- 1 - ! "#$ %$&!$!$ '$!( ! " # $ %# # % & % # ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ( # # ' ( &' # ) ! "#* #% + # %'$ ) % ' ,% % $ ) % %% & & ( ' ' ( % $ ) % - - ( $ % % ) ) % % % - 3 - % ) .* # ".* #$ /01023234506786090:4602/374;629035<8<<630=0> 9? 2/0 8@2345 45 2/0 1862 4: 607145>05278;2/4632307 35 ;23A3B35< 1462345 4: 2/036 1641062? 35 ?4 - :46 2/0 1;614704::46C82345@45726;@23454:648>:64C068<068 *8A3905@/3 =38 8>/86 85> #8C8A81;6 =3AA8<0 " &DC$ ;5>06 2/0 68>/85 85263 68C 8>8D 4E858 "$ @/0C0 /0@8704:2/010232345067372/822/0?8602/0 4F50673514770773454:850G20524:8@607&-<;52874: A85> 35 ?4 - F/3@/ 35@A;>07 <;5287 4: /42 #/8689A85>732;820>828>/86=3AA8<083@/;6 8A;D85> 37263@2F/3@/10232345067@A83C24/8=035/06320>2/64;</ 2/03685@072467 /060=05;060@46>760:A0@235<2/058C07 4:2/01023234506737164>;@0>82550G;60 - 4 - & /0 @870 4:2/010232345067 372/82 24F86>7 2/0 74;2/06573>04:2/0783>A85>2/0600G3727872608CF/3@/ 37 8A74 :46C7 1862 4: 2/0 @;A23=89A0 8608 /82 2/0 607145>052 47 85> ' 35 :;62/0685@0 24 & @/0C0 /8=0 28D05 ;1 648> :46C82345 F46D 35 83@/;6 ;68A 770C9A? 457232;05@? 7286235< :64C 068<068 24 *8A3905@/3=388>/8685>#8C8A81;6=3AA8<0248>37285@0 4: &DC7 /0783>648>1877072/64;</2/01641062? 4:2/01023234506735?4 - /822/0607145>05247 85> ' F32/4;2 353238235< 164@00>35<7 ;5>06 2/0 811A3@89A0 A8F:468@H;3635<2/0A85>85>18?35<2/0@4C10578234587 106 A8F /8=0 /3</ /85>0>A? 8220C120> 24 :46C 2/0 648> 4=06 2/014623454: 2/0 1641062? 90A45<35< 2410232345067 /82 10232345067 /8> :3A0> 7;32 35 "%$4 F/3@/ @8C0 24 90 >37C3770> :46 542 @4C1A?35< F32/ 2/0 377;85@04:7282;246?5423@0;5>060@23454: /82 2/0 607145>05278;2/4632307 58C0A? 607145>052 47 85> ' /8> 377;0> 5423@0 24 2/0 10232345067@8AA35<;1452/0C2460C4=02/0@6417285>35< - 5 - 45 2/0 /42 #/8689 A85> 0589A35< 2/0C 24 :86C 2/0 648> 5 60714570 2/0604: 10232345067 /8=0 377;0> 8 601A? >820>- 87D35<2/0C54224A8?2/0648>872/0 78C0 F4;A> >8C8<0 2/0 @641 5 60714570 2/0604: 2/0 607145>05278;2/4632307 /8> 377;0> 05>4670C052 728235< 2/82 735@0 2/0 A85> 4=06 F/3@/ 2/0 648> 37 35205> 24 90 :46C0> 37 8 /42 #/8689 A85> 2/060 37 54 500> 46 60H;360C052:468@H;3635<2/0783>A85>873290A45<7242/0 4=065C052035<8<<630=0>9?2/078C02/010232345067 86090:4602/374;62875420>894=0 08650>@4;570A:462/0102323450660A?35<;145 2/0 46>06 4: 2/0 446>35820 05@/ 4: 2/37 4;62 >820> ,& & 18770> 35 )4' 8A45< F32/ @4550@20> C822067 35 2/0 @870 4: 7;9C327 2/82 2/0 10232345067 9035< 4F5067 24 2/0 052360 0G2052 4: 8@607 &- <;5287 4: A85> 35 ?4 - F/3@/ 8A7435@A;>07850G20524: <;52874:/42#/8689A85> 2/0 607145>0528;2/4632307 @85542 @A83C 85? 