Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63271 (KAR)
VICTIM v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.RP/200176/2024 · 2025-11-19
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63271 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63271 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$%
&$'!!!$ $
$#! ()(*+,),- !!+ -
!"#$
% &
'
#
(
( ! #$"
"
!#$"
% &
(#)
("'
( *+,&
'*! " ( "$"* &'
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( '
*#$,"$"
( # & ' $""$" & (
(&' #,"$""'
"!$ "$" ( *#+ (
"
(
-
&
- '
./012345/40101231678094:1;01<.66.1=13>0942?54? 5.045 *# $,
"$" /.6645 78 094 =4.?345 4661236 @5>4 23.3.//=1;.0123A1=4578:1;01<@354?4;0123*#+2A094 254 2A ?1<13.= ?2;45@?4 #+,* &A2? 692?0 B? C' D94?413 . /?.84? D.6 62@>90 02 6@<<23 ?46/235430 26 #02 .35,.6.;;@645 94=4.?3454661236@5>4 9.6 .==2D45 094 .//=1;.0123 A1=45 @354? 4;0123 *#+ 2A ? 13 /.?0 .35 094?478 094 /?2/2645 ?46/235430 26 # 02 .35 , .?4 .??.1>345 .6 .;;@645 26
" 02 ,
2D4:4? 094 .//=1;.0123 D.6 ?4E4;045 1362A.? .6 094
- 3 -
/?2/2645 ?46/235430 2 3.<4=8 .8.>235 15.//. .3.? 094 0943 2=1;4 36/4;02? 94 2?54? ?4>.?513> /.?01.= ?4E4;0123 2A .//=1;.0123 A1=45 @354? 4;0123 *#+ 2A ? 16@354?;9.==43>4
"
94 /?46430 /40101234?;2</=.13.30 =25>45 . ;2</=.130 23 # ##
"$"" 74A2?4 1E.8./@? 2<43 2=1;4 0.012360.013>09.0094:1;01<D929.5>23402;2==4>423 #$ ##
"$""515320?40@?392<4 46/1044AA2?06<.5478 094<2094? .35A.<1=8<4<74?6 094:1;01<;2@=5 320 74 0?.;45 ;2</4==13> 094 ;2</=.13.30 02 =25>4 . <16613> ;2</=.130 /23A@?094?13:4601>.01230945.@>904?2A094 ;2</=.13.30D.60?.;45.3594?60.04<430D.6?4;2?545
.6452309413:4601>.0123.;.64D.6?4>1604?45A2?094 2AA43;46 /@3169.7=4 @354? 4;01236 ** * *,&"'&3' .35 $2A094 .354;01236 &='.352A094 ;0
*
A04? ;2</=40123 2A 094 13:4601>.0123 5@?13> D91;90943:4601>.013>AA1;4??4;2?54509460.04<43062A
- 4 -
094:1;01<.352094?D10346646.;9.?>469440;.<40274 A1=45
@?13> 094 /43543;8 2A 094 0?1.= 094 ;2</=.13.30<2094? 2A 094 :1;01< A1=45 .3 .//=1;.0123 @354? 4;0123 *#+ ? ;23043513> 09.0 ;4?0.13 1351:15@.=69.57443=4A02@02A094.??.82A.;;@645 94 .==4>4509.0?46/2354302 546/1049.:13>F32D=45>42A 0942AA43;4A.1=45020.F4.;0123.3513604.5.66.@=045094 .;;@645 .35 ;24?;45 094 :1;01< 02 <.??8 91< 0 D.6 A@?094? .==4>45 09.0 ?46/235430 2 9.5 ?4;41:45 1==4>.= >?.01A1;.0123 2A 6 $$$$$G A?2< 094 .;;@645 02 6@//?466094.==4>.012362AF153.//13>.3564H@.=.66.@=0 .359.5.004</04502/?2E4;0094<.004?.6234?4=.013>02 <.??1.>46@7E4;002094:1;01<320516;=2613>09413;15430
94 6.15 .//=1;.0123 D.6 2//2645 78 .== /?2/2645 .;;@645 13;=@513> ?46/235430 2 78 A1=13> 540.1=4527E4;01236 0D.66/4;1A1;.==8;2304354509.0094 :1;01<C660.04<4306?4;2?545@354?4;01236##.35# ? .35 094 <451;.= 4:1543;4 52 320 516;=264 .38 .==4>.012309.0694D.6F153.//452?09.0?46/2354302
- 5 -
?4;41:45 1==4>.= >?.01A1;.0123 .6 .==4>45 0 D.6 ;23043545 09.0094.==4>.01236D4?4.3.A04?092@>90.35@36@//2?045 78.38;2304</2?.342@6<.04?1.=
94 =4.?345 4661236 @5>4 @/23 4H.<1313> 094<.04?1.=23?4;2?5A2@3509.0.A04??4>160?.01232A094 (23# ##
"$""094:1;01<.//4.?4574A2?41E.8./@? 2<43 2=1;4 23 ## #"
"$"" .35 94? 60.04<430 D.6 ?4;2?545 23 #" #"
"$"" &H ' 94 .=62 >.:4 94? 60.04<430 74A2?4 094 .>160?.04 23 #* #"
"$"" &H *'
94:1;01<.55?46645.=4004?02094 ?46154302A09491=5 4=A.?4 2<<10044 23 #* #"
"$"" &H #' .35 .>.13 6@7<10045 .32094? =4004? <.F13> .==4>.01236 .>.1360 ?46/235430 26 # 02 , &H
"' A@?094?
