Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63308 (KAR)
MADIVALAPPA v. SHRISHAIL AND ANR
MFA/202897/2024 · 2025-11-06
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63308 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63308 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%! & '!%! & '!"'# " ! !%%
(#) *
!"#$# %
&
'(
#
)
#! !*#)
# + + !"#$#
%
&
#
$"##$ , +
(
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
+ #* &#( +
#-!! ( +
( +
#$#$ # $$++
+
."$$
+
/
+
0
0
' &
0
(
#
12. 344536 7895: 5;<2=8 #*&#( => =<=: 512;65. ;< #-!! &15:5283><5: :5>5::59 <= 3. ?<15 ;</( 13. @558 >2659 @A <15 ;632B38< ;136658C28C <15 D79CB58< 93<59 #$#$43..59@A<15:28;2436 582=:2E2679C5389 5B@5:2D3A347:28= # $$
- 3 -
+3;<. C2E28C :2.5 <= <15 >2628C => <15 344536 @:25>6A .<3<593:5<13<=8 $ $$3<3@=7<*$F158<15 ;632B38< 36=8C F2<1 12. >:2589 F3. 4:=;55928C =8 B=<=:;A;65 @53:28C :5C2.<:3<2=8 =! $)$* >:=B 2D3A347: <=F3:9. =893C762 3< <13< <2B5 =8 2D3A347:
2893C2
=3936=::A@53:28C:5C2.<:3<2=8=)! -*" ;3B5 >:=B =44=.2<5 .295 @528C 9:2E58 @A 2<. 9:2E5: 3< 3 12C1 .4559 389 28 3 :3.1 389 85C62C58< B3885: 93.159 28<= <15 E512;65 => <15 ;632B38< . 3 :5.76< => <15 3>=:5.329 3;;2958< <15 ;632B38< .7.<32859 C:25E=7. 28D7:25.389F3..12><59<=/.1=.42<362D3A347:
15;632B38<>2659345<2<2=87895: 5;<2=8#""=><15 ;<.55G28C;=B458.3<2=8<F3.4653959<13<15.458< .2C82>2;38<3B=78<<=F3:9.B592;365H458.5.;=8E5A38;5 ;13:C5. 389 =<15: :563<59 ;=.<. < F3. >7:<15: 4653959 <13< <15 3;;2958< =;;7::59 .=656A =8 3;;=78< => :3.1 389 85C62C58<9:2E28C=><15=>>58928CE512;65@A2<.9:2E5:
- 4 -
) 4=8 .5:E2;5 => 8=<2;5 <15 :5.4=8958<. 13E5 34453:59<1:=7C1;=78.56389>2659<152:.543:3<5F:2<<58 .<3<5B58< 958A28C <15 3E5:B58<. B395 28 <15 ;632B 45<2<2=8
8 <15 @3.2. => <15 4653928C. => <15 43:<25. <15 632B.:2@7836>:3B59<152..75.389<15:53><5::5;=:959 <15 5E2958;5 15 :2@7836 @A 2B47C859 D79CB58< 389 3F3:913.43:<6A366=F59<15;632B45<2<2=83891569<13< <15;632B38<2.58<2<659<=;=B458.3<2=8=>
.#*!"!$-
36=8CF2<128<5:5.<3<<15:3<5=>"I4338992:5;<59<15 8.7:38;5 =B438A <= 954=.2< <15 ;=B458.3<2=8 3B=78< 36=8C F2<1 28<5:5.< 528C 3CC:25E59 <15 4:5.58< 344536 13.@558>2659
" 53:859 ;=78.56 34453:28C >=: <15 ;632B38< 13. ;=8<58959<13<975<=<153;;2958<;632B38<13..7>>5:59 C:25E=7. 28D7:25. 5 13. 5H3B2859 <15 9=;<=: 3. 15 9=;<=: 28 12. 5E2958;5 954=.59 <13< ;632B38< 13. .7.<32859 .5E5:5 ;:7.1 28D7:A <= 65>< 6=F5: 62B@ 75 <=
