- 1 - ! "! #$!%!$$ $ & ' &()* '&!!)) + ! " # ! $ ! # $ ! !! # ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % $ # "% $ # & ! ' $ " ! ( ) $ * & # + ! " , - $, # ' ". #$ ! ( ) $ & / "* & " & ) * " & !!' "!" """!" ' "!" !"!"!" & & & & $$& ' "!" - 3 - & & # +$ ) +$ * 0121234056 70248 9::;60< 36 13 ' 24 52=0 3' "!" 3> #3=04 3?2:0 191234 2<95 @04<248 24 3' "!" 34 1A0 >2?0 3> 1A0 ?09540< <<212349? 2B2?$;<8094<$& 2<95C>356A351D1A0529?3;51EF 508261050< >35 1A0 3>>04:06 @;426A97?0 ;4<05 0:12346 . "!!%509<G21A0:1234.3> 4<294049? 3<0 %!C>356A351D1A0 EF950600H24813I;96A1A0 :52=249?@53:00<248624212910<98924611A0= " &9:16 3> 1A0 :960 24 7520> 950 1A91 506@34<041 3">2?0<1A0>256124>35=9123498924619::;60<3613' 9??082481A919::;60<326A05A;6794<9::;60<36" 94< 950 A05 =31A0524?9G 94< >91A0524?9G 9::;60< 3 26 1A0 626105 3> 9::;60< 3" 9::;60< 36 94< % 950A05626105624?9G94<9::;60<3'26A057531A0524 - 4 - ?9G::;60<3702481A0A;6794<94<9::;60<36" 13'70248A2650?912B06619510<2??15091248A057J97;6248 24 >2?1AJ ?948;980 9669;?1248 A05 94< :52=249??J 2412=2<91248 13 3;61 A05 >53= 1A0 =9152=3429? A3;60 A;6 150910< A05 G21A :5;0?1J 1 26 61910< 1A91 506@34<041 3" 431 70248 97?0 13 13?05910 1A0 2?? 15091=041 7J 1A0 9::;60< 619510< 5062<248 G21A A05 @950416 4 ""!" 9::;60< 3 :9=0 13 1A0 @950416E A3;60 3> 506@34<041 3" 97;60< A05 24 >2?1AJ ?948;980 2462610< >35 <2B35:0 :52=249??J 2412=2<910< 13 19H0 9G9J A05 ?2>0 94< 9669;?10< A05 G21A A94<6 94< H2:H0<A05A050>3501A024>35=94150I;0610<1A0@3?2:0 13508261051A0:96094<24212910?089?9:1234::35<248?J & :9=0 13 70 508261050< 94< 24B0612891234 G96 ;4<0519H04>10524B0612891234:A95806A001:9=01370 >2?0<9??08248:3==2662343>1A03>>04:06@;426A97?0;4<05 0:12346 . " ! !% 509< G21A 0:1234 . 3> A0@0121234056702489::;60<3613'95070>350 - 5 - 1A26 3;51 600H248 13 I;96A 1A0 :52=249? @53:00<2486 24212910<98924611A0= 095< 52 9K9 04H919@@9 92H ?09540< :3;460?>351A0@012123405694<52$9=9<95A9A97;<<24 ?09540< 28A 3;51 3B054=041 ?09<05 >35 506@34<041 3 L 1910 06@34<041 3" 1A3;8A 605B0< A96 50=9240< ;450@5060410< 05;60< 1A0 =910529?6 34 50:35< 4 B20G 3> 1A0 52B9? :3410412346 ;580< 7J 1A0 ?09540<:3;460?>35731A1A0@9512061A0@32411A91G3;?< 95260>35=J:3462<059123426 !"#$% J 946G05 13 1A0 973B0 @3241 26 >351A0>3??3G248 !! 06@34<041 3" :34104<0< 1A91 6A0 =95520< 9::;60<334 !"! 94<A9<708311049:A2?<24 - 6 - 1A0=9552980 42129??J6A0G965062<248241A0=9152=3429? A3;60 9?348 G21A 9::;60< 36 13 94< ' ::;60< 36 94< % 70248 1A0 626105624?9G 94< 9::;60< 3 702481A06261053>9::;60<3";60<13B26211A0A3;603> 9::;60< 3 94< 9?? 