60.04<430 D.6 ?4;2?545 23 *$ $
"$"* &H ' 4? .5510123.= # ? 60.04<430 D.6 ?4;2?545 23 $* $
"$"* 94 ;9.?>4 69440 D.6 @=01<.04=8 A1=45 23 "$ #$
"$"* A2? 2AA43;46 @354? 4;01236 ** * *,&"'&3' .35 4;01232A094 ;0
- 6 -
94:1;01<.=6254/2645.6 #23"$ $
"$"* .35$ $
"$" /23?4A4??13>02094<@=01/=460.04<4306 2A094:1;01<.3509460.04<4302A94?<2094?094=4.?345 4661236@5>4A2@3509.0.032/2130515094:1;01<.==4>4 09.0 ?46/235430 2 ?4;41:45 1==4>.= >?.01A1;.0123 2? <16@645 916 2AA1;1.= /2610123 :43 13 094 :1;01<C6 # ? 60.04<430 5.045 #* #"
"$"" 32 6@;9 .==4>.0123 D.6 <.54 94 <2094? 2A 094 :1;01< 13 94? 60.04<430 5.045#" $
"$"*9.56/4;1A1;.==8;=.?1A14509.0.==4>.01236 .>.1360 094 /2=1;4 2AA1;4? .35 916 60.AA D4?4 7.645 23 . <16@354?60.3513>
,
94 4:16123.= 2@?0 23 4H.<1313> 094 4301?4 ?4;2?5.=623204509.0?46/2354302 9.532?2=413094 13:4601>.0123.0.3860.>4 3:14D2A094.7643;42A.38 /?1<. A.;14 <.04?1.= 094 4661236 2@?0 94=5 09.0 094 .==4>.01236.>.1360?46/2354302 D4?4@36@//2?04578 4:1543;4 .35 .<2@3045 <4?4=8 02 @36@760.301.045 .664?01236 78 094 :1;01< 2364I@430=8 094 .//=1;.0123
- 7 -
@354?4;0123*#+? 021</=4.5?46/2354302 .6 .3.;;@645D.6?4E4;045
! 4.?5 =4.?345 ;2@364= A2? 094 /40101234? =4.?345
1>9 2@?0 2:4?3<430 =4.54? A2? ?46/235430 2 #G0.04 .35 =4.?345 ;2@364= A2? ?46/235430 2
".;;@6452
9162@?09.6;.?4A@==84H.<1345094 <.04?1.=23?4;2?5
+
94 6;2/4 2A E@51;1.= ?4:14D 13 ?46/4;0 2A .3 2?54? /.6645 23 .3 .//=1;.0123 @354? 4;0123 *#+ 2A ? 16 4H0?4<4=8 =1<1045 304?A4?43;4 16 D.??.3045 23=813;.6462A<.31A460/4?:4?6108 3094/?46430;.64 094 =4.?345 4661236 @5>4 9.6 <401;@=2@6=8 ?4A4??45 02 094<@=01/=460.04<43062A094:1;01<13;=@513>94?#2A ? 60.04<4306 .6 D4== .6 094 60.04<4306 2A 094 ;2</=.13.30 ?4;2?545 .0 :.?12@6 60.>46 94 A13513>6 ?4;2?545 .?4 7.645 23 . 540.1=45 .66466<430 2A 094 4:1543;4
- 8 -
#$ 4A2?4 /?2;44513> A@?094? 10 16 .//?2/?1.04 02 4H0?.;0 094 ?4=4:.30 /2?01236 2A 094 :1;01<C6 60.04<430 ?4;2?545@354?4;0123#? D91;9?4.5.6A2==2D6 #./0.1 203041450 6574* !4/0.5
* *4/*7475)
! "
# $
#
%
# &
'( )* +
,-
./
0
1 ,/. 2
(2
3
45
67
' 89 !2
(
3
:7 9;
/< =
$1 7> ?@A??AB@BB CD 0 E 0 F%
G
H +
)#) #C( G
H01( +IJ
.