- 5 -
3;;2958<3628D7:A<1592.3@262<A3..5..59@A<15:2@78363< $I2.=86=F5:.295
* 5;=896A1513.;=8<58959<13<975<=<153;;2958< <15 ;632B38< 13. .7.<32859 C:25E=7. 28D7:25. 5 F3. <:53<593.382843<258<>=:345:2=9=>#*93A.E583><5:
92.;13:C5 >:=B <15 1=.42<36 15 F3. 8=< 28 3 4=.2<2=8 <= 92.;13:C5 12. :5C763: F=:G 5 13. .7>>5:59 6=< => 4328 97:28C <:53<B58< =8.295:28C <15 .3B5 <15 ;=B458.3<2=83F3:959@A<15:2@78367895:<151539.=> 06=.. => 3B582<25.0 04328 389 .7>>5:28C.0 389 =<15: 28;2958<365H458.5.3:5=8<156=F5:.295
! 3.<6A 15 13. ;=8<58959 <13< 5E58 9=;<=: 13. 3..5..59 <15 92.3@262<A 3< $I 28 E25F => 3B47<3<2=8 => 65>< 65C @56=F <15 G855 975 <= <15 3;;2958< 15 13. <= .7>>5:<12.92.3@262<AF12;13>>5;<.12.3E=;3<2=88E25F=> D79CB58<=>45H=7:<28<15;3.5=>
- 6 -
<15 ;632B38< 2.
36.= 58<2<659 >=: >7<7:5 4:=.45;<.58;515.=7C1<>=:366=F28C<15344536
- 5: ;=8<:3 653:859 ;=78.56 34453:28C >=: 28.7:38;5 ;=B438A 13. ;=8<58959 <13< 5E58 <1=7C1 65>< 65C @56=F <15G8552.3B47<3<593.45:<155E2958;5=><159=;<=:
<15 F1=65@=9A 92.3@262<A 2. $I ;;=:928C6A <15 :2@783613.:2C1<6A3..5..59F1=65@=9A92.3@262<A3< $I .28;5 <15 28D7:25. .7>>5:59 @A <15 ;632B38< 3:5 B28=: 28 83<7:5=8.295:28C<155E2958;5=><159=;<=:<1528D7:A .7>>5:59 @A <15 ;632B38< 389 <15 B592;36 :5;=:9. <15 ;=B458.3<2=8 3F3:959 @A <15 :2@7836 >=: 4328 389 .7>>5:28C6=..=>3B582<25.=<15:28;2958<365H458.5.3:5 D7.<389:53.=83@6558;515.=7C1<>=:92.B2..36=><15 344536
#$ 53:9 <15 653:859 ;=78.56 >=: <15 43:<25. 389 45:7.59<15D79CB58<3893F3:9=><15:2@7836
## < 2. 8=< 28 92.47<5 <13< ;632B38< 13. .7>>5:59 38 28D7:A 28 3 :=39 <:3>>2; 3;;2958< =;;7::59 =8 $ $$
- 7 -
975 <= :3.1 389 85C62C58< 9:2E28C => 9:2E5: => <15 =::A @53:28C
5C=)! -*" 75<=<153;;2958<;632B38< 13..7>>5:59<15>=66=F28C28D7:A
# 15;632B38<13.5H3B2859:.1=G3A3G3. 8 12. 5E2958;5 15 13. 954=.59 <13< ;632B38< 13. .7.<32859.5E5:5;:7.128D7:A<=<1565><6=F5:62B@@56=F <15G85513.@5583B47<3<59389<159=;<=:13.3..5..59 <15 F1=65@=9A 92.3@262<A 3< $I E58 3. 45: <15 .;159765 => B46=A55. =B458.3<2=8 ;< >=: <15 3B47<3<2=8 => <15 @56=F <15 G855 => <15 6=F5: 62B@ <15
- 8 -
