- 1 - ! "#$$ !! %$& ' ! "#$ % & " ' % (# ) * () +) ) ! # '' $ + & " * (, -! ! !#% Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - -,"% # . .! . .(! + # ) ) / ' # 0123 433510607 89 :;0 <=73>02: 427 4?457 74:07 . .! . @4AA07 12 B.(! 89 :;0 021B5 161C=730D D =547";050124E:0550E05507 :B 4A F:;0 518=24CG EB5 A;B5:% :;0 4@@0CC42:2A=542H0 B>@429 1A 80EB50 :;1A B=5: H;4CC023123 :;0 C1481C1:9 E4A:0207B21: ! 510EE4H:AC047123:BE1C123BEHC41>@0:1:1B2450 :;4: B2 ! 4: 48B=: ), 4> 4: :;0 C427 BE B20'4C94254BB2#4734B2=575B472045454942@=5 :;0 751605 BE CB559 8045123 B!(.! 75B60 ;1A 60;1HC012454A;427203C1302:>42205427:B@@C077B?2 - 3 - :;0 60;1HC0 12:B 4 71:H; 7=0 :B ?;1H; :;0 HC41>42: ?;B ?4A12>4:0BEA41760;1HC0:5460C1234CB23?1:;;1A3BB7A A=A:41207 35106B=A 12<=510A 427 :4I02 :504:>02: EB5 :;0 12<=510AA=A:4120789;1>427:;0HC41>42:E1C07:;0HC41> @0:1:1B2;0518=24C4AA0AA07:;0HB>@02A4:1B2427;0C7 :;4: :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 1A C148C0 :B @49 :;0 HB>@02A4:1B2 4>B=2: 0123 433510607 89 :;0 C1481C1:9 E4A:0207 B2 1: :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 ;4A E1C07 :;0 @50A02:4@@04C , 0457 C045207 HB=2A0C EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42: 2A=542H0 B>@429 427 C045207 HB=2A0C EB5 50A@B2702: BHC41>42: 045207 HB=2A0C EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42:2A=542H0 B>@429?B=C7HB2:027:;4::;0HC41>42:?4AE450@417 @4AA02305 12 3BB7A 60;1HC0 427 :;050EB50 :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 1A 2B: C148C0 :B @49 :;0 4?457 4>B=2: ;0 E=5:;05 HB2:02707 :;4: 12 J 427 J!HB>@C412: >02:1B207 :;4: 4E:05 7B123 HBBC10 ?B5I :;0 HC41>42: - 4 - 8B45707 :;0 CB559 427 :;050 1A 2B >02:1B2 BE ;0 CB47123 :?B <B?45 843A ;0 E=5:;05 HB2:02707 :;4: # 12 ;1A H5BAA0J4>124:1B2 ;4A 47>1::07 :;4: ;0;4A @417 A ( :B:;0751605 B2A1705123:;0A4174A@0H:1:1AHC045:;4: :;0 HC41>42: 1A E450 @417 @4AA02305 12 3BB7A 60;1HC0 ;050EB50:;02A=542H0 B>@4291A2B:C148C0:B@49:;0 4?4574>B=2: 045207 HB=2A0C EB5 :;0 50A@B2702:HC41>42: ?B=C7HB2:027:;4::;0HC41>42:?4A:5460C1234CB23?1:; ;1A3BB7A:;4:1A:?B<B?45843A427:;050EB50;01A2B:4 E450 @417 @4AA02305 ;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 ;4A 2B: 0J4>1207:;0751605BE:;0CB559:B0A:48C1A;?;0:;05:;0 HC41>42: ?4A :5460C123 4CB23 ?1:; 3BB7A B5 ;0 ?4A E450 @417 @4AA02305 0 E=5:;05 A=8>1:A :;4: 12 J,A@B: @42H;424>4:;0501A2BK=0A:1B2BE>02:1B2123:;0<B?45 843A H455107 89 :;0 HC41>42: A12H0 :;0 A417 CB559 ?4A :B@@C07 7B?2 602 :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 ;4A 2B: 0J4>1207 :;0 4=:;B5 BE :;0 A417 A@B: @42H;424>4 B2A17051234CC:;0A04A@0H:A:;0518=24C;4A513;:C9;0C7 - 5 - :;4: :;0 HC41>42: ?4A :5460C123 4CB23 ?1:; 3BB7A 427 2A=542H0 B>@4291AC148C0:B@49:;04?4574>B=2: 46123 ;0457 C045207 HB=2A0CA :;0 B=5: ;4A @05=A07:;01>@=3207<=73>02:427514C B=5:0HB57A - ;0 HC41>42: 12 ;1A HC41> @0:1:1B2 427 12 ;1A H;10E0J4>124:1B2 ;4A A@0H1E1H4CC9 A:4:07 :;4: ;0 ?4A :5460C123 4CB23 ?1:; ;1A :?B <B?45 843A 12 :;0 60;1HC0 # 12 ;1A H5BAA0J4>124:1B2 ;4A 702107 :;0 A=330A:1B2 :;4:;0?4A2B::5460C1234CB23?1:;3BB7A;047>1AA1B2 BE#:;4:;0@417A (:B:;0751605BE:;0CB5591A HB2A17050789:;0518=24C4AA:54947>1AA1B2 ;02A=542H0 B>@429;4A2B:0J4>1207:;0 751605BE:;0CB559:B0A:48C1A;:;4::;0HC41>42:?4A4E450 @417@4AA023051243BB7A60;1HC0B52B:;03BB7A?;1H; ?050 12 :;0 60;1HC0 ;460 2B: 8002 2B:07 12 A@B: @42H;42>4J, A12H0 CB559 ?4A :B@@C07 7B?2 427 HB2:02:A BE :;0 A417 CB559 ?050 2B: 2B:07 4: :;0 :1>0 BE 754?123:;0A417A@B:@42H;424>4;04=:;B5BE:;0A@B: - 6 - @42H;424>4 ;4A 2B: 0J4>1207 89 :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 . B2A1705123 4CC :;0A0 4A@0H:A :;0518=24C ;4A 513;:C9 ;0C7 :;4: :;0 HC41>42: ?4A :5460C123 4CB23 ?1:; 3BB7A 12 :;0 60;1HC0 ?;1H; >0: ?1:; 42 4HH1702: ;0 518=24C ;4A 513;:C9 ;0C7 :;4: :;0 2A=542H0 B>@429 1A C148C0:B@49:;0HB>@02A4:1B24?45707 2 610? BE :;0 48B60 :;050 450 2B 35B=27A :B 4CCB?:;04@@04C02H0:;04@@04C1A71A>1AA07 ;0031A:591A7150H:07:BA02784HI:;0514C B=5: 0HB57A:B:;0HB2H05207 B=5: ;0 4>B=2: 12 70@BA1: 1E 429 1A B570507 :B 80 :542A>1::07:B:;0HB2H05207 B=5: () %$$& # ) )!- :*I