( )
..92 C( G
6
;K
F )
E+
/ H 2
3 4 19 E
L.
FM
8/
2
N G 7 F%
G
O ) P
H 01FM
8/2
G)
/
2
) QA 'KRS 3 C
TUJ01
2
0
4
. !7(
V
. !7(2
- 9 -
0
W
1 +
K X ;
C,
L. 0 ) *Y
W 1
"M ( ,/ NC3 E
Z"
;) 2 [7 0 9 /. 0
FM
0
W 1,) C12 #./0.1 203041450 6574* !4/0.5
* *4/*7475)
)
! "
# $
#
%
# &
'( )* 0
,-
./
0
1 ,/. 2
6
( #
\# 6#
6
45)
892
="
E+ 0
]8
892 F%
! )
; CD ( 7Q8 ] / [ 89 # 7> @^2??2B@BB
="
=
F%
! )3 W C _
0 2 ( L
$ E
0#
7 &
G _ 1 :O )
_
. 2
01
2
="
7> ?@2??2B@BB
)YUC:IR +)R LC94 0 8
3/
7
45 L ="
) 0 ' 92
F%
! 7 )C G
01 ) 0 8
- 10 -
'
H
0
2 +
!7( E
0
) 0
!7(2
="
( 9
"GI
: CR
!1 + ;/
67
'UJ. 9 2
="
(#
R )
H ); ( . . 92 $ )
(#
="
%Y
222 7
) 0
7
:O )
_ . 2 L ="
! 0 L
0 ;) 8 92 O1
;+`;
) 0
3
4 19 E G)R a4 (
L.
FM
83 2 $
+
;
H TUJ 2
0
2 ( L ="
'+`
/( )O
);
="
7
. 2 )
="
E+
';/ 9 2 ( ) 0
="
7 +
1 :O )
_
.
2
7 8 $
'
$1
FM
8/
2 $
L
$1 9
$1 )
.7 E #
H L ="
)O
)
="
# ) M ="
')( G
# ) % ="
# )
="
%
)O
:
2 7> ?B2??2B@BB
L
O G)R a4
TUJ L G)
'KRS 3
TUJ 019 E 0 '(
L
L
\ 6
)3) E 0 ;/
2 $
; 0 ; G)
Y
#
3
:. 9;
/< =
. )#
- 11 -
) # C( G
H 01 ( +IJ . ( )
. '9#
0
4 . !7(E )
N092$
b[b Y
F ;/
+ 72
'M JF(#7
) 0
="
7 +
1
. :O
)
_ . 2 L ="
="
L ) 0
. #' ;
+0
M J Y 1
2
0
W 1+
K X ;
C,
L. 0 ) *Y
W 1
"M ( ,/ NC3 E
Z"
;) # [70 9 /. 2
0 FM
0
W 1,) C12
## 3 . ;.?4A@= ?4.513> 2A 094 60.04<4306 2A 094 :1;01<.35094;2304</2?.342@660.04<4302A094<2094? ?4;2?545 .0 .3 @3516/@045 /2130 2A 01<4 10 74;2<46 <.31A460 09.0 320 4:43 . D916/4? 2A .==4>.0123 16 <.54 .>.1360 ?46/235430 2 6@>>46013> 09.0 94 <16@645 916 2AA1;1.= /2610123 .6 . 2=1;4 AA1;4? 2?09.0 94 D.6 13 .38 <.334?13:2=:45136@//?46613>09413;154302AF153.//13> 2? 09.0 94 9.5 ?4;41:45 .38 1==4>.= >?.01A1;.0123 A?2< 094 .;;@645 94 2<166123 2A 6@;9 .==4>.01236 13 094 4.?=1460 .35 <260 <.04?1.= 60.04<4306 2A 094 :1;01< .35 94? - 12 -
<2094? 16 . ;1?;@<60.3;4 2A ;236154?.7=4 61>31A1;.3;4 /.?01;@=.?=8 D943 6@;9 60.04<4306 D4?4 ?4;2?545 @354? 4;0123#2A? 74A2?4094.>160?.04D91;9;.??8. 91>94? 4:154301.?8 :.=@4 .0 094 60.>4 2A ;236154?13> .3 .//=1;.0123@354?4;0123*#+2A? #" 0 16 D4== 6400=45 09.0 094 /2D4? @354? 4;0123 *#+ 2A ? 02 6@<<23 .5510123.= .;;@645 16 4H0?.2?513.?8516;?40123.?8.3502744H4?;16456/.?13>=8 .3523=8D94360?23>.35;2>4304:1543;44<4?>465@?13> 0?1.= 1351;.013> 094 13:2=:4<430 2A . /4?623 D92 16 320 .=?4.58.??.1>345.6.3.;;@645 94@/?4<42@?09.6 ;236160430=8 94=5 09.0 094 54>?44 2A 6.016A.;0123 ?4I@1?45 A2? 13:2F13> 4;0123 *#+ 2A ?
