- 1 - !" # $!%!&!! !!&& '() * !"! # $%$$% ! $$ & $%$' &()"( $ &("!! $*$$ !"! '' $ $ &$' %% % $ !"! #$ $$%'+ !$$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' '$ !,&! ' % $% ' $ $' $ $ $ $$ "!!"& $ $$ % $ $ % &&"!' $* ' $ $ $ $%$ $ - $ % ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 3. /==./> <8 :<>.1 /4/<782 23. /?/01 9: 23. 0<;57/> <7 % 9&&"! 1/2.1 "!!"& =/88.1 ;@ 23. 11<2<97/> .7<90 <A<> 514. /71 ' /<B350 :90 83902C23.0<;57/>D & 7E50.1B>/<6/72 :<>.1 / B>/<6 =.2<2<97 B>/<6<74 B96=.78/2<97 9: 8(""""" ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: !F =.0 /7756 3. 0<;57/> /:2.0 B978<1.0<74 .72<0. .A<1.7B. 97 0.B901 40/72.1 /7 /69572 9: 8 ((" - 3 - ?<23<72.0.82/223.0/2.9:)F=.0/7756:09623.1/2.9: =.2<2<972<>>1/2.9:0./><8/2<97 440<.A.1 ;@ 23. 8/<1 901.0 23<8 /==./> <8 =0.:.00.1<7?3<B3<2<8B972.71.123/23.?/8/4.1 @./08 . 8582/<7.1 40<.A958 <7E50<.8 /71 8=.72 354. /69572 :90 6.1<B/> .G=.78.8 . ?/8 ./07<74 8"""" =.0 69723 ;52 23. 0<;57/>3/8 2/H.7 8!," ;/8.1 97 23.B3/02 ?3<B3 <8 97 23. >9?.0 8<1. ./4.0 /695728 ?.0. 40/72.1 :90>9889:/6.7<2<.8/71=/<7/7185::.0<74/7123.<72.0.82 2923./?/01<829;..73/7B.129!F ==.>>/72D8 B9578.> B972.71.1 23/2 23. /==.>>/72 3/8 3/A<74 ! /B0. 4572/8 9: >/71 /8 =.0 G!! I .G20/B29:850A.@9!&/713.?/8839?7/8B5>2<A/290<7 9>5679!/713.?/8409?<740<B.B09=/71/8=.023. .A<1.7B.9:23.19B29023./==.>>/72?/8/1A<8.12958.82<BH /:2.0 23. /BB<1.72 39543 3. 3/8 82/2.1 23/2 3. ?/8 ./07<74 8"""" =.0 69723 :096 /40<B5>250/> ?90H 23. 0<;57/>3/82/H.723.7/2<97/><7B96.9:8!,"/8=.0 - 4 - 23.B3/02/7123580.J5.82.123.B9502292/H.23.<7B96. /88""""=.069723 ( .8=971.72 B9578.> B972.71.1 23/2 23. 0<;57/> 3/8 2/H.7 23. <7B96. /71 1<8/;<><2@ =09=.0>@ /71 0<432>@ 40/72.1 E582 B96=.78/2<97 /71 23<8 9502 7..18 79 <72.0:.0.7B. , 3. =.2<2<97.0 8582/<7.1 23. >.:2 ;97. :0/B250. /71 0<432 >.4 /;0/8<97 =0.8.72 /8 =.0 G I 9571 .02<:<B/2. . ?/8 /16<22.1 97 " "!"! /71 1<8B3/04.1 97"!"!/71/4/<7/:2.0:<A.6972383.?/8/16<22.1 97 "("! /71 1<8B3/04.1 97 &""("! /71 2358 3. ?/8 398=<2/><8.1 :90 !) 1/@8 /8 /7 <7=/2<.72 G, /71 G /0. 23. 1<8B3/04. 8566/0<.8 $9B290 /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<><2@/8F/7123.0<;57/>3/8B978<1.0.123.8/6. 3.0.:90.23.0.<8790./89729<72.0:.0.?<2323.1<8/;<><2@ /88.88.1;@23.19B290 16<22.1>@ 23. /==.>>/72 <8 /7 /40<B5>250<82 3/A<74 9?7 >/71 /71 B5>2<A/2<74 0<B. B09= 3.0.:90. 23<8 - 5 - B9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 2/H. 3<8 <7B96. /8 8"""" =.069723BB901<74>@23.>9889::5250.<7B96.B96.829 8""""G!G!&GFK8( ("" ) 978<1.0<74 23. 7/250. 9: <7E50<.8 =.0<91 9: 398=<2/><8/2<97/7123.9BB5=/2<979:23.B>/<6/7223<89502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 .73/7B. =/<7 /71 85::.0<74 29 8"""" >988 9: /6.7<2<.8 29 8""" /71 8&"""" <8 29 ;. 40/72.1 :90 20/78=902/2<97 .G20/ 7950<836.72/71/22.71<74B3/04.8 !" .6<4327923/A./22.71.1/7@/40<B5>250/>?90H /2 >./82 :90 / =.0<91 9: :950 697238 15. 29 23. <7E50<.8 8582/<7.1 <7 23. /BB<1.72 23.0.:90. 3. <8 .72<2>.1 :90 8 """" """" G 571.0 23. 3./1 >988 9: <7B96. 150<74>/<15==.0<91 !! 3.6.1<B/>.G=.78.8?/840/72.1/223.0/2.9: 8&"";@23.0<;57/>/71<27..1879<72.0:.0.7B. ! 7 />> 23. 292/> B96=.78/2<97 B96.8 29 8!!,((" ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: (F =.0 /7756 :09623.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>0./><L/2<97 - 6 - !& 3./?/019:23.0<;57/><8691<:<.1/8571.0 +,-. /01231. !9889:<7B96. ( ("" /<7/7185::.0<74 """" &9889:/6.7<2<.8 """ .1<B/>.G=.78.8 &"" 0/78=902/2<97.G20/7950<836.72/71 /22.71/72B3/04.8 &"""" ( 988 9: ./07<74 150<74 23. >/<1 5= =.0<91:90697238 """" 2,4 556 BB901<74>@ 23. /==.>>/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 / 292/> B96=.78/2<979:. 556/8/4/<7828 ((" 3. B>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 /7 .73/7B.1 B96=.78/2<97 9: .""6 ! 723.0.85>223.:9>>9?<74901.0<8=/88.1 < 3./==./><8 << 3. B>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 / 292/> B96=.78/2<979:8!!,(("?<23<72.0.82 /223.0/2.9:(F=.0/7756:09623.1/2.9: =.2<2<972<>>0./><L/2<97 <<< 7850/7B.B96=/7@3/8/>0./1@1.=98<2.123. /?/01.1 /69572 ;.:90. 23. 0<;57/> 23.0.:90. 0.8=971.72 9 <8 1<0.B2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. .73/7B.1 B96=.78/2<97 9: - 7 - 8&!!& "?<23<72.0.82/223.0/2.9:(F ?<23<7!69723:09623.1/2.9:23<8901.0 <A 7 85B3 1.=98<2 /==.>>/72 <8 =.06<22.1 29 ?<2310/? 23. .72<0. /69572 />974 ?<23 <72.0.82/BB05.197<2 .-6 '&!! ) % <829!>9(&