63</2 232A0 - 6 - 85> 35206072 4=06 2/0 783> - <;5287 4: /42 #/8689 A85>07;9C3272/82352/0A3</24:7022A0>147323454:A8F 2/0 4F506 35 1477077345 4: A85> F/3@/ 35@A;>07 /42 #/8689A85>378A742/04F506242/0783>D/8689A85> 2/0 607145>0528;2/4632307 3: 35205>35< 24 ;23A3B0 2/0 783> /42 #/8689 A85> 7/8AA 90 >360@20> 24 35323820 2/0 8@H;3732345 164@00>35<7 85> 18? 2/0 @4C105782345 F/3@/ F4;A>C0022/060H;360C05285>500>4:2/010232345067 ' 5 60714570 63 4;637/ #/87/8C1;6 A08650> @4;570A 81108635< :46 607145>052 47 85> ' 7;9C3272/821;67;852242/046>0618770>9?2/374;628 E4352 7;6=0? /87 9005 @45>;@20> 601462 35 2/37 60<86> /87 9005 :3A0> 8A45< F32/ C0C4 >820> ' 5 206C7 4: F/3@/ 32 90@4C07 @A086 2/82 85 0G2052 4: <;5287 4;2 4: <;5287 4: /42 #/8689 A85> 37 9035< ;70> 9? 2/0 607145>052 47 85> ' :46 2/0 1;61470 4: :46C82345 4: 2/0 8:460783> 648> 0 7;9C327 2/82 2/0 05>4670C052377;0>9?2/0607145>05278;2/4632307@85542 90 :4;5> :8;A2 F32/ 3587C;@/ 87 2/0 10232345067 @85542 - 7 - @A83C 4F5067/31 4=06 2/0 /42 #/8689 A85> 87 106 550G;60 4: 2/0 46>06 4: 2/0 01;2? 4CC37734506 05@0700D7:46>37C3778A4:2/010232345 , 08650> >>323458A 4=065C052 >=4@820 81108635< :46 2/0 8;2/4632307 35 2/0 A3</2 4: 2/0 46>06 18770> 9? 2/0 446>35820 05@/ 4: 2/37 4;62 35 "7;168$ :836A? 7;9C327 2/82 735@0 2/0 A8F F32/ 60<86> 24 2/0 4F5067/31 4: /42 #/8689 A85> /87 9005 1;282607210232345067F/4@A83C24902/04F50674: <;52874:/42#/8689A85>F3AA/8=02490@4573>060>87 2/0 4F5067 4: 2/0 A85> 85> 85? 1462345 4: 783> /42 #/8689 A85> 4: 2/0 10232345067 37 ;70> :46 :46C82345 4: 648>2/0?7/8AA90183>@4C105782345358@@46>85@0F32/ A8F /0 A08650> >>323458A 4=065C052 >=4@820 :46 2/0 607145>0527 7;9C327 2/82 60706=35< A39062? 24 2/0 607145>05278;2/4632307 24 35323820 164@00>35<7 :46 8@H;3732345 85> >0206C350 2/0 @4C105782345 18?89A0 24 - 8 - 2/010232345067242/00G20524: <;52874:/42#/8689 A85>871062/07D02@/164>;@0>2/0?C8?90106C3220>24 164@00>F32/2/0@45726;@23454:648> /0?:;62/067;9C32 2/82 2/0 @870 4: 2/0 10232345067 90 @4573>060> 35 8@@46>85@0 F32/ A8F 85> 2/0 @4C105782345 87 18?89A0 ;5>062/0A8FF3AA90>0206C350><3=0574C023C0352/0 C82206 - 08650>@4;570A:462/0102323450677;9C322/82 3:7;@/;5>0628D35<3728D054560@46>85>3:823C0A3C3237 :3G0> :46 2/0 607145>05278;2/4632307 24 >0206C350 2/0 @4C105782345 18?89A0 24 10232345067 2/0 10232345067 C8? 