<@60 74 91>94? 09.3 094 6.016A.;0123 34;466.?8 A2? A?.<13> . ;9.?>4 .35 09.0 0942@?0<@60746.016A14509.00944:1543;423?4;2?51A =4A0@3?47@0045D2@=5=4.502094;23:1;01232A094/4?623 62@>90 02 74 6@<<2345 4?4 .==4>.01236 6@6/1;123 2? ;23E4;0@?46 ;.3320 A2?< 094 7.616 A2? 13:2F13> 6@;9 . /2D4? - 13 -
#* 14D45.>.13600916=4>.=7.;F5?2/094=4.?345 4661236 @5>4 9.6 <401;@=2@6=8 ;236154?45 094 <@=01/=4 60.04<4306 2A 094 :1;01< .35 094 <2094? 094 ;2304</2?.342@6 52;@<4306 .35 094 2:4?.== A.;0@.= <.0?1H .35 9.6 ;2??4;0=8 ;23;=@545 09.0 094 <.04?1.= 23 ?4;2?5 A.==6 D24A@==8 692?0 2A 094 91>9 09?4692=5 ?4I@1?45 @354?4;0123*#+2A? 02.??.8?46/2354302 .6 .3.;;@645 9446612362@?09.6A@?094?0.F4332042A 094 A.;0 09.0 ?46/235430 2 9.5 32 ?2=4 D9.0624:4? 13 094 13:4601>.0123 .35 09.0 32 /?1<. A.;14 13;?1<13.013> <.04?1.= 9.6 6@?A.;45 A?2< 094 4:1543;4 =45 74A2?4 094 ?1.=2@?0
# I@.==81</2?0.3016094=1<10456;2/42AE@51;1.= ?4:14D .:.1=.7=4 02 0916 2@?0 13 ?4:16123.= E@?1651;0123 D91=44H.<1313>.32?54?/.664523.3.//=1;.0123@354? 4;0123 *#+ 2A ? 916 2@?0 ;.3320 4<7.?F @/23 . ?4.//?4;1.0123 2A 4:1543;4 32? 6@76010@04 106 2D3 ;23;=@61236 A2? 09264 .??1:45 .0 78 094 0?1.= 2@?0 @3=466 094 2?54? 1</@>345 6@AA4?6 A?2< >?266 /4?:4?6108
- 14 -
1==4>.=108 2? /.0430 <16.//?4;1.0123 2A =.D 94 /2D4? 2A 09162@?0166@/4?:162?8.35;2??4;01:4320.//4==.04.35 094 ?4:16123.= E@?1651;0123 ;.3320 74 13:2F45 02 ?4.66466 A.;0@.=5404?<13.012365@=8<.547809446612362@?013 4H4?;1642A106516;?40123@354?4;0123*#+2A? # 3094/?46430;.64094=4.?3454661236@5>4 9.6 ?4354?45 . ?4.62345 2?54? 7.645 23 . 092?2@>9 .66466<430 2A094 <.04?1.= /=.;4523?4;2?5 94A13513> 09.0 094?4 16 32 /?1<. A.;14 4:1543;4 D.??.3013> 094 6@<<2313>2A?46/2354302 .6.3.5510123.=.;;@64516 341094? /4?:4?64 32? ;230?.?8 02 =.D 94 <4?4 A.;0 09.0 ?46/2354302
16. 2=1;4AA1;4?;.332074.>?2@3502 ;.6@.==8 1</=1;.04 91< 13 ;?1<13.= /?2;44513>6 .6 6@;9 @3D.??.3045 1</=1;.0123 <.8 ;.??8 64?12@6 /?2A466123.= .35 /4?623.= ?.<1A1;.01236 94?4 094 0?1.= 2@?0 @/23 4:.=@.013> 094 4301?4 <.04?1.= 9.6 ?1>90=8 ;23;=@545 09.0 32 6@;9 13;?1<13.013> <.04?1.= 4H1606 0916 2@?0 A1356 32 E@601A1;.0123021304?A4?4
- 15 -
# (2? .== 094 A2?4>213> ?4.6236 0916 2@?0 16 2A 094;236154?452/1312309.00941</@>3452?54?5246320 6@AA4? A?2< .38 13A1?<108 1==4>.=108 2? /4?:4?6108 D.??.3013> 1304?A4?43;4 13 4H4?;164 2A ?4:16123.= E@?1651;0123
;;2?513>=8 094 ?1<13.= 4:16123 4010123 7413> 54:2152A<4?1060.356516<16645
!7, (!!$ $+ '
1602
"=2 *