92.3@262<A 2. <3G58 3. $I =8.295:28C <15 5E2958;5 => <159=;<=:389B592;36:5;=:9.F53:5=><15=4282=8<13< :2@78362.D7.<2>25928;=8.295:28C<15F1=65@=9A92.3@262<A 3< $I 15 :2@7836 13. :2C1<6A 3..5..59 <15 B=8<16A 28;=B5=><15;632B38<3. .#)* $ 45:B=8<1
# 8E25F=><15D79CB58<=>45H=7:<28<15;3.5=>
<15 ;632B38< 2. 58<2<659 >=:
>7<7:5 4:=.45;<. < <15 <2B5 => 3;;2958< <15 ;632B38< F3. 3C59 3@=7< A53:. )$I => <15 28;=B5 => <15 ;632B38< 13. <= @5 39959 >=: >7<7:5 4:=.45;<. 15 B76<24625: 34462;3@65 <= <15 3C5 C:=74 2. ?#!/ 17. <15 ;632B38< 2. 58<2<659 >=: ;=B458.3<2=8 => +
$,$ - &
.$" $J#J#!J $I( =8 3;;=78< => 06=.. => >7<7:5 28;=B50
#) 75 <= <15 3;;2958< <15 ;632B38< 13. .7>>5:59 C:25E=7.28D7:25.38936.=7895:C=85.7:C5:A=8.295:28C <15 4:=6=8C59 4328 97:28C <:53<B58< 3. F566 3. <15 45:B3858< 92.3@262<A ;5:<2>259 @A <15 9=;<=: F5 3:5
- 9 -
28;62859 <= 58138;5 <15 ;=B458.3<2=8 3F3:959 @A <15 :2@7836 7895: <15 1539 => 04328 389 .7>>5:28C.0 >:=B . $$$$ <=+$-389 7895: <15 1539 =>06=.. =>3B582<25.0>:=B
. $$$$ <=+
$-
# 15:2@783613.3F3:959
.! $$ <=F3:9.6=..=> 28;=B5 97:28C <15 6329 74 45:2=9 7< <15 28D7:25.
.7.<32859@A<15;632B38<.7CC5.<.<13<<15;632B38<B7.< 13E5 @558 7895: :5.< 389 <:53<B58< >=: 3 45:2=9 => #* 93A.15:5>=:5<15;632B38<2.58<2<659>=:;=B458.3<2=8 => +$ - &
.#)* $J B=8<1.( 7895: <15 1539 ?6=..=>28;=B597:28C63297445:2=9/
#" =8.295:28C<1583<7:5=>28D7:25.<15;=B458.3<2=8 3F3:959 @A <15 :2@7836 7895: =<15: 1539. 2. D7.< 389 :53.=83@65
#*
17. <15 ;632B38< 2. 58<2<659 <= <15 >=66=F28C ;=B458.3<2=8
- 10 -
./01+2341 516076407013 026+ +28276069: 3;0749512< (+) +2827606 9:3;4+573 (+) 328389.7>>5:28C. . $$$$
.* $$$
592;365H458.5. .! $-
.! $-
=..=>28;=B5 97:28C63297445:2=9 .! $$
.)) $
=..=>3B582<25. . $$$$
." $$$
=..=>>7<7:528;=B5 .# -$$$ .$$$
32< +$
$-
$$-
#! 8<15:5.76<<15>=66=F28C=:95:2.43..59
3( 153445362.2<<80641/273 @( 15 D79CB58< => <15 632B. :2@7836 2.B=92>259 ;( 15 ;632B38< 2. 58<2<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=B458.3<2=8 => + $$- 3. 3C328.< .#*!"!$- 3F3:959@A<15:2@7836
- 11 -
9( 158.7:38;5=B438A2.92:5;<59<= 954=.2< <15 ;=B458.3<2=8 3B=78< 36=8C F2<1 28<5:5.<3<"I43>:=B<1593<5=>>2628C=><15 ;632B45<2<2=8<266<1593<5=>:5362K3<2=8F2<1283 45:2=9 => .2H F55G. >:=B <15 93<5 => :5;524< => ;=4A=><12.D79CB58< 5( 15 344=:<2=8B58< 954=.2< 389 :5653.5=>3B=78<.1366@5B39528<5:B.=><15 3F3:9=><15:2@7836
!6- (%!) '
!6- ("'# ") '
2.<=# 6=#)