542/8=049E0@23457352/0?:46C35<2/0648> 086>06;70>2/060@46>7 /0102323450679035<2/04F50674:8@607&- <;52874:A85>:46C0>3518624:?4 -F/3@/35@A;>07 <;5287 4: /42 D/8689 A85> 37 542 35 >371;20 >0523:3@823454:850G2052 <;52874:A85>F/3@/379035< ;23A3B0> 9? 2/0 607145>0528;2/4632307 C460 18623@;A86A? - 9 - 607145>052 47 85> ' :46 2/0 1;61470 4: :46C82345@45726;@2345 4: 648> :64C 068<068*8A3905@/3 =38 8>/86 85> #8C8A81;6 =3AA8<0 " &DC$ ;5>06 2/0 68>/85 85263 68C 8>8D 4E858 "$ @/0C0 37 8A7454235>371;20 /0 446>35820 05@/ 4: 2/37 4;62 35 @870"7;168$/87/0A>87;5>06 !" #"# !" #"# $ % &'( )' % % ' & 5 2/0 A3</2 4: 2/0 E;><C052 85> 46>06 18770> 9? 2/0 446>35820 05@/ 4: 2/37 4;62 35 2/0 @870 4: "7;168$ /4A>35< 2/82 8 4F506 4: A85> F/3@/ 35@A;>0D/8689A85>378A742/04F506242/00G20524:783> D/8689 A85> 10232345067 35 2/0 3572852 @870 @85542 90 >0530>2/03663</2232A085>352060724=062/0783>0G20524: - 10 - <;5287 4: 1/42 D/8689 A85> /0 607145>052 8;2/4632307F/4860352/0164@0774:;23A3B35< <;52874: 1/42 D/8689 A85> 90A45<35< 24 10232345067 @85542 @45205>242/0@452686?;@/87285>6;57@452686?242/0 164=3734574:A8F85>2/0A8FA83>>4F59?2/0446>35820 05@/4:2/374;6260:0660>24894=0 0A0=852 82 2/37 E;5@2;60 8A74 24 60:06 2/0 E;><C052 4: 2/0 10G 4;62 35 2/0 @870 4: =7 ' ( ) ! F/06035 82 1868<681/&2/010G4;62/87/0A>87;5>06 *+, - .% - - / 0 # % 1 - # % 2 1 - # % 1 - # % 1 - 1 - 11 - # % - # % 1 - / # - ' 5 2/82 =30F 4: 2/0 C82206 2/37 10232345 37 F32/2/0:4AA4F35<>360@23457 3$ /0102323450677/8AAC8D0860160705282345 24 607145>052 47 85> & 8A45< F32/ 2/37 46>06 85> 2/0 >4@;C052 E;723:?35< 2/036 63</2232A085>352060724=062/01641062? 33$ /0 607145>052 4&77372852 4CC377345067/8AA353238202/0164@00>35<7 :468@H;37323454: <;52874:A85>F/3@/37 086C86D0>>0A350820>85>3>0523:30>87106 2/0 7D02@/ 164>;@0> 8A45< F32/ 2/0 C0C4 >820>' 3>0523:?35< <;52874: A85>90A45<0>242/010232345067 - 12 - 333$ 07145>052 4& 7/8AA 164@00> 24 >0206C3502/0@4C10578234587106C37739A0 ;5>062/0811A3@89A0A8F28D35<2/0>8204: 8@H;373234587452/0>8204:>371478A4:2/0 1607052F63210232345 3=$ 07145>052 4& 7/8AA @45@A;>0 2/0 8@H;3732345 164@077 85> >0206C350 2/0 @4C105782345 F32/35 85 4;206 A3C32 4: 73G C452/7:64C2/0>8204:60@03124:@0623:30> @41?4:2/3746>06 =$ /0 >0206C3582345 4: 2/0 @4C105782345 87 >360@20>7/8AA28D03524@4573>06823458AA2/0 7282;246?9050:327F/3@/2/010232345067860 05232A0>24;5>06A8F =3$ 52/0C085F/3A0607145>0524785>' 86082A39062?24164@00>F32/2/0:46C82345 4: 2/0 648> :64C 068<068*8A3905@/3 =38 8>/86 85> #8C8A81;6 =3AA8<0 " & DC$ - 13 - ;5>06 2/0 68>/85 85263 68C 8>8D 4E858"$@/0C08735205>0> !*+ '$!$( & 3724A4 21D