1A0 9::;60< ;60< 1397;60 94<2?? 15091 A05 A0J A9B0 9?63 9669;?10< A05 34 =94J 3::962346 % 06@34<041 3" :9108352:9??J 61910< 1A91 >35 973;1 =350 1A949 J095 6A0 G96 5062<248 24 A05 @950416E A3;60;52481A91@0523<6A0A96431>2?0<94J:3=@?9241 9892461 9::;60< 36 94< % GA3 950 9<=2110<?J 1A0 =95520< 6261056 3> 9::;60< 3 35 9892461 9::;60< 3 GA3 26 1A0 626105 3> 9::;60< 3" 1 26 61910< 1A91 9::;60< 36 " 94< ' 950 5062<248 13801A05 24 1A0 =9152=3429?A3;603>506@34<0413"06@34<0413" 6@0:2>2:9??J6191061A9121G9634""!"9::;60<3 :9=0 13 A05 @950416E A3;60 97;60< 94< 9669;?10< A05 - 7 - 246261248 >35 <2B35:0 GA2:A ?0< 13 1A0 >2?248 3> 1A0 >2561 24>35=91234 7J 506@34<041 3" 34 """!" B04 9::35<24813506@34<0413"34""!"43403>1A0 31A05 9::;60< A9B0 :3=0 13 A05 @950419? A3;60 94< :3==2110< 94J 3>>04:0 A0 31A05 9??08912346 50895<248 15091248A05G21A:5;0?1J7J9::;60<36"13'9?348G21A 9::;60< 3 G96 =;:A @5235 13 3B0=705 "!" 94< 9<=2110<?J 43 :52=249? :3=@?9241 G96 >2?0< 7J A05 24 1A91 50895< 1 26 @05124041 13 4310 1A91 0B04 9::35<248 13 506@34<041 3" 6A0 G96 5062<248 24 A05 @950416E A3;60 9?348G21AA05<9;8A105>35=3501A94MJ0956@523513 ""!" ' 3462<052489??1A060>9:1694<:25:;=6194:06 9= 3> 1A0 3@24234 1A91 506@34<041 3" A96 53@0< 24 9::;60<36"13'702481A0>9=2?J=0=70563>9::;60< 3241A0:3=@?9241=9H24879?<94<804059?9??08912346 9892461 1A0= 3G0B05 1A050 950 6@0:2>2: 9??08912346 =9<0 9892461 9::;60< 3 >35 A9B248 :3==2110< 1A0 3>>04:06 >53= 1A0 <910 3> =9552980 94< 0B04 34 - 8 - ""!" 91 %!! @= 24 1A0 @950419? A3;60 3> 506@34<0413"4<056;:A:25:;=6194:06 9=3>1A0 3@24234 1A91 1A0 :52=249? @53:00<2486 24212910< 9892461 9::;60< 36" 13 ' 26 24 97;60 3> @53:066 3> ?9G 13 @5066;52N0 1A0 9::;60< >35 105=6 A050>350 21 26 13 70 I;96A0<3G0B05:52=249?@53:00<248698924619::;60< 326?297?01370@53:00<0<G21A24B20G3>1A06@0:2>2: 94<60523;69??08912346::35<248?J 946G051A0973B0 @3241 D@951?J 24 1A0 9>>25=912B0E 94< @53:00< 13 @966 1A0 >3??3G248 )2* A052=249?012123426 )22* 0121234 >2?0< 7J @012123405 3 26 A0507J )222* 0121234 >2?0< 7J @012123405 36" 13 ' 26 A0507J )2B* 52=249? @53:00<2486 9892461 @012123405 36"13'2452=03' "!"3>#3=04 3?2:0 191234 2<95 @04<248 24 - 9 - 3' "!"341A0>2?03>1A0?09540< <<212349? 2B2? $;<80 94< $& 2<95 >35 1A0 3>>04:06 @;426A97?0 ;4<05 0:12346 . "!!%509<G21A0:1234. 3> 26A0507J 4 B20G 3> <26@369? 3> 1A0 :52=249? @0121234 3 "!"9?636194<6<26@360<3> !,* &$$) % # 2613?3