- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( !"" ## $! # # # % &'! "( !"" % ## # ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # % * * + # ,-./ 01, -.234,506 78 9,-.5,/ :7356,96 8.74 ;7016</,6 1<6 -==,-9 <6 8<9,/ ;> 01, 8-01,. 78 - 4<57. /-3210,. -2,/ >,-.6 ?17 6360-<5,/ <5@3.<,6 <5 - .7-/ 0.-88<: -::</,50 -2-<560 01, 3/24,50 -5/ -?-./ /-0,/ !""=-66,/<57&'! "(;>01,//<0<75-9 ,5<7.<A<93/2,-5/-0<@->-=3.-87.617.0B01, 0.<;35-9C ! 1,4<57.:9-<4-50-2,/D>,-.64,0?<01-.7-/ 0.-88<: -::</,50 75 &"$"D ,. 8-01,. 8<9,/ - :9-<4 =,0<0<756,,E<52:74=,56-0<75 78 6"""""" -9752?<01 <50,.,60 -0 01, .-0, 78 &F =,. -5534 1, 0.<;35-9 -80,. :756</,.<52 01, 4-0,.<-9 ,A</,5:, 75 .,:7./ 1-6 -?-./,/ 297;-9 :74=,56-0<75 78 6!"""" -9752 ?<01 (F <50,.,60 8.74 01, /-0, 78 =,0<0<75 0<99 01, /-0, 78 .,-9<G-0<75 - 3 - 22.<,A,/;>01,6-</7./,.01,8-01,.7801,4<57.<5@3.,/ 8<9,/ 01, =.,6,50 -==,-9 6,,E<52 ,51-5:,4,50 78 01, :74=,56-0<75 501,=.,6,50-==,-9<0<64-<59>:750,5/,/01-0 01, 4<57. <5@3.,/ ?-6 176=<0-9<G,/ 87. D /->6 -5/ 61, 6360-<5,/ 8.-:03., <5@3.<,6 1, 9760 ""F 8303., ,-.5<52 :-=-:<0>-5/-9676=,50-634786!""""" 07?-./61,. 4,/<:-90.,-04,50;3001,6-4,1-6570;,,5:756</,.,/;> 01, 0.<;35-9 0 <6 -967 63;4<00,/ 01-0 61, 1-6 0-E,5 0.,-04,50 <5 01, 176=<0-9 87. 47., 01-5 873. 475016 -5/ 0136.,H3,60607,51-5:,4,507801,:74=,56-0<75 D 1, 4<57. <5@3.,/ 6360-<5,/ 9,80 =.7I<4-9 !./ .-/<36 -5/ 9,80 63=.-:-5/> 8,43. :730 ?1<:1 <6 4-.E,/ -6 I! 1, :,.0<8<:-0, I( <6 <663,/ ;> 01,7:07.6=,.01,:,.0<8<:-0,01,4<57.<5@3.,/2<.9 6360-<5,/01,87997?<52<5@3.<,6* < %0,9;7?:3;<0-98766-J << ;.-66<757A,.:1,60J <<< 75036<75780E5,,-50 - 4 - 3078-;7A,01.,,<5@3.<,697<-5/97<<<-., 2.<,A736<55-03.,-5/97<<<66<4=9,<5@3.> ( 1, :9-<4-50 /</ 570 ,I-4<5, 01, 7:07. -5/ 013601,H3,60<7578-66,66<5201,/<6-;<9<0>/7,6570-.<6, 136 01, 0.<;35-9 -?-./,/ - 297;-9 :74=,56-0<75 78 6!"""" -9752?<01(F<50,.,608.7401,/-0,78=,0<0<75 0<99 .,-9<G-0<75 6 =,. 01, 4,/<:-9 ;<996 01, :9-<4-50 1-6 6=,50-634786($ 6=,.01,:,.0<8<:-0,01, 4<57. <5@3.,/ 2<.9 6360-<5,/ 0?7 2.<,A736 <5@3.<,6 -5/ 75, 6<4=9,<5@3.> $ 756</,.<5201,5-03.,7801,<5@3.<,6-2,7801, :9-<4-50 =,.<7/ 78 176=<0-9<G-0<75 -5/ 701,. 8-:07.6 01<6 73.0 8<5/6 <0 .,-675-;9, 07 2.-50 -634 78 6!"""" 87. 01,<5@3.<,66388,.,/;>01,4<57.2<.96D"""" 07?-./6 =-<5 -5/ 6388,.<526 6D""" 35/,. 01, 1,-/ 78 9766 78 -4,5<0<,6 6!"""" 07?-./6 0.-56=7.0-0<75 ,I0.- 573.<614,50 -5/ -00,5/-50 :1-.2,6 -5/ - 634 78 6"""" 07?-./6 4,/<:-9 ,I=,56,6 ,5:, 01, 070-9 :74=,56-0<75?739/;,6D""" - 5 - & ,-.5,/ :7356,9 87. 01, 563.-5:, :74=-5> 63;4<0601-001,-?-./-47350786!"""" -?-./,/;> 01, 0.<;35-9 1-6 ;,,5 /,=76<0,/ ;,87., 01, 0.<;35-9 -9752 ?<01<50,.,60-::.3,/01,.,75 ' ::7./<529>01,87997?<527./,.* < 1,-==,-9<6-997?,/<5=-.0J << 1,4<57.<5@3.,/ :9-<4-50<6,50<09,07 -070-9:74=,56-0<75786D""" -9752?<01 (F <50,.,60 8.74 01, /-0, 78 =,0<0<75 0<99 .,-9<G-0<75 -6 -2-<560 - 634 78 6!"""" -?-./,/;>01,0.<;35-9-6297;-9:74=,56-0<75J <<< <5:, 01, 9,-.5,/ :7356,9 87. 01, 563.-5:, :74=-5> 63;4<00,/ 01-0 01, :74=,56-0<75 -47350 -?-./,/ ;> 01, 0.<;35-9 1-6 ;,,5 /,=76<0,/ 01, 563.-5:, :74=-5> <6 /<.,:0,/ 07 /,=76<0 01, ;-9-5:, :74=,56-0<75 -9752 ?<01 <50,.,60 -::.3,/ 01,.,75 ?<01<5 - =,.<7/7875,475018.7401,/-0,7801<6=,0<0<75J <A 5 63:1 /,=76<0 01, 8-01,. 78 01, 4<57. <5@3.,/ :9-<4-50 <6 =,.4<00,/ 07 ?<01/.-? - 6 - ,50<., :74=,56-0<75 -47350 -9752 ?<01 <50,.,60 -::.3,/01,.,75 )* %$ ' # <607*97*D *