12=0! 6 :/0 5D10630 7< ;977< 7< 2637B0 :/0 789: /51 :7 511011 :/0 2637B051;09:/013/0=84067:2<20=DE:/05965:5H50A54 09F23018:/792:E! 2630:/05332=06:217<:/0E059 51 - 11 - ;09:/013/0=84067:276542637B07<:/0;0:2:27609/51:7D0 5110110=5:1!I ;09B76:/! I! /0;0:2:27609:7;97F0:/0;09B5606:=215D242:E 0J5B260= :/0 =73:79 51 ! C/7 /5= 21180= =215D242:E 309:2<235:0B59H0=51J!)56=/0/5==0;710=:/5:/0/51 0J5B260= :/0 ;0:2:27609 342623544E 56= 95=2747A23544E 56= 7;260=:/5::/0;0:2:27609/5=18<<090==215D242:E:7560J:06: 7<(K:7:/0C/740D7=E!7C0F09:/092D8654/51:5H06 :/0=215D242:E5:K!7612=0926A:/00F2=06307<:/0=73:79 56=:/0B0=235490379=1:/21789:217<:/07;26276:/5::/0 =215D242:E 5110110= DE :/0 92D8654 21 76 :/0 47C09 12=0! /81 5B 7< :/0 7;26276 :/5: :/0 ;09B5606: =215D242:E 18<<090= DE :/0 ;0:2:27609 /51 :7 D0 37612=090= 5: K! 5H26A 26:7 533786: :/0 5A0 7< :/0 ;0:2:27609 C/7 C51 G E0591 5: :/0 :2B0 7< 5332=06: B84:2;4209 7< NO /51 :7 D0 5=7;:0=51;09:/0@8=AB06:7<:/076.D40 8;90B0789: 26 :/0 3510 7< 90;79:0= 26 !"# $ ! /090<790 :/0;0:2:27609C784=D006:2:40=:7:/037B;0615:276:7C59=1 - 12 - 4711 7< <8:890 2637B0 5: 1! #1!I & & & %! *! 7612=0926A:/065:8907<26@89201181:5260=DE :/0 ;0:2:27609 56= 5417 :/0 0F2=0630 7< !=73:79 :/21 789: 90511011 :/0 37B;0615:276 5C59=0= 86=09 :/0 <7447C26A/05=1 ",-./012,-3 45673,./7 ,8,-969 :; .<6-/:17,2 45673,./7 ,8,-969 :; .</31-. 52656=18<<0926A 1!G 1!I 0=23540J;06101 1!(G 1!(G 7117<<8:8902637B0 1!)GG 1! ::06=56:?13/59A01 <77=56=376F0E5630 1!I 1! 7117<5B062:20156= 68:92:276<77= 1! 1! 7117<2637B0=8926A :/0;0927=7< :905:B06: 1! 1!( .,2 3 # # =) 17969. 3 # =#) 3=# =# =) - 13 - ! /81 :/0 ;0:2:27609 21 06:2:40= :7 5 :7:54 37B;0615:276 7< 1!GGG 51 5A5261: 1!)G 5C59=0= DE :/0 92D8654! /81 :/0 ;0:2:27609 21 06:2:40= <7906/5630=37B;0615:2767<1!( G ! )! 6 F20C 7< :/0 5D7F0 =213811276 ;97300= :7 ;511:/0<7447C26A 2! /05;;05426'7! (( <240=DE :/0 618956307B;56E21 ! 22! /05;;05426'7! ((* *<240=DE :/0;0:2:2760921 222! /0@8=AB06:56=5C59==5:0=! ! * ;5110=DE:/092D8654267!)* ( 21 B7=2<20=! /0 ;0:2:27609 21 06:2:40= :7 06/5630=37B;0615:2767<1!( G 26 5==2:276 :7 :/0 37B;0615:276 5C59=0= DE :/092D86545476AC2:/26:0901:5::/095:0 7< IK ;!5! <97B :/0 =5:0 7< <2426A 7< :/0 3452B;0:2:276:244:/0=5:07<90542L5:276! - 14 - 2F! /0 61895630 7B;56E 21 =2903:0= :7 =0;712: :/0 37B;0615:276 5B786: C2:/ 533980= 26:0901: C2:/26 02A/: C00H1 <97B :/0=5:07<90302;:7<37;E7<:/21@8=AB06:! F! /0 5B786: 26 =0;712: 21 79=090= :7 D0 :9561B2::0=:7:/092D8654! F2! /0 0A21:9E 21 =2903:0= :7 106= D53H :/0 9254 789: 90379=1 56= 5B786: 26 =0;712: :7:/092D8654! 9) &( % 21